Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents penalised for formula feeding

683 replies

thechristmaspudding · 14/08/2023 17:56

I just wanted to open up a discussion to find out the perspectives of other parents on this subject. I would also be interested to hear the opinions of midwives, health visitors and other health care professionals involved with families.
To give a bit of background information, I am a member of the Boots parenting club, which has many parents are likely to be aware gives you access to discounts and offers on baby related items in store. I went into my local boots today to buy my son's formula, hoping to get a good deal as I had been notified of an offer in store. Now, in my sleep deprived state I did not read the offer properly and it did clearly state that it was an offer for follow on formula and not infant first. The cashier was very polite and explained that due to government regulations shops are not legally allowed to offer discounts on infant first formula due to the government expectation that breastfeeding should be encouraged for the first six months. To be clear, I am not taking issue with Boots or any other shop, but it got me questioning whether this is fair? No, I do not believe that formula companies should be able to dissuade women from breastfeeding through aggressive marketing campaigns that encourage parents to buy their product. But surely parents have the right to weigh up the pros and cons of bottle feeding and make an informed choice that reflects the needs and circumstances of their own family? I tried really, really hard to breastfeed but found it extremely difficult and due to a lack of postnatal support gave up (the inadequate breastfeeding support in this country is another issue in itself). This is something I still regret and struggle with. However, my personal experience aside, formula feeding is a valid choice to make whether parents decide to feed this way from birth or at a later stage.
I also remember watching an episode of dispatches a few years ago on how due to the cost of formula many families resort to watering down their baby's feed or even to stealing. This is a situation that is likely to have worsened as a result of the cost of living crisis.
So my question is, AIBU in thinking that it is wrong to penalise bottle-feeding parents when it comes to the cost of formula?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TheoTheopolis23 · 14/08/2023 22:04

Even the MHS antenatal breast feeding info ..... What little breast feeding I managed was due to watching YouTube on breast feeding and pumping.

TheoTheopolis23 · 14/08/2023 22:02

Oh and the NHS insistence in NHS antenatal classes on teaching only breast feeding meant that my partner and I were having to look up and follow instructions online for safely making up a bottle of formula, while stressed shitless and sleep deprived and me with a caesarian wound etc. Not one word on how to do what we ended up forced to do what felt like a million times by the time lo was 6 months.

ditalini · 14/08/2023 22:00

Wexone · 14/08/2023 21:50

it the who that have implemented these rules and I actually agree with them. it stops parents buying the cheapest each week and switching brands. also the damage that has happened in the past especially China.
aptamil and cow and gate are different recipes you need to look at at the ingredients specifically to see it. it's also the likes of tescos etc that set the price. the law only states you can't sell below cost. so the retailer is buying at cost price and then putting their mark up on that in trh shops. it's not an easy product to make if it was there would be loads more brands producing it. aldi have their own brand however you don't see tescos etc having their own brand do you ? manufacturing is heavily regulated and audited by every health board. its as close to phrama standards as food will eve be. they also make a load of specialised milk such as pre term allergies to protein lactose intolerant etc all which help babies get fed. I do however disagree with the huge bashing ff mamies get. I have worked in prevosie life with people who can't breastfed fir whatever reason and suffered so badly mental health wise. the shame they carried and judgement they felt was shocking. and it came from women. why on earth why ? shown also in this thread no one whatsoever should be judged and shamed by it. we should be celebrating the fact that you have brought life into teh world and are tenderly going through teh beginning stages of your child's life. we are lucky to live in a country where we have a choice and shouldn't shame anyone for their choice whatever it is. there is a blogger I follow who has spoken candidly that she has chosen to ff and that's her choice. but the vile messages she got from people about it was pure spiteful. its your choice and do not let anyone make you feel shameful for it

Actually there used to be more brands of milk including supermarket brands.

It's very difficult to compete on price in the market - there is enormous brand loyalty and the bulk of the cost to the leading brands is in marketing to reinforce this loyalty, and the image of an Aptimil baby or a SMA baby.

The formula is set by law to be as nutritious and safe as possible. Any differences are marketing, not proven improvements - if they were proven beneficial all formulas would have it.

Formula is good, essential food for babies and massively overpriced.

TheoTheopolis23 · 14/08/2023 21:59

*breast implanted, obviously

TheoTheopolis23 · 14/08/2023 21:57

Oliotya · 14/08/2023 21:39

Breastfeeding is a skill. It has to be learned. It took me 2 babies, nipples shields, copious amounts of lanolin, and paracetamol before I mastered it. It comes easier to some than others, but it has to be learned none the less. Other cultures are exposed to breastfeeding all their lives, so they've already had "lessons." Whereas I had never seen breastfeeding close up until I was trying to feed my own baby.
Breastfeeding is not a privilege. It is a skill, and it is an achievement. But it absolutely does not make a superior mother.

This . We in the UK are so cut off from breast feeding.

Boobs on page 3 - acceptable & normal.
Boobs being used to feed children - abnormal and l, to some extent, unacceptable.

There was virtually nowhere I felt comfortable feeding.

I have three older sisters and none of them breast fed past a week or so. I'd never seen it. I tried watching YouTube videos. Neither my mum not my sisters could advise or help because they hadn't done it. Mum and one sister were helpless verging on obstructive. I was made to feel selfish, foolish, idealistic, unrealistic, earth mama wannabe, zealous etc for wanting to. It was so clearly seen as pointless by the. And they so clearly thought a baby could not he fed to sustenance that way.

The midwives were useless.

I was advised to use sticky, non spreading lanolin on deep gouges I had on both nipples. They stayed sticky and sore. I had an Epsom salts bath, entirely my own idea; and they closed up and healed v quickly.

The breast feeding support consisted of me sitting in a narrow room with three women and their male husbands/partners sitting opposite .... The men trying to avert their eyes from women other than their wives, while the assistants went around each couple (or in my case just me, because I'd left my partner in the car). I paid for a private midwife session rather than go back. That was pretty much useless too - the only thing of use was her telling me I could just feed from one breast if one wasn't working out, as it wasn't at the time.

I had one public place where I felt just about comfortable breast feeding in public, esp if the other antenatal class Mums were there doing it too, but I moved back home to my rural, parochial, conservative region of the UK and there was nowhere I felt comfortable.... I never saw other women breast feeding. Then I travelled (put under pressure to see relatives with the baby) and same story, so what little breast feeding I was doing fell away.

There is no culture of breast feeding in this country.

The contrast of the Botoxed, lip filled, brear implanted, glam, cleavage-y, page 3, culture we've got . With the discomfort we have with the use of breasts for their main purpose is beyond fucked up.

110APiccadilly · 14/08/2023 21:56

Clefable · 14/08/2023 18:07

I do wish there was an easier way to donate formula - I had an unopened tub of Kendamil from when I was getting BFing established with DD2 and trying to get rid of it was is really difficult. The food bank won't take it, I can't advertise it on FB or anywhere like that, so I eventually managed to offload it at a baby class to someone who probably didn't really need it to save money but it was better than it going to waste. Perhaps there was another avenue, but it wasn't immediately obvious to me where that was. It feels like there needs to be a common sense approach when breastfeeding is no longer an option; 3/4mo babies needs to be fed and aren't going to be able to be suddenly be breastfed.

But I think the rewards points thing is fairly inconsequential. You could just use the points to buy other stuff you need and use the money saved to buy formula really. And I think if cost is an initial reason for people to consider breastfeeding when they might not have otherwise, that's probably a good thing.

I had an opened tin of formula and put it on a local Facebook parents' free stuff group. Are you not supposed to do that? Seems a bit off. I just wanted it not to be wasted.

Snugglemonkey · 14/08/2023 21:55

ironorchids · 14/08/2023 19:48

The argument that "you're not being penalised, just not being rewarded" doesn't make any sense.

Not being rewarded is being penalised.

If a man doing your job was paid 40% more than you as part of a government scheme to encourage men into the workplace, and you asked for that payrise but were told "it's only available to men" due to government regulations, then yes you're being penalised. But for those government restrictions, you'd be able to get that 40%? Penalised.

The idea that formula companies will exploit any regulation loophole they can seems clearly true though.

OK, so breastfeeding mothers are not rewarded. Is it not OK that actually noone is rewarded/benefitted and that rewards are kept away from infant feeding.

Rollonsept · 14/08/2023 21:54

MarleyMallow · 14/08/2023 21:48

I’m really sorry. That’s so shit. And as I say, it just doesn’t matter by the time they get to school, you wouldn’t know who was and who wasn’t. Such a weird flex.

Agree it's weird to complain people sneered at you. Then you also go and sneer at others for the opposite choice all because "I had my fair share". You sound about 5 years old.

Rollonsept · 14/08/2023 21:52

StrandedStarfish · 14/08/2023 21:40

Why don’t you suggest to the companies who market infant formula to charge less and make less profit so that families buying it pay less? I’m sure they will happily do this.

Great idea 🤣

Oliotya · 14/08/2023 21:51

Babyboomtastic · 14/08/2023 21:45

I'm not sure it does always have to be learned. As I mentioned upthread, my baby essentially strongarmed me into breastfeeding. I knew nothing about holds or latches, baby just helped herself and got on with it. It was mentally difficult (especially as I was desperate for her to take a bottle), but physically there was no learning curve. I tried to jepardise my supply, and I couldn't even.

I appreciate that my experience may be unusual, and is very much 'breastfeeding privilege'. I appreciate that for most women its difficult at first, but there's also a huge range, and sometimes it just happens. For others it won't, irrespective of effort.

Great if it does come that naturally to some. I still thoroughly disagree that it's a privilege. Even if the struggle is only mental, even if it's easy to establish, it requires dedication and commitment from the mother alone that formula feeding doesn't. I don't see why you wouldn't consider that an achievement.

Wexone · 14/08/2023 21:50

it the who that have implemented these rules and I actually agree with them. it stops parents buying the cheapest each week and switching brands. also the damage that has happened in the past especially China.
aptamil and cow and gate are different recipes you need to look at at the ingredients specifically to see it. it's also the likes of tescos etc that set the price. the law only states you can't sell below cost. so the retailer is buying at cost price and then putting their mark up on that in trh shops. it's not an easy product to make if it was there would be loads more brands producing it. aldi have their own brand however you don't see tescos etc having their own brand do you ? manufacturing is heavily regulated and audited by every health board. its as close to phrama standards as food will eve be. they also make a load of specialised milk such as pre term allergies to protein lactose intolerant etc all which help babies get fed. I do however disagree with the huge bashing ff mamies get. I have worked in prevosie life with people who can't breastfed fir whatever reason and suffered so badly mental health wise. the shame they carried and judgement they felt was shocking. and it came from women. why on earth why ? shown also in this thread no one whatsoever should be judged and shamed by it. we should be celebrating the fact that you have brought life into teh world and are tenderly going through teh beginning stages of your child's life. we are lucky to live in a country where we have a choice and shouldn't shame anyone for their choice whatever it is. there is a blogger I follow who has spoken candidly that she has chosen to ff and that's her choice. but the vile messages she got from people about it was pure spiteful. its your choice and do not let anyone make you feel shameful for it

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 21:49

TheoTheopolis23 · 14/08/2023 21:41

WTAF.

If you have a brain, you observe and retain the brand names of anything you see, it doesn't mean you but it or don't think it's crap.

There are plenty of people who will have seen formula brands in eg relative's houses but not formula fed themselves.

In general, I'm aware of the brand names of cigarettes, chocolate, washing powder etc I don't smoke, I eat only 70% cocoa fair trade chocolate, and I buy whatever the cheapest or most readily available eco brand of washing detergent I can get a hold of. Being aware of the brand names of anything does not make me affected by their marketing.

Do you think marketing only works if 100% of the population buy the product?

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 21:49

If you have a brain, you observe and retain the brand names of anything you see

Yes - because you’re being marketed to in a way you remember.

Dont be offended by it - we are ALL susceptible to marketing

MarleyMallow · 14/08/2023 21:48

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 21:39

You’re too nice that’s why. Trust me I had my share of being sneered at.

I’m really sorry. That’s so shit. And as I say, it just doesn’t matter by the time they get to school, you wouldn’t know who was and who wasn’t. Such a weird flex.

Babyboomtastic · 14/08/2023 21:45

Oliotya · 14/08/2023 21:39

Breastfeeding is a skill. It has to be learned. It took me 2 babies, nipples shields, copious amounts of lanolin, and paracetamol before I mastered it. It comes easier to some than others, but it has to be learned none the less. Other cultures are exposed to breastfeeding all their lives, so they've already had "lessons." Whereas I had never seen breastfeeding close up until I was trying to feed my own baby.
Breastfeeding is not a privilege. It is a skill, and it is an achievement. But it absolutely does not make a superior mother.

I'm not sure it does always have to be learned. As I mentioned upthread, my baby essentially strongarmed me into breastfeeding. I knew nothing about holds or latches, baby just helped herself and got on with it. It was mentally difficult (especially as I was desperate for her to take a bottle), but physically there was no learning curve. I tried to jepardise my supply, and I couldn't even.

I appreciate that my experience may be unusual, and is very much 'breastfeeding privilege'. I appreciate that for most women its difficult at first, but there's also a huge range, and sometimes it just happens. For others it won't, irrespective of effort.

JenWillsiam · 14/08/2023 21:43

Oliotya · 14/08/2023 21:39

Breastfeeding is a skill. It has to be learned. It took me 2 babies, nipples shields, copious amounts of lanolin, and paracetamol before I mastered it. It comes easier to some than others, but it has to be learned none the less. Other cultures are exposed to breastfeeding all their lives, so they've already had "lessons." Whereas I had never seen breastfeeding close up until I was trying to feed my own baby.
Breastfeeding is not a privilege. It is a skill, and it is an achievement. But it absolutely does not make a superior mother.

I completely disagree. When I was well it was a breeze, no issues at all. A LOT easier than formula feeding. Had I not been in intensive care for my other child I would never have gone through the effort of formula.

TheoTheopolis23 · 14/08/2023 21:41

WeetabixTowels · 14/08/2023 18:52

Also makes me laugh that people confidently proclaim that THEY aren't affected by marketing/advertising, yet simultaneously fall for the ridiculous "closest to breastmilk" claims by the likes of Aptamil

Yea this always makes me laugh. If people know the brand names - SMA, Aptamil etc - they have been affected by marketing

WTAF.

If you have a brain, you observe and retain the brand names of anything you see, it doesn't mean you but it or don't think it's crap.

There are plenty of people who will have seen formula brands in eg relative's houses but not formula fed themselves.

In general, I'm aware of the brand names of cigarettes, chocolate, washing powder etc I don't smoke, I eat only 70% cocoa fair trade chocolate, and I buy whatever the cheapest or most readily available eco brand of washing detergent I can get a hold of. Being aware of the brand names of anything does not make me affected by their marketing.

StrandedStarfish · 14/08/2023 21:41

Why don’t you suggest to the companies who market infant formula to charge less and make less profit so that families buying it pay less? I’m sure they will happily do this.

StrandedStarfish · 14/08/2023 21:40

Why don’t you suggest to the companies who market infant formula to charge less and make less profit so that families buying it pay less? I’m sure they will happily do this.

Rollonsept · 14/08/2023 21:39

MarleyMallow · 14/08/2023 21:34

See I don’t get this. I breastfeed and so do some of my friends, but I couldn’t care less about those that formula feed or why. Not my baby, not my business. I’ve never met anyone (except for online) who is sanctimonious about it. The only time I’ve met wankers in real life was a doctor who told me not to use formula (I won’t say why on here) and all the people who give me stares or their opinion on the fact I still breastfeed my 3 year old - but I couldn’t care less, not their baby (well, not a baby anymore), not their business.

Are people in real life really giving shit to formula feeding mums? I just don’t get why? It’s not their child so who cares? And by the time they reach school you couldn’t tell which kid has been breastfed and which hasn’t?!

👏👏👏

Oliotya · 14/08/2023 21:39

JenWillsiam · 14/08/2023 21:21

Thats the point. It’s only straightforward if you can do it. If there are any difficulties it’s not straightforward. For some it comes easy, for others it does not.

“breastfeeding privilege” refers to those who were able to do it. And yes “poo privilege” would be the same. To those who cannot do it, who require support, intervention etc etc looking at those who can do it with ease, that’s a privilege.

Breastfeeding is a skill. It has to be learned. It took me 2 babies, nipples shields, copious amounts of lanolin, and paracetamol before I mastered it. It comes easier to some than others, but it has to be learned none the less. Other cultures are exposed to breastfeeding all their lives, so they've already had "lessons." Whereas I had never seen breastfeeding close up until I was trying to feed my own baby.
Breastfeeding is not a privilege. It is a skill, and it is an achievement. But it absolutely does not make a superior mother.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 21:39

MarleyMallow · 14/08/2023 21:35

Sorry, that was @Blossomtoes. I’m not being critical or disbelieving what you say I just can’t get my head round it.

You’re too nice that’s why. Trust me I had my share of being sneered at.

MarleyMallow · 14/08/2023 21:35

Sorry, that was @Blossomtoes. I’m not being critical or disbelieving what you say I just can’t get my head round it.

ChristmasKraken · 14/08/2023 21:35

JusthereforXmas · 14/08/2023 21:04

We used cow and gate because it was always cheapest.

Same with little angel nappies, purely because it was cheapest and the cost adds up quick.

I didn't go 'ooo... Hienz make these shitbag so it must be so much better than Asdas own brand'.

Branding doesn't really matter with baby stuff, you are more likely to get recommended something by other mams who say something works than to just see 'adverts' for them and think that it we are 'pampers' family from now on.

Branding doesn't really matter with baby stuff

I hate to tell you, but even the "recommended by other mums" will have been a marketing strategy at some point. There are people who teach and study the psychology of marketing. Branding isn't just the adverts. It's the price, the packaging, the subtly sponsored articles in parenting magazines, the subliminal messaging that we don't even register (take the phrase "breast is best" that several people have mentioned here - a phrase that was actually developed by a formula company to quietly suggest that breastfeeding is an almost unachievable gold standard..). Huge amounts of money goes in to researching how best to influence people's purchasing decisions, and if word of mouth is deemed most effective, then they'll be making damn sure their product is the one being recommended by all your mum friends.

elliejjtiny · 14/08/2023 21:35

I've done both so I know everything Wink. Personally I much preferred breastfeeding because it was easier once I got the hang of it, especially post section. It was so much easier to scoop the baby out of his cot and latch him on than go and sterilize everything when I had just had a section.