Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend's dad convicted paedophile. Wwyd?

163 replies

Namechangerererererer · 14/08/2023 18:22

Dc started school last year, got chatting to one of the other mums in the playground as our kids seem to get on well. She seems quite open and is has been telling me about her dad who is dying of cancer etc. I've tried to be supportive as much as an acquaintance would be.

Before we broke up for the holidays we agreed to meet up a few times so the kids could see each other. Met up last week, lovely few hours.

While we were chatting last week I mentioned dhs job, he's a pc. Didn't think anything of it tbh.

Then today she messaged asking if we want to go round to hers later in the week to play. I agreed and then she messaged a few hours later asking if she could speak to my dh. This happens now and again where people just want some police advice without ringing the police.

So she basically disclosed she was being harassed on social media by a now ex friend who had found out her dad is a convicted paedophile. He was apparently convicted for downloading images a few years ago and was given a suspended sentence.

Apparently he's not allowed unsupervised contact with her dc, dc is not allowed to stay over unless there's a lock on the door (!!) That sounds bizarre to me tbh. Her dad doesn't live with them and is unlikely to last til the end of the month.

She said she'd understand if we didn't want our dc to play together. I just don't know how to feel. Obviously it's not her crime, and her dc is totally innocent in this but there's something nagging at me that makes me very uncomfortable. I think it's the fact that despite the conviction she's obviously still supports him with his illness. If it was a family member of mine, they'd be dead to me.

Iabu- not her crime so shouldn't be punished

Ianbu- her judgements off and I'd be uncomfortable too

Also, bugger odd daily mail journalists.

OP posts:
AlexandriasWindmill · 15/08/2023 09:25

Lots of us have been in this situation and would never let our DCs in the same area as the convicted paedophile - supervised or not.
This isn't about emotion. It's about risk. Why the hell would you prioritise putting your DC in contact with someone who is a convicted paedophile? The posters who are trying to justify that decision are either very naive or/and paedophile enabler. Tbh they can all fottfsoftfosm.

Changedtothisnow · 15/08/2023 09:17

This thread is very close to home as I’m just about to navigate your friends position but with a brother who isn’t dying.

Clearly I will have nothing to do with him and neither will my kids but honestly, I still love him and I can imagine when I get older and if he doesn’t reoffend and commits to a rehabilitation programme I can see myself having some contact. I would never have said that a month again, before this happened, I would have said that he would be dead to me.

When he gets out of prison in a few months, he will have no one and I can see my Mum, who lives fairly local to me, taking him in. Who could see their child on the streets, at real risk of killing themselves? Think about that if your child was to commit a terrible crime, would you just cut them off? I obviously won’t be visiting them but I am terrified of the backlash and repercussions for my kids if people find out and me. Also the threat of vigilante action on my Mum’s house.

Please don’t judge someone by someone else’s crimes.

Janedoelondon · 15/08/2023 09:08

Alicethecamelhasa · 14/08/2023 18:55

I’d like those who say that a relative would be dead to them if they got convicted of downloading indecent images of children to come back when they are in that situation. Because, honestly, I would have said that before it happened to me. When it’s someone you have loved your entire life then it might be different.

This.

Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 15/08/2023 08:48

AnnaMagnani · 14/08/2023 18:35

She isn't her dad.
She has been totally up front and honest with you about her situation.
She sticks to the rules about contact with him.

And he'll be dead very soon.

Can't see what there is to be worried about TBH.

This.

1967buglet · 15/08/2023 08:46

Her father is dying of cancer, and in a month or two it is a moot point.
She didn’t commit any crime
She was honest with you and seems a kind person.

You can shun her if you want, but I hope that you think about the above. She’s been put in a horrible situation. Her kids can come to yours whilst her dad is dying if you are worried

I also suspect if she went NC with her dad and refused to visit him when he was dying, people on here would criticise her for that too. Imagine being in her shoes. Crickey.

claireismyname · 15/08/2023 08:45

The past is in the past. It does not matter. Anyone who thinks it matters is being unreasonable and insecure.

NeverNoMore221 · 15/08/2023 08:16

Mollymalone123 · 15/08/2023 06:27

Op has your friend actually ever introduced her dc to her father or was she just telling you the rules around his conditions ? Everyone here is assuming she visits her father with her dc?
i know if a family in the same scenario of downloading images etc and worryingly it turns out it’s surprisingly common for men who are addicted to pornography who end up downloading child sex abuse images and extreme pornography as that is where the addiction has led them . This category seems to be treated as being out in sex offenders register and suspended sentence.this particular individual is deemed low risk of reoffending and has supervised access to his own dc. I’m not saying it doesn’t appal me but the people who understand this sort of thing definitely see it as a different issue and not true paedophilia. I’m sure they’ll be someone on mumsnet who can explain it better than me. All I’m saying is she has been upfront with you and sought your husband’s advice. I bet lots of people are allowing their children to play dates without truly knowing anything about their friend’s family-it’s hardly something you advertise.I really hope she isn’t on mumsnet as she’s being doubly punished here. She must be very conflicted about her father . Guilt must play a huge part and is she only now having contact because he is dying?

This is the lie women tell themselves so they can justify staying with their paedophile partners or stay in touch with a family member that has offended.
Oh it's not his fault he has a porn addiction and is just seeking the next thrill - Jesus what crap.
It's nonsense - a man who gets sexual gratification from watching children being sexually abused is a paedophile no matter the stages of porn he went through to get to it.

HowToSaveAWife · 15/08/2023 08:11

Oof. I feel for your friend but ultimately I think I'd be uncomfortable with - and sorry to say but also judgemental of - someone who puts their child's welfare as a secondary thing to an adult, doubly so if that adult is a paedophile.

But I understand she's in a difficult position. Maybe it's a case that she's only living relative willing to do paperwork etc. Maybe she wants to make sure he's dead and gone.

As it happens, I had a friend who's parent was convicted of killing their partner. Partner was abusive but didn't deserve the ending they got. I really really really struggled with friend accepting the facts of what the parent did but kind of minimizing their actions by the things that had preceded the death. Different circumstances to your friend obviously, I'm not saying she would justify or minimize it at all, but when you're the child of someone who has done a very bad thing I don't think it's as simple as "dead to me" all the time. Especially if the child ends up being their medical proxy/advocate or point of contact for official affairs.

Blueblell · 15/08/2023 07:23

I wouldn’t cut her off, on a practical level her Dad has a month to live and presumably is no longer a threat.

It’s easy to say that your relative would be dead to you but I don’t think it is that simple.

WiggelyWooWorm · 15/08/2023 07:19

I think what people say they will do and what they actually do when faced with a difficult situation, are often two very different things.

Many on here who say they would cut that person out, would do so. But many would not - if and when faced with it. They are the lies we tell ourselves when it's safe to do so.

If she had otherwise been a good friend, I would not change course now. (But then again - basses in the above, how could I be sure Confused).

UghStopSnoring · 15/08/2023 06:53

She has had to cope with the revelation her dad is a paedophile, manage the complicated effect on their relationship as she grieves for the man she thought he was, and then he now has a diagnosis of terminal cancer which must lead to so many conflicting emotions. On top of that she must have suffered abuse and shunning from people she knows.

I feel sorry for her and wouldn’t want to be in her position at all. I actually think she needs support from others. Maybe just have her and her child over to yours. She is not a criminal and people should not be punished for what their disgusting dads have done.

She is probably very lonely. I hope she is having some therapy. She will need it now and after her dad dies.

Hummingbird89 · 15/08/2023 06:52

People saying the OP is shunning this woman for her father’s crimes- I wouldn’t be shunning her for her father’s crimes, but for her own reaction to them. If she had a dad who was a paedophile but had zero contact with him and had cut him off, I wouldn’t even consider ending the friendship.

Blondeshavemorefun · 15/08/2023 06:41

Her dad did the Crimes not her

She was upfront and honest with you /dh

Is her dad staying at hers till he dies

As a parent I would need to make sure my child was protected

So wouldn't send dc to their home without me

But happy to have child at yours /meet at park /go to here with my dc

panko · 15/08/2023 06:37

Personally I'd say no playdates round hers until her dad has died.

Mollymalone123 · 15/08/2023 06:27

Op has your friend actually ever introduced her dc to her father or was she just telling you the rules around his conditions ? Everyone here is assuming she visits her father with her dc?
i know if a family in the same scenario of downloading images etc and worryingly it turns out it’s surprisingly common for men who are addicted to pornography who end up downloading child sex abuse images and extreme pornography as that is where the addiction has led them . This category seems to be treated as being out in sex offenders register and suspended sentence.this particular individual is deemed low risk of reoffending and has supervised access to his own dc. I’m not saying it doesn’t appal me but the people who understand this sort of thing definitely see it as a different issue and not true paedophilia. I’m sure they’ll be someone on mumsnet who can explain it better than me. All I’m saying is she has been upfront with you and sought your husband’s advice. I bet lots of people are allowing their children to play dates without truly knowing anything about their friend’s family-it’s hardly something you advertise.I really hope she isn’t on mumsnet as she’s being doubly punished here. She must be very conflicted about her father . Guilt must play a huge part and is she only now having contact because he is dying?

CallItLoneliness · 15/08/2023 06:23

Qilin · 15/08/2023 01:53

I think I'm just a bit shocked tbh. Also the way she said she would understand if we didn't want to be friends etc made me feel like that is a reasonable outcome iyswim.

I think it just shows that she has had to get used to people shunning her and her child as a result of her father's crimes.

Absolutely this. It has happened to her before, and therefore she knows to expect it, and doesn't want things to get even weirder.

I'm pretty appalled how many on this thread would punish a woman for a man's crimes. I had hoped that as a society, we were moving toward holding men responsible for their own crimes; this thread makes me despair.

AlexandriasWindmill · 15/08/2023 03:06

What does your DH think? I'm surprised he doesn't have a strong view about associating with someone who is in contact with a paedophile under a suspended sentence.
Ask yourself if you'd allow your DC to have even supervised contact with a convicted paedophile. I wouldn't. The fact she does points to her having poor judgement. Other people who know her father is a paedophile might also judge your parenting and approach to safeguarding.

Northernsouloldies · 15/08/2023 03:00

His crime and conviction, why should she and her children suffer because of what he done. Can't imagine the heartbreak finding out your dad is a nonce.

pompomdaisy · 15/08/2023 02:54

She's getting flamed by you when she's been totally open and honest. You're not her friend really are you? No friend of mine would behave like that. She deserves your honesty in return. If you don't feel your dc is safe then tell her. If you don't think she's made wise decisions tell her.

DebbieLouiseDairyleaCheese · 15/08/2023 02:40

I do understand your hesitation, but I think the fact she felt she could tell you, and also wanted to speak to your husband is really the best thing she could have done. I'm not sure as black and white, she's related to paedophile, so I would honestly put my guard up. But I agree that she's not done the crime and must feel such a dreadful mix of emotions.

TeenLifeMum · 15/08/2023 01:59

My friend’s brother did similar but a bit worse and was in prison for 18 months. Friend came round to tell me as she’d been my dc nanny when they were little and was worried some horrible trouble makers would get to me first with the news. He brother lived in a different county but after prison, lost his job so moved home with her parents temporarily. Lots of rules in place re her dc and they couldn’t see her brother. Her parents took him in because they thought he’d kill himself. I can’t imagine how hard it was but then for the bitchy mums at school to all pile in, refusing their dc to play with my friend’s dc. Those poor dc were horribly bullied. Friend did nothing wrong but she and her dc suffered awfully.

Qilin · 15/08/2023 01:53

I think I'm just a bit shocked tbh. Also the way she said she would understand if we didn't want to be friends etc made me feel like that is a reasonable outcome iyswim.

I think it just shows that she has had to get used to people shunning her and her child as a result of her father's crimes.

Qilin · 15/08/2023 01:50

It's not her crime and it's certainly not her DCs crime. They shouldn't have to pay for his wrong doing.

Although we think we might do something in advance, if and when events happen we really have no idea how we will actually react. She would have been conflicted - the dad she knew growing up and the man who commuted the crime. No one really knows what they'd do unless in that very situation.

GG1986 · 15/08/2023 01:39

I don't think you should punish the children because her dad is a paedo. Tell her you would rather meet at the park or a soft play.

WhereTheSuburbsMeetUttoxeter · 15/08/2023 01:30

I can't see anywhere that this woman has left her children unsupervised with this man.

Kids may be able to sleep over with locks on doors, but I can't see where this has actually happened.

Visit the man maybe - all under their mothers scrutiny I imagine.

I'd rather know who's who because then you know to be extra vigilant. I don't think OPs kids will be seeing the disgusting dying old perv for who I have zero sympathy.

How many generations of this family should suffer due to his actions. 2 are suffering already. When her kids remember grandad as nice man as they know no different, should their kids suffer too?