Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents penalised for formula feeding

683 replies

thechristmaspudding · 14/08/2023 17:56

I just wanted to open up a discussion to find out the perspectives of other parents on this subject. I would also be interested to hear the opinions of midwives, health visitors and other health care professionals involved with families.
To give a bit of background information, I am a member of the Boots parenting club, which has many parents are likely to be aware gives you access to discounts and offers on baby related items in store. I went into my local boots today to buy my son's formula, hoping to get a good deal as I had been notified of an offer in store. Now, in my sleep deprived state I did not read the offer properly and it did clearly state that it was an offer for follow on formula and not infant first. The cashier was very polite and explained that due to government regulations shops are not legally allowed to offer discounts on infant first formula due to the government expectation that breastfeeding should be encouraged for the first six months. To be clear, I am not taking issue with Boots or any other shop, but it got me questioning whether this is fair? No, I do not believe that formula companies should be able to dissuade women from breastfeeding through aggressive marketing campaigns that encourage parents to buy their product. But surely parents have the right to weigh up the pros and cons of bottle feeding and make an informed choice that reflects the needs and circumstances of their own family? I tried really, really hard to breastfeed but found it extremely difficult and due to a lack of postnatal support gave up (the inadequate breastfeeding support in this country is another issue in itself). This is something I still regret and struggle with. However, my personal experience aside, formula feeding is a valid choice to make whether parents decide to feed this way from birth or at a later stage.
I also remember watching an episode of dispatches a few years ago on how due to the cost of formula many families resort to watering down their baby's feed or even to stealing. This is a situation that is likely to have worsened as a result of the cost of living crisis.
So my question is, AIBU in thinking that it is wrong to penalise bottle-feeding parents when it comes to the cost of formula?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
SnackSizeRaisin · 14/08/2023 21:35

Tygertiger · 14/08/2023 21:00

Cow and Gate and Aptimil are made by the same company, in the same factories. It’s 99.9% the same product. And there are no special ingredients that Aptimil put in which justify the price (that really would be unethical). The difference is the marketing. C&G is targeted at a different woman to Aptimil. The C&G mum wants to FF, probably always knows she will from being pregnant or even before. She’s happy with her choice, FF is probably what her family/friends do too. The brand promotes itself as a heritage British brand, one you can rely on that’s always been there. It uses cutesy images like lambs and teddies on the packaging.

The Aptimil target Mum either tried to BF and couldn’t, or wanted to and couldn’t for another reason. She probably feels a lot of guilt for not BF. She buys Aptimil as it’s expensive, scientific-looking and promotes itself as being close to breastmilk. The packaging looks sleek and modern, no teddies on those boxes.

This isn’t marketing bollocks - it works. There is no reason not to buy Aldi milk, from an ingredients point of view. The essential ingredients are regulated by law, and there is no proven science behind anything else which Aptimil claims justifies their price. But lots of parents wouldn’t buy the Aldi milk on principle.

This explains it well.
There's a lot of middle class educated assumption on this thread.

Also breastfeeding is definitely not free. The mother needs to eat more for a start but also the cost of bras, pumps, nipple cream, lactation consultants, milk storage bags, etc adds up. Plus many people still use bottles and sterilisers as well.

MarleyMallow · 14/08/2023 21:34

See I don’t get this. I breastfeed and so do some of my friends, but I couldn’t care less about those that formula feed or why. Not my baby, not my business. I’ve never met anyone (except for online) who is sanctimonious about it. The only time I’ve met wankers in real life was a doctor who told me not to use formula (I won’t say why on here) and all the people who give me stares or their opinion on the fact I still breastfeed my 3 year old - but I couldn’t care less, not their baby (well, not a baby anymore), not their business.

Are people in real life really giving shit to formula feeding mums? I just don’t get why? It’s not their child so who cares? And by the time they reach school you couldn’t tell which kid has been breastfed and which hasn’t?!

Babyboomtastic · 14/08/2023 21:28

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:36

I totally agree with you!

my best friend from the off said “I’m using formula because the thought of a baby on my tits creeps me out and it’s also seems easier”. I respect that FAR more than someone who says they were forced into formula feeding when they weren’t.

I chose to FF my first, and some of the things people said to me, were illuminating. I had more than one friend, (who had told people they wanted to bf) that they were relieved when bf didnt work for them, as they didn't really want to do it, but felt pressured to 'try'.

I think there's a huge amount of pressure on new mums to say that bf didnt work out because its more socially acceptable than saying they chose to FF. For many its somewhere in between, where the trying is aspirational, but without enough drive to make it work if it isn't easy (just like I do with diets and exercise every January 😂).

Obviously some women try incredibly hard and have to eventually conceed defeat for their health and that of their babies. I don't think that's really a true choice of theirs.

In the same way, I accidentally BF my second (for 2.5y). It WAS my choice because I could have refused, and eventually my baby would have accepted a bottle after a lot of distress, but it wasnt a true choice of mine.

Sometimes we are strongarmed into decision that weren't what we wanted, but are for the best.

AnneAnon · 14/08/2023 21:27

One formula feeder, to be fair.

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 21:27

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 21:14

Maybe that’s because of the nauseating sanctimony of some of their breastfeeding counterparts.

And yet formula feeders can tell breastfeeders they should be delighted at being discriminated against.

Imagine if that were the other way around!

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 21:24

youwerentthere · 14/08/2023 21:09

I still cry in the night because I never had chance to hear these things. When you know you're doing whats best for your baby, those comments would be easy to brush off.

Re the cost of breastfeeding vs bottle, I bought the nursing bras, nursing clothes, 2 different pumps, vitamins, mad cookies off of Etsy, nipple shields, nursing pillow, the blanket thing, paid for breastfeeding support then still had to buy bottles, steriliser, prep machine and formula every single week for a year, so please, begrudge me 50p every so often

WTAF have I just read? Women should be grateful that they were discriminated against, made fun of, belittled, and made to feel worthless because ‘they were doing what was best for their baby’. Bullshit!! Some of us actually value our feelings and no it didn’t make it all OK to have shitty comment aimed at us.

And with the greatest of respect of you really are crying yourself to sleep because you couldnt breastfeed - that really isn’t healthy and I think it would help if you spoke to someone who could make you feel better about what happened. (Rather than tell women online that they should feel good about people being shitty towards them)

Rollonsept · 14/08/2023 21:22

FairAcre · 14/08/2023 21:12

Mums who bottle feed do seem to have a chip on their shoulders. I realise that there are some mums out there who have a genuine difficulty breastfeeding but I’ve also met a fair few who can’t be bothered/don’t persevere who then spend a lot of time justifying their decision.

Are you oblivious to this whole thread or something. Nobody owes you an explanation as to why they don't breastfeed it isn't any or your business. How would you know if someone has persevered? how long is long enough in your books? You sound quite judgmental yourself.

People usually justify themselves when someone else is getting on to them about something and they feel attacked. Ring any 🔔

JenWillsiam · 14/08/2023 21:21

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 20:55

No but aside from the fact that breastfeeding is rather more complex and tougher to do than having a poo (and also involves another human) I have never actually said breastfeeding is an achievement. Unless you can point out where I’ve said this? Or are you just making things up?

Thats the point. It’s only straightforward if you can do it. If there are any difficulties it’s not straightforward. For some it comes easy, for others it does not.

“breastfeeding privilege” refers to those who were able to do it. And yes “poo privilege” would be the same. To those who cannot do it, who require support, intervention etc etc looking at those who can do it with ease, that’s a privilege.

ditalini · 14/08/2023 21:19

HowNice23 · 14/08/2023 21:14

It's really extortionate and priced high because most people using it have no choice. You're right OP.

So why are points the solution?

You pay for the points with slightly higher prices the rest of the time.

The discount on your brand is temporary and you pay a little more the rest of the time to fund it.

Your closest shop suddenly becomes too expensive because the big out of town supermarket has the discounts and so the price at Spar has rocketed to fund the deal the company made with the supermarket.

Meanwhile, it costs pennies to make and could easily be cheaper ALL the time for everyone if there were any ethics involved.

Hayley0203 · 14/08/2023 21:18

youwerentthere · 14/08/2023 21:09

I still cry in the night because I never had chance to hear these things. When you know you're doing whats best for your baby, those comments would be easy to brush off.

Re the cost of breastfeeding vs bottle, I bought the nursing bras, nursing clothes, 2 different pumps, vitamins, mad cookies off of Etsy, nipple shields, nursing pillow, the blanket thing, paid for breastfeeding support then still had to buy bottles, steriliser, prep machine and formula every single week for a year, so please, begrudge me 50p every so often

I totally understand your perspective, I really do, but I promise it's not easy to brush these comments off when you actually experience them. When you're unbelievably sleep deprived and it's only you who can feed the baby, and people keep telling you "they'd sleep better with formula" like their own babies, it makes you question whether you even are doing the best thing - especially when your own baby doesn't seem to be getting proper rest.

Or when people make you insecure for revealing a bit more flesh in public because they'd personally feel very uncomfortable (I wasn't bothered until someone said this, and suddenly I lost all confidence and started feeding in private). When people say they love having freedom, while you're chained to the house and don't get more than 2 hours away from your baby for almost a year, while they're all out partying, having solo days out/self care while dad feeds the baby, etc.

I look back and I'm like, was it all worth it? Was the loneliness, the isolation, the insecurity, the sleepless nights, the sole burden of feeding, all worth it? How are my (much older now) children any better off than their formula fed peers?

BreatheAndFocus · 14/08/2023 21:17

More here from The Lancet

“For decades, the commercial milk formula (CMF) industry has used underhand marketing strategies, designed to prey on parents' fears and concerns at a vulnerable time, to turn the feeding of young children into a multibillion-dollar business. The immense economic power accrued by CMF manufacturers is deployed politically to ensure the industry is under-regulated and services supporting breastfeeding are under-resourced. These are the stark findings of the 2023 Breastfeeding Series, published in The Lancet today.
The three-paper Series outlines how typical infant behaviours such as crying, fussiness, and poor night-time sleep are portrayed by the CMF industry as pathological and framed as reasons to introduce formula, when in fact these behaviours are common and developmentally appropriate However, manufacturers claim their products can alleviate discomfort or improve night-time sleep, and also infer that formula can enhance brain development and improve intelligence—all of which are unsubstantiated. Infant feeding is further commodified by cross-promotion of infant, follow-on, toddler, and growing-up milks using the same branding and numbered progression, which aims to build brand loyalty and is a blatant attempt to circumvent legislation that prohibits advertising of infant formula.”

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 21:16

JusthereforXmas · 14/08/2023 21:04

We used cow and gate because it was always cheapest.

Same with little angel nappies, purely because it was cheapest and the cost adds up quick.

I didn't go 'ooo... Hienz make these shitbag so it must be so much better than Asdas own brand'.

Branding doesn't really matter with baby stuff, you are more likely to get recommended something by other mams who say something works than to just see 'adverts' for them and think that it we are 'pampers' family from now on.

Except choosing one thing based on price is marketing in action!

AnneAnon · 14/08/2023 21:16

Also Pampers were the actual worst of all the nappies we used. Aldi and Asda were much better.

LesbianNaan · 14/08/2023 21:16

begrudge me 50p every so often

This isn’t a breastfeeding vs formula feeding issue though, no breastfeeding mother will take delight that formula feeding mothers have to pay more.

It’s about protection from predatory marketing tactics that take away free choice.

Fierce marketing broke down generations of breastfeeding women. We are all currently protected in a very small way to try to ensure that we retain that choice.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 21:14

FairAcre · 14/08/2023 21:12

Mums who bottle feed do seem to have a chip on their shoulders. I realise that there are some mums out there who have a genuine difficulty breastfeeding but I’ve also met a fair few who can’t be bothered/don’t persevere who then spend a lot of time justifying their decision.

Maybe that’s because of the nauseating sanctimony of some of their breastfeeding counterparts.

HowNice23 · 14/08/2023 21:14

It's really extortionate and priced high because most people using it have no choice. You're right OP.

willywallaby · 14/08/2023 21:13

Summerdayy · 14/08/2023 20:23

@willywallaby when my child was a baby we used Aptamil from the very beginning and then tried to switch to Cow and gate as apparently same but cheaper.
I don’t believe it was same as my child was ok on Aptamil but not ok on the Cow and gate ( same type of milk) so went back to Aptamil.
I still remember having the half tab of Cow and gate and binning it.

Oh I'm not saying they're the same formulation, and different babies react differently to different formula brands. There will also be some babies that get on better with Cow and Gate than with Aptamil. My point is that neither is objectively proven better and that they charge £4 extra for Aptamil because it's branded as a premium product and Cow and Gate is branded as a budget product. Your baby did better on Aptamil and you shouldn't have had to pay £££ subsidising their marketing budget for that.

AnneAnon · 14/08/2023 21:12

Absolutely agree there should be restrictions and regulations. Also think that they go too far e.g. being excluded from the £10 off when you spend £X voucher.

I chose to FF and would absolutely do so again. Didn’t attempt to breastfeed, no idea if I could manage it or not (note: my kids are in primary school now and you can’t tell the difference. But a lot of my militant breast feeder acquaintances, who judged me so harshly at the time, are now awfully fond of shoving happy meals, chocolate and greggs sausage rolls into their kids now. Just saying).

I don’t feel penalised by the lack of points etc, I accepted that as part of my decision to FF, but then I was in the privileged position of being able to afford the extortionate amounts for formula. If I was on the bones of my arse with no choice but to FF, that would be very very difficult (and restrictions such as the voucher one mentioned above make life much harder for those people, for no apparent reason or benefit to the greater good).

FairAcre · 14/08/2023 21:12

Mums who bottle feed do seem to have a chip on their shoulders. I realise that there are some mums out there who have a genuine difficulty breastfeeding but I’ve also met a fair few who can’t be bothered/don’t persevere who then spend a lot of time justifying their decision.

PleaseInsertNameHere · 14/08/2023 21:11

Agreed…there should be ration tokens for parents or something.

We had twins during lockdown, they only have premade C&G formula and we’re limited to three bottles per shop…we were going though more that one bottle a day.

Another gripe

SnackSizeRaisin · 14/08/2023 21:11

Sunfl0w3r5 · 14/08/2023 18:24

Lots of things are better for children that we’re not penalised for. Surely any snack products and any processed foods shouldn’t have offers as really kids should be just having whole grains, dairy, a lot of veg with a little organic meat. Most tech really shouldn’t have offers as screen time too has proved to be detrimental, highly perfumed non natural toiletries,….

As the mum of teens can I just say formula makes f*k all difference and actually is pretty much the smallest parenting choice you spend thinking over further down the line .It’s laughable the things you end up worrying about as parents in comparison.

I think you are right. Snack foods marketed at weaning babies are probably much worse for them than formula.

Deals on formula are bad as they encourage swapping of brands which can cause digestive upsets for babies.

I think really deals or advertising for any form of processed food need to be banned. Most of these deals aren't real anyway (apart from reductions due to short dates). They just hike the price for a week before putting it down again. They don't genuinely save you money, just make you buy more.

Boots points make it more expensive than other similar shops. Just shop somewhere like savers and you can get the savings without faffing about with the points.

Aldi is the cheapest formula milk I came across

barms90 · 14/08/2023 21:11

Ok so my take. I had both my children in another European country where most people bf. The reason why....after birth min stay in hospital is two nights!!it'd not fun but this gives you time to establish bf. With my first everytime I needed to feed I pressed the button and the nurse came to check my latch. Also on night two the milk comes in and it's known on the ward...oh the baby will be up most of the night feeding....good luck.
In the uk you don't get this help. When baby is cluster feeding people think something is wrong...not enough milk...ect...panic and change to bottle. Of course there are people who can't bf or don't want to and thats fine you should choose what you want but I feel sorry for the people who want to bf but can't because of a lack of help.

BreatheAndFocus · 14/08/2023 21:10

YABU. The rates of breastfeeding are woeful in this country. The formula milk companies have massive amounts of money behind them to market their goods. Vast amounts. I read the figures a few years ago, comparing what was spent on the promotion of formula compared to breastfeeding. It’s aggressive marketing:

Here

Do you know why follow-on milks were developed? For the benefit of children and mums? Of course not! They’re unnecessary. The reason follow-on milks were developed was to get around a government ban on promotion of infant formula. You’re might be too young to remember, but infant formula used to have pretty boring brand names. What happened was the companies realised they could invent follow-on milks, which were exempt from the ban, being for babies over 6 months. They could then rebrand their infant formulas with the same name and the ads for the new follow-on milks would indirectly promote the infant formula. In fact, lots of people don’t even realise promotion of infant formula is banned. Formula, follow-on, growing up milk - it all blends into one, ‘helpfully’ linked under the same names.

So, you are being very unreasonable. Personally I’d extend the advertising and promotions ban to follow-on milks. Most women can breastfeed. They’re being let down in some areas of the country by the lack of support, and by insidious promotion of artificial milks that are inferior to breast milk. Yes, women should be able to choose, but because of the constant promotion of formula and the rather cleverly pushed lies about breastfeeding, the amount of women making that choice is higher than it would naturally be.

Milk Formula Companies | Save The Children UK

New Save the Children analysis reveals six companies spend the equivalent of £36 on marketing for each baby born worldwide - amounting to £5 billion every year

https://www.savethechildren.org.uk/news/media-centre/press-releases/leading-milk-formula-companies-spend-p36-on-marketing-for-every-

Goldencup · 14/08/2023 21:10

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 14/08/2023 18:06

Not the point, I know, but for a while now I’ve been noticing the huge difference in price between identical size tubs of Aptamil (£14) and Cow and Gate (£10) for the same product (first milk, follow on, etc.)

Why on earth would anyone choose to pay the higher price? Do they think that more expensive must = better?
Cow and Gate is an old and trusted U.K. brand - I can’t imagine that it’s inferior to Aptamil. If Aptamil is imported (I don’t know whether it is) that could account for at least some of the difference.

I mostly breathed but used aptamil from 4 months. It was what I had seen used in hospitals and I think was thought to be closest to breast milk (2004 for refference). Yes more expensive but was never my babies' sole food source.

youwerentthere · 14/08/2023 21:09

Hayley0203 · 14/08/2023 20:42

You guys know breastfeeding mums get judged the crap out of too? Some examples of things said to me when I breastfed my children:

"Oh wow you're STILL breastfeeding? You don't need to after the first month?"
"I could never breastfeed, it's too limiting/I need my freedom"
"Don't you feel uncomfortable doing it in public?"
"There's nothing in breastmilk that you can't get in formula"
"Breastfeeding mums always look down on formula fed mums"
"Oh you're not drinking because of breastfeeding? Booooring"
"A breastfeeding space? Yeah you can use the toilets"
"Ah yeah, your baby sleeps terribly because you chose to breastfeed. Mine sleeps through"

I still cry in the night because I never had chance to hear these things. When you know you're doing whats best for your baby, those comments would be easy to brush off.

Re the cost of breastfeeding vs bottle, I bought the nursing bras, nursing clothes, 2 different pumps, vitamins, mad cookies off of Etsy, nipple shields, nursing pillow, the blanket thing, paid for breastfeeding support then still had to buy bottles, steriliser, prep machine and formula every single week for a year, so please, begrudge me 50p every so often