Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents penalised for formula feeding

683 replies

thechristmaspudding · 14/08/2023 17:56

I just wanted to open up a discussion to find out the perspectives of other parents on this subject. I would also be interested to hear the opinions of midwives, health visitors and other health care professionals involved with families.
To give a bit of background information, I am a member of the Boots parenting club, which has many parents are likely to be aware gives you access to discounts and offers on baby related items in store. I went into my local boots today to buy my son's formula, hoping to get a good deal as I had been notified of an offer in store. Now, in my sleep deprived state I did not read the offer properly and it did clearly state that it was an offer for follow on formula and not infant first. The cashier was very polite and explained that due to government regulations shops are not legally allowed to offer discounts on infant first formula due to the government expectation that breastfeeding should be encouraged for the first six months. To be clear, I am not taking issue with Boots or any other shop, but it got me questioning whether this is fair? No, I do not believe that formula companies should be able to dissuade women from breastfeeding through aggressive marketing campaigns that encourage parents to buy their product. But surely parents have the right to weigh up the pros and cons of bottle feeding and make an informed choice that reflects the needs and circumstances of their own family? I tried really, really hard to breastfeed but found it extremely difficult and due to a lack of postnatal support gave up (the inadequate breastfeeding support in this country is another issue in itself). This is something I still regret and struggle with. However, my personal experience aside, formula feeding is a valid choice to make whether parents decide to feed this way from birth or at a later stage.
I also remember watching an episode of dispatches a few years ago on how due to the cost of formula many families resort to watering down their baby's feed or even to stealing. This is a situation that is likely to have worsened as a result of the cost of living crisis.
So my question is, AIBU in thinking that it is wrong to penalise bottle-feeding parents when it comes to the cost of formula?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
GreggingIt · 14/08/2023 21:08

JusthereforXmas · 14/08/2023 21:04

We used cow and gate because it was always cheapest.

Same with little angel nappies, purely because it was cheapest and the cost adds up quick.

I didn't go 'ooo... Hienz make these shitbag so it must be so much better than Asdas own brand'.

Branding doesn't really matter with baby stuff, you are more likely to get recommended something by other mams who say something works than to just see 'adverts' for them and think that it we are 'pampers' family from now on.

You buy on price - fair enough.

Not everyone does. Some people watch those pampers adverts with wriggly babies and would be convinced they are a better fit to avoid poonamis. Maybe they are, maybe they aren’t. Some people want the green eco ones as perceive it’s better for the environment etc.

Clearly lots of people do buy pampers or else they wouldn’t exist as a brand. It is a complete fallacy to say people aren’t persuaded by brands.

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 21:08

JusthereforXmas · 14/08/2023 20:59

And if a mother is breastfeeding on certain drugs either prescription of street its dangerous... Any could be dangerous if done 'wrong'. Drinking too much water can even kill you.

But used as per correct direction formula is perfectly safe and nutritionally balanced.

There zero truth in the myth that breastfeed babies are magically stronger, healthier and smarter.

As for cost of living, if they weren't going out of their way to make formula less accessible by implementing laws like this then that wouldn't be an issue.

Breast milk is a live substance that filters out as much as it can and gives the baby the best it can. Very few medications can’t be taken with breastfeeding. Myths indeed!

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 21:06

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 20:58

No but when BF didn’t work out how did you know to switch to formula

You’d have to be non sentient not to know that the alternative to breastfeeding is formula.

EXACTLY 🤣🤣 because at some point marketing has been invoked!

Do you think undiscovered Amazon tribes know formula exists? If not why not?

LesbianNaan · 14/08/2023 21:06

do you really think women see an aptamil ad and think oh I better feed my baby aptamil instead of breastfeeding that advert is just so good and my neighbour mentioned it years ago. Maybe explore why you have such a poor opinion of women.

It’s not about having a poor opinion of women, it’s about marketing and how it works.

Companies don’t spend billions on marketing for no reason.

We feel like we have free choice, but you cannot underestimate the power of marketing on all humans.

JustAnotherCheeseburger · 14/08/2023 21:04

If it's all about ensuring women attempt to breastfeed and aren't led astray by a Boots 3 for 2, then maybe we need to look more at breastfeeding support to make this a viable and successful option to those that want to.

I certainly felt stigmatised breastfeeding in public and absolutely expected at times to be told I couldn't. I also received next to no useful real life breastfeeding support. I managed it thanks to the boards on here. It wouldn't have been discounted formula causing me to switch, it would have been the lack of support to be successful with breastfeeding.

JusthereforXmas · 14/08/2023 21:04

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:56

No but when BF didn’t work out how did you know to switch to formula and specifically Aptamil.

I don’t have a poor opinion of women. What a weird reach. I was simply responding to someone who thinks they’re immune from marketing tactics. No one is

We used cow and gate because it was always cheapest.

Same with little angel nappies, purely because it was cheapest and the cost adds up quick.

I didn't go 'ooo... Hienz make these shitbag so it must be so much better than Asdas own brand'.

Branding doesn't really matter with baby stuff, you are more likely to get recommended something by other mams who say something works than to just see 'adverts' for them and think that it we are 'pampers' family from now on.

Tygertiger · 14/08/2023 21:03

HelloItsMeAgainHello · 14/08/2023 20:46

It's also to stop parents chopping and change formula to whatever is on offer that week. Which is bad for babies stomach.

Also offers don't always make things cheaper. Most of the time they hike the price up just so they can reduce it. So overall you probably wouldn't even save anything

Totally untrue. If your baby doesn’t have any intolerances, swapping brands is actually beneficial as then babies get slightly different tastes (which is more similar to breastmilk, which tastes different depending on time of day/mother’s diet etc).

You know who made up the myth that it’s bad to change brand? The manufacturers. Because they know that once babies start on their brand, they’ve generally got them until they wean off formula.

ditalini · 14/08/2023 21:03

JusthereforXmas · 14/08/2023 20:59

And if a mother is breastfeeding on certain drugs either prescription of street its dangerous... Any could be dangerous if done 'wrong'. Drinking too much water can even kill you.

But used as per correct direction formula is perfectly safe and nutritionally balanced.

There zero truth in the myth that breastfeed babies are magically stronger, healthier and smarter.

As for cost of living, if they weren't going out of their way to make formula less accessible by implementing laws like this then that wouldn't be an issue.

But the formula companies could cut their prices tomorrow - there's no law against that at all.

Babies need reliably cheap, accessible formula. Not temporary discounts and points from selected retailers.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 21:02

Whattheflipflap · 14/08/2023 21:00

Probably not the answer but I think formula should be a prescription medication tbh

You want to put even more pressure on the poor NHS that’s already on its knees? Really?

Papernotplastic · 14/08/2023 21:00

Do you think formula companies spend millions in advertising because it doesn’t work? As someone’s already said, they basically created stage 2 milk so they could get around the advertising ban on formula.

Whattheflipflap · 14/08/2023 21:00

Probably not the answer but I think formula should be a prescription medication tbh

Tygertiger · 14/08/2023 21:00

Cow and Gate and Aptimil are made by the same company, in the same factories. It’s 99.9% the same product. And there are no special ingredients that Aptimil put in which justify the price (that really would be unethical). The difference is the marketing. C&G is targeted at a different woman to Aptimil. The C&G mum wants to FF, probably always knows she will from being pregnant or even before. She’s happy with her choice, FF is probably what her family/friends do too. The brand promotes itself as a heritage British brand, one you can rely on that’s always been there. It uses cutesy images like lambs and teddies on the packaging.

The Aptimil target Mum either tried to BF and couldn’t, or wanted to and couldn’t for another reason. She probably feels a lot of guilt for not BF. She buys Aptimil as it’s expensive, scientific-looking and promotes itself as being close to breastmilk. The packaging looks sleek and modern, no teddies on those boxes.

This isn’t marketing bollocks - it works. There is no reason not to buy Aldi milk, from an ingredients point of view. The essential ingredients are regulated by law, and there is no proven science behind anything else which Aptimil claims justifies their price. But lots of parents wouldn’t buy the Aldi milk on principle.

JusthereforXmas · 14/08/2023 20:59

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:53

Formula is also PERFECTLY safe

It is when made up properly.

Sadly, too frequently it isn’t made up properly. I have seen many people add formula to a cold bottle of water. And now people are watering it down to make it last longer Sad

And if a mother is breastfeeding on certain drugs either prescription of street its dangerous... Any could be dangerous if done 'wrong'. Drinking too much water can even kill you.

But used as per correct direction formula is perfectly safe and nutritionally balanced.

There zero truth in the myth that breastfeed babies are magically stronger, healthier and smarter.

As for cost of living, if they weren't going out of their way to make formula less accessible by implementing laws like this then that wouldn't be an issue.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 20:58

No but when BF didn’t work out how did you know to switch to formula

You’d have to be non sentient not to know that the alternative to breastfeeding is formula.

Rollonsept · 14/08/2023 20:58

@Kindofcrunchy that's good for you.

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:56

Dasisr · 14/08/2023 20:53

What does having heard of something and brand awareness have to do with making a decision about formula or breastfeeding? There are hundreds of things I’ve heard about and seen advertised or discussed that I’ve never tried or purchased because I don’t want to.

do you really think women see an aptamil ad and think oh I better feed my baby aptamil instead of breastfeeding that advert is just so good and my neighbour mentioned it years ago. Maybe explore why you have such a poor opinion of women.

No but when BF didn’t work out how did you know to switch to formula and specifically Aptamil.

I don’t have a poor opinion of women. What a weird reach. I was simply responding to someone who thinks they’re immune from marketing tactics. No one is

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:55

JenWillsiam · 14/08/2023 20:53

And do you consider going for a poo an achievement?

No but aside from the fact that breastfeeding is rather more complex and tougher to do than having a poo (and also involves another human) I have never actually said breastfeeding is an achievement. Unless you can point out where I’ve said this? Or are you just making things up?

Papernotplastic · 14/08/2023 20:55

ditalini · 14/08/2023 20:39

Yes, the company who makes Aptimil are very aware of that. It's specifically priced as a premium product despite, by law, having exactly the same proven nutritional value as the others.

It also deliberately targets women who breastfed and then switched to formula - totally cashes in on the guilt factor.

Exactly. You only need to read this thread to see what an emotive issue this is.
Every mother wants to do the best for their baby. That’s what the brands package and sell along with the milk powder.

They can’t offer time limited promotions but there’s absolutely nothing stopping these companies from dropping their prices or bringing in a price freeze.

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:53

Formula is also PERFECTLY safe

It is when made up properly.

Sadly, too frequently it isn’t made up properly. I have seen many people add formula to a cold bottle of water. And now people are watering it down to make it last longer Sad

JenWillsiam · 14/08/2023 20:53

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:32

No I but I don’t say ‘breast is best’ eithwr

And do you consider going for a poo an achievement?

Dasisr · 14/08/2023 20:53

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 19:47

So you’d never heard of formula and the brand names before having a baby?

What does having heard of something and brand awareness have to do with making a decision about formula or breastfeeding? There are hundreds of things I’ve heard about and seen advertised or discussed that I’ve never tried or purchased because I don’t want to.

do you really think women see an aptamil ad and think oh I better feed my baby aptamil instead of breastfeeding that advert is just so good and my neighbour mentioned it years ago. Maybe explore why you have such a poor opinion of women.

Oliotya · 14/08/2023 20:52

JenWillsiam · 14/08/2023 20:22

It’s not that black and white though is it? I breast fed one child until 5. The other was combi fed from birth. Why? Because I was literally unconscious in ICU. Was it impossible to feed? No. Was it a realistic expectation for someone with the the health issues I had? No. Was I penalised? Well that depends on your view. Kid who was BF free. The other where I was gravely unwell cost me money. So yeah it did feel a bit like a punishment.

What I would like to see is a system where mothers are prescribed formula at a cost to the NHS when it’s not a mothers choice but difficulties establishing breastfeeding. if nothing else it will incentivise CCG’s to actually support mothers to feed.

I agree it's not black and white. I formula fed 1, breastfed 2 (still feeding 1 now). There's no moral judgement from me either way. But I don't think it's helpful to deny the biological reality that most women are able to breastfeed. The focus should be on properly supporting women to feed however they want to without bringing "success" or "failure" into it. I don't think it's responsible to encourage low income mothers onto formula, when affordability is clearly an issue.
But it's a complex issue, and doesn't start and end with feeding. We're not a mother and baby friendly society imo.

GreggingIt · 14/08/2023 20:51

If parents are having to water down formula, instead of a ‘price promotion’, why are we not asking the shareholders to stop being so greedy and actually reduced the price across the board as standard?

Governments have to intervene in certain areas of capitalism as some capitalists are evil.

JusthereforXmas · 14/08/2023 20:51

I couldn't breastfeed with my oldest and was made to feel shite, litrally bullied by the nurses. Apparently it was all about meeting their quotas.

When I had my second (and third) I had already had a partial mastectomy and no body pushed it, I don't even think many knew so I think things had changed.

We have it somewhat lucky here, in many countries you aren't ALLOWED to decide to use formula. A doctor has to approve your request and prescribe formula which is utterly fucking batshit.

I have always mentioned how amazing it is the 'our body, our choice' stuff never seems to support women in choosing formula as an option.

Formula is also PERFECTLY safe, theres no downsides too it anymore... this isnt the victoria era of refrigerated and unpasteurized milk in unsterile porous bottle.

GreggingIt · 14/08/2023 20:49

I don’t think preventing formula companies from marketing/pricing products in such a way that encourages FF is the same as penalising FF babies - which is a valid choice. You have issues you didn’t BF and are projecting a bit in my view.

This is nestle and others we’re talking about. Why did they even need regulating in the first place - because they use underhand tactics otherwise. The consequence of that is they can’t use price promos for infant formula, which sucks for FF parents but is likely a necessary evil.