Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend's dad convicted paedophile. Wwyd?

163 replies

Namechangerererererer · 14/08/2023 18:22

Dc started school last year, got chatting to one of the other mums in the playground as our kids seem to get on well. She seems quite open and is has been telling me about her dad who is dying of cancer etc. I've tried to be supportive as much as an acquaintance would be.

Before we broke up for the holidays we agreed to meet up a few times so the kids could see each other. Met up last week, lovely few hours.

While we were chatting last week I mentioned dhs job, he's a pc. Didn't think anything of it tbh.

Then today she messaged asking if we want to go round to hers later in the week to play. I agreed and then she messaged a few hours later asking if she could speak to my dh. This happens now and again where people just want some police advice without ringing the police.

So she basically disclosed she was being harassed on social media by a now ex friend who had found out her dad is a convicted paedophile. He was apparently convicted for downloading images a few years ago and was given a suspended sentence.

Apparently he's not allowed unsupervised contact with her dc, dc is not allowed to stay over unless there's a lock on the door (!!) That sounds bizarre to me tbh. Her dad doesn't live with them and is unlikely to last til the end of the month.

She said she'd understand if we didn't want our dc to play together. I just don't know how to feel. Obviously it's not her crime, and her dc is totally innocent in this but there's something nagging at me that makes me very uncomfortable. I think it's the fact that despite the conviction she's obviously still supports him with his illness. If it was a family member of mine, they'd be dead to me.

Iabu- not her crime so shouldn't be punished

Ianbu- her judgements off and I'd be uncomfortable too

Also, bugger odd daily mail journalists.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WhereTheTeapotsJibberJabberJoo · 23/08/2023 21:48

babbscrabbs · 19/08/2023 15:21

You will never leave your kids alone on a play date?

Ever?

What happens when they reach the age they want some independence?

By that age they will hopefully know what to do if a paedophile tries to do anything inappropriate with them. Small children can't defend themselves as easily.

Cattenberg · 23/08/2023 21:40

What about the argument that paedophiles with family support are less likely to reoffend? I don’t know if this is true, by the way, but it’s often mentioned on here.

Giantpig · 20/08/2023 12:46

CallItLoneliness · 20/08/2023 10:34

That I have no idea of the impact of CSA. That I propose centering the experiences of abusers. Just for two.

Um, you did propose centring the needs of abusers. Your argument is ‘abusers exist and families don’t want to cut them off so we should find a way to protect kids while still supporting abusers’. My argument is no one in their right mind would care what a paedophile wants or needs, and they don’t deserve support in ill health or any other situation.

Also I didn’t assume you do or don’t know anything about CSA, I said your posts make it sound like you either don’t know or don’t care.

CallItLoneliness · 20/08/2023 10:34

Giantpig · 19/08/2023 15:13

What assumptions?!

That I have no idea of the impact of CSA. That I propose centering the experiences of abusers. Just for two.

SlippySarah · 19/08/2023 15:36

Controversial I know, but I'd still have something of a relationship with close family even if they had been convicted of very serious crimes. Its possible to not be collusive or an apologist, to protect yourself and others and still offer some support - emotional, practical etc to someone that you feel a personal connection to.

babbscrabbs · 19/08/2023 15:21

Namechangerererererer · 15/08/2023 15:21

I did message her back to say thanks for being upfront. Now the initial what the fuck feeling has worn off I will still go and see her. Her father doesn't live with her, and is bedridden at his home so there's no risk there.

She replied saying how horrible it was for her and her mum to deal with. Her mum didn't have funds to split so I think it's quite complicated.

I wouldn't leave my kids alone anyway on a play date because of things like this. You never know who might pop in for a cup of tea as a pp said.

You will never leave your kids alone on a play date?

Ever?

What happens when they reach the age they want some independence?

Giantpig · 19/08/2023 15:13

CallItLoneliness · 19/08/2023 13:11

You're making an awful lot of assumptions there. Most of them are incorrect, but hey, I hope they make you feel better.

What assumptions?!

AdoraBell · 19/08/2023 13:22

I voted YANBU, but I agree that it’s not her crime. I would cut contact if any of my relatives/friends were convicted of this crime, but some people find it difficult to let go of the person they experienced.

In this instance I wouldn’t let my DC go to her home.

CallItLoneliness · 19/08/2023 13:15

NeverNoMore221 · 18/08/2023 06:37

One of the articles you have linked is from Cosmopolitan Magazine 🤣

It also references a very questionable study. It was only included 73 men and was hardly representative of the general population - they were all American university students.

I’m not saying I disagree with your general argument - I’m sure there are many more male sexual predators around than most women realise.

However, there is a huge difference between knowingly and unknowingly supporting or associating with male sex offenders.

Yeah, so I generally do try to link to (accurate) representations of academic research in the popular media, because most academics don't write for a general audience, and much research is paywalled. I've read the original study, and it is...at best, worrisome.

CallItLoneliness · 19/08/2023 13:11

Giantpig · 18/08/2023 12:25

I’m nothing like privileged thanks, neither are the many survivors I have known who have all cut off their abusers and the family who stand by them.

Expecting people to centre decisions around abusers and the best way to support them speaks of the privilege of not knowing the effects that CSA has.

You're making an awful lot of assumptions there. Most of them are incorrect, but hey, I hope they make you feel better.

Giantpig · 18/08/2023 12:25

CallItLoneliness · 18/08/2023 01:50

To everyone on this thread who says "I could never..." one in 25 men is a rapist. One in three men would rape if they could get away with it. Between 1/100 and 1/20 men is a paedophile. The fact of the matter is, you already are supporting a man who has done something we consider monstrous, that is a near statistical certainty. Whether we like it or not, these crimes are not rare, and we need to find ways to deal with them that are actually realistic and actually protect women and children, and perpetuating the myth of "only monsters..." opens the door to "but he's such a nice guy, he would never..." defences. Until there is an island somewhere to which we are prepared to export 1/5 of the male population (who in your life would you export?) "just cut them off" is an answer that speaks of the privilege of not having had to deal with the reality

I’m nothing like privileged thanks, neither are the many survivors I have known who have all cut off their abusers and the family who stand by them.

Expecting people to centre decisions around abusers and the best way to support them speaks of the privilege of not knowing the effects that CSA has.

NeverNoMore221 · 18/08/2023 06:37

CallItLoneliness · 18/08/2023 01:50

To everyone on this thread who says "I could never..." one in 25 men is a rapist. One in three men would rape if they could get away with it. Between 1/100 and 1/20 men is a paedophile. The fact of the matter is, you already are supporting a man who has done something we consider monstrous, that is a near statistical certainty. Whether we like it or not, these crimes are not rare, and we need to find ways to deal with them that are actually realistic and actually protect women and children, and perpetuating the myth of "only monsters..." opens the door to "but he's such a nice guy, he would never..." defences. Until there is an island somewhere to which we are prepared to export 1/5 of the male population (who in your life would you export?) "just cut them off" is an answer that speaks of the privilege of not having had to deal with the reality

One of the articles you have linked is from Cosmopolitan Magazine 🤣

It also references a very questionable study. It was only included 73 men and was hardly representative of the general population - they were all American university students.

I’m not saying I disagree with your general argument - I’m sure there are many more male sexual predators around than most women realise.

However, there is a huge difference between knowingly and unknowingly supporting or associating with male sex offenders.

CallItLoneliness · 18/08/2023 01:50

To everyone on this thread who says "I could never..." one in 25 men is a rapist. One in three men would rape if they could get away with it. Between 1/100 and 1/20 men is a paedophile. The fact of the matter is, you already are supporting a man who has done something we consider monstrous, that is a near statistical certainty. Whether we like it or not, these crimes are not rare, and we need to find ways to deal with them that are actually realistic and actually protect women and children, and perpetuating the myth of "only monsters..." opens the door to "but he's such a nice guy, he would never..." defences. Until there is an island somewhere to which we are prepared to export 1/5 of the male population (who in your life would you export?) "just cut them off" is an answer that speaks of the privilege of not having had to deal with the reality

https://time.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/repeat_rape.pdf

Atethehalloweenchocs · 16/08/2023 22:40

do you really think she would have talked about the conditions for her child staying over rather than just saying he doesn’t see them? Obviously we don’t know for sure,

No, we dont know. And yes, I think she may have talked about that to reassure someone that things were safe.

As for the research, look up effects on mental health of family estrangement. Easy to access online.

Greenwitchhorse · 16/08/2023 01:12

I could never stand by a paedophile, relative or not.

I would cut them out of my life the minute I hear about what they did. They are the worst and I don't believe they can ever change.

So I would question her judgement and I would not want to be around her.

Giantpig · 15/08/2023 23:37

@Cattenberg cutting of an abusive parent isn’t the same as cutting off a child, it’s a different relationship.

For one thing many abusive people were abused as children (I don’t mean that most/all survivors become abusers, the vast majority don’t- but when you investigate the background of abusers, being victims is often a feature). So maybe they feel guilty about something. Maybe they condone his crimes. Or maybe they think they can better keep their grandchildren safe if they watch him with them since they aren’t able to stop his contact with them.

Whatever their deal is it doesn’t mean the op should be friends with someone she isn’t sure about!

Hummingbird89 · 15/08/2023 23:32

@Cattenberg it depends on the crime commuted. Honestly, a crime as heinous as child sex abuse, yes I think I would.
Shoplifting/tax evasion/traffic offences, no I wouldn’t. There’s massive grey areas in between and it would take a huge amount for me to cut off my son but honestly if he was a paedophile, yes I believe I would.

Cattenberg · 15/08/2023 23:11

Hummingbird89 · 15/08/2023 22:16

@Cattenberg what crime though? We’re not talking about council tax dodging here, he’s a convicted paedo.
I am honestly so, so shocked at the responses in this thread. Gobsmacked.

@Hummingbird89 , so if you were in the same situation as the couple I mentioned, you’d cut off your son, even if it meant not seeing your grandchildren again? Their mother wouldn’t facilitate contact with her ex’s family.

Sorry to detail the thread slightly. But I hope it doesn’t descend into the typical Mumsnet argument of, “I hate paedophiles more than you”, “no, you don’t, I hate them more than you”, because I don’t think that’s very helpful.

Doggyhelp · 15/08/2023 23:00

I’m quite a sceptical person.

I would want to know exactly what his crime was to make sure my friend wasn’t watering it down to make it more “palatable”.

I would want to know who is harassing her and why. Is it a person linked to the abuse/images?

I would want to know who decided a locked door was an acceptable safeguard from a convicted criminal.

Knowing the answer to the above would inform my view. I don’t hold a relative accountable for a crime but I do have a view if they facilitate lies and minimising.

On a personal note I would be angry that id been told all about the cancer etc and probably emotionally invested a lot in being there for a friend in need. If I then found out the person I felt sad for was nothing but a dirty nonce I would feel deceived. But that’s just my personal response based upon a few lives experiences.

HopefulSeller · 15/08/2023 22:41

I think it helps to separate out the issues.

It isn’t her crime - but we don’t really know how much she and her mum support her Dad, but that she hasn’t cut off and does on some level emotionally support him.

Your DC aren’t in danger and we presume she hasn’t put her own kids in danger.

She was open and honest, but in a way that was about getting help for herself first (contacting your DH and asking for his help).

So for me this would put me off my friend. I think because she involved you in expressing sympathy for her with her Dad being ill, without knowing. She has made the decision to still give him emotional support. And because there is a certain amount of drama. I don’t think I would want to be near that drama, or support someone supporting their father who had done this. It’s their decision of course, but I think it would be hard to be someone’s friend and there is also the whole back story which is quite a heavy load for a friendship.

Giantpig · 15/08/2023 22:36

Atethehalloweenchocs · 15/08/2023 21:54

And, by the way @Giantpig , the research shows that 75% of people who initiate a family estrangement regret it. While it is important to do at times, it is never easy and there are huge MH implications.

What research?

Giantpig · 15/08/2023 22:29

Atethehalloweenchocs · 15/08/2023 21:52

Why does she want to have contact with him though? Who knowingly enjoys the company of paedophiles?

There are a lot of people who have contact with relatives through a feeling of duty or because there is no one else to help them who dont enjoy it.

It really isn’t difficult to cut contact with people, there is no need for her to see him or let him see her children (which presumably she does because otherwise she wouldn’t have said he can only see them when he is supervised, she would have said‘obviously I never let my children near him’)*

Thats a big presumption. It is highly likely she has been told that IF he was to have contact these things would have to be in place. They are pretty standard. We have no idea if there actually is contact.

No one has a duty to paedophiles. If abusers end up without anyone to care for them in illness/ old age that’s their own doing.

If she doesn’t let her kids see him, and she is at pains to let people know she doesn’t condone his crime and isn’t a risk to their children, do you really think she would have talked about the conditions for her child staying over rather than just saying he doesn’t see them? Obviously we don’t know for sure, we don’t know anything about it- but if I was trying to convince someone of this I wouldn’t be even mentioning my child in the same sentence as sleeping over at his house.

Hummingbird89 · 15/08/2023 22:16

@Cattenberg what crime though? We’re not talking about council tax dodging here, he’s a convicted paedo.
I am honestly so, so shocked at the responses in this thread. Gobsmacked.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 15/08/2023 21:54

And, by the way @Giantpig , the research shows that 75% of people who initiate a family estrangement regret it. While it is important to do at times, it is never easy and there are huge MH implications.

Cattenberg · 15/08/2023 21:53

Alicethecamelhasa · 14/08/2023 18:55

I’d like those who say that a relative would be dead to them if they got convicted of downloading indecent images of children to come back when they are in that situation. Because, honestly, I would have said that before it happened to me. When it’s someone you have loved your entire life then it might be different.

I know an elderly couple whose adult son was convicted of this crime. They still have a relationship with him. This might be because a) their only other child died very young and b) if they cut off their son, they would likely lose contact with their grandchildren who are clearly the light of their lives.

In theory these scenarios might look black-and-white, but in real life, things often aren’t that simple.