Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend's dad convicted paedophile. Wwyd?

163 replies

Namechangerererererer · 14/08/2023 18:22

Dc started school last year, got chatting to one of the other mums in the playground as our kids seem to get on well. She seems quite open and is has been telling me about her dad who is dying of cancer etc. I've tried to be supportive as much as an acquaintance would be.

Before we broke up for the holidays we agreed to meet up a few times so the kids could see each other. Met up last week, lovely few hours.

While we were chatting last week I mentioned dhs job, he's a pc. Didn't think anything of it tbh.

Then today she messaged asking if we want to go round to hers later in the week to play. I agreed and then she messaged a few hours later asking if she could speak to my dh. This happens now and again where people just want some police advice without ringing the police.

So she basically disclosed she was being harassed on social media by a now ex friend who had found out her dad is a convicted paedophile. He was apparently convicted for downloading images a few years ago and was given a suspended sentence.

Apparently he's not allowed unsupervised contact with her dc, dc is not allowed to stay over unless there's a lock on the door (!!) That sounds bizarre to me tbh. Her dad doesn't live with them and is unlikely to last til the end of the month.

She said she'd understand if we didn't want our dc to play together. I just don't know how to feel. Obviously it's not her crime, and her dc is totally innocent in this but there's something nagging at me that makes me very uncomfortable. I think it's the fact that despite the conviction she's obviously still supports him with his illness. If it was a family member of mine, they'd be dead to me.

Iabu- not her crime so shouldn't be punished

Ianbu- her judgements off and I'd be uncomfortable too

Also, bugger odd daily mail journalists.

OP posts:
Atethehalloweenchocs · 15/08/2023 21:52

Why does she want to have contact with him though? Who knowingly enjoys the company of paedophiles?

There are a lot of people who have contact with relatives through a feeling of duty or because there is no one else to help them who dont enjoy it.

It really isn’t difficult to cut contact with people, there is no need for her to see him or let him see her children (which presumably she does because otherwise she wouldn’t have said he can only see them when he is supervised, she would have said‘obviously I never let my children near him’)*

Thats a big presumption. It is highly likely she has been told that IF he was to have contact these things would have to be in place. They are pretty standard. We have no idea if there actually is contact.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 15/08/2023 21:49

Not sure I agree about the online abuse - I have an unusual surname and a druggie brother. Would not be hard to link us online and I regularly meet people who ask me or tell me about him. In real life I have not seen him for years because of his behaviour.

I did family therapy with people with mental health problems who had often committed crimes (including sexual abuse, drug crimes, murder - the worst was a teenage girl who had killed her baby). This was in another country. The research does show it helps to have family involvement and that the higher the isolation of the offender, the more likely they are to re-offend. You can never demand family stay involved of course, and sometime they had to cut off for safety and for their own mental health. I was always so moved by the people who were staying in touch while treading that line between holding their loved one to account and being supportive of them. It is a really hard thing to do because we tend to only want to feel one thing at a time. And I got to see how much family can suffer because of what someone else did - the horror of loving someone who does something so heinous, the anger, the shame of being related to this person, the shunning and abuse they can receive - people being driven out of their house or sacked. Even when it was family members who reported to the police or helped the police with their investigations. The MH implications for those innocent people can go through generations.

But you are right, there are a lot of offenders who will not change and the difficulty is figuring out which ones they are. Those are the ones who family may have to step away from. For what it is worth, as several people have said upthread, there does seem to be a difference in primary motivation. Some people are motivated by sexual sadism (in which case children are seen as ideal victims), some by sexual attraction to children (for which, incidentally, there is a real lack of support for those who are horrified by their attraction and want to resist) and some because their porn use is pushing them to break more and more boundaries to get their thrill. Why people access these images makes a big difference to how likely they are to change in future. And for me, that would make a difference to whether I could stay involved.

Giantpig · 15/08/2023 21:38

Atethehalloweenchocs · 15/08/2023 19:32

Yes, I do know that I would not want to be in contact with someone who condoned child abuse. Because that is what it is, condoning it.

How ridiculous. There is a big difference between having contact with someone and excusing what they have done. And in fact, black and white thinking that makes these situations worse - because people cant accept that they can still love and care about someone but hate/condemn/disagree with their actions, people minimize and dismiss wrongdoing so they can keep relationships going. Better to be realistic and honest, like this poor woman has been. As for her children having contact with him, there is no evidence of that here. And OP, never know who may pop round? Come on. You could say that about literally anyone.

Why does she want to have contact with him though? Who knowingly enjoys the company of paedophiles? It really isn’t difficult to cut contact with people, there is no need for her to see him or let him see her children (which presumably she does because otherwise she wouldn’t have said he can only see them when he is supervised, she would have said‘obviously I never let my children near him’)

Doyouknowtheway · 15/08/2023 21:26

@Atethehalloweenchocs well you'd have more experience than me.
But her having trouble online about her father tells me she's invested enough for people to have an issue with it.
Is a locked unit a place that families visit offenders?
I have read before that families sticking by offenders is supposed to help in rehabilitation but I don't believe certain people can change.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 15/08/2023 21:06

But we dont know that the OPs friend was minimizing what her father did @Doyouknowtheway . I agree that how people talk about what their relative did is really important. But it is not clear from the post what her attitude is. Having worked in locked units, I can vouch that relatives dont always minimize what their family member has done.

avemariiiaa · 15/08/2023 21:01

Your kids will never be in the presence of your friends dad, and you don't have to leave them in the care of your friend if without you being there ifit makes you uncomfortable.
But I wouldn't end a friendship over it, I would just be way more cautious overall with that particular friend.

Doyouknowtheway · 15/08/2023 20:34

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Atethehalloweenchocs · 15/08/2023 19:32

Yes, I do know that I would not want to be in contact with someone who condoned child abuse. Because that is what it is, condoning it.

How ridiculous. There is a big difference between having contact with someone and excusing what they have done. And in fact, black and white thinking that makes these situations worse - because people cant accept that they can still love and care about someone but hate/condemn/disagree with their actions, people minimize and dismiss wrongdoing so they can keep relationships going. Better to be realistic and honest, like this poor woman has been. As for her children having contact with him, there is no evidence of that here. And OP, never know who may pop round? Come on. You could say that about literally anyone.

Namechangerererererer · 15/08/2023 15:24

@x2boys hence the name change. There are no identifiable details. She could recognise herself but actually the thread is mostly supportive of her so it's not a bad thing to read. I've also said how horrendous I find it to her via whatsapp so there's nothing coming as a surprise.

I wanted anonymous opinions on a tricky situation which isn't unreasonable.

OP posts:
x2boys · 15/08/2023 15:21

If I found out my supposed friend had started a,thread on mums net about me posting very specific details about my situation the friend would nt have decide wether to cut all.contact with me I would be cutting all.contact with them

Namechangerererererer · 15/08/2023 15:21

I did message her back to say thanks for being upfront. Now the initial what the fuck feeling has worn off I will still go and see her. Her father doesn't live with her, and is bedridden at his home so there's no risk there.

She replied saying how horrible it was for her and her mum to deal with. Her mum didn't have funds to split so I think it's quite complicated.

I wouldn't leave my kids alone anyway on a play date because of things like this. You never know who might pop in for a cup of tea as a pp said.

OP posts:
drpet49 · 15/08/2023 14:08

Hummingbird89 · 15/08/2023 06:52

People saying the OP is shunning this woman for her father’s crimes- I wouldn’t be shunning her for her father’s crimes, but for her own reaction to them. If she had a dad who was a paedophile but had zero contact with him and had cut him off, I wouldn’t even consider ending the friendship.

Exactly this.

GingerIsBest · 15/08/2023 14:07

AlexandriasWindmill · 15/08/2023 13:05

It's a straw man to say we need to be compassionate to the family members of criminals. No-one is suggesting a lack of compassion. Posters are discussing a lack of physical access.
Yy family members are conflicted. Yy there are lots of emotions. But DCs rely on adults to keep them safe; and to prioritise their safety and vulnerability over putting them in contact with adults who have abused DCs.
No-one who has family members affected by this (and I do - both as victims and as convicted paedophiles) would be making excuses for abusers and letting them have access to their DCs - not even supervised visits. The posters white knighting for paedos need to take a long hard look at themselves. In fact I don't know why MN has even let this thread stand.

Quite a few comments have told OP to cut all ties with this woman because she has not cut all ties with her father and therefore she is "condoning" his behaviour.

That is different to saying you would not want your child to go to her father's house.

tillytoodles1 · 15/08/2023 13:30

A friend's dad was a convicted paedophile and they had no contact for years. He developed alzheimers, and he allowed him to live with them as their children had grown up.

AlexandriasWindmill · 15/08/2023 13:05

It's a straw man to say we need to be compassionate to the family members of criminals. No-one is suggesting a lack of compassion. Posters are discussing a lack of physical access.
Yy family members are conflicted. Yy there are lots of emotions. But DCs rely on adults to keep them safe; and to prioritise their safety and vulnerability over putting them in contact with adults who have abused DCs.
No-one who has family members affected by this (and I do - both as victims and as convicted paedophiles) would be making excuses for abusers and letting them have access to their DCs - not even supervised visits. The posters white knighting for paedos need to take a long hard look at themselves. In fact I don't know why MN has even let this thread stand.

Tessasanderson · 15/08/2023 12:47

You cant chose your family. Its 100% not her fault and from what you wrote, she has been absolutely honest and sounds like a very nice mother in unbelievably difficult conditions. Imagine putting yourself in her shoes or even the grandchilds shoes. Having to explain situations or deal with people not wanting to know you because of someone elses behaviour.

How about a reasonable compromise. Tell her you need to 100% protect your family so if she wants to stay friends then it can only be at your own home. That way you are guarenteed to be there and she should understand the need to be extra vigilant.

MsMarch · 15/08/2023 12:35

Greysofa · 15/08/2023 12:23

Yes, I do know that I would not want to be in contact with someone who condoned child abuse. Because that is what it is, condoning it. I work with the victims of this crime, even ‘just’ downloading images is abhorrent, because for that image to be taken, a child has been harmed. We all have our own values and stand points, and for me, someone who continues a relationship with a child abuser would not be someone I would want to be associated with.

You should be grateful you've never been in this situation or one similar to it. I know people who have and it's not as simple as saying that a parent is "condoning" child abuse if they still love their child or that an adult child is condoning their parents' poor behaviour. And where is the line? So child abusers must be immediately cut off from everyone but what about someone who murders someone? Or someone who steals? Or attacks someone on a drunken night out? Or causes a car accident....

And believe me, the family and loved ones of people who commit heinous crimes struggle a great deal with how to manage their conflicting feelings. A little compassion for those people would be nice.

GingerIsBest · 15/08/2023 12:32

Did she say her and her DD sleep at her father's house? Or just that part of the order was that if they DO, there needs to be a lock on the door? And unfortunately, I know from the personal experience of a friend, that a family member who is a paedophile may be a danger to one child, but not necessarily another because age/stage/gender plays such an important role which may impact her decision making, if, for example, as part of his care she sometimes feels she has to sleep at her father's house.

I don't think you should be cutting this woman off or refusing to allow her and your DD to be friends. This is HIS crime, not hers. Obviously, I can't imagine a situation where she would want your DD to be at her father's house, but that is a big fat no if she did.

I can appreciate that she is conflicted in her relationship with him but it's perfectly reasonable for you, a complete stranger, to have zero conflict in how you feel about him and a total unwillingness to engage with him in any way.

Greysofa · 15/08/2023 12:23

Alicethecamelhasa · 15/08/2023 10:54

@Greysofa

Theoretically, let’s say you found out your brother had downloaded images and your Mum, the lady who gave birth to him and has loved him unconditionally up until that point, wanted to remain in contact.

You literally have no idea how you would feel until the situation arises. You also have no idea who is doing what before you say my family member would never do that. Downloading indecent images is rife.

I am absolutely not defending those who do download them. It’s abhorrent but to judge their family members for wanting to stay in contact is wrong.

Yes, I do know that I would not want to be in contact with someone who condoned child abuse. Because that is what it is, condoning it. I work with the victims of this crime, even ‘just’ downloading images is abhorrent, because for that image to be taken, a child has been harmed. We all have our own values and stand points, and for me, someone who continues a relationship with a child abuser would not be someone I would want to be associated with.

Alicethecamelhasa · 15/08/2023 10:54

@Greysofa

Theoretically, let’s say you found out your brother had downloaded images and your Mum, the lady who gave birth to him and has loved him unconditionally up until that point, wanted to remain in contact.

You literally have no idea how you would feel until the situation arises. You also have no idea who is doing what before you say my family member would never do that. Downloading indecent images is rife.

I am absolutely not defending those who do download them. It’s abhorrent but to judge their family members for wanting to stay in contact is wrong.

Greysofa · 15/08/2023 10:47

Sorry, I couldn’t be friends with someone who has a relationship, in whatever form, with someone who they know is a paedophile. It’s hideous and how these horrible people work their way in to the lives of children.

NotAMug · 15/08/2023 10:41

CallItLoneliness · 15/08/2023 06:23

Absolutely this. It has happened to her before, and therefore she knows to expect it, and doesn't want things to get even weirder.

I'm pretty appalled how many on this thread would punish a woman for a man's crimes. I had hoped that as a society, we were moving toward holding men responsible for their own crimes; this thread makes me despair.

I haven't seen anyone say to punish her for her dad's crimes, the issue is that she still has contact with his and it appears her DCs do also. That shows awful judgement and also condones his crimes.

RedPony1 · 15/08/2023 10:19

My Grandad was a convicted sex offender too (all he got was a suspended sentence) - some victims were his own family. Weirdly, none of them cut complete contact, and one of his victims even cared for him in his final years.
My mum never let him in the house, visits etc. But my dad kept in minimal contact alone.

My friend's brother recently got convicted. List, suspended sentence and not allowed to live by a school. That's it. it's not downplaying what he done, but more a comment of that the punishment isnt enough! My friend has cut all ties with his brother, but his sister and mum havent. People deal with things differently.

Don't judge her on her dads actions.

BatsHaveButtcheeks · 15/08/2023 09:39

You don't know the full story and are judging her and shaming her on the Internet.

There is absolutely no risk to your children. You, like most of us, have zero experience of what its like to be in her shoes. You can say you'd behave a certain way, with all the conviction in the world - but do the complete opposite if the situation arose.

She gave you an out. Grow up and tell her you don't want to develop a friendship with her, nor your children to be friends with hers.

Hopingforno2in2023 · 15/08/2023 09:31

Unfortunately MIL is with a man who has accusations of crimes against children on his record. DS is not allowed any contact with him and is only allowed very limited contact with MIL (has to be in a public place and supervised at all times by DH). It has broken DH as he was v close to the man and to MIL but once he knew he had no other choice. I would be understanding if her DC have no contact with her father but if they do I can’t get my head around that at all. However as long as you supervise all play dates I can’t see there being an issue in terms of your DCs’ safety.

Swipe left for the next trending thread