Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate the whole NHS heroes mantra

61 replies

Whatsthepoint1234 · 13/08/2023 21:15

As the title says. I’m a nurse and to be quite honest the whole ‘nhs hero saves the day’ tripe really pisses me off. I’ve worked in healthcare since I left uni and the amount of useless colleagues I have who genuinely don’t give a shit about patients annoys me. My ds is disabled and the attitude of some staff towards him has been disgusting. I think as nhs workers some of us are good and some bad and we don’t need worshipping.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Whatsthepoint1234 · 14/08/2023 15:33

@Kabbalah sorry English isn’t my first language…

OP posts:
Kabbalah · 14/08/2023 15:31

PAID

Motomum23 · 14/08/2023 14:49

I think the word hero is too easily banded about. The NHS treats its staff terribly, as do most medical institutions, but its what you sign up for... no point going into medicine expecting an easy ride, you know its long thankless shifts full of other people's bolidy fluids. A hero is someone who does something extraordinary that isn't expected of them... like the nurses who sat next to my husbands uncle when he was a child and the air raid sirens had gone off but he was too ill to be moved... that's a hero.

Whatsthepoint1234 · 14/08/2023 14:45

Glad to see I’m not alone. I never once clapped/banged a saucepan and neither did dh! I dreaded Thursdays because ds1 would have an inevitable meltdown due to the noise. Oddly enough I had this conversation with a colleague the other day and she seemed appalled that I didn’t join in/don’t see our job as some kind of heroic gesture. I chose to work in the NHS and although I wish I was payed more, I am payed for it! This same colleague was bemoaning the Oliver McGowan training because ‘we aren’t a mental health service’ so we don’t need to understand those with developmental disabilities!?

OP posts:
Hbh17 · 14/08/2023 09:27

Like any organisation, there will be good and bad staff. The problem is that the NHS in its current financial and administrative structure needs to be completely scrapped because it's 70 years out of date and not fit for purpose. But when one says this, then one is accused of having a go at NHS staff - not at all. I know quite a few doctors/nurses, and without exception they would all shift to some kind of insurance system that provided accountability, value for money and professionalism. Sadly, the "great British public" don't get it and just want to Save Our NHS, without understanding anything about it.
Oh, and people doing a job they are paid to do are obviously not heroes!

daffodilandtulip · 14/08/2023 09:06

It's their actual job. They get paid to do it. They are free to leave if they don't like it.

As in all walks of life there are people who go above and beyond. But there are also lazy NHS staff who spin the system, incompetent staffs who it's impossible to sack and terrible mismanagement of people and resources.

If you go in with a simple problem that's easy to fix on the conveyor belt system of GP - Specialist - Treatment then all well and good. But if you've got something that is a bit strange that needs a bit of investigation - no chance.

cptartapp · 14/08/2023 07:39

Agreed. I'm a nurse of over thirty years. It never was, or has been a vocation.
Just a job.

rwalker · 14/08/2023 07:36

The majority of my nhs friends share the same view

iloveeverykindofcat · 14/08/2023 07:20

I don't know anyone in real life who thinks this. It's a Daily Mail soundbite. Most NHS workers I've interacted with have been fine. Not great, not bad. Just people doing their jobs, mostly conscientiously enough. A couple who took the piss and a couple who went the extra mile, same as anywhere. My GP readily admits that I know more about my slightly unusual condition than he does and its not surprising. He's a generalist, I have one condition that it benefits me to read up on.

tuvamoodyson · 14/08/2023 06:58

Ex nurse, hated that whole ‘angels’ nonsense. All that doorstep clapping during covid was toe curling!

TheaBrandt · 14/08/2023 06:57

How mortifying is that clapping now. Dh said so at the time and refused to do it as always (annoyingly) he was right. Remember there were threads slagging off non clappers. Madness.

110APiccadilly · 14/08/2023 06:56

The vast majority of NHS staff I've interacted with have been brilliant and lovely, though of course as it's hunan nature you remember the terrible ones better! But at the end of the day they're doing a paid job. They're mostly ime doing it well and I'm glad of that but I do find it weird the way people talk about them. (I did buy a big box of chocolates for the antenatal department after DD2 was born though - she was measuring very small and I was in there a lot.)

tiredwardsister · 14/08/2023 06:49

Mushroo · 13/08/2023 21:55

This. All my interactions with the NHS have been fine. Mainly because I have very low expectations, so everything running 30 mins behind schedule is seemingly ok, and any element of customer service is none existent.

The individuals I’ve dealt with have been perfectly pleasant and done their job to an ok standard, but I’ve never had an experience I’ve come away and felt someone had really gone the extra mile.

So your appointment was running 30 mins late?
I now work as part of a small team let me tell you about our last clinic. I work with one of the kindest most caring doctors I’ve ever met in my 40 years in the NHS. Our patients get 30 mis for each appointment. Our first patient appeared straight forward although an elderly frail man but when my colleague in polite conversation asked him if he lived alone he tells us he has no children his wife died 3 months ago and then starts to cry he reaches for his wallet and shows us a photo of his wife for 10 mins we listened to how he met her their lives together and the sadness of her developing dementia at the end of her life and his loneliness now. This added 10 mins onto his 1/2 an hour. The second patient also elderly with a elderly wife was told they had cancer we spent a long time explaining treatment and options he was shocked by the diagnosis and struggled to understand what we were saying he also had no family to help and support him. Another 15 mins added onto his 1/2 an hour. The third patient was young but exceedingly anxious she might have cancer she needed lists a reassurance queried everything we said repeatedly that added another 5 mins onto her 1/2 consultation. So the fourth patients appointment was 1/2 an hour late, they too were elderly and anxious worried and struggling to understand what was being told to them but still we sat with talked over the same info repeatedly until they understood again 10 mins longer than the allocated 1/2 an hour. We were meant to finish at 5 and by the end we were still there at 6. Every patient gets the time and treatment they require regardless of how late we running.
So next time you moan about an appointment running 1/2 an hour late it’s not because we’re sitting drinking tea it’s because we’re with patients trying to offer them the best service we can.

Bliss1221 · 14/08/2023 05:26

I never did the seal claps or dont view the nhs workers as heroes, there are some workers who i think have gone extra mile for me i have thanked the derpatment with card and chocolates but otherwise as a foreignerer i have experienced also xenophobic comments and bullying by the nhs staff

speakingofart · 14/08/2023 05:21

Oh, me too! Partly because it means we can't have sensible conversations about whether the NHS model is still feasible, and partly because my experience of the NHS over the last 3 years (thankfully limited to one A and E visit and several failed attempts to get my GP to do their job) is so utterly dire.

We need to have a serious conversation about healthcare in this country, how much money we're prepared to put into the boomer generation and several other things, and none of it will happen whilst we're going on about angels and banging bloody saucepans.

Sparklybutold · 14/08/2023 01:33

I recently had my daughter. I self discharged owing to piss poor care.

Sparklybutold · 14/08/2023 01:32

As an ex medic - I agree, most doctors don't need anymore hero worshipping! Ime many don't go into the profession because of a desire to care - motivations evolve around 2 things - power and money.

avemariiiaa · 14/08/2023 01:22

I've had to endure:

A 2 year wait for dietician support. Then got discharged with a food group chart and advice to take multi vitamins "because this could go on for years". No ongoing support and no help and advice to improve my sons extremely limited diet.

An 18 month wait for SALT.

Confirmation that the toileting issues we are facing is too complex and unusual and there is no such service available in my local area.

Still on a 1 year + wait list for CAHMS.

A forced admission to a hospital ward for obs and tests due to mental health concerns because they didn't believe the symptoms were psychological.

All for a 7 year old autistic child who is struggling massively, and I am out of my depth with complex issues.

Aswell as my relative dying face down on a toilet floor during the pandemic. Although they were known to be very unsteady and disoriented they were encouraged to make their own way to the toilet so as to avoid 'unnecessary close contact' between them and the staff. I read this in the hospital notes that I requested.

So no, I don't buy into the whole NHS heroes thing. They are doing a job that they get paid to do.
Admittedly it is a tough and unforgiving job. But I have very low expectations and high levels of disappointment and piss poor service.

QueenBitch666 · 14/08/2023 01:02

They lost all credibility with the dancing Tik Tok shite

TVstolemyevenings · 14/08/2023 00:31

EmilyBrontesGhost · 13/08/2023 23:36

Why were the government making the NHS out to be heroes?

To perpetuate the myth that there was a deadly virus going around when there clearly wasn't.

It was all gaslighting.

Oh please

can we not turn this into a covid denial thread

Those of us who worked on Hopi tap during covid can feel very sure there was a deadly virus thank you. Whether the response to it was proportionate or matched the changing knowledge is up for debate but pretending it didn’t exist? Did we all imagine the wards where every single patient died week after week?

Comfortablechair · 14/08/2023 00:25

Sorry just to add - we must talk about the mental health trauma for patients that (through personal experience) no longer can trust their health provider. This is an absolutely horrid feeling - if I get hurt or then I’m not confident I’ll survive this cos of NHS

Comfortablechair · 14/08/2023 00:19

@Whatsthepoint1234 great chat - I’ve been to see a lot of nurses and Drs in the last 24 mths due to my awful long covid - I have also ended up in a&e three times and countless (pointless) interactions with GP. Every single interaction - bear the two private ones - has been absolutely shockingly dreadful - no empathy at all (I have a fucking chronic illness which was treated like shit), no NHS support services that I could talk to about MH issues, no continuity i was a very serious case at one point life / death kind of thing and the GP doesn’t know my name and has NEVER called me for an update. They literally tried to make me feel so small,
unimportant and worthless. when your ill and vulnerable and drained you literally cannot battle through this system or raise complaints.

I’m genuinely probably tramautised by the experience but when the whole systems is basically against you where do u turn. So my lived experience is certain individuals are amazing but the NHS are not full of heroes. Sorry to offend anyone but that’s my lived honest experience.

If I could move back to a sane and respectful country like Aus I would definitely

Kabbalah · 13/08/2023 23:50

……. understanding of pain on the fuss someone visibly kicks up about it, invariably it tends to be men that do that more.

Not my experience at all and I’ve worked in A&E, Major Trauma , HDU and ICU. At home and abroad.

Fluffyowl00 · 13/08/2023 23:37

I do understand where you’re coming from. But from another perspective- NHS and firefighters are constantly glorified by the press. Try being in the police or a teacher. Same package - some are great, some awful but you are constantly the scapegoat. I know what I’d prefer.

EmilyBrontesGhost · 13/08/2023 23:36

Tinysarah1985 · 13/08/2023 23:08

Yes I am sick of it. I worked in a gp surgery during covid, all our nurses spent all day making tic tok videos, hardly being heroes! Why were the government making the NHS out to be heroes? It is their job to nurse the sick and help people recover. So glad the clapping bollocks stopped. When they put it on the telly that was when I thought it was too much.

Why were the government making the NHS out to be heroes?

To perpetuate the myth that there was a deadly virus going around when there clearly wasn't.

It was all gaslighting.

Swipe left for the next trending thread