Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people do not 'obsess' over why a woman is childfree?

264 replies

Eastie77Returns · 13/08/2023 17:21

I know several women in their late 30s/early 40s who do not have children. I know one is not childfree by choice (close friend) but have no idea about the others apart from two who have actively chosen to share that they have never wanted kids. I do not spend any time at all wondering why the others do not have children. I assume they don't want them or, as is sadly the case of my friend, are unable to but it isn't something I dwell on or speculate about.

I've read multiple columnists in newspapers and articles in magazines in which child free women declare that the public at large, and mothers in particular, are 'obsessesed' with women who do not have children and it's exhausting having to constantly explain why you do not have any etc. They are fed up with the general assumption that they are selfish, career-mad, horrible child haters and this sentiment mostly comes from women who have kids. I have DC as do most of my friends. In my 10 years as a parent I have never had a conversation with any of them about 'selfish' childless women. Most of us completely understand why someone would prefer not to have kids!

I might be alone in thinking this but I honestly don't think most people really care about a woman's childbearing status. Obviously there are many ridiculous individuals who think it's ok to question a woman's choice and trott out BS like "you've never known true love/what tiredness really is until...." but I honestly think they are in the minority and the majority of mothers do not really care. Or am I being naive? My friends who are childfree by choice tell me they have occasionally been asked if they have kids but with rare exceptions have not been asked why not or any other follow up questions.

OP posts:
Louloulouenna · 15/08/2023 13:12

I do provide 24/7 care for an elderly relative and I would never describe them as a burden.

How can you describe children as a burden if you’ve never had any? You might imagine what it’s like but the reality may well be different.

awaytofrance · 15/08/2023 13:08

Louloulouenna · 15/08/2023 12:59

@JudgeAnderson I can’t imagine any decent parent labelling their children a burden. I also don’t find it acceptable to label any group of people as a “burden” whether it be the elderly or the disabled or any one else.

People can decide for themselves what is and isnt a burden to them. it's not for you to decide or judge. Burden means a load, particularly a heavy one.
You try providing 24/7 care for a severely disabled child or elderly relative and come back and tell me it's never ever felt like burden.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/08/2023 13:07

Louloulouenna · 15/08/2023 12:59

@JudgeAnderson I can’t imagine any decent parent labelling their children a burden. I also don’t find it acceptable to label any group of people as a “burden” whether it be the elderly or the disabled or any one else.

A parent calling their own child a burden is pretty awful (mine did it, to my face!). That’s completely different from a person with no children saying they don’t want the financial or emotional burden of hypothetical children who don’t exist.

If you genuinely can’t see the difference then I don’t know what to say.

MeadAndPie · 15/08/2023 13:05

EbiRaisukaree · 15/08/2023 12:39

You’d be surprised just how much some people seem to care. Have a look on some of the threads on the Childfree Mumsnetters board, and you might get a clearer idea.

Ignorant people, wind up merchants and people with massive fucking chips on the shoulders really don't mean vast bulk of people actually care in any way shape or form.

If it actually bothers you in real life - find a way of answering that makes them feel uncomfortable about their rude questions.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/08/2023 13:03

Louloulouenna · 15/08/2023 12:43

Possibly not those precise terms but a recent discussion on a Mumsnet CF board described children using terms such as “ghastly” “shrieking” and a “burden”. I struggle to see how it would be acceptable to label any other group of people in this way and find it very odd that people would do it on a parenting site.

What parents have said about kids in recent AIBU threads is much worse.

As you’ve been told all twenty eight times you’ve raised this point, “shrieking” is a description, and children can indeed be burdensome on those who don’t want them. Neither of these are insults.

Ghastly isn’t a nice word but it’s much tamer than “little shits” and “feral brats” (very frequently used on kid behaviour threads by parents).

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/08/2023 13:00

So why are you even married if you don't want kids?

Argh, this one comes up on every childfree wedding thread! “But but but marriage is abouuuut procreation!”

Louloulouenna · 15/08/2023 12:59

@JudgeAnderson I can’t imagine any decent parent labelling their children a burden. I also don’t find it acceptable to label any group of people as a “burden” whether it be the elderly or the disabled or any one else.

JudgeAnderson · 15/08/2023 12:52

Diddums

What a lovely example you must be to your offspring.

Cakesandbabes · 15/08/2023 12:50

I just did quick AS or "crotch droppings" and it appears to be used by parents on here?

LuvSmallDogs · 15/08/2023 12:49

JudgeAnderson · 15/08/2023 12:45

So if the CF are correct about their lifestyle being judged, it's at least a two way street.

You didn't caveat where it was or wasn't a two-way street, so your sweeping generalisation is then including MN and it's our fault for what people post elsewhere.

Diddums.

JudgeAnderson · 15/08/2023 12:47

@Louloulouenna objectively those that don't wish to have children would view them as a burden though, as they take a large amount of financial, time and energy resources so that would be burdensome to someone who didn't wish to have them. It's not a value judgement. I'd find having a dog a burden too.

awaytofrance · 15/08/2023 12:46

SleepingStandingUp · 13/08/2023 17:53

But you're ignoring the people who are experiencing this who are saying in the v blog you've read that this happens. Why do you think she's lying? Why do you think that because you don't do something that other people don't?

I had kids in my 30s, i was constantly asked in my 20s when is be having kids. Largely by women with kids. I can only imagine the horror of is declared I just didn't want them.

But that's the point...you can only imagine. Because it's only in your imagination.

It's not even vaguely unusual these days for women to not want children, and to say so. As with all things, there will be a tiny minority of people who think its their business, but they're the same people who if you had one child would want to know why not two, if you had four why do you have so many...it's nothing unique or special about you.

JudgeAnderson · 15/08/2023 12:45

So if the CF are correct about their lifestyle being judged, it's at least a two way street.

You didn't caveat where it was or wasn't a two-way street, so your sweeping generalisation is then including MN and it's our fault for what people post elsewhere.

Louloulouenna · 15/08/2023 12:43

Possibly not those precise terms but a recent discussion on a Mumsnet CF board described children using terms such as “ghastly” “shrieking” and a “burden”. I struggle to see how it would be acceptable to label any other group of people in this way and find it very odd that people would do it on a parenting site.

LuvSmallDogs · 15/08/2023 12:41

@JudgeAnderson I missed the bit in my post where I specified I was talking about CFers on MN, could you point it out to me please?

EbiRaisukaree · 15/08/2023 12:39

MeadAndPie · 15/08/2023 12:31

I don't think most people really care - I think it is careless used as a conversation started/filler/small talk.

Women with kids get impertinent questions often loaded with judgement - often arounds working/pt/SAHM and increasingly age gaps and number had. I once had a question from potential house buyer - did I mean to have as many kids as we had - I made it politely clear it was very rude question.

I do think perhaps people speaking out about it might make some people think twice but I'm not convinced it will.

MIL was often upset as she got comments about DH being an only - horrific early labour and pnd - was frequently told she change her mind or that DH would be damaged - yet she had to be taken aside and told to stop as she will persist in asking questions and giving unwanted advice to family members with known fertility issues.

You’d be surprised just how much some people seem to care. Have a look on some of the threads on the Childfree Mumsnetters board, and you might get a clearer idea.

MeadAndPie · 15/08/2023 12:31

I don't think most people really care - I think it is careless used as a conversation started/filler/small talk.

Women with kids get impertinent questions often loaded with judgement - often arounds working/pt/SAHM and increasingly age gaps and number had. I once had a question from potential house buyer - did I mean to have as many kids as we had - I made it politely clear it was very rude question.

I do think perhaps people speaking out about it might make some people think twice but I'm not convinced it will.

MIL was often upset as she got comments about DH being an only - horrific early labour and pnd - was frequently told she change her mind or that DH would be damaged - yet she had to be taken aside and told to stop as she will persist in asking questions and giving unwanted advice to family members with known fertility issues.

KimberleyClark · 15/08/2023 12:00

JudgeAnderson · 15/08/2023 11:57

@LuvSmallDogs please provide evidence of any CF women on MN using those terms. Yet we still get judged, right on this board, so no I would not say it's a two way street on here.

In my experience parents are much nastier about other parents and other people’s children than childfree women are.

JudgeAnderson · 15/08/2023 11:57

@LuvSmallDogs please provide evidence of any CF women on MN using those terms. Yet we still get judged, right on this board, so no I would not say it's a two way street on here.

LuvSmallDogs · 15/08/2023 09:52

Let's face it, for how much CF people believe they are judged, there are a awful lot of nasty nitpicking posts from them online about children and parents. They've popularised terms such as fuck trophy and crotch dropping to describe children (which pick me cool mums sometimes use about their own kids 🙄).

So if the CF are correct about their lifestyle being judged, it's at least a two way street.

CrunchyCarrot · 15/08/2023 09:40

The only thing I would say to those childfree by choice anonymously is that there are repercussions later

Every decision has potential repercussions, though!

"So why are you even married if you don't want kids?

Gah! Yes I have heard this one, too!

Eastie77Returns · 15/08/2023 07:41

Teder · 14/08/2023 18:39

@Eastie77Returns you say you acknowledge it happens but perhaps not as often as was suggested. You’re not in that target demographic so why don’t you listen to the people who are? I am not. However, it’s similar to when non disabled people go to great lengths to say there are plenty of disabled parking spaces even though, sometimes there aren’t enough. I say there are often not enough and I would know because I look every single time.

Several child free women on this thread mention they are rarely asked or have never been asked why they do not have children.
I also know other child free women have to put up with intrusive, judgemental behaviour.

Is it possible to accept that all not all child free women go through the exact same experience? That was the point I was making in my OP about the articles I’ve read (which then got drowned out by people claiming I’m invalidating the lived experience of some women)

If someone has endured a negative experience it doesn’t ‘invalidate’ them if someone else in their exact position hasn’t had the same experience.

Re the parking space analogy: it’s a quantifiable fact there is insufficient provision for disabled drivers which I think is different from a subjective opinion.

OP posts:
Teder · 14/08/2023 18:39

@Eastie77Returns you say you acknowledge it happens but perhaps not as often as was suggested. You’re not in that target demographic so why don’t you listen to the people who are? I am not. However, it’s similar to when non disabled people go to great lengths to say there are plenty of disabled parking spaces even though, sometimes there aren’t enough. I say there are often not enough and I would know because I look every single time.

Cakesandbabes · 14/08/2023 13:54

JudgeAnderson · 14/08/2023 13:39

I am not married though and have had 4 different relationships since I turned 30, which might play a part in that. I can imagine that if you're very settled then people would be more likely to ask.

This is a good point. If you get married in your early thirties and then follow it up with a move to a four-bed house, the questions certainly come!

Indeed!
We married in 20s, then moved to 3 bed🙈

"So why are you even married if you don't want kids? Stopped from the few people after I started asking why they are not married if they want/have kids😂

JudgeAnderson · 14/08/2023 13:39

I am not married though and have had 4 different relationships since I turned 30, which might play a part in that. I can imagine that if you're very settled then people would be more likely to ask.

This is a good point. If you get married in your early thirties and then follow it up with a move to a four-bed house, the questions certainly come!