Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people do not 'obsess' over why a woman is childfree?

264 replies

Eastie77Returns · 13/08/2023 17:21

I know several women in their late 30s/early 40s who do not have children. I know one is not childfree by choice (close friend) but have no idea about the others apart from two who have actively chosen to share that they have never wanted kids. I do not spend any time at all wondering why the others do not have children. I assume they don't want them or, as is sadly the case of my friend, are unable to but it isn't something I dwell on or speculate about.

I've read multiple columnists in newspapers and articles in magazines in which child free women declare that the public at large, and mothers in particular, are 'obsessesed' with women who do not have children and it's exhausting having to constantly explain why you do not have any etc. They are fed up with the general assumption that they are selfish, career-mad, horrible child haters and this sentiment mostly comes from women who have kids. I have DC as do most of my friends. In my 10 years as a parent I have never had a conversation with any of them about 'selfish' childless women. Most of us completely understand why someone would prefer not to have kids!

I might be alone in thinking this but I honestly don't think most people really care about a woman's childbearing status. Obviously there are many ridiculous individuals who think it's ok to question a woman's choice and trott out BS like "you've never known true love/what tiredness really is until...." but I honestly think they are in the minority and the majority of mothers do not really care. Or am I being naive? My friends who are childfree by choice tell me they have occasionally been asked if they have kids but with rare exceptions have not been asked why not or any other follow up questions.

OP posts:
Alconleigh · 14/08/2023 13:21

I'm 47, no kids and have never really had people asking why. Clearly they wouldn't now, as I'm quite obviously too old, but I don't remember it in my thirties either. I am not married though and have had 4 different relationships since I turned 30, which might play a part in that. I can imagine that if you're very settled then people would be more likely to ask.
I have many friends with kids, and quite a few with none. It's not really been a major topic of conversation with either set, nor have I had some of the terrible comments from acquaintances / colleagues / randoms that other posters have experienced. I have a famously forbidding RBF though so perhaps they don't dare.....

FlakiestCornflakeInTheCerealBox · 14/08/2023 12:56

It's none of anyone's business but I think that absolutely other people take an extensive interest in why a woman doesn't have kids. Having kids seems to be the norm (especially for women) and not having them seems a noteworthy departure from that norm and people wonder what's wrong with them if not judge them outrightly. The (tabloid) media seems to love discussing whether a woman has kids or not and when even more than their love life.

I had kids late and before that every tom, dick and harry thought it was their right to ask me what's wrong and to advise me to have them before it's too late.

Sandra1984 · 14/08/2023 12:44

SquashPenguin · 13/08/2023 20:58

I can’t have kids. I’ve lost count of the number of times I’ve been asked when I’m having them, been told my biological clock is ticking, why don’t I have any yet, the list goes on and on. You might not feel inclined to ask yourself, but society as a whole is very geared towards wanting to know a woman’s reproductive status. It’s so hurtful.

Funny thing is they have no interest in finding out the man’s reproductive status. I yet have to hear a male or male celebrity being asked when is he planning to have children, yet it’s done to women in a regular basis. Sexism is alive n kicking.

Defiantjazz · 14/08/2023 12:10

I've been on the receiving end of countless racist, demeaning comments. If I extropolated the views of the people who made those comments and made the blanket statement "all white people in the UK are obsessed with race" what would you think?

It’s never good to make generalisations but racism does exist so I wouldn’t think you were making it up if that’s what you’re asking. It’s making reference to a problem that does exist (although some would like to think it doesn’t)

Defiantjazz · 14/08/2023 12:03

In my OP I clearly stated that what I disagree with is the articles and blogs I've read by child-free women who suggest that a) most women with children are obsessed with child-free women and think they are all cold, selfish individiuals. b) society in general is fixated with CF women

Some people do think that as you conceded. I think blogs and articles making reference to that fact are allowed. Genuinely not sure why it irritates you so much.

WomblingTree86 · 14/08/2023 11:24

I think this is one of those situations where you can't know about others experiences if you haven't experienced it yourself. I.e. If you aren’t childfree yourself how would you know that other people aren’t questioning those that are?

fitzwilliamdarcy · 14/08/2023 10:21

I’m not sure I’ve read an article from a journalist suggesting that all women are obsessed with childfree women.

I’ve read ones which suggest that lots of women ask intrusive questions or raise counterarguments (as has happened on this very thread), but never one which suggests that childfree women are the subject of an obsession per se.

I did a quick google and the only article I could find using that precise language was written by a mum asking why she was obsessed with childfree women.

The others were challenging views at a societal level about CF women - that we’re career obsessed, selfish, don’t know our own minds etc. Those attitudes exist - don’t get me started on the time I had to argue with several posters on here who kept insisting I was rich because I have no kids. There was a thread just last week where a mum was envious of CF women because they have multiple holidays a year and great careers, as if we’re a monolith.

Point being, I dunno, I just find this entire thread really goady. There have been a fair number of attempts to get at the CF since our board was established and I feel like this is just another of those.

Louloulouenna · 14/08/2023 10:07

I think being motivated to have children by the fear of not having anyone to look after you when you are old is probably a good way of ensuring you have a pretty lonely old age.

GalileoHumpkins · 14/08/2023 09:59

The only thing I would say to those childfree by choice anonymously is that there are repercussions later - I work with the elderly and most of our loneliest people, those with social services intervention are childless (no idea if by choice) just anecdotal but I have done this job for 14 years, it's a definite pattern

So we should have children we don't want on the off chance it'll stop us feeling lonely later on? What an excellent suggestion.

Eastie77Returns · 14/08/2023 09:46

EdgeOfACoin · 14/08/2023 06:57

I didn't have kids by choice until I was almost 40. I was in a position to do so for years but I didn't want children at that point. Nobody else cared. Barely anyone asked me about it. If they did, they didn't challenge me. It Wasn't A Big Deal. However, I recognise that living in a big city probably helped with that.

But the birth rate in the UK is currently hovering around 1.5 children per woman (down from 1.9 in 2010) and getting lower. The population replacement rate needs to be 2.1. We're obviously well below that now. We're on the same trajectory as the rest of Europe where the birth rate is around 1.3 in a lot of European countries. In East Asia the downward trajectory is even more marked - the South Korean birth rate is 0.8 children per woman.

My point is that the percentage of people who are choosing a childfree life is growing rapidly. From an environmental perspective that's great! It also means that this choice is becoming increasingly normalised. There's an explosion of articles about being childfree because so many more women are opting for this lifestyle. Very soon it will stop being a radical decision (it already has, I think, although a lot of people have yet to realise it) and people who write about this topic will need to find something else to write about.

I agree that not having children is becoming commonplace and increasingly seen as sensible choice rather than something revolutionary (in the UK anyway). But as I metnioned upthread cultural norms play a big part in this and some women will face huge pressure if they choose not to.

OP posts:
Eastie77Returns · 14/08/2023 09:39

Defiantjazz · 14/08/2023 07:44

I’ve stated several times that I’m fully aware that child free women have to deal with intrusive questions, crappy comments, suspicion etc and it is 100% a big deal.

So why did you start a thread with an OP implying otherwise.

In my OP I clearly stated that what I disagree with is the articles and blogs I've read by child-free women who suggest that a) most women with children are obsessed with child-free women and think they are all cold, selfish individiuals. b) society in general is fixated with CF women.

I'm aware that some people make stupid, insensitive and intrusive comments. And as I said, I suppose many people might idily wonder why a 40+ year old woman doesn't have children. I don't think that means the UK population at large is sitting around thinking about the subject. I don't think most (sane) women care about other women's reproductive decisions.

I've been on the receiving end of countless racist, demeaning comments. If I extropolated the views of the people who made those comments and made the blanket statement "all white people in the UK are obsessed with race" what would you think?

OP posts:
tuvamoodyson · 14/08/2023 09:30

Child free…not one person cares!

Caprisunny · 14/08/2023 09:20

In all fairness, even when you have kids people seem to think it’s an appropriate work conversation or conversation when meeting someone for the first time. How many I have, how old they are, what’s their sex, what are they studying, how do I manage to work and have kids and so on.

And for me you can see the flicker of judgment when they realise my eldest (now an adult) must have been born when I was in my teens and confusion that I still hold a very senior position. Despite being a very young mum.

Which is nothing compared to the fact that I am also a single parent. Yes I get asked ‘what does their dad do?’. It makes them uncomfortable when I say ‘I don’t. He lives off grid and we haven’t seen him for years‘. What their Dad does is irrelevant wether I am with him or not.

I think some people just think it’s ok to be intrusive about women’s lives.

TaigaSno · 14/08/2023 09:12

As a woman who does not have any children, I would say that yes, people regularly comment on it and ask me about it. It happens all the time, in work situations, social situations, you'd be surprised how quickly it comes up when meeting someone new. Just like the author of the article you read, I also find it mentally exhausting having to explain that to others. I find it rude and intrusive.

Caprisunny · 14/08/2023 08:54

I would have thought having kids when you don’t really want them wouldn’t increase your chances of being not being alone when you die.

Being a parent isn’t easy. Even when you really want to be one. I love being a parent. But it’s still hard. Doing something hard when you didn’t really want to do it in the first place is soul destroying and the kids, usually, pick up on it. Creating a poor relationship between the kids and the parents.

Having kids doesn’t ensure you aren’t alone in old age even when the relationships are good. It doesn’t ensure you aren’t alone when you die. Almost 2 years ago, I spoke to my mum on the phone at half 10. She didn’t feel so well and was going to the doctors to have her inhalers reviewed. She got off the phone to me and went for shower. She never made it into the shower. She collapsed and died. Dad was downstairs. She tried to make it out of the bathroom onto the landing. But she was alone and scared. She was only in her 60s and had 2 kids that adored her, 5 grandkids who thought she was amazing. And she died alone. I will never forgive myself. Neither will dad.

My Dad is amazing and we are close. But me and my brother work. As do our partners. Our kids are all in school or at uni. We see him as much as we can, but he has had to build a life with friends and socialise. We can’t physically be there all the time. Again, lots of family. But he had to make a life of his own without mum and independent of us.

KimberleyClark · 14/08/2023 08:42

gogomoto · 14/08/2023 08:28

I think people are naturally intrigued by those who have made different choices to them and perhaps slightly jealous of their lifestyle. I also think journalists have to fill column inches and the fact we are even discussing it means they have hit upon a topic that people find interesting/ are nosy about!

Do I care why? No. Do I feel sympathy for those who want children and can't? Of course. Is any of it my business? No!

The only thing I would say to those childfree by choice anonymously is that there are repercussions later - I work with the elderly and most of our loneliest people, those with social services intervention are childless (no idea if by choice) just anecdotal but I have done this job for 14 years, it's a definite pattern.

Your second paragraph says you don’t care, none of your business, and in your very next breath you’re coming out with one of our childfree bingo squares - “won’t you be lonely when you’re old”. Plenty of people with children are lonely in old age too - those with children living in different countries who simply don’t give a shit about them. Having kids is no guarantee you would be lonely in old age, and not having them doesn’t mean you won’t still have people who care about you, especially if you invest in friendships.

Jousting · 14/08/2023 08:41

gogomoto · 14/08/2023 08:28

I think people are naturally intrigued by those who have made different choices to them and perhaps slightly jealous of their lifestyle. I also think journalists have to fill column inches and the fact we are even discussing it means they have hit upon a topic that people find interesting/ are nosy about!

Do I care why? No. Do I feel sympathy for those who want children and can't? Of course. Is any of it my business? No!

The only thing I would say to those childfree by choice anonymously is that there are repercussions later - I work with the elderly and most of our loneliest people, those with social services intervention are childless (no idea if by choice) just anecdotal but I have done this job for 14 years, it's a definite pattern.

I work with elderly people as well and lots of it involves comforting people whose children don't visit, haven't visited for ages or won't visit which is so upsetting for the people I work with. It's something I see personally as well eg I have two aunts at opposite ends of children - one childfree and one with A LOT of children and it was the one who was childfree who had many visitors in her final days at home while the aunt with lots of children was alone. This is true of other relatives, relatives of my husband and my sister in laws family. There are also many campaigns about lonely older people and older people reaching out to their communities, they can't all be childless or childfree.

JudgeAnderson · 14/08/2023 08:36

The only thing I would say to those childfree by choice anonymously is that there are repercussions later - I work with the elderly and most of our loneliest people, those with social services intervention are childless (no idea if by choice) just anecdotal but I have done this job for 14 years, it's a definite pattern.

Even if this is the case (and I'd imagine it's far more lonely and painful knowing you have children who are not bothering with you or are living far away), the very elderly life stage is short and hardly the best part of your life so I'd argue that it's not worth sacrificing decades of your more youthful years doing something huge that you really don't want to do, just in case it makes the final few least enjoyable years a bit easier. Which it may or may not do anyway.

BadNomad · 14/08/2023 08:32

The only thing I would say to those childfree by choice anonymously is that there are repercussions later - I work with the elderly and most of our loneliest people, those with social services intervention are childless (no idea if by choice) just anecdotal but I have done this job for 14 years, it's a definite pattern.

I'm a nurse and in my experience it is the opposite. Those with children feel lonelier because they have children who don't visit enough. The people without children tend to be better prepared for old age.

gogomoto · 14/08/2023 08:28

I think people are naturally intrigued by those who have made different choices to them and perhaps slightly jealous of their lifestyle. I also think journalists have to fill column inches and the fact we are even discussing it means they have hit upon a topic that people find interesting/ are nosy about!

Do I care why? No. Do I feel sympathy for those who want children and can't? Of course. Is any of it my business? No!

The only thing I would say to those childfree by choice anonymously is that there are repercussions later - I work with the elderly and most of our loneliest people, those with social services intervention are childless (no idea if by choice) just anecdotal but I have done this job for 14 years, it's a definite pattern.

MotherofGorgons · 14/08/2023 08:21

Things I don't ask
Do you have children? Why not?
Do you have a husband or partner? Why not?
Do you have a job? Why not?
If they do, they will come up in the convo anyway.
I stick to the weather or my old standby " Have you come far?" 🙂 Dull but offends no one.

Louloulouenna · 14/08/2023 08:14

I would never ask someone I’ve just met if they have children let alone why not, I just can’t imagine asking anyone such intrusive and potentially sensitive questions. I wouldn’t even ask someone what they do for a living unless they were bringing it into the conversation.

I don’t think any of these things are the most interesting aspects of a person and there are better things to talk about.

I adore my children and they are the centre of my life but I don’t expect anyone else to want to hear about them!

JudgeAnderson · 14/08/2023 07:58

@LindorDoubleChoc How unpleasant. This is a thread about childfree women and you're taking exception that they actually contribute?

ButterCrackers · 14/08/2023 07:51

It’s none of my business why some doesn’t have kids. I’m actually careful to not ask if people have kids because I know it’s intrusive. I have a big family and get intrusive questions and comments that are out of order.

ToDoListAddict · 14/08/2023 07:50

I've always been questioned why I don't have children. Very recently a child free friend asked me why I didn't have any, but I think that was more for her to tell me that she never had any due to fertility issues. It made me realise that I never ask my childfree friends why they don't have children. (Nor my parent friends if they're having more etc)
But I've been questioned to the point of intrusiveness like "have you even tried?!" - which to me felt like they were asking if I ever even have sex with my husband!
I think what baffles my friends & family is that I'm very good with children. A photo of me and my infant niece was posted on a family chat and my MIL commented I was a natural.
I have multiple reasons for why I don't want children- some are deeply personal (but not fertility issues), and I don't see why I need to share this.
I've now learned to tailor my response to the type of person asking, to minimise the questions, but it took me a long time to learn this skill!