Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents penalised for formula feeding

683 replies

thechristmaspudding · 14/08/2023 17:56

I just wanted to open up a discussion to find out the perspectives of other parents on this subject. I would also be interested to hear the opinions of midwives, health visitors and other health care professionals involved with families.
To give a bit of background information, I am a member of the Boots parenting club, which has many parents are likely to be aware gives you access to discounts and offers on baby related items in store. I went into my local boots today to buy my son's formula, hoping to get a good deal as I had been notified of an offer in store. Now, in my sleep deprived state I did not read the offer properly and it did clearly state that it was an offer for follow on formula and not infant first. The cashier was very polite and explained that due to government regulations shops are not legally allowed to offer discounts on infant first formula due to the government expectation that breastfeeding should be encouraged for the first six months. To be clear, I am not taking issue with Boots or any other shop, but it got me questioning whether this is fair? No, I do not believe that formula companies should be able to dissuade women from breastfeeding through aggressive marketing campaigns that encourage parents to buy their product. But surely parents have the right to weigh up the pros and cons of bottle feeding and make an informed choice that reflects the needs and circumstances of their own family? I tried really, really hard to breastfeed but found it extremely difficult and due to a lack of postnatal support gave up (the inadequate breastfeeding support in this country is another issue in itself). This is something I still regret and struggle with. However, my personal experience aside, formula feeding is a valid choice to make whether parents decide to feed this way from birth or at a later stage.
I also remember watching an episode of dispatches a few years ago on how due to the cost of formula many families resort to watering down their baby's feed or even to stealing. This is a situation that is likely to have worsened as a result of the cost of living crisis.
So my question is, AIBU in thinking that it is wrong to penalise bottle-feeding parents when it comes to the cost of formula?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
FloweryName · 15/08/2023 13:35

WeetabixTowels · 15/08/2023 12:56

I think people should be accounting for the fact that circumstances change in pregnancies sometimes and whilst £46 a month may have been affordable when trying, job losses, shit maternity pay rules etc can result in this being a huge cost.

Having children was always going to cost money though and formula companies aren’t obliged to sell their product at cost to compensate for normal life happening to people.

Formula feeding parents should be able to manage the cost of it between two adults, healthy start vouchers, child benefit, universal credit elements related to children and food banks should they need to.

Honestlyy · 15/08/2023 13:11

IhaveanewTVnow · 15/08/2023 12:14

It hasn’t triggered me. I did breast feed. I just think those comments are insulting to women that are already feeling vulnerable, disappointed, failing etc. they don’t need to be told that they didn’t try hard enough or phone enough people for help etc.

I acknowledged that women feel they unable to because of not having facts, support and advice.
It doesn't change the fact that it is very rare for a woman to be physically incapable of feeding.

WhatNoRaisins · 15/08/2023 13:08

Personally I had no idea until after my first child was born how expensive formula was. It wasn't talked about at all antenatally. I also didn't know that the formula you saw advertised on TV wasn't meant for newborns.

WeetabixTowels · 15/08/2023 12:56

I think people should be accounting for the fact that circumstances change in pregnancies sometimes and whilst £46 a month may have been affordable when trying, job losses, shit maternity pay rules etc can result in this being a huge cost.

Somethingsnappy · 15/08/2023 12:36

WouldJustlikeaLatte · 15/08/2023 11:49

FF does not INCREASE the risk of SIDS. BF lowers the risk yes but FF does not increase it 🤦‍♀️

You are absolutely wrong. You may not like the language, and that's understandable, but we take breastfeeding as the baseline, as it's the norm, biologically speaking. So any risks are compared with breastfeeding as the starting point.

Oliotya · 15/08/2023 12:18

AdaAnt · 15/08/2023 11:40

What are you ON?? Broken down it’s approx £46 a month per child. It’s one of the biggest reasons why poor British babies who are formula fed have d&v because it’s so expensive parents often use expired / dilute etc. Breastfeeding doesn’t cost nearly as much as this (even if you take into account the cake addiction)!

£46 doesn't seem all that much. I spend far more than that each on food for my kids.

IhaveanewTVnow · 15/08/2023 12:14

Honestlyy · 15/08/2023 08:58

Just because it's triggered you doesn't mean it's not true. It really is a very small number of women who really physically can't feed. Lots of women feel they are unable to, however because they've received inadequate support and shitty advice.

In some of the breastfeeding groups I'm in, there are women on their third or fourth child who are happy that they're finally managing to breastfeed because they've received proper advice and support.

It hasn’t triggered me. I did breast feed. I just think those comments are insulting to women that are already feeling vulnerable, disappointed, failing etc. they don’t need to be told that they didn’t try hard enough or phone enough people for help etc.

littleboymama · 15/08/2023 12:11

I exclusively formula feed my son due to the fact he was in the neonatal / NICU at the start of his life on a feeding tube. He wasn’t able to breastfeed because of this but I pumped and we use formula to top up. Formula saved my son, he would have died without it. He didn’t want to latch, even with help and after 7 weeks of bottle combi feeding and my supply dropping due to anxiety I now formula only.

Those stating that BF babies have lower SIDS risks, all these benefits etc are correct. I really do understand why they try and push breastfeeding, if you can do it rather than formula feed and that’s coming from a FF mum.

That being said it’s also a kicker when you buy formula tins or go on formula websites and they state how breastfeeding is better than formula - knowing you aren’t able too and reading that, yes it’s true but can be hard to read. World breastfeeding week was hard for me.

So I do kind of understand why you don’t get extra reward prices on first infant milk, obviously I massively agree formula is extremely expensive. I think I go through a tin every 4/5 days.

Loverofoxbowlakes · 15/08/2023 12:10

AdaAnt · 15/08/2023 11:40

What are you ON?? Broken down it’s approx £46 a month per child. It’s one of the biggest reasons why poor British babies who are formula fed have d&v because it’s so expensive parents often use expired / dilute etc. Breastfeeding doesn’t cost nearly as much as this (even if you take into account the cake addiction)!

Yes, that's my maths too, around £46 a month to ff a baby. One of the (many) necessary costs of having a baby that the majority of uk parents should be factoring into the cost of having a child.

I agree that poorer families (those who would be eligible for FSM for example) should have some additional financial support (or additional support to bf).

But still there is no PENALTY for ff, it's just a cost of raising a child.

In another example, look at the price of nappies - disposable vs myriad washable types.

Ghan · 15/08/2023 11:58

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

doroda · 15/08/2023 11:57

WouldJustlikeaLatte · 15/08/2023 11:49

FF does not INCREASE the risk of SIDS. BF lowers the risk yes but FF does not increase it 🤦‍♀️

No. BF is the biological norm, so it doesn't lower the risk of anything.
The risks are increased with FF, as the artificial choice.

Ghan · 15/08/2023 11:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Simonjt · 15/08/2023 11:52

Loverofoxbowlakes · 15/08/2023 11:35

So I'm a little bit anal and have just worked out that (according to C&G first milk recommended scoops/bottle/days) over a whole year a baby 'should' drink the equivalent of just about 52 tubs of formula in their first year.

Which, for C&G works out to be around £550 in their first year.

Hardly breaking the bank (for MOST families) when you think of how much we spend on car seats, cots, pushchairs/prams, toys they'll never use, clothes they'll never wear, shoes they won't even touch the floor in, in their first year.

It's the equivalent of a decent takeaway and some beers/wine once a month. In the grand scheme of things I don't think it's a massive expense (knowing how much teenagers cost to feed, my school dinners are costing me £200 a month in September for one 'meal' a day for 2 teens). I bf'd mine and I know I consumed far more than a tenner's worth of extra calories over the first 12m to produce that 'oh so special' elixir but the cost to my MH as nobody else could feed was far more.

We couldn’t use cows milk based formula due to my son having a severe allergy to cows milk. If we had had to pay for our daughters formula on 104 tins (smaller size than C&G) it would have cost around £4,000 in the first year.

WouldJustlikeaLatte · 15/08/2023 11:49

ButterCrackers · 15/08/2023 09:41

@georgianwindow read about the benefits of breast milk. Links to research as well https://www.laleche.org.uk/amazing-milk/

FF does not INCREASE the risk of SIDS. BF lowers the risk yes but FF does not increase it 🤦‍♀️

Somethingsnappy · 15/08/2023 11:47

WeWereInParis · 15/08/2023 09:47

Has it been proven scientifically? If it has parents need to know

Yes, it has. It shouldn't be a controversial statement, it's just a fact.

Yes, this is true. The reasons being it are not yet properly understood though. While we do know that SIDS is a higher risk for babies that aren't breastfed, we have yet to fully understand why, although there are some pretty robust theories.

As others have said, nobody should feel ashamed to state facts. But there is also no need for people to panic or feel upset. Statistics about risk can be applied to many other aspects of baby rearing too, many of which don't seem to make people panic in the same way.

AdaAnt · 15/08/2023 11:45

WeetabixTowels · 15/08/2023 11:07

They just didn’t produce enough milk.

This is why education is vital - because this is so fleetingly rare and no evidence that it’s genetic. Very, very few women don’t produce milk. If their baby seems hungry or fussy it’s likely very little to do with having ‘no milk’ and it can be rectified with the right support and advice.

I have met so many women who think they’ll be unable to breastfeed and I really don’t understand why the NHS doesn’t promote better and more honest information around breastfeeding. Are they still telling women breastfeeding shouldn’t hurt? The biggest load of nonsense I’ve ever heard!

Accurate.

I do think one of the reasons why wealthy and poc women of all income classes are more likely to breasfeed is because they have been taught how - either by buying in support, or by their mums / female relatives who breastfed. I have pcos and was told by ignorant NHS midwives that I’d automatically have lower milk supply and then after DS was born that was blamed for him not feeding (despite me feeding DD well). I had to fight to even get his tongue examined and even then it only happened because I paid for a private mw who recommended it.

AdaAnt · 15/08/2023 11:40

Loverofoxbowlakes · 15/08/2023 11:35

So I'm a little bit anal and have just worked out that (according to C&G first milk recommended scoops/bottle/days) over a whole year a baby 'should' drink the equivalent of just about 52 tubs of formula in their first year.

Which, for C&G works out to be around £550 in their first year.

Hardly breaking the bank (for MOST families) when you think of how much we spend on car seats, cots, pushchairs/prams, toys they'll never use, clothes they'll never wear, shoes they won't even touch the floor in, in their first year.

It's the equivalent of a decent takeaway and some beers/wine once a month. In the grand scheme of things I don't think it's a massive expense (knowing how much teenagers cost to feed, my school dinners are costing me £200 a month in September for one 'meal' a day for 2 teens). I bf'd mine and I know I consumed far more than a tenner's worth of extra calories over the first 12m to produce that 'oh so special' elixir but the cost to my MH as nobody else could feed was far more.

What are you ON?? Broken down it’s approx £46 a month per child. It’s one of the biggest reasons why poor British babies who are formula fed have d&v because it’s so expensive parents often use expired / dilute etc. Breastfeeding doesn’t cost nearly as much as this (even if you take into account the cake addiction)!

Loverofoxbowlakes · 15/08/2023 11:35

So I'm a little bit anal and have just worked out that (according to C&G first milk recommended scoops/bottle/days) over a whole year a baby 'should' drink the equivalent of just about 52 tubs of formula in their first year.

Which, for C&G works out to be around £550 in their first year.

Hardly breaking the bank (for MOST families) when you think of how much we spend on car seats, cots, pushchairs/prams, toys they'll never use, clothes they'll never wear, shoes they won't even touch the floor in, in their first year.

It's the equivalent of a decent takeaway and some beers/wine once a month. In the grand scheme of things I don't think it's a massive expense (knowing how much teenagers cost to feed, my school dinners are costing me £200 a month in September for one 'meal' a day for 2 teens). I bf'd mine and I know I consumed far more than a tenner's worth of extra calories over the first 12m to produce that 'oh so special' elixir but the cost to my MH as nobody else could feed was far more.

FloweryName · 15/08/2023 11:23

Why is formula the only product that to be 'ethical' needs to promote itself into being used less?

If there weren’t a ban on promoting formula how would you protect babies from the effect of parents who chased special offers instead of sticking to one brand that they know their baby can have?

People would be chopping and changing their brands of formula all over the place just to get the cheap deals or the most points. That is not something that would be good for babies, even if it were good for parents wallets.

WeetabixTowels · 15/08/2023 11:17

BTW I agree with whoever said baby food labelling is far more harmful than formula. Why is it allowed to be labelled 4 months+? I know a GP can prescribe early weaning for various reasons but prettt much everyone I know weaned early, which is heavily against medical advice, because it looks like it’s ‘allowed’ and trying new things after a boring 4 months of a newborn is exciting.

WeetabixTowels · 15/08/2023 11:07

They just didn’t produce enough milk.

This is why education is vital - because this is so fleetingly rare and no evidence that it’s genetic. Very, very few women don’t produce milk. If their baby seems hungry or fussy it’s likely very little to do with having ‘no milk’ and it can be rectified with the right support and advice.

I have met so many women who think they’ll be unable to breastfeed and I really don’t understand why the NHS doesn’t promote better and more honest information around breastfeeding. Are they still telling women breastfeeding shouldn’t hurt? The biggest load of nonsense I’ve ever heard!

Margrethe · 15/08/2023 11:02

This thread reminds me of a dear friend from 20 tears ago. She was very depressed because she could not breast feed her baby. She was from East Germany, her mother hadn’t been able to breast feed, nor her grandmother. It was a genetic thing. They just didn’t produce enough milk. In East Germany, in the old days, you couldn’t just buy formula. You could only get it by prescription from the doctor. She felt such sorrow and shame.

So, I don’t think treating formula like restricted product really does anyone any good.

That said, I breast fed each of mine for over a year. I do think it’s far better to feed babies, fresh, live milk delivered by their mother’s embrace, rather than starting life on UPF.

We can only give facts and trust that mothers love their children and have very good reasons for feeding their infants as they do.

Twizbe · 15/08/2023 10:21

I see I was unclear in what I meant. I didn’t mean for formula to be in private companies hands therefore not branded. I also meant that the money they can spend on marketing be available for breastfeeding support. Not that the companies themselves should unbrand or spend their money on it.

Babyboomtastic · 15/08/2023 10:05

Twizbe · 15/08/2023 09:15

No one said they should be forced to sell it unbranded or use their marketing budgets for that. It would be great if formula wasn’t in the hands of private companies and if health authorities had their marketing budgets for breastfeeding support.

wine does carry warnings about drinking to excess. But wine and condoms are products chosen by adults to be used by adults. Nappies don’t have the potential for life threatening illness if used incorrectly.

You said this:

"In an ideal world formula would be unbranded and available at cost price for those who need / want it. All those advertising budgets would go towards universal breastfeeding support and correcting the mass of misinformation out there."

So you actually are advocating for formula companies to sell unbranded and use their marketing budgets to promote breastfeeding.