Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents penalised for formula feeding

683 replies

thechristmaspudding · 14/08/2023 17:56

I just wanted to open up a discussion to find out the perspectives of other parents on this subject. I would also be interested to hear the opinions of midwives, health visitors and other health care professionals involved with families.
To give a bit of background information, I am a member of the Boots parenting club, which has many parents are likely to be aware gives you access to discounts and offers on baby related items in store. I went into my local boots today to buy my son's formula, hoping to get a good deal as I had been notified of an offer in store. Now, in my sleep deprived state I did not read the offer properly and it did clearly state that it was an offer for follow on formula and not infant first. The cashier was very polite and explained that due to government regulations shops are not legally allowed to offer discounts on infant first formula due to the government expectation that breastfeeding should be encouraged for the first six months. To be clear, I am not taking issue with Boots or any other shop, but it got me questioning whether this is fair? No, I do not believe that formula companies should be able to dissuade women from breastfeeding through aggressive marketing campaigns that encourage parents to buy their product. But surely parents have the right to weigh up the pros and cons of bottle feeding and make an informed choice that reflects the needs and circumstances of their own family? I tried really, really hard to breastfeed but found it extremely difficult and due to a lack of postnatal support gave up (the inadequate breastfeeding support in this country is another issue in itself). This is something I still regret and struggle with. However, my personal experience aside, formula feeding is a valid choice to make whether parents decide to feed this way from birth or at a later stage.
I also remember watching an episode of dispatches a few years ago on how due to the cost of formula many families resort to watering down their baby's feed or even to stealing. This is a situation that is likely to have worsened as a result of the cost of living crisis.
So my question is, AIBU in thinking that it is wrong to penalise bottle-feeding parents when it comes to the cost of formula?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Paq · 14/08/2023 20:32

The problem is that formula is produced by absolutely ruthless multinationals that will find any way to persuade women to buy their product, so the rules have to be iron clad.

Step outside of your own narrow perspective and consider the issue from all angles. There is a lot of material on the damage these companies' agressive marketing tactics have done to women and babies, here and in less developed countries.

ditalini · 14/08/2023 20:32

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 20:28

Quite possibly because most people want the best possible for their baby. Didn’t you?

Who told you Aptimil was the best?

Was it..... Aptimil by any chance?

(Of course they NEVER say it's best because that would land them in bother because it's bollocks. They use "closest to breastmilk" as an insinuation that it is.)

Thanksitsmac · 14/08/2023 20:32

Proclaiming that CB is ‘not a thing anymore’ is not an account of your experience 🙄

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:32

JenWillsiam · 14/08/2023 20:24

If someone had medical difficulties preventing them from emptying their bowels would you parrot “in the loo is best?”

No I but I don’t say ‘breast is best’ eithwr

mamabells · 14/08/2023 20:31

ScarlettSunset · 14/08/2023 20:23

I do think it's quite disappointing that the rules say no discounts on formula milk. I do understand the reasons but it does make life more expensive for those who are using formula feed and I can see that people could end up tempted to water it down to eke it out.
I had to rely on formula milk when my son was born as I never produced any milk at all. It caused me a great deal of disappointment and anguish at the time. Having the added (and at the beginning very unexpected) expense of formula milk didn't help that any!

Thank you for this. A sensible comment and exactly how i feel x

TinyRebel · 14/08/2023 20:31

’The Politics of Breastfeeding’ is an excellent book, I’d highly recommend it.
I had my first baby in another European country and I think I read it beforehand. Perfectly healthy but removed at birth and taken straight to the nursery, scrubbed and dressed. I wasn’t allowed to see her until I’d staggered downstairs post-c-section (no pain relief) as they cited ‘hygiene’ for not allowing babies in with mothers during visiting hours and at night. They used to stick glucose coated bottle teats in their mouths to keep them quiet, despite my asking them not to.
I made a right nuisance of myself and insisted on staying in the nursery (the nurses’ personal fiefdom) and attempting to establish breastfeeding but I can easily see why many mums found it hard.
When she started nursery, I was told by the staff that “a mother’s milk goes bad after six months” so I should stop BF. I think by that point I was considered the stroppy hippy foreigner who carried her baby around (used public transport, so more practical) and whose baby used her as a dummy.😂

Babies two and three were born in the UK and it was a completely different experience. Both BF, although I had to beg for #3 to be taken away and cup fed some formula as my milk took ages to come in and he was hungry and cross. He also needed tongue tie snipping, which thankfully they were able to do while I was still in hospital with me. In hindsight I’d lost a lot of blood too, so it would have been more of a struggle. If I hadn’t known I was capable of successfully BF, I’d have possibly given up on the idea.

There needs to be more support for mothers who want to BF, in both establishing and continuing and I agree with previous posters about formula being in unbranded packaging and perhaps being sold at a set price. It does seem unfair that babies with reflux/intolerances get their formula completely free of charge too.

I don’t think formula should ever be included in sales promotions or points earning.

Papernotplastic · 14/08/2023 20:31

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 20:28

Quite possibly because most people want the best possible for their baby. Didn’t you?

Bingo. That’s why we have regulations about the advertising and promotion of formula milk.

Why do you think Aptamil is ‘the best possible’? Why do you think Aldi’s milk is less good? That’s the power of advertising and branding.

ButterCrackers · 14/08/2023 20:31

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:16

How am I nasty?

Very few women cannot physically breastfeed. That’s a fact. The vast majority of parents use formula. Also a fact. Ergo, most are doing it by choice rather because they physically can’t.

Please explain how that’s nasty. If you are taking offence that’s nothing to do with me and everything to do with how YOU feel about YOUR choice.

Again - it feels like you believe FF isn’t a valid or good choice. Because otherwise why would you be so angry about having to feed your baby formula? That’s certainly not how I feel about formula so it’s rather sil calling ME ‘vile’

I agree that the majority of women can breastfeed but some, of this specific group, make a choice not to breastfeed. It’s fine to make that choice (happily or with not wanting to make this choice) when fully informed and it should be supported. It’s really hard and unrelenting work to breastfeed. Many woman can’t manage that because of pnd/work/studying/not wanting to pump at work/ looking after other kids/caring for relatives/there’s many reasons including also not wanting to breastfeed. There is nothing wrong to make a choice. For the mums who don’t want to breastfeed it’s fine to say this. I knew a family member who didn’t want to breastfeed. They decided this and it was fine. There is a smaller subset of women who can’t breastfeed and they should have formula prescribed by their doctor and be supported and helped.

SouthLondonMum22 · 14/08/2023 20:31

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:19

Oh come on, that must be so insanely rare and difficult to come by.

I can’t say I’d ever have let my babies be fed with a random’s donated milk.

I've heard about this. Facebook has several groups dedicated to donating breast milk.

It isn't something I'd do either.

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:30

Thanksitsmac · 14/08/2023 20:23

But modified cows milk is absolutely fine?

It’s a valid and regulated choice.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 14/08/2023 20:30

Papernotplastic · 14/08/2023 20:26

You think advertising doesn’t have an impact? Why are people paying £5 more for a tub of formula (Aldi vs Aptamil)

Because they aren't exactly the same and most of us will give our babies the one that suits them best. We tried a few different ones before her stomach settled down with Aptimil. Trust me, I'd rather have paid less. Couldn't.

WomblingTree86 · 14/08/2023 20:30

If you want to argue that you're being penalised because you can't get formula cheaper in a promotion then aren't you being penalised by having to pay for it in the first place?

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:29

LesbianNaan · 14/08/2023 20:19

If “breast is best” (which I agree is awful!) was accompanied by good, freely available and non-judgemental breastfeeding support more women would find it easier to breastfeed, whilst still making choices for themselves.

As it is, unless things have changed dramatically in the last decade or so, support in maternity wards and from community midwives is inconsistent and often downright shit. Support helplines are undermanned, and not everyone can afford a lactation consultant.

No one has a right to lecture that breast is best unless women are offered a level playing field, and right now it’s weighted towards formula feeding because of shit advice and support from the second a new baby is born and a mother is made, whilst simultaneously knocking new mothers for formula feeding - if you’re a woman you can’t win, you’re wrong no matter what you do!

Fuck em all, do what you need to do, but in the meantime the regulations around marketing formula protect us all from deeply toxic marketing strategies, so they must stay.

Well said!

ditalini · 14/08/2023 20:29

ScarlettSunset · 14/08/2023 20:23

I do think it's quite disappointing that the rules say no discounts on formula milk. I do understand the reasons but it does make life more expensive for those who are using formula feed and I can see that people could end up tempted to water it down to eke it out.
I had to rely on formula milk when my son was born as I never produced any milk at all. It caused me a great deal of disappointment and anguish at the time. Having the added (and at the beginning very unexpected) expense of formula milk didn't help that any!

Don't you think it should be cheaper across the board?

Why should new parents have to potentially travel to get cheaper formula at a shop offering points rather than just buy it at a fair price at their closest retailer?

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:29

Getting reward points, or being able to spend them in formula is a far cry from people dressing up as nurses giving free sneaky formula

True.

But the reward points are just the thin end of the wedge. Give free reign, formula companies would push and push and cross every boundary they could

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 14/08/2023 20:29

Thanksitsmac · 14/08/2023 20:27

Oh aren’t you pleasant. I meant derail the thread. Was trying to help but you do you hun

I'm sorry you think me giving you an account of my experience, which you keep telling me is incorrect, is unpleasant. I'm just being honest.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 20:28

Papernotplastic · 14/08/2023 20:26

You think advertising doesn’t have an impact? Why are people paying £5 more for a tub of formula (Aldi vs Aptamil)

Quite possibly because most people want the best possible for their baby. Didn’t you?

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:27

Bandyarsia · 14/08/2023 20:19

Is physically the only reason? What about mentally? What about PND?

Look through the thread and you will find many, many ladies who could not breastfeed. You are telling them women that they made a conscious choice to FF and that is wrong.

Again - difficult is not impossible.

If a woman said to me ‘breastfeeding is so hard is making me depressed’ I’d say ‘fuck that for a game of soldiers’ and match her to the nearest Co op for formula milk. This is why I don’t like ‘breast is best’ - because whilst breastmilk as a substance is for the average baby more beneficial, that doesn’t mean breastfeeding is holistically a better experience. A Baby whose mum is on the brink, who is lactose intolerance, etc will not have a better experience is she continues a struggle than if she just switched he’s to formula.

however - it’s still a choice to formula feed in those circumstances. that’s not nasty - it’s just fact. What is wrong with telling women they chose to feed their baby formula? It’s a valid and perfectly decent choice.

I also think better BF education would reduce the stress and depression many women feel. I know so many women who believe their milk dried up when actually it was just their supply had been established meaning no more leaky Barbie boobs. But they don’t tell you that - you have to go hunting for that information. Breastfeeding education seems to amount to handing you a leaflet with green notes and it only serves to seriously damage women who end up struggling to feed. they need HONEST (such as doing away with this ‘it shouldn’t hurt’ bollocks) and practical advice for mums including what happens when it goes wrong. My MW friend told me they don’t cover ‘when breastfeeding doesn’t go to plan’ incidents with pregnant women because it might put them Off 🙄apparently far better to throw them under the bus and let them struggle

Thanksitsmac · 14/08/2023 20:27

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 14/08/2023 20:23

Everything says "you MAY be entitled" or "you MAY be able to claim". We applied. We were told no. You sending me a screenshot isn't derailing anything. Feel free to speak to the government about what I'm entitled to though.

And the picture you sent is talking about a charge you may have to pay if you earn over 50k. Doesn't actually say everyone who earns under a threshold is entitled to anything.

Oh aren’t you pleasant. I meant derail the thread. Was trying to help but you do you hun

Papernotplastic · 14/08/2023 20:26

You think advertising doesn’t have an impact? Why are people paying £5 more for a tub of formula (Aldi vs Aptamil)

MarleyMallow · 14/08/2023 20:26

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:19

Oh come on, that must be so insanely rare and difficult to come by.

I can’t say I’d ever have let my babies be fed with a random’s donated milk.

Um, no not at all? I’m not lying? I’m putting about it here should anyone need the help. It’s actually fairly common. I am on a huge breastfeeding group on Facebook and lots of people donate their milk. I think they’re amazing for doing so, I would if I could but I could never pump. It was especially important where there were formula shortages and especially in America when formula was really short for a while.

That’s up to you if you wouldn’t accept a donation, but lots of mums appreciate it because they have babies with dietary issues or because they want to use breastmilk but can’t produce milk themselves or because formula is expensive. It’s a wonderful thing.

ladygindiva · 14/08/2023 20:26

Merseymum seems a nice person. Why is it that rabid breastfeeding fanatics are often such horrible people?

SaySomethingMan · 14/08/2023 20:25

Dasisr · 14/08/2023 19:25

I didn’t say they were comparing it to alcohol and cigarettes. I’m saying it’s ridiculous that a completely valid and safe and monitored and approved food for babies is excluded from any kind of promotion. Meanwhile I can buy my now 1 year old as much chocolate and processed food as I like and receive a discount for doing so. Obviously noone gives a crap about the health of my baby once they’re past formula age. Just need to make sure we are policing women with newborns it seems.

And my god I’m so tired of hearing blah blah back 50 years ago in Africa nestle did this so in modern western society we need to prevent advertising of formula. I wanted to breastfeed. I wasn’t remotely influenced by advertising of follow on milks in making my decision. However I didn’t manage to exclusively breastfeed so I bought formula. How is excluding it from a promotion having an influence on women’s decisions.

Wow,@Dasisr you sound utterly terrible. They’re people too, you know. And it wasn’t just “50years ago in Africa”.

JenWillsiam · 14/08/2023 20:24

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:05

Since when was being able to carry out a natural task a privilege?

Do I also have poo and wee privilege? Or eating privilege?

Breastfeeding privilege - what bollocks.

If someone had medical difficulties preventing them from emptying their bowels would you parrot “in the loo is best?”

Jl2014 · 14/08/2023 20:24

It’s not about penalising you. At a macro health level, breast feeding has better outcomes for mothers and children, including reduction of breast cancer. This is at a macro level (which is what the government care about- an important point to note if you want to understand the why), and doesn’t mean there won’t be individuals where outcomes do not fit within this.

Ultimately it saves the government money and so is encouraged for mums and so there is a reward system (of sorts) in place. You aren’t being penalised- you’re just not getting a discount. Why should you? And it’s not about denying a choice either. You had a choice and you made that. There is reasoning behind it, as unappealing to your own personal situation as that may be.

Swipe left for the next trending thread