Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take voluntary redundancy @ £115k

206 replies

anon5mill · 13/08/2023 19:22

Around £80k after tax. Or should I stay in current role with package of £140-150k + pension, healthcare. Current role is comfortable and suits lifestyle. Could be difficult to find another role with the same flexibility and money. Have niggling doubt about taking the redundancy. Have dependents, already own home, no debts. Likely to be made redundant within next 18 months if not now.

OP posts:
Grumpy101 · 14/08/2023 16:58

Take it.

  1. First round is always the most generous.
  2. If you don't, you will spend every day of work wondering when/if the second round is coming.
  3. Don't underestimate how depressing is working in a business that is in trouble and everyone is scared for their job.
MaryQueenofSocks · 14/08/2023 16:39

Comparison is the their of joy. Chin up lovely... you likely have something others don't have and would kill for. Our generation lacks being content. I work part time by choice, I prioritise being a mum and making memories with DC who is 8. I do all the school runs this come as a finicial cut for me but in happy with my choices. You do you 🙂

I work in the tech industry and I'm a high earner. I walk the kids to school in the morning and walk them home at pickup, i do every sports day, nativity, and so on. My job enables me to work remotely, live by the sea and take my kids to the beach after school in the summer.

I have zero desire to kill for what you have because I already enjoy it. I prioritise being a mum by working in an industry that provides flexibility and reward. I appreciate you're trying to make someone feel better but don't do it by throwing the rest of us under the bus.

F0RBIDDEN · 14/08/2023 13:54

*Comparison is the their of joy. Chin up lovely... you likely have something others don't have and would kill for. Our generation lacks being content. I work part time by choice, I prioritise being a mum and making memories with DC who is 8. I do all the school runs this come as a finicial cut for me but in happy with my choices. You do you 🙂
*
@Rollonsept - I just wanted to say thank you for these words. I know it's not my thread and I interrupted and everyone told me so which is fine. But I was having a shit day and shouldn't have opened or commented on it. These words really cheered me up today. You are right and I did make choices similar to yours and I wouldn't take those back! Must remind myself of that!

Thanks again

Back to your predicament OP!

MadCatLady27 · 14/08/2023 13:47

I took way way way less redundancy during COVID. I hated the job but had been treading water for ages as job hunting and writing applications were grim, and almost needed to be fired from the cannon.

What was crucial in me deciding was as it was just me and one other in our department, I thought I was safe. To have that shattered would have meant I would always be looking over my shoulder waiting for the next round. I had my consultation call and everything they said confirmed my suspicion that if it wasn't now it would be eventually so I told them I wanted voluntary, took the money and ran. It helped I hated the role and so the fact they were effectively paying me to leave, yes please!

However I very much discussed it with OH and applied for everything going even if it was a case of taking SOMETHING while I continued to look. Fortunately I got one of the roles I wanted before my notice came to an end

The fact you own your house and you have no debts and the amount you'd get would be life changing for me would make me take it. Could you put a decent chunk in something like premium bonds which can hopefully just stay safe but also acts as emergency fund if it takes longer to get a job than you think?

alwaysmovingforwards · 14/08/2023 13:13

Dotcheck · 14/08/2023 10:29

@Rollercoaster1920
I can’t imagine claiming jobseekers on such a high payout. I would hope OP is more responsible than to claim benefits she doesn’t need

Lol

BCCoach · 14/08/2023 12:48

Take it. I know people who have turned down a great voluntary deal (1 year salary + all RSUs in cash), only to be made involuntarily redundancy at statutory rates later on. Also tech sector.

Rollonsept · 14/08/2023 12:47

F0RBIDDEN · 13/08/2023 19:42

I have reached peak disappointment in myself. I earn 20k. MN makes me feel like such a fucking failure all the time.

Comparison is the their of joy. Chin up lovely... you likely have something others don't have and would kill for. Our generation lacks being content. I work part time by choice, I prioritise being a mum and making memories with DC who is 8. I do all the school runs this come as a finicial cut for me but in happy with my choices. You do you 🙂

1967buglet · 14/08/2023 12:46

I would take it, and invest the money if you can, take some time off. I’m sure you’ll get another role in the tech industry.

Blossomtoes · 14/08/2023 12:43

Currentlyonabike · 13/08/2023 20:14

You also need to consider the knock on tax implications, as it may take you into the higher earner tax bracket (the next level about 40%) where you lose tax allowance above £125k (iirc), no savings allowance, likely to move into self assessment terrority so the overall may not work as much as 80k.
Check out the higher earner tax calcs, redundancy above 30k does count as earnings.

You can avoid that to a degree by paying the maximum you can into your pension.

Crapsummer2023 · 14/08/2023 12:42

Timetochangegonzo · 13/08/2023 19:54

I have reached peak disappointment in myself. I earn 20k. MN makes me feel like such a fucking failure all the time

Sorry you feel like this but it has nothing to do with the question - start your own post

This.

murasaki · 14/08/2023 12:39

It's about getting your NI paid.i was told by a friend in the DWP who checked for me that I can't claim UC but ask for no money just NI contributions, I have to claim jobseekers to get the NI. Madness.

TenderDandelions · 14/08/2023 12:38

Mariposa26 · 13/08/2023 23:19

It’s not illegal. Most companies do this. You can’t take a tax free redundancy payment and then start a new job with the same organisation soon after. HMRC can investigate and ask whether it was a true redundancy in the first place.

Unfortunately, I've also known senior people that have been made redundant from the NHS and have then been re-employed almost immediately on a contract basis, earning more than they did as an employee.

Different budget heading isn't it?!

It also makes a mockery of their own rules about re-employment, but it is the NHS, so are we really surprised?!

TenderDandelions · 14/08/2023 12:37

I'd suggest speaking to a recruitment agent specialist to your industry if you haven't already OP. I know they all talk themselves up but they should hopefully be able to indicate what the market is like for someone of your experience and level and how flexible employers are.

If they were to enforce redundancy later, I just did a calculator that suggested statutory redundancy for a 45 year old, earning £150k p.a., having worked there for 25 years is only £14,146. Pay is capped at £643 per week for the calculation purposes.

If you think enforced redundancy is likely, and you're hesitant about whether they'd come up with a termination settlement, I'd take it now and start the job search.

To begin with you can focus on finding something that suits you perfectly, then after a few months can consider some compromises. Having a substantial redundancy in your bank account would at least help to pay for any extra childcare costs you might incur if you have to be in the office more regularly, for example.

Dotcheck · 14/08/2023 11:02

MrsDBaddiel · 14/08/2023 10:58

Why shouldn’t she? This is why she paid national insurance. What a ridiculous, sanctimonious attitude.

Perhaps. But is IS irresponsible to claim for something you don’t need.

MrsDBaddiel · 14/08/2023 10:58

Dotcheck · 14/08/2023 10:29

@Rollercoaster1920
I can’t imagine claiming jobseekers on such a high payout. I would hope OP is more responsible than to claim benefits she doesn’t need

Why shouldn’t she? This is why she paid national insurance. What a ridiculous, sanctimonious attitude.

Timeless01 · 14/08/2023 10:41

I took voluntary redundancy and I was in the first round of redundancies within a couple of years and I had a better deal than those who waited. Everybody was made redundant in the end. So I agree with pps who say take it now.

Btw yes it was taxed over £30k.

I didn’t get back to work as quickly as I hoped due to personal circumstances but as long as you have a plan that you stick to you should manage. I was also desperate to go so in that sense it was a no-brainer.

Dotcheck · 14/08/2023 10:29

@Rollercoaster1920
I can’t imagine claiming jobseekers on such a high payout. I would hope OP is more responsible than to claim benefits she doesn’t need

Rollercoaster1920 · 14/08/2023 09:14

I was in a similar (sub 100k salary) position 18 months ago. I vowed during the previous redundancy round that I would go so, had already 50% made the decision, but it was still hard.

Get a calculator out and spreadsheet the hell out of it!
Can you live off your partner's salary?
What is the leaving date? I negotiated to leave 1 May to make the most of tax allowances (and have more time before I had to get a job).
£30k is tax free, then you'll pay tax on the rest at whatever rate for that year. You are in the 60% maginal band, so definitely get the payout at the beginning of a tax year.
You can get 6 months of job seekers allowance even with a large redundancy payout.
Do you have redundancy insurance?
Watch out for the end of corporate things like death in service cover (needed for mortgage) health insurance. Company car.
Expect your tax code to be buggered for the year. Redundancy was paid to me on an emergency tax code, then new work too. So I didn't see the cash until I did self assessment the following April (first time I've ever done it early!).
I paid some money into a personal pension to get under the 60% tax trap. Your employer might let you pay into pension via salary sacrifice, with asking. Mine wouldn't.

I got 11 months salary in April. Picked up a short contract with a supplier for a few weeks, then 6 months off/job hunting. Currently on a fixed term contract for a target company. Lower level job than before but pays more.

Start looking for work properly 6 months before you are able to start. At your level 6 months notice is quite common.

Good luck!

alwaysmovingforwards · 14/08/2023 08:20

F0RBIDDEN · 13/08/2023 19:42

I have reached peak disappointment in myself. I earn 20k. MN makes me feel like such a fucking failure all the time.

Well errr thanks for sharing that.
Why not start / join a thread that's more your thing then.

Seasidechippylover · 13/08/2023 23:53

Timetochangegonzo · 13/08/2023 19:54

I have reached peak disappointment in myself. I earn 20k. MN makes me feel like such a fucking failure all the time

Sorry you feel like this but it has nothing to do with the question - start your own post

Neither does your reply. Start your own post 😂

Mumof2teens79 · 13/08/2023 23:35

Usually the first round of VS is the best offer....but it depends how many accept and the financial situation of the company.
If no-one goes for it they may up the offer if they can afford to.
If they can't afford to and continue to decline then ultimately the forced option will be closer to statutory.

Typically our highly unionised VS offers have been pretty good and lots of older staff choose to go. But you have to apply, and can be declined if your package works out too expensive or you are considered too critical. So (touch wood) never had a round of forced redundancy....but we do get people transfered to jobs they don't want, who then quit with no package.

If you need a job, and don't think you will find another within 12 months I would hang tight, simply because they may shed enough with this round that you can be secure going forward.

If you want some time with the kids and think you can find an alternative then seriously consider it.
Remember we pay a lot to work...childcare, transport, meals at work, convenience food when too busy yo cook....so you may cope for longer than you think on a payout or transfer to a different type of role.

anon5mill · 13/08/2023 23:29

Lolaandbehold · 13/08/2023 21:01

I work in a similar sector to you OP, similar earnings etc.
I originally though you should stick with your current role. On reflection, I would probably take the redundancy. Get your CV in order over the next few days. Start speaking to a few good HHs. You’re a women in tech, you’ll walk into something else. And stop with the self doubt, there’s no reason why you can’t find a new role with similar earning power or at least potential. Good luck; if you get a new role quickly, you’ll have a nice windfall towards the school fees!

No school fees to worry about!

This is exactly what I would tell other women but still find it hard to convince myself Smile

OP posts:
anon5mill · 13/08/2023 23:24

Thank you so much to everyone for sharing your experiences, perspectives and advice. Lots more to think about!

It is a really difficult decision but I also know I am really fortunate whichever decision I make.

Responses here are about 50/50. Not sure how I will get off the fence but the comments around the state of the tech sector I think confirm my thinking that it may be pretty difficult to get back into this kind of position at the moment.

OP posts:
Mariposa26 · 13/08/2023 23:19

thenightsky · 13/08/2023 21:55

Pretty sure that is illegal.

It’s not illegal. Most companies do this. You can’t take a tax free redundancy payment and then start a new job with the same organisation soon after. HMRC can investigate and ask whether it was a true redundancy in the first place.

ConstitutionHill · 13/08/2023 23:07

FudgeSundae · 13/08/2023 21:18

ALWAYS TAKE VOLUNTARY REDUNDANCY. It means you’ve already been marked for redundancy but it’s exponentially more generous than it will be when it’s mandatory. Also, when mandatory all your other colleagues will be jobhunting too. Polish your CV, take the offer and apply for jobs like mad.
(if you need more convincing work out what your statutory/contractual redundancy would be. It’s typically peanuts, 1/1.5 weeks per year of service.)

I agree