Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents penalised for formula feeding

683 replies

thechristmaspudding · 14/08/2023 17:56

I just wanted to open up a discussion to find out the perspectives of other parents on this subject. I would also be interested to hear the opinions of midwives, health visitors and other health care professionals involved with families.
To give a bit of background information, I am a member of the Boots parenting club, which has many parents are likely to be aware gives you access to discounts and offers on baby related items in store. I went into my local boots today to buy my son's formula, hoping to get a good deal as I had been notified of an offer in store. Now, in my sleep deprived state I did not read the offer properly and it did clearly state that it was an offer for follow on formula and not infant first. The cashier was very polite and explained that due to government regulations shops are not legally allowed to offer discounts on infant first formula due to the government expectation that breastfeeding should be encouraged for the first six months. To be clear, I am not taking issue with Boots or any other shop, but it got me questioning whether this is fair? No, I do not believe that formula companies should be able to dissuade women from breastfeeding through aggressive marketing campaigns that encourage parents to buy their product. But surely parents have the right to weigh up the pros and cons of bottle feeding and make an informed choice that reflects the needs and circumstances of their own family? I tried really, really hard to breastfeed but found it extremely difficult and due to a lack of postnatal support gave up (the inadequate breastfeeding support in this country is another issue in itself). This is something I still regret and struggle with. However, my personal experience aside, formula feeding is a valid choice to make whether parents decide to feed this way from birth or at a later stage.
I also remember watching an episode of dispatches a few years ago on how due to the cost of formula many families resort to watering down their baby's feed or even to stealing. This is a situation that is likely to have worsened as a result of the cost of living crisis.
So my question is, AIBU in thinking that it is wrong to penalise bottle-feeding parents when it comes to the cost of formula?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Ghan · 16/08/2023 12:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Oliotya · 16/08/2023 12:36

FlipFlop1987 · 16/08/2023 12:17

Think they asked around the ethics/economical impact of points for formula not individuals being targeted because they are unable to breastfeed. The breastfeeding brigade are vicious behind a computer screen

It's not an attack to state statistics. People tend to perceive facts and opinions as attacks because it's an emotive subject. There's an awful lot of projection on these threads and not much room for objectivity.

Weddingblues23 · 16/08/2023 12:31

FlipFlop1987 · 16/08/2023 12:17

Think they asked around the ethics/economical impact of points for formula not individuals being targeted because they are unable to breastfeed. The breastfeeding brigade are vicious behind a computer screen

Nobody cares how anybody feeds their kid. Some people do care when formula is deemed of equal nutritional value as breastmilk, because that simply isn't true. Pointing that out isnt judging people who choose to feed formula. The fact that some mums who formula feed are upset by it is unfortunate, but it doesn't mean that they are being judged.

FlipFlop1987 · 16/08/2023 12:17

Oliotya · 15/08/2023 19:40

Most people don't care irl. But OP asked for a discussion. So it's being discussed.

Think they asked around the ethics/economical impact of points for formula not individuals being targeted because they are unable to breastfeed. The breastfeeding brigade are vicious behind a computer screen

MarleyMallow · 16/08/2023 11:59

@thechristmaspudding you have no need to explain anything. Formula feeding doesn’t need to be defended - you do what you do because it’s best for you and your family, no matter what the reasons are. Please ignore anyone telling you you should have breastfed or ff is wrong. It isn’t. Unfortunately judgement towards parental choices, especially mothers, is rife and it will happen a lot! Stand tall, you’re doing what you need to for your family. X

thechristmaspudding · 16/08/2023 11:56

,*Chocolate, crisps, oven chips...those foods have next to no nutrional value

OP posts:
thechristmaspudding · 16/08/2023 11:50

I wanted to give one last up to date as I feel like I've planted a bomb by starting this thread. I wanted to start a discussion about how families could be better supported with the cost of formula during this cost of living crisis that we all face, and whether or not easing the regulations around shops being able to offer promotions on first infant formula would help with that. I was prepared and happy for people to disagree with me on this. I am a 35 year old woman, I have come accross many people in my life who hold a difference of opinion to me, I really do not get offended by it and in fact I welcome it as it gives life a dose of variety. However, this thread descended into chaos very quickly and it was never my intention to start a discussion that would lead to mothers, both breast feeding and formula feeding, to feel ashamed by their choices. It was one of the worst days of my life when my son got admitted to hospital with severe weight loss and dehydration, and I am ashamed to say that rather than being thankful when a doctor came into the room with a little bottle of formula for me to supplement with to help my baby to recover, all I felt was a deep sense of failure and embarrassment. It caused a bout of postnatal depression for me and even now, even though my son is thriving, I am still often kept awake at night wandering if I have failed as a mother. No new mother should feel like that. I spike to a friend of mine who is a senior community midwife and has previously worked as a senior midwife on a delivery ward about this thread. Her words are that yes of course breastfeeding should be championed as the healthiest choice for babies, formula is not the 'devil' and is a healthy and valid alternative. She gets many new mothers coming to her in tears as they have been told they are feeding their babies an ultra processed for when giving formula. Again, in her words, although formula is processed I the sense of how it is produced, it is not to be put on the same category as UPF such as chocolate, crisps and frozen chips. Those food have next to nutritional value. Formula on the other hand is highly nutritious for babies. On a final point she stated that community midwifery services are vastly over stretched and that most new mothers leave the hospital with the intention to breast feed, bit community midwives in her area are able to see mothers on day 1 and then not again until the baby is five days old. By day five, if a mother has struggled and lost confidence in breast feeding it is often too late to rectify that and they are likely, in a panic, to already have turned to formula. I doubt if I will return to this thread again as I don't feel it is doing anyone any good. But on a final note, as I often tell the students I work with, you may feel you are anonymous online and therefore can say what you like, but the people on the other end of your comments are real and your words have real life consequences. So please think before you become a keyboard warrior and seek to shame others.

OP posts:
Weddingblues23 · 16/08/2023 11:29

Tygertiger · 16/08/2023 10:36

This is an utter myth. As if it would be remotely ethical for the cheapest milk to have inferior ingredients. The ingredients in formula are regulated. Companies add in things to justify the price on “premium” brands but there’s no evidence they have benefit - because if anything is found to have proven benefits, it then becomes mandatory for all manufacturers to add it. But essentially formula is cows’ milk, vegetable oil, sugar and vitamins. There’s basically no difference between the brands, cost is no indication of quality (it is about trying to attract a different category of consumer, see previous discussion on the thread) and if anything, switching brands is beneficial as it means babies get a slightly different taste which more closely replicates the experience they get with breastmilk.

I wasn't talking about inferior ingredients in cheaper milk - just that a cheaper price (from promotion) would encourage switching and that changing from brand to brand isn't great for babies' tummies. This used to be NHS guidance from when my first was born, but I can see that actually there was an NHS study in 2019 which disproves that, so i was working with outdated advice!

Weddingblues23 · 16/08/2023 11:22

I find the chip on the shoulder posts hilarious. Ultimately, breast milk IS better for babies than formula milk. Pointing that out does not mean the women who breastfeed are looking down on women who formula feed. Fine, you tried, you didn't have enough milk, you didn't have enough support, your nipples were inverted, your baby had tongue tie, you were struggling with your mental health, you wanted to split the feeding load. That's fine, no problem, all sensible reasons. But to pretend that formula is just as good for babies as breast milk is simply not true and nobody should have to say that just to protect your feelings. Just as nobody has to pretend that chicken nuggets and chips is more nutritious than homemade food containing lots of fresh veg - everybody knows that's not true, but that nuggets are something that will fill your kid's tummy and that's ok.

I say this as somebody who has inverted nipples, breastfed one baby and combi fed the other. I don't give shit how anyone feeds their baby, but I do know that my first baby received better milk than my second, but I equally don't feel bad about that in the slightest.

VerbenaGirl · 16/08/2023 11:20

PotteringAlonggotkickedoutandhadtoreregister · 14/08/2023 17:59

But you’re not being penalised? You’re just not being rewarded.

I'd say this about covers it?

FlipFlop1987 · 16/08/2023 10:45

swimminginthesun · 15/08/2023 20:58

Actually, when you look at it at population level, it is hugely important.

Some examples… formula fed babies are more likely to get ear infections, respiratory infections, gastrointestinal issues… the list goes on. Women who breastfeed are less likely to develop breast and ovarian cancers. At an individual level, the differences in risk are fairly small. But at population level an increase in breastfeeding rates would result in significant decreases in many common illnesses. It’s not a quick fix but, over time, an increase in breastfeeding rates would have a positive impact on the health of the general population.

So everyone should care how babies are fed (especially given that the NHS is at breaking point!). And we should be demanding better education for health professionals (who are often frighteningly misinformed) and accessible support for women who wish to breastfeed.

The vast majority of women who stop breastfeeding in the first 6 weeks wish they could have continued (it’s around 90% I think). This is not ok. Women’s feelings matter. Their grief and guilt over switching to formula matters. Please don’t dismiss them.

I don’t have the figures or the research to hand but, if anyone is interested, Professor Amy Brown is doing incredible work in this area and her book “Breastfeeding Uncovered” is well worth a read.

Don’t disagree more needs to be done by professionals and that’s for the Government to sort, it’s the personal direct message I’m referring to. Who tells another mother, who may be struggling mentally and physically unable to feed her baby, that her baby is more at risk of death. You just don’t do it. It’s wrong and not that person’s responsibility. I wouldn’t walk down the street, go over to a mother using a bottle and say something like that, I very much doubt anyone would but sat behind a computer screen suddenly the gloves are off and people say all sorts of very harmful things. It’s not their place to say it. A medical professional who knows the mother’s full circumstances can give advice. Not a total stranger.

Tygertiger · 16/08/2023 10:36

Weddingblues23 · 16/08/2023 09:51

That suggests you think that the formula companies made the rule not to be able to discount. The legislation was made by government to, amongst other things, stop people switching brands from cheapest milk to cheapest milk, which isn't great for baby's tummy.

This is an utter myth. As if it would be remotely ethical for the cheapest milk to have inferior ingredients. The ingredients in formula are regulated. Companies add in things to justify the price on “premium” brands but there’s no evidence they have benefit - because if anything is found to have proven benefits, it then becomes mandatory for all manufacturers to add it. But essentially formula is cows’ milk, vegetable oil, sugar and vitamins. There’s basically no difference between the brands, cost is no indication of quality (it is about trying to attract a different category of consumer, see previous discussion on the thread) and if anything, switching brands is beneficial as it means babies get a slightly different taste which more closely replicates the experience they get with breastmilk.

Oliotya · 16/08/2023 09:53

Weddingblues23 · 16/08/2023 09:51

That suggests you think that the formula companies made the rule not to be able to discount. The legislation was made by government to, amongst other things, stop people switching brands from cheapest milk to cheapest milk, which isn't great for baby's tummy.

That's not at all why the legislation exists. Because it's not true.

Weddingblues23 · 16/08/2023 09:51

Oliotya · 15/08/2023 21:46

Because it's not true. They don't want you switching milk because they want your buying their products.

That suggests you think that the formula companies made the rule not to be able to discount. The legislation was made by government to, amongst other things, stop people switching brands from cheapest milk to cheapest milk, which isn't great for baby's tummy.

Ineedcoffee2021 · 16/08/2023 09:35

SouthLondonMum22 · 15/08/2023 23:39

Because formula is a perfectly valid, safe & healthy alternative to breastfeeding
Because no one is entitled to a woman's body without her permission, not even her child
Because correlation doesn't equal causation
Because some of the benefits of breastfeeding are overstated
Because breastfeeding is such a small part of parenting overall and it doesn't automatically make you a better parent

This with bells on

BF wasnt for me, didnt want to for many reasons with number 1 being - i NEEDED my body back. I couldnt be the only food source.

I say i was lucky milk never came in cos in societies eyes i had a 'valid' reason for not BF. I was met with pity when asked why FF, i didnt need pity, i was happy to FF
BF would have made me a horrible parent

MarleyMallow · 16/08/2023 08:58

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

But a lot of people do use packet food and children’s snacks. I see this most of the time when with children of similar ages. Same as most people but convenience food. And this is being marketed at us and our children too. A lot of children don’t have a good diet 90% of the time unfortunately, it’s why there is a lot of obesity in children.

Ghan · 16/08/2023 08:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Blossomtoes · 16/08/2023 08:39

There’s plenty of aggression coming the other way too.

Ghan · 16/08/2023 08:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Oliotya · 16/08/2023 08:18

GreggingIt · 15/08/2023 23:56

The ’grown up’ conversation about nutrition needs to be around the food weaned children are eating.

The amount of UPF and dodgy marketing tactics aimed at children and encouraging huge portions is really the health epidemic we are facing, not whether someone was FF.

But formula is UPF.

MarleyMallow · 16/08/2023 08:15

GreggingIt · 15/08/2023 23:56

The ’grown up’ conversation about nutrition needs to be around the food weaned children are eating.

The amount of UPF and dodgy marketing tactics aimed at children and encouraging huge portions is really the health epidemic we are facing, not whether someone was FF.

Absolutely.

Theres a ‘meme’ about both formula and breast fed children all going on to eat McDonald’s chips off the floor of the car. They nearly all end up at birthday parties drinking juice and stuffing their faces with crisps and sweets, after being weaned onto packets of ‘foods’ made by exploitative companies. Even the crisps and snacks aimed at children said to be made from vegetables or whatever are absolutely loaded with salt and sugar. Yet women will attack each other over breastmilk and formula.

Wexone · 16/08/2023 08:09

@Laserbeam24 - C+G and Aptamil are both owned by Danone. Nutricia Danone - full name

NewName122 · 16/08/2023 01:52

Yabu you were never penalised.

GreggingIt · 15/08/2023 23:56

The ’grown up’ conversation about nutrition needs to be around the food weaned children are eating.

The amount of UPF and dodgy marketing tactics aimed at children and encouraging huge portions is really the health epidemic we are facing, not whether someone was FF.

SouthLondonMum22 · 15/08/2023 23:39

Meifly · 15/08/2023 22:39

Why would someone actively choose a more unhealthy option for their baby if they didn't have to? Do you also support a mothers choice to drink in pregnancy?

In the end I have a huge amount of sympathy for mothers who have been let down by lack of breastfeeding support be it physical or mental and of course those who formula feed because of adotion etc. but if you're choosing a less healthy option for your baby against all medical advice because you don't have enough time or you just don't like the idea then maybe you need to question if you have enough time to raise a child or if you're in the right frame of mind to put someone's needs above your own

Because formula is a perfectly valid, safe & healthy alternative to breastfeeding
Because no one is entitled to a woman's body without her permission, not even her child
Because correlation doesn't equal causation
Because some of the benefits of breastfeeding are overstated
Because breastfeeding is such a small part of parenting overall and it doesn't automatically make you a better parent