Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people do not 'obsess' over why a woman is childfree?

264 replies

Eastie77Returns · 13/08/2023 17:21

I know several women in their late 30s/early 40s who do not have children. I know one is not childfree by choice (close friend) but have no idea about the others apart from two who have actively chosen to share that they have never wanted kids. I do not spend any time at all wondering why the others do not have children. I assume they don't want them or, as is sadly the case of my friend, are unable to but it isn't something I dwell on or speculate about.

I've read multiple columnists in newspapers and articles in magazines in which child free women declare that the public at large, and mothers in particular, are 'obsessesed' with women who do not have children and it's exhausting having to constantly explain why you do not have any etc. They are fed up with the general assumption that they are selfish, career-mad, horrible child haters and this sentiment mostly comes from women who have kids. I have DC as do most of my friends. In my 10 years as a parent I have never had a conversation with any of them about 'selfish' childless women. Most of us completely understand why someone would prefer not to have kids!

I might be alone in thinking this but I honestly don't think most people really care about a woman's childbearing status. Obviously there are many ridiculous individuals who think it's ok to question a woman's choice and trott out BS like "you've never known true love/what tiredness really is until...." but I honestly think they are in the minority and the majority of mothers do not really care. Or am I being naive? My friends who are childfree by choice tell me they have occasionally been asked if they have kids but with rare exceptions have not been asked why not or any other follow up questions.

OP posts:
extramintgum · 13/08/2023 22:14

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have deleted their posts and threads.

LolaSmiles · 13/08/2023 22:13

As a childfree woman myself, I can say I have had some odd and intrusive comments/questions from people I hardly knew. "But who will look after you when you're old?" or "It's selfish not having children" and most often "you'll change your mind" or, after congratulating a woman when she told me she had just found out she was pregnant "Why do you care? You don't even like children!" and I'd never said any such thing, only that I didn't want to have any (I was 34 at the time).
That's so unpleasant. Sorry you had to deal with that.

MrsCrouch · 13/08/2023 22:11

Childfree and late 30s here. I certainly couldn't care less about whether people have kids or not. But as soon as I hit 35, certain people began asking probing and inappropriate questions about it though.

Particularly from:

  1. MIL, who is a very conservative 60s housewife type. Seems to feel embarrassed and left out that she doesn't have grandkids she can show off to all her friends who have grandkids?
  2. DP's grandma, makes it clear she thinks it's my sole purpose in life... has delusions that I would make a great SAHM, which would be financially impossible!
  3. A lot of family members/people we meet over the age of 50
  4. A manager at my work who has 4 kids and keeps asking if I think I'll end up having kids, practically on a weekly basis
  5. Couple of school friends who had kids young and seem somewhat baffled (and a little repulsed?!) by me not wanting kids

I have very complex reasons for not wanting kids, it's been a tough choice, I don't want to keep being grilled about it when I've made it clear my decision is made.

CockneySignora · 13/08/2023 22:07

CrunchyCarrot · 13/08/2023 22:05

As a childfree woman myself, I can say I have had some odd and intrusive comments/questions from people I hardly knew. "But who will look after you when you're old?" or "It's selfish not having children" and most often "you'll change your mind" or, after congratulating a woman when she told me she had just found out she was pregnant "Why do you care? You don't even like children!" and I'd never said any such thing, only that I didn't want to have any (I was 34 at the time).

Once, a total stranger at a bus stop asked if I had children, I said no. She said 'it's not too late you could still have IVF'. I was just...stunned into silence. I was 41 at the time.

And yes to all this. Then, when I did have a child, the same type of people were horrified I wasn’t planning a second. One wasn’t ‘enough’, I suspect because it looked suspiciously easy.

Lavender14 · 13/08/2023 22:06

It's not something I'd give any thought to as I'd see it as none of my business. But before we had ds, we were at a wedding and the table we were sat with (none of whom we'd met before) were doggedly asking questions about why we had no children yet, did we want children, when would we try for children etc etc and when we tried to be vague they repeatedly asked again anyway. So I can see that there are people out there who can't see why it's not an appropriate question to ask.

CockneySignora · 13/08/2023 22:05

Pandaflop · 13/08/2023 17:48

You'd have to think whether your close friends have children? Are you sure they're close friends? I mean I don't place value on my friends with children over those without but that's wild!

I’d agree with that. I was happily childfree till I was almost 40, and parenthood doesn’t particularly factor in my friendships with people with or without children, apart from the few friends I’ve made because our children are friends.

CrunchyCarrot · 13/08/2023 22:05

As a childfree woman myself, I can say I have had some odd and intrusive comments/questions from people I hardly knew. "But who will look after you when you're old?" or "It's selfish not having children" and most often "you'll change your mind" or, after congratulating a woman when she told me she had just found out she was pregnant "Why do you care? You don't even like children!" and I'd never said any such thing, only that I didn't want to have any (I was 34 at the time).

Once, a total stranger at a bus stop asked if I had children, I said no. She said 'it's not too late you could still have IVF'. I was just...stunned into silence. I was 41 at the time.

Optionyougot · 13/08/2023 21:47

Finlesswonder · 13/08/2023 21:46

I mean isn't it a bit like starting a thread saying "I've read loads of articles by people who claim to have experienced racism, but none of my friends feel that way, so what's the big deal?".

Glad I'm not the only one to think it

honeybonbon · 13/08/2023 21:46

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have deleted their posts and threads.

Finlesswonder · 13/08/2023 21:46

I mean isn't it a bit like starting a thread saying "I've read loads of articles by people who claim to have experienced racism, but none of my friends feel that way, so what's the big deal?".

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 13/08/2023 21:44

To be fair, most people don’t obsess over it. But those who do are so fucking awful that it sticks in your memory and it’s easy to think they represent the majority. When you’re told “You don’t know love until you’ve had a child”, “You’ll be lonely when you’re old” or “You’ll regret it” (note: every one of these has been said to me) it’s very easy to fear that conversations are going to lead into this emotional minefield because comments like this are bloody horrible. Yes, the people who say these things are grade A cunts but that doesn’t make it any easier to deal with.

And you’ve only got to look at the people who plop themselves onto threads on the Childfree Mumsnetters board to tell us why we’re selfish/missing out/defective to see that, sadly, these views aren’t entirely uncommon.

LolaSmiles · 13/08/2023 21:44

I don't think about someone remaining child-free/-less any more than I'd sit around ruminating on why a friend chose to have one child, or any they only have 3 instead of 4. Other women's reproductive decisions are none of my business.

If a friend shares something in their circumstances or their reasons for their situation then I would have appropriate empathy obviously, but otherwise I don't give thought to it.

Eastie77Returns · 13/08/2023 21:39

Optionyougot · 13/08/2023 21:33

I don't think you quite understood my post. I haven't said that you have written those things, I'm questioning your motivation and the relevance of your opinion in the face of those women's lived experiences.

I had a similar conversation recently with a guy who couldn't fathom that just because he wasn't sexually harassing women/his friends weren't sexually harraasing women that didnt mean the issue of sexual harassment is overblown. Enough women had experienced sexual harassment to say there was a problem with it, it's a widespread problem and at a societal level.

That's the kind of attitude that seems (to me) to be at the core of your post.

I don’t have any motivation beyond gauging other people’s opinions. I mean, this a a public forum where anyone can ask questions. I don’t have any kind of ulterior motive beyond a general interest in a topic related to women. My opinion is no more or less ‘relevant’ than anyone else’s.

You’re right in that perhaps I don’t fully understand the point you’re making.

OP posts:
Sleepytimebear · 13/08/2023 21:38

I have not wanted children for almost 40 years and I am consistently told by people I will change my mind. 1 month ago I was told by some acquaintances i still had time and if I could only find the right man they're sure I would change my mind.

I expect when I'm beyond child bearing age it will stop but for now people really think they know better. Me saying "it's not happening, I will not have a child, I'm not interested in a relationship," falls on deaf ears. I really don't think I could be clearer.

Appreciate some posters here may not care but in my experience people genuinely can't believe you are happy single and child free, no matter how clear you are with them.

honeybonbon · 13/08/2023 21:33

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have deleted their posts and threads.

Optionyougot · 13/08/2023 21:33

Eastie77Returns · 13/08/2023 20:30

I don’t think my opinion invalidates experiences.

I said I don’t think most women with children are obsessed with or particularly concerned about women who don’t have children. I was asking if anyone shared that view.

Of course judgement exists about child-free women. I didn’t say that wasn’t the case.

I don't think you quite understood my post. I haven't said that you have written those things, I'm questioning your motivation and the relevance of your opinion in the face of those women's lived experiences.

I had a similar conversation recently with a guy who couldn't fathom that just because he wasn't sexually harassing women/his friends weren't sexually harraasing women that didnt mean the issue of sexual harassment is overblown. Enough women had experienced sexual harassment to say there was a problem with it, it's a widespread problem and at a societal level.

That's the kind of attitude that seems (to me) to be at the core of your post.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 13/08/2023 21:31

But no, I'm otherwise not interested in why people don't have kids. It's none of my business and boring anyway. I'd much rather talk about interesting stuff now that I've got my childrearing years out of the way.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 13/08/2023 21:25

You know sometimes there are posts about "I'm pg and want to tell the world but SIL can't have dch/has just had a mc and I feel guilty" (or the other way round - friend is pg and I can't have dch)? Well, I feel a bit like that around childfree friends because I've seen how one of them reacts if any of us mention our dch - it obviously hurts that she couldn't have dch (she told me IVF had failed). So this is the reason that I like to know if someone has kids or not - so that I don't wade in with my size nines about how hard work/wonderful kids are in front of someone who would've loved to have them but couldn't.

faithloveandpixiedust · 13/08/2023 21:15

A childfree friend of mine said that she felt continuously judged by other women for not having children. I admit I was a bit shocked. I love being a Mum but I have never thought to question why someone else would choose not to have children. You only get one life, live it in a way that makes you happy. I have also never heard another mother talk in a judgemental way about a childfree woman. But I guess as others have said, just because I have never felt this way does not mean that the feelings of childfree women who experience judgement are not valid.

optimistic40 · 13/08/2023 21:13

I don't know anyone who is bothered in real life, but noticed a lot of odd comments to child free people on Instagram. It surprised me.

WhatDoIKnowAboutThis · 13/08/2023 21:11

HoliHormonalTigerLillyTheSecond · 13/08/2023 21:02

Who tells them this???

People.

HoliHormonalTigerLillyTheSecond · 13/08/2023 21:11

To be fair that poster was literally replying to someone who said she would pity a child-free woman whether it was by her own choice or not.

@MiddleParking think that's a troll though no? I mean in real life, how many times do people actually mention your child free status? Really?

xXJoy · 13/08/2023 21:06

There is a portion of people who judge but it's more like "id be too scared to be non-conforming myself, and I can't accept you are braver than I am, so to avoid feeling admiration, I'll judge you". This is the thought process of somebody completely lacking in self-awareness, and most people do have some self-awareness.

I know when I was younger I felt judged for being single. Couldn't give a monkeys now, if conservative people are pitying me, so me it. They can do that.

MiddleParking · 13/08/2023 21:05

HoliHormonalTigerLillyTheSecond · 13/08/2023 20:58

and this attitude of “you’re something to be pitied because you made a different choice to me,” is a problem.

you can keep your pity and save it for someone who actually needs it. Imagine if it was the other way around and child free by choice people felt sorry for you for having kids?

@CleverLilViper I don't think anyone pities you because you don't have kids. That's kind of the whole point of the thread.... why do you think anyone cares if you have kids or not?

To be fair that poster was literally replying to someone who said she would pity a child-free woman whether it was by her own choice or not.

HoliHormonalTigerLillyTheSecond · 13/08/2023 21:02

WhatDoIKnowAboutThis · 13/08/2023 17:45

If only the reast of the world was so uninterested as people here claim to be (of course few had to say they piti childfree women 🙄) but reality is that women without children do get judged, harshly.
And told they are selfish, cold, don’t know love, will regret it, die alone etc.

So, I think it’s good it talked about, so childfree women don’t have to feel so alone in this.
Society still sadly put mother’s on a pedestal and look down on women who aren’t.

Who tells them this???

Swipe left for the next trending thread