Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not enforce property rights of young children?

35 replies

FlakiestCornflakeInTheCerealBox · 14/08/2023 12:02

How do you deal with this in your house with your kids? I feel like I need a systematic approach that is consistent and fair without breaking the bank or having to buy two sets of all toys.

DD is 6 and DS is 2. When they both want the same toy my rule is that irrespective of whom the toy "officially belongs to", the person that is playing with it at the moment gets to keep it till they are done and then the other child gets their turn. (It's the same rule when their friends come to our house to play). The only exceptions are toys that are unsafe for ds2, crafty things that dd6 is working on or anything that belongs to DD that ds might break or ruin somehow because he's a wild little toddler. Oh and dd's favourite soft toy is also exempt from this rule and theoretically anything else that means a lot to either child but so far it's just the one soft toy. If they told me categorically that they don't want to share something I'd respect that. The toys up for grabs are things like Duplo, cars, balls, etc. These are mostly toys that are usually in the living room aka their play room that both of them have equal access to.

Yanbu

My reasons for this rule are:

  1. DD being the older one has a ton of toys that I want to reuse with ds. A lot of them she has outgrown but obviously when she sees ds play with them she finds them irresistibly interesting again. I don't want to have to buy lots of toys for Ds again when our house is already full of them especially when he's still too young to really notice who gets more presents, etc. (I do try to balance the numbers on Christmas kind of so thqt DD doesn't feel we treat Ds differently but some of the presents he gets are dd's old toys picked by her and given to him by her).
  1. Ds, being a toddler, screams blue murder if he doesn't get what he wants immediately and I want neither of them to learn that screaming (and hitting, kicking, etc) gets you what you want.
  1. I don't want DD to learn that she always has to give in to others to keep the peace (as dh and grandparents sometimes encourage her to). What kind of message does that send especially to a girl?

The alternative would be to give the "owner" of the toy absolute power over the toy. So if ds is playing with Duplo blocks that were given to DD originally then he has to return them as soon as she asks for them as they belong to her. However, this would then usually go in dd's favour as over the years she has accumulated many more toys obviously.

So what do you do (or have done)?

Yabu: each child should have clear ownership of their toys and not need to share them (or take turns with them) till they officially gift the other child said toy, which then transfers full ownership to the other child.

Yanbu: continue doing what you are doing and stop overthinking things. They will learn about property rights soon enough.

Also apologies for the length and messiness of the post. I just can't express myself concisely.

OP posts:
TropicalTrama · 14/08/2023 12:14

Re your update- DD needs to tidy up herself and put stuff back in her room if she doesn’t want it to become communal. One of those fabric toy baskets with handles is ideal as she can chuck everything in it at the end of the day and carry it up to bed. Remind her then when she brings something down it’s to
share and play with together. If she doesn’t want to do that then of course that’s fine but then it needs to stay in her room.

FlakiestCornflakeInTheCerealBox · 14/08/2023 12:12

Notsoadmirablecrichton · 14/08/2023 12:08

Get an egg timer or similar and teach them to ask politely for a turn and then the one with the toy can either choose to pass it on straight away or extend for the period of the timer.

I sometimes time it (eg if there are most children and everyone wants a turn) but sometimes it's good for them to have something for as long as they want so that they can really express their ideas without being rushed.

OP posts:
TropicalTrama · 14/08/2023 12:12

I have a the same ages and sex so I totally get this!! DD keeps her special toys that she doesn’t want her brother touching and/or stuff that really isn’t suitable like lego in her room. Anything in the living room is communal so whoever got their first gets to play with it. If he’s playing happily will the Duplo fire truck then she does not get to snatch it off him because we bought it before he was born. She has learned to get him to trade so to offer him something else to get what she wants but as long as no one’s screaming then I just stay out of it tbh.

FlakiestCornflakeInTheCerealBox · 14/08/2023 12:10

Cloudsandrainnotsunandsand · 14/08/2023 12:05

Isn't sharing the best option?

What do you mean by sharing? With some things they can't both have it at exactly the same time.

OP posts:
FlakiestCornflakeInTheCerealBox · 14/08/2023 12:10

Normalnormal · 14/08/2023 12:05

In our house if toys are in communal areas then whoever gets it first can continue playing with it but special toys you don’t want others to touch have to stay in your bedroom and others have to ask before playing with others toys in their rooms.

This is kind of what we do but most things end up coming down to the living room because the kids don't want to.play on their own in their room and nobody can be bothered to tidy up in the evening so if the toys are safe for both and not explicitly special to DD I just let them be downstairs while both kids are still interested in them. Also, the bigger toys like ride along cars or a play kitchen are in the living room and they both love both thouf originally the ride along car was dd's (though she never showed any interest till ds fell in love with it and the kitchen we got for ds but knowing that both of them would love playing with it).

This is sort of light hearted but I want to be fair, I don't want either child to feel they are being treated unfairly and I don't want to do anything that might inadvertently make them resent each other.

OP posts:
TeenDivided · 14/08/2023 12:08

Normalnormal · 14/08/2023 12:05

In our house if toys are in communal areas then whoever gets it first can continue playing with it but special toys you don’t want others to touch have to stay in your bedroom and others have to ask before playing with others toys in their rooms.

That's what we did. (5 year gap)
Plus DD1 wasn't allowed to give toys / books etc to DD2.
If DD1 didn't want them any more then she said so, but I decided if and when to pass them to DD2.

Notsoadmirablecrichton · 14/08/2023 12:08

Get an egg timer or similar and teach them to ask politely for a turn and then the one with the toy can either choose to pass it on straight away or extend for the period of the timer.

PuttingDownRoots · 14/08/2023 12:06

We have communal toys and personal toys.

Personal stuff is things like your latest birthday present, the special lego set, your Teddy etc

Communal stuff was the general lego, the train set, the barbies, the building blocks, general craft supplies etc.

Anything someone was working on was personal... but you could hog the whole lego your personal creation for example

Cloudsandrainnotsunandsand · 14/08/2023 12:05

Isn't sharing the best option?

Normalnormal · 14/08/2023 12:05

In our house if toys are in communal areas then whoever gets it first can continue playing with it but special toys you don’t want others to touch have to stay in your bedroom and others have to ask before playing with others toys in their rooms.