Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Downstairs neighbour works nights, AIBU?

241 replies

WFHWithNightsNeighbour · 13/08/2023 23:38

It’s just me and a DC aged 9 at home.

Downstairs neighbour works 4 nights a week then has his own DC every Saturday to Monday.

We be as considerate as we can but I wfh 3 days a week, I have already upped my office days by 1 per week to accommodate downstairs. I cannot go in anymore days as we no longer have our own desks and there’s more staff than desks, we have to book and we’re only guaranteed 1 day per week in the office, I had to argue for 2 days.

Which means at least 3 days per week I am wfh. Sadly my office days are Monday (when he’s off) and Thursday. I have no control over my days, I can’t swap them unless I have a face to face meeting on another day which doesn’t tend to happen.

I don’t run my washing machine in the day, I don’t use my hoover in the week at all, I don’t play music while I’m working.

But I do have to take virtual meetings, sometimes with clients. These are usually 2-3 times a day for 30-60minutes at a time.

I do these at the kitchen table which is the furthest room from downstairs bedroom. I use noise cancelling headphones and talk as quietly as possible. I get that it’s noisy but I have to work, if I don’t work then my own mental health suffers. I love my job.

I don't let DC run around inside with shoes on, and they're at school in term time or holiday club in holidays unless I'm on Annual Leave (I don't WFH with my DC at home).

Apparently, I’m constantly disturbing him, he can hear me typing reports and taking calls. He's been woken up several times over the last week by me working and he's knocked on my door each time. He’s also complained to our housing association previously who sympathised but basically told him it was normal household noise. I know because I've had a letter which had the title "Noise Complaint" but said "We've visited the complainents property at the times of day the complaint was made about and decided that this falls into the category of everyday household noise and therefore no action will be taken. No further complaints on this matter will be considered"

He then accused me of running a business from my flat (which is against tenancy) but they came and saw it was just a wfh job and said it was fine.They did ask me if I could go into the office more but when I showed them the email from my manager saying he had to cap it at 2 days per week and the reasons why they said that he (downstairs) would have to cope.

What else can I do? I don’t want to fall out with him. No chance of being rehoused as there’s a CAO for contact which states I have to live within a certain distance of ExH and we’re already at that boundary, I’ve been offered further away but when I discussed it with ExH he said he’d take me back to court over it which I can’t afford either mentally or monetary – the last case cost me over £15k which I’m still repaying 4 years after it ended.

OP posts:
PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 14/08/2023 06:47

tabulahrasa · 14/08/2023 06:04

I don’t believe he can hear you typing... I have perfectly normal hearing and I can’t hear it from the next room of my house if the door is shut, I absolutely definitely don’t hear it from upstairs when I’m downstairs.

He is just harassing you at this point

We have terribly thin walls in the office. I can definitely hear the person next to me typing. Typing, talking, opening a particularly loud can / fizzy drink.

but that shouldn’t be the case in a regular office.
and it certainly shouldn’t be the case across floors / between apartments.

the neighbour is either overly sensitive (and / or lying). Or it’s a case of absolutely abysmal noise isolation. Either way: not the OP’s problem.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 14/08/2023 06:44

you sound like a very reasonable, considerate and lovely neighbour.

there is nothing else you can or should do.

Ignore the neighbour.
his behaviour actually seems on the verge of being harassing. I would keep that in mind going forward.

MintJulia · 14/08/2023 06:40

Your neighbour is being absurd. You are entitled to 'normal enjoyment' of your home and that includes talking on the phone.

Normal life goes on in daylight, and he needs to accept that other people are active during the day. If he wants total silence he needs to find a detached property in the middle of nowhere.

sashh · 14/08/2023 06:34

In your place I'd probably learn to tap dance. While using the washer and vacuum.

It's his problem, he can move or buy ear plugs.

tabulahrasa · 14/08/2023 06:04

I don’t believe he can hear you typing... I have perfectly normal hearing and I can’t hear it from the next room of my house if the door is shut, I absolutely definitely don’t hear it from upstairs when I’m downstairs.

He is just harassing you at this point

Misty84 · 14/08/2023 05:58

Symphony830 · 14/08/2023 00:09

I am totally dumbfounded that you have rearranged your working life and normal activities to accommodate this individual - a man that lives downstairs and works unsociable hours.

I’d start making a log of when he knocks on your door and present it to the Housing Association as harassment.

He is the problem!!!!

This!!!

mafsfan · 14/08/2023 05:39

You need to toughen up OP.

All the noise has been described as normal household noise - if two adults lived there they would be talking so no difference to your work calls.

Time to stop living by his rules. Tell him you will no longer answer the door when you're working - he needs to respect your work as you have been respecting his working patterns. Keep a log if his harassment of you and take it to the HA if you need to. You're allowed to use your washing machine during the day if you want to!

truthhurts23 · 14/08/2023 05:28

he needs to shut the fuck up

Codlingmoths · 14/08/2023 05:24

You have done more to accomodate him than I would have if it were my own Dh working nights. I’d have told my Dh well if i can’t run the washing machine then we won’t have any clean washing so you can either let me get on with it or take over doing all the washing. I’ve worked nights. My bedroom was next to the laundry and I can guarantee you nobody adjusted anything about their schedule to accomodate me. If he comes around again tell him you are going to complain about being harassed if he knocks on your door one more time to complain about the noise, which has been assessed as normal everyday life, and the only thing he has accomplished is make you truly regret making the efforts you have to be quiet during the day.

jellybe · 14/08/2023 05:19

I work nights and though it is annoying to be woken by the neighbours on a sleep day I know that it isn't OTT noise it is just normal life and that I need to suck it up and sort it my end to help me sleep rather than blaming them for living in their house. (We live in a semi).
Honestly, ignore him. It isn't your problem you are being as considerate as you can but at the end of the day you are allowed to live in your home and make noise.

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/08/2023 05:07

You've already gone too far IMO and I say this as someone who WFH, but works late/stays up late/sleeps late. I finish work at 10, I rarely go to bed before 6am and so sleep til 11 or 12 (sometimes I do a super late and finish work at 2am or even 6am!).

People who choose to work nights or live a more nocturnal lifestyle have to suck it up, the rest of the world, the majority of the world does not run to those hours. You learn to sleep through noise - I can kip through most things except loud building work/lawnmowers outside my window!

Start pulling back on some of the OTT things you're doing - he doesn't appreciate the efforts you're already making. Hoover at a normal time of day, take calls where its comfy for you to do that, listen to the bloody radio or music if you want, its your home, you're meant to be able to enjoy it!

He has already burned his bridges by complaining about stuff that is perfectly reasonable. If he continues to try that and tries making malicious complaints again, he is going to find no one listens and if he really persists he is possibly going to get himself evicted!

I think trying to avoid falling out with this guy is a ship that sailed long ago, you were NEVER going to avoid that, because his demands are not reasonable and no matter what you did, it would not be enough.

forgetmenottt · 14/08/2023 05:06

I really think he can't hear you

Badgerstmary · 14/08/2023 05:06

Realistically op I think you are treating your neighbour more as a controlling partner than a neighbour. You should be able to do your washing & vacuuming, & live a normal life & not be controlled by a neighbour who chooses to work unsociable hrs. He should be wearing earplugs & if he can’t cope living there, he needs to move or change jobs. He should be grateful to you, not complaining.

user1492757084 · 14/08/2023 04:56

I agree that you are reasonable and your neighbour needs to use ear plugs.

If you are threatened with having to move you could always invest in a small work pod - a manufactured sound proof, glassed in tiny wooden room with a table and power sockets.
One benefit is that you only have to heat and cool that little chamber for the day's work too.

forgetmenottt · 14/08/2023 04:48

How old is the flat? Is it just you and him or do you have other neighbours?

readingismycardio · 14/08/2023 04:41

You're not the one with the anti social schedule. he is!!! This is his problem, not yours.

momamama · 14/08/2023 04:21

I work a lot of nights and sleep in the day in a busy house with 3 young children and barky dogs. Some white noise does wonders for blocking them out!

saffronsoup · 14/08/2023 04:21

Sounds like the building has terrible sound proofing if he can hear your calls and typing from the other end of the house.

I would be a bit concerned about confidentialy / privacy with clients given he can hear you. Different issue from sleep.

I have lived upstairs and downstairs and also worked nights. I was never a great day sleeper and had both upstairs and downstairs neighbours when I worked nights. It does wear you down both mentally and physically but the options are to move as you can't manage anyone's environment but your own. Some jobs / careers just come with nights. You can't just switch to straight days.

Mumof3girlsandaboy · 14/08/2023 03:53

Sparklynewname · 14/08/2023 00:31

I worked nights for years. Next door had a loft conversion done and the builders apologised that they had taken the roof off when I left the house to go and get the kids from school. I assured them that they could have taken MY roof off and I would have slept through it because I was so knackered lol
Your neighbour needs to either learn to block out noise a bit or change his shifts.

This is me. I work 3 nights straight and when I go to sleep I don’t hear anything until my alarm goes off. My children are at home even with my son’s tv on loud I hear nothing!

Toddlerteaplease · 14/08/2023 03:45

It's really not your problem. I work nights and would not expect my neighbours to cut down their normal household noise so I can sleep.

Thatladdo · 14/08/2023 03:37

He's not managing with working nightshifts, simple as that.
Ive worked shifts for over 20 years, if your tired you'll sleep - He needs earplugs maybe.
His problem not yours, if you live around other people your going to hear them. The world doesnt stop just because you work nights - youve been more than accomodating so stop worrying about it.

Legendofthesea · 14/08/2023 02:46

As a shift worker, he must be a light sleeper

Go about your day as normal
Use the washing machine, TV, hoover etc

He can change his job, if he has issues sleeping

QueenofLouisiana · 14/08/2023 02:25

Honestly OP, I think you are being really considerate. It’s now a him problem, not a you problem.

LadyGaGasPokerFace · 14/08/2023 02:22

If your neighbour wants peace and quiet he can go buy himself a detached house.

PeanutButterOnToad · 14/08/2023 02:19

He has taken his complaint as far as he can so now he just has to live with it or take whatever measures HE needs to take, this is not on you. If he continues to knock on your door, or approach you to complain, I would make it very clear that you view such actions as harassment and will be contacting the police if he doesn’t stop. Nobody wants to fall out with their neighbours but you can’t live your life afraid of annoying him.