Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people do not 'obsess' over why a woman is childfree?

264 replies

Eastie77Returns · 13/08/2023 17:21

I know several women in their late 30s/early 40s who do not have children. I know one is not childfree by choice (close friend) but have no idea about the others apart from two who have actively chosen to share that they have never wanted kids. I do not spend any time at all wondering why the others do not have children. I assume they don't want them or, as is sadly the case of my friend, are unable to but it isn't something I dwell on or speculate about.

I've read multiple columnists in newspapers and articles in magazines in which child free women declare that the public at large, and mothers in particular, are 'obsessesed' with women who do not have children and it's exhausting having to constantly explain why you do not have any etc. They are fed up with the general assumption that they are selfish, career-mad, horrible child haters and this sentiment mostly comes from women who have kids. I have DC as do most of my friends. In my 10 years as a parent I have never had a conversation with any of them about 'selfish' childless women. Most of us completely understand why someone would prefer not to have kids!

I might be alone in thinking this but I honestly don't think most people really care about a woman's childbearing status. Obviously there are many ridiculous individuals who think it's ok to question a woman's choice and trott out BS like "you've never known true love/what tiredness really is until...." but I honestly think they are in the minority and the majority of mothers do not really care. Or am I being naive? My friends who are childfree by choice tell me they have occasionally been asked if they have kids but with rare exceptions have not been asked why not or any other follow up questions.

OP posts:
VerasRaincoat · 14/08/2023 07:45

I was child free not by choice but by infertility until I was 39. From about age 28 onwards I had to deal with people’s nosy enquiries or unsolicited opinions and advice about how I wasn’t getting any younger and that how children would ‘complete me’. I was quietly suffering from multiple pregnancy losses, infertility and Ivf.

So big whoop the article annoyed you, because for me when I read them and think yippee! Hopefully classless people will think before they open their traps when speaking to childfree women.

Defiantjazz · 14/08/2023 07:44

I’ve stated several times that I’m fully aware that child free women have to deal with intrusive questions, crappy comments, suspicion etc and it is 100% a big deal.

So why did you start a thread with an OP implying otherwise.

Defiantjazz · 14/08/2023 07:38

Predictably this has become a thread dominated by child-free women telling the rest of us that we actually ARE obsessed with them and their very special specialness.

It’s become a thread dominated by child free women explaining that, yes, they are sometimes looked down on and are not unhinged just because they don’t have kids.

Thesenderofthiscard · 14/08/2023 07:38

NOPE! Nor do I wonder or obsess over why someone only has one kid, or if they’re twins were naturally conceived.

because I do know that there are reasons but they ain’t my business, and if I know someone we’ll enough for them to share details then they probably will eventually

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 14/08/2023 07:34

LindorDoubleChoc · 13/08/2023 22:34

Predictably this has become a thread dominated by child-free women telling the rest of us that we actually ARE obsessed with them and their very special specialness.

Yanbu op.

It’s nothing to do with “very special specialness” as you so nastily put it. It’s to do with the fact that childfree women often have to insist again and again and a-fucking-gain that we are quite happy and fulfilled, thanks, usually in the face of someone’s insistence that we don’t know what love is/have shallow empty lives/haven’t grown up/will change our minds.

And when that message finally gets through we’re accused of insisting we’re special. Yeah, fuck off with that.

EdgeOfACoin · 14/08/2023 06:57

I didn't have kids by choice until I was almost 40. I was in a position to do so for years but I didn't want children at that point. Nobody else cared. Barely anyone asked me about it. If they did, they didn't challenge me. It Wasn't A Big Deal. However, I recognise that living in a big city probably helped with that.

But the birth rate in the UK is currently hovering around 1.5 children per woman (down from 1.9 in 2010) and getting lower. The population replacement rate needs to be 2.1. We're obviously well below that now. We're on the same trajectory as the rest of Europe where the birth rate is around 1.3 in a lot of European countries. In East Asia the downward trajectory is even more marked - the South Korean birth rate is 0.8 children per woman.

My point is that the percentage of people who are choosing a childfree life is growing rapidly. From an environmental perspective that's great! It also means that this choice is becoming increasingly normalised. There's an explosion of articles about being childfree because so many more women are opting for this lifestyle. Very soon it will stop being a radical decision (it already has, I think, although a lot of people have yet to realise it) and people who write about this topic will need to find something else to write about.

sammylady37 · 14/08/2023 06:56

A pp’s comment about builders has reminded me of when I was renovating my home and the architect kept talking about ‘space for the kids to chill out’ and ‘imagine the kids doing their homework here while you’re doing…’ etc. This was despite me having told him in our very first meeting about my needs and wants for a home, which very clearly did not encompass space for kids. When reminded of that he breezily brushed me aside with a hand wave and “oh you’re young, it’ll happen yet”. It was only when I threatened to sack him that he took me seriously.

TwistofFate · 14/08/2023 06:08

I personally don't obsess about it, because whether they never wanted them or couldn't have them is none of my business. However, a lot of other people are nosy and don't see it as a personal question so I can believe that they do get asked. We struggled with infertility and I do remember being asked if I wanted kids (often with a reminder not to leave it too late!) by people who had no idea about what we were going through. I think most people are just trying to make conversation but I also think some get defensive if someone says no I don't want them as if the questioner is being judged for having them.

theprimesuspect · 14/08/2023 01:31

I got, as a free gift along with the pity and condescension, "you could always adopt" when I was in my early fifties, chronically ill and broke!

Catsmere · 14/08/2023 01:24

Women who are childfree by choice therefore either (lucky?) that they don't have that biological instinct or aren't being honest, and both of those options I find worthy of me (privately) pondering about.

Why would we lie about it, when all society is loaded with the "you should have children" message? Or perhaps not everyone feels this urge with any strength, or just goes along with it? I certainly never felt the slightest urge to reproduce.

User3735 · 14/08/2023 00:54

Well, I don't know if I'd say obsess, but I do find it a curiosity, in that wanting children for me personally was a biological urge I'd felt since I was a child, and not a rational choice in anyway at all. I often wonder would choose to have children otherwise, it doesn't make much sense rationally. Women who are childfree by choice therefore either (lucky?) that they don't have that biological instinct or aren't being honest, and both of those options I find worthy of me (privately) pondering about. Also I bet many others like me have known women who are very vocally anti children who later have children and reinvent themselves as mother earth, and those type of people probably make it hard for those who are authentically childfree by choice to be believed. I would never question someone's choices in person, but yes, I do wonder.

Catsmere · 14/08/2023 00:23

HoliHormonalTigerLillyTheSecond · 13/08/2023 21:11

To be fair that poster was literally replying to someone who said she would pity a child-free woman whether it was by her own choice or not.

@MiddleParking think that's a troll though no? I mean in real life, how many times do people actually mention your child free status? Really?

I've had plenty of dumbfucks trot out pity and amazement that I don't have children. It only stopped when I was obviously past childbearing age - I was still getting "it's not too late!" bullshit in my late 40s.

Wednesdaysotherchild · 14/08/2023 00:18

You’d be surprised! and if it’s not you in this category then you OBVIOUSLY aren‘t facing the endless questioning so YABVU - I just tell them about all my dead babies if they won’t shut up. Older generations are the worst I find but not exclusively. It’s the damn assumption.

JamSandle · 14/08/2023 00:18

They don't obsess.

But when I'm with family they do tend to bring up those without kids with a tone of feeling sorry for them/looking down on them.

Eastie77Returns · 14/08/2023 00:12

fitzwilliamdarcy · 13/08/2023 23:49

There’s something quite odd about a mum starting a thread about how much she doesn’t care about CF women and what they do, and asking CF women to explain why we think mums think otherwise.

You clearly do care - if only to question and/or minimise our experience - so your very thread defeats the purpose of your question.

I haven’t asked child free women to explain a single thing or their opinion on what mums think. The question in my OP was not specifically directed to any particular group of women.

As it happens, several child free women responded and said no-one has ever questioned their child free status. And some responded and disagreed with my points, stating that society is in fact fixated with women who don’t have children. Isn’t that the point of a discussion board? I was writing my opinion and asked others for theirs. I’m not attempting to minimise anyone’s experience.

It’s true that I don’t care what child free women do. I don’t care what women with children do either. It’s none of my business.

OP posts:
Catsmere · 14/08/2023 00:07

Inmybirthdaysuit · 13/08/2023 17:38

Some women once they become a mum just identify as mum, it becomes the most important thing about them. I think the same can be said for some childfree people, generally the ones that would write articles about it or join specific forums, childfree is their identity.

The mum would be outraged if someone asked is Johnny walking yet? They take it as a personal slight, a dig, pointing out that their baby is behind in development and all the rest. When in reality it was just trying to make conversation. The childfree if someone asks do you have kids sees it as an attack, they think it's weird that I don't have kids, why do they want to know about my ovaries, they think every woman should have a child etc. When in reality they were just trying to make conversation.

When you don't have much in your life other than your kids or your identity as childfree then you become really protective over it and really sensitive to anything you perceive as criticism. Where as the truth is most people are too busy living their own lives and too wrapped up in themselves to care about your kid or your choice not to have kids.

I've found a clear difference between the normal making-conversation types you described and the but-don't-you-want-baybeeeees sorts - and I have encountered idiots of the latter type too often over the years! Same category who can't fathom that a woman is happy without a man, usually. 🙄

fitzwilliamdarcy · 13/08/2023 23:52

(I could give a long list of rude things that’ve been said or asked of me but I can’t be arsed. The best two are a colleague reacting to my having a lifesaving hysterectomy with “I’d rather have died than not had my kids, how do you cope with this?”, and a different colleague suggesying that people with kids don’t need annual leave as they have weekends; so they should get 1 week and parents should get double their current amount.

It’s not everyone but some people are vile.)

fitzwilliamdarcy · 13/08/2023 23:49

There’s something quite odd about a mum starting a thread about how much she doesn’t care about CF women and what they do, and asking CF women to explain why we think mums think otherwise.

You clearly do care - if only to question and/or minimise our experience - so your very thread defeats the purpose of your question.

Ponoka7 · 13/08/2023 23:26

I have been getting questions about my child free eldest for about fifteen years. She said that she can't wait to hit 40, the intrusiveness, put downs and pity might stop. My Son in law also gets it. I've been supervising my youngest DD's house renovations. She's removed radiators. One of the builders couldn't get his head around her not wanting children and seemed convinced that she will change her mind and need extra heating.
When I had one child, I found women who had 3+ insufferable. I had Single mum friends in the 80's who were demonised, as we all know. Women can't win.

zoomingale · 13/08/2023 23:15

HoliHormonalTigerLillyTheSecond · 13/08/2023 21:02

Who tells them this???

Well the third poster on this thread for one.

theresastormcoming · 13/08/2023 23:12

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Eastie77Returns · 13/08/2023 22:53

Finlesswonder · 13/08/2023 21:46

I mean isn't it a bit like starting a thread saying "I've read loads of articles by people who claim to have experienced racism, but none of my friends feel that way, so what's the big deal?".

Try re-reading my posts.

I’ve stated several times that I’m fully aware that child free women have to deal with intrusive questions, crappy comments, suspicion etc and it is 100% a big deal.

OP posts:
Evieanne · 13/08/2023 22:44

HoliHormonalTigerLillyTheSecond · 13/08/2023 20:58

Who? Where?

Ethnic and religious communities, for example

KimberleyClark · 13/08/2023 22:37

LindorDoubleChoc · 13/08/2023 22:34

Predictably this has become a thread dominated by child-free women telling the rest of us that we actually ARE obsessed with them and their very special specialness.

Yanbu op.

You sound bitter.

LindorDoubleChoc · 13/08/2023 22:34

Predictably this has become a thread dominated by child-free women telling the rest of us that we actually ARE obsessed with them and their very special specialness.

Yanbu op.