Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a house guest shouldn’t be parenting your kids?

312 replies

evuscha · 13/08/2023 17:13

We had my DH’s friend staying with us for a few days, she’s single and childless in her early 50’s though claims that she knows everything about kids because she was a nanny when she was young. The whole time she wouldn’t get off my 4yo DD’s case, constantly reprimanding her for every little thing, saying things like “don’t you ever do that again” then saying it to my DH as a funny story later became of “how terrified” my DD looked at her….constantly throwing little digs like “oh you don’t give her time outs” or “oh she gets to pick which songs you listen to in a car?” (we take turns btw sometimes our music sometimes kids songs, apparently that’s appalling 😀) I’m expecting #2 soon so more digs like “oh I thought that was planned/wanted” whenever I said it will probably be tough or something along those lines.

I did speak up and stood up for my DD but none of my comments helped and I feel like it’s DH’s job to put HIS friend in her place? I would certainly be having stern words if my family/friends did that. I also have friends whose kids in my opinion get away with more than my DD but I would never dream of bossing their kids around (beyond the basic keeping everyone safe) in front of them? AIBU?

OP posts:
MzHz · 22/08/2023 22:55

Have you replied to her @evuscha

if it were me I’d say “thanks for your words, you don’t need to explain, not everyone likes kids and that’s fine, but my family is my priority and I don’t appreciate being criticised or undermined in my own home, so while im not going to get it in the way of DH friendships, it’s a huge effort to host people in my home and I’m only willing to do that for people are kind and loving to us all. Dd included.”

id specifically avoid thanking her for an apology because it wasn’t one and you both know this. She absolutely knows what she’s done and is trying to undermine you again by gas lighting you all.

tell her you know she knows she crossed a line and you’re not stupid enough to make the mistake of having her beat you/dd again.

evuscha · 22/08/2023 16:41

Mummy08m · 22/08/2023 16:34

evuscha thought you were too negative to DD and didn’t like some things you said

Wow your dh is sounding less attractive with every update.

I'd be telling him to piss off and go marry the friend instead.

@billy1966 is right on this one. Your dh is selfish. He puts himself and his feelings before you and your dd, and unless this changes, it'll seriously affect your relationship

That is more of an issue for me now than the original issue. She’s noone to me essentially but he’s the one that is supposed to have my back.

I don’t know how do I get him to change though. How do you make someone see that something is an issue, when they don’t think it is? He’s all about apologizing to me and promising how he will try harder - but I don’t know if that’s possible.
I suppose the only outcome for me is knowing that I only have myself to rely on, and next time I have to speak up if I don’t like his family or friends doing something to me or DD. And work on that assertiveness for myself.

OP posts:
Mummy08m · 22/08/2023 16:34

evuscha · 22/08/2023 16:10

So the friend got suspicious of the fact I ignored all the group messages, and messaged DH privately to ask if I’m ok. Him realizing that pretending this situation never happened and hoping that by next year I forget will not work, eventually told her something like “evuscha thought you were too negative to DD and didn’t like some things you said”, so she sent me a half arsed apology about how she’s “sorry if she said some things that may offend, I didn’t mean it, sometimes I talk too much but I adore DD” 🙄

Somehow it didn’t make things all peachy for me, I am still just as determined to not let her near DD again, maybe even more determined actually.
I’m also extremely angry with DH, all this talk about how sorry he is and how he can see she was out of line and is on board with me, all was just a talk to shut me up and make the drama go away. Next opportunity he had, he made it an “evuscha issue”, when he could have said “we talked and WE thought you crossed the line and we do not wish for you to ever speak to DD that way”…no, of course it’s all evuscha.

evuscha thought you were too negative to DD and didn’t like some things you said

Wow your dh is sounding less attractive with every update.

I'd be telling him to piss off and go marry the friend instead.

@billy1966 is right on this one. Your dh is selfish. He puts himself and his feelings before you and your dd, and unless this changes, it'll seriously affect your relationship

evuscha · 22/08/2023 16:10

So the friend got suspicious of the fact I ignored all the group messages, and messaged DH privately to ask if I’m ok. Him realizing that pretending this situation never happened and hoping that by next year I forget will not work, eventually told her something like “evuscha thought you were too negative to DD and didn’t like some things you said”, so she sent me a half arsed apology about how she’s “sorry if she said some things that may offend, I didn’t mean it, sometimes I talk too much but I adore DD” 🙄

Somehow it didn’t make things all peachy for me, I am still just as determined to not let her near DD again, maybe even more determined actually.
I’m also extremely angry with DH, all this talk about how sorry he is and how he can see she was out of line and is on board with me, all was just a talk to shut me up and make the drama go away. Next opportunity he had, he made it an “evuscha issue”, when he could have said “we talked and WE thought you crossed the line and we do not wish for you to ever speak to DD that way”…no, of course it’s all evuscha.

OP posts:
Phoenixfire1988 · 22/08/2023 14:05

I have now and she would be getting told to pack her sh!t and leave immediately then cut off, tbh I don't know how they've put up with it for this long she sounds absolutely horrendous

evuscha · 21/08/2023 17:32

Ihaveamagicwand · 21/08/2023 10:47

Evuscha
The problem, as I’m sure you’ve already found, is letting your resentment and frustration build up about someone’s rude behaviour.

You say it eventually brings you to the point where you explode. If you’re anything like me, that leaves you feeling worse about yourself than before because you, as a reasonably calm rational person, recognise it as a loss of self control.

You may even say things you have not thought through properly in a way you may not have meant. I know I did!
After hours of dissecting how I had dealt, or not dealt with a situation, I would come to the conclusion I was rubbish at dealing with conflict which only reinforced my reluctance to deal with it.

It’s a reinforcing cycle of reluctant restraint, building resentment and explosive reaction!

However, I’ve realised if I can deal with situations assertively as they arise, I can do it in a more controlled way before I get to exploding point.

It’s not easy to change, you may even have to practice some responses to imaginary situations in front of the mirror, but it will pay dividends in boosting your confidence and setting a good example for your DD and possibly even your DH!

The link below may be useful to help you, learning to be more assertive has certainly helped me.

https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/healthyliving/assertiveness#

Thank you. That’s definitely useful! I absolutely freeze in the moment, then overthink the situation and then explode. Responding politely and assertively but without the anger or sarcasm is something I need to work on. Even now I probably wouldn’t be able to get into this discussion with her without emotions, and would likely be dismissed as hormonal and over sensitive, rather than actually being taken seriously.

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 21/08/2023 11:16
  1. "not to sound mean but an opinion of someone that hasn’t raised their own kids is just not relevant to me"

Some children are raised by their nannies...
In any case, childless people have to live in society with spoilt children so I don't think it's quite fair to say that the childless should just put up with naughty behaviour from the children around them.

Ihaveamagicwand · 21/08/2023 10:47

Evuscha
The problem, as I’m sure you’ve already found, is letting your resentment and frustration build up about someone’s rude behaviour.

You say it eventually brings you to the point where you explode. If you’re anything like me, that leaves you feeling worse about yourself than before because you, as a reasonably calm rational person, recognise it as a loss of self control.

You may even say things you have not thought through properly in a way you may not have meant. I know I did!
After hours of dissecting how I had dealt, or not dealt with a situation, I would come to the conclusion I was rubbish at dealing with conflict which only reinforced my reluctance to deal with it.

It’s a reinforcing cycle of reluctant restraint, building resentment and explosive reaction!

However, I’ve realised if I can deal with situations assertively as they arise, I can do it in a more controlled way before I get to exploding point.

It’s not easy to change, you may even have to practice some responses to imaginary situations in front of the mirror, but it will pay dividends in boosting your confidence and setting a good example for your DD and possibly even your DH!

The link below may be useful to help you, learning to be more assertive has certainly helped me.

https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/healthyliving/assertiveness#

Assertiveness

It is helpful to imagine assertiveness as the middle ground between aggression and passivity.

https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/healthyliving/assertiveness#

evuscha · 21/08/2023 08:38

billy1966 · 21/08/2023 07:35

OP, you are a maturing woman who wants to evolve from being a people pleaser, and I really commend you for that.

Invariably people pleasers are concerned with how they feel primarily, and what makes life more comfortable for them, and not of those closest to them.

You have clearly been woken up from this and want to assert yourself, for yourself, and for your child.

Your husband is irritating you because he is absolutely putting himself ahead of doing the right thing for his child.

I hope you work and will continue to be financially independent.

I think that is very important for you.

As you mature you may well leave your scared husband behind, your feelings may well change for him, as you realise you are not a real team whom has each others back.

As the children grow and you see other issues like this your respect for him will be chipped at and your love will diminish.

These things happen slowly and you realise you are actually the only real adult in the relationship and your childrens father is a scared little man that will deny things happened or pretend not to see things, absolutely a form of gaslighting IMO.

So protect yourself, because long term, losing your respect for your partner is terribly damaging to a relationship.

Yeah, unfortunately that is something to consider and keep in mind. I don’t want that to happen, I love DH very much, he is very kind, loving and my soul mate in so many ways. But I have been very annoyed by his continued non-reaction to this, and it’s irritating to think that he just wouldn’t have our back. (probably why I keep posting and dwelling on it even though my initial question was answered) He will agree to my terms (not having her over, not seeing her with kids) but only to keep peace with me and not to genuinely protect DD. And I also agree that tricky situations and issues around kids will happen more in future, and we really need to do better by them and not pretend they’re not happening.

Unsurprisingly we did have issues to do with his conflict avoidance before. One major discussion was around me not wanting in-laws here right after baby #2 is born - again he was very reluctant to tell them that and couldn’t see why it’s an issue when they’re “so helpful” (but that’s a whole other thread I made a while ago). Second event when a friend of his owed him a very large sum of money (that he invested with them way before we even met, so in theory nothing to do with me, but now he needed it back for our house renovation, and the said friend started ignoring him, not answering calls etc) - again a whole long other story but I was pushing him to take a legal action and he just wouldn’t. (the friend did pay him back eventually but it really could have gone either way) So the current score is not great really.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 21/08/2023 07:35

OP, you are a maturing woman who wants to evolve from being a people pleaser, and I really commend you for that.

Invariably people pleasers are concerned with how they feel primarily, and what makes life more comfortable for them, and not of those closest to them.

You have clearly been woken up from this and want to assert yourself, for yourself, and for your child.

Your husband is irritating you because he is absolutely putting himself ahead of doing the right thing for his child.

I hope you work and will continue to be financially independent.

I think that is very important for you.

As you mature you may well leave your scared husband behind, your feelings may well change for him, as you realise you are not a real team whom has each others back.

As the children grow and you see other issues like this your respect for him will be chipped at and your love will diminish.

These things happen slowly and you realise you are actually the only real adult in the relationship and your childrens father is a scared little man that will deny things happened or pretend not to see things, absolutely a form of gaslighting IMO.

So protect yourself, because long term, losing your respect for your partner is terribly damaging to a relationship.

evuscha · 21/08/2023 01:55

mathanxiety · 21/08/2023 01:44

She wants to get her claws into your child to do what she thinks is a better job than you, her parents, are doing.

She wants another chance to verbally abuse your child.

Wrt calling your H 'too boring' - she seems to be ready and willing to verbally abuse the whole family.

This woman isn't a friend, she's a predator. She has found your husband is a doormat and latched on to your family. She's probing to see what you and your spineless H will let her get away with.

I'd drop her completely if I were you. She is grooming all three of you.

Yes I think you have a point and yeah I would be more than happy to drop her completely. It would just be nice to be properly backed up by DH, as in him actually seeing her behavior as toxic, rude and abusive, rather than “she loves DD, it’s just her ways”. That is kind of setting me up to be undermined again in future.
Although to be fair I don’t think DH will go to any extreme lengths to see her even on his own, he agreed to not letting her stay again, and she does live a long(ish) flight away so maybe I’m stressing over a non issue and maybe it will just fizzle out naturally (without significant effort to meet up from both sides). If she does directly ask me something, I will “tell her like it is” though.

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 21/08/2023 01:44

evuscha · 20/08/2023 01:36

But then why would she say she wants to have DD over 🤷‍♀️ just so weird.

Tbh we can’t win this one; my DH who is super mellow and polite is “too boring” for her, my DD who is chatty and energetic is “full of personality”, it’s hard to be “just perfect”.

She wants to get her claws into your child to do what she thinks is a better job than you, her parents, are doing.

She wants another chance to verbally abuse your child.

Wrt calling your H 'too boring' - she seems to be ready and willing to verbally abuse the whole family.

This woman isn't a friend, she's a predator. She has found your husband is a doormat and latched on to your family. She's probing to see what you and your spineless H will let her get away with.

I'd drop her completely if I were you. She is grooming all three of you.

evuscha · 20/08/2023 23:14

Oh yeah, plus noone can force me to see her again really, so I am overthinking this a bit. At this point it’s just about trying to get DH to finally open his eyes and freaking see my point, which he still doesn’t and it’s very annoying!

OP posts:
MzHz · 20/08/2023 22:12

Well @evuscha if the group chat is just you and dh and you do most of the correspondence generally there isn’t anything stopping you from sending a reply that acknowledges the surprise in her text given her clear stance whilst in your home.

be blunt, what have you personally got to lose?

evuscha · 20/08/2023 18:26

And I really don’t know why DH is like that. He has zero reason to be, his family is lovely, in-laws are his biggest fans and extremely supportive, he didn’t have any abusive relationships…

For myself, I absolutely know why I am like that. My upbringing was more along the lines of “be seen, not heard”, “don’t argue”, “girls should always be nice”, and I didn’t have much of a say in things growing up.

OP posts:
evuscha · 20/08/2023 18:22

FictionalCharacter · 20/08/2023 18:08

I really do sympathise. I have a people pleasing dh. It can be difficult. However I don’t think he’s as bad as yours, because he wouldn’t have tolerated someone being like that to one of our kids. At the very least, he would have said no more visits.
In your shoes I’d do exactly what you’re planning.
”DH, we are not seeing Friend with dd again. If she really does like children/dd she should act like she does, instead of being sharp, critical and hurtful. I’m not prepared to let her do that to dd whatever you say. I’m not letting Friend upset dd just because she’s your friend”.
Have you ever explored DH’s people pleasing and conflict avoidance with him? He might not realise how bad he is. As you say he might not want to change himself, but assertiveness gets easier with age and maturity for some people. And he might come round to feeling like you do - you recognise this trait in yourself, and as a parent you want to deal with it, so that you can stand up for dd when you need to and be a model for her.

He did agree to no more visits from her, and he insists he understands my point, but that’s ultimately to please me and avoid arguments with me I think, and not because he genuinely recognizes what she did was bad and hurtful. He is so used to getting and tolerating mean “jokey” comments from her towards him, that he doesn’t understand that to someone else let alone a child those just aren’t okay!

Right now I haven’t responded to her message at all, and he did respond in a neutral way to other points but ignored the DD bit.

My worry is, if I leave it ignored, then DH just hopes I will forget about it and next time she asks to come (could be in a year) I will just say yes. He just wants to avoid that drama and make it go away as usual.

He’s not a bad person at all and generally puts us first always. But confidence, self esteem, being able to stand up to someone is something he’s really lacking. (and I’m bad at it too but nowhere near this bad, I eventually do explode)

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 20/08/2023 18:08

evuscha · 20/08/2023 17:37

I agree! I can’t change DH unless he wants to (and sadly despite respecting my wish to not see her again, he still doesn’t really even agree with me that she was in the wrong)…but I certainly do want to change myself. The older I get the less patience I have for this kind of people, so that’s good. And most importantly I don’t want DD to grow up a people pleaser too which unfortunately I contributed to that weekend. In my defense it took me by surprise - reacting in the right moment (rather than just knowing what to say “after”) is something I need to work on.

I really do sympathise. I have a people pleasing dh. It can be difficult. However I don’t think he’s as bad as yours, because he wouldn’t have tolerated someone being like that to one of our kids. At the very least, he would have said no more visits.
In your shoes I’d do exactly what you’re planning.
”DH, we are not seeing Friend with dd again. If she really does like children/dd she should act like she does, instead of being sharp, critical and hurtful. I’m not prepared to let her do that to dd whatever you say. I’m not letting Friend upset dd just because she’s your friend”.
Have you ever explored DH’s people pleasing and conflict avoidance with him? He might not realise how bad he is. As you say he might not want to change himself, but assertiveness gets easier with age and maturity for some people. And he might come round to feeling like you do - you recognise this trait in yourself, and as a parent you want to deal with it, so that you can stand up for dd when you need to and be a model for her.

FrenchBoule · 20/08/2023 17:51

”It’s just her way”. Ok but you don’t have to tolerate it,neither does your DD.
This is a poor excuse trotted out to justify somebody’s poor behaviour.

To hell with people pleasing. Sometimes you have to be confrontional,that’s how you get people to back off.

I can stand a lot of crap but the minute you start on my kids I’ll give it to you tenfold.

Your DD is your priority. DH should be told his fate. Your house is your DD safe place and comfort zone,nobody should wreck it for her including some stranger and parent with no backbone.

evuscha · 20/08/2023 17:37

FictionalCharacter · 20/08/2023 17:29

@evuscha You keep saying that you and dh are people pleasers, as though that’s your fate for ever. You don’t have to be. You can break this habit just like any other. The first time you stand up to someone will be a revelation. Then you’ll find it easier. And you’ll be able to teach your daughter to stand up for herself too.
Be kind and helpful to others, sure, that’s a good thing. Allowing yourself to be taken advantage of and letting people treat you like dirt is not.

I agree! I can’t change DH unless he wants to (and sadly despite respecting my wish to not see her again, he still doesn’t really even agree with me that she was in the wrong)…but I certainly do want to change myself. The older I get the less patience I have for this kind of people, so that’s good. And most importantly I don’t want DD to grow up a people pleaser too which unfortunately I contributed to that weekend. In my defense it took me by surprise - reacting in the right moment (rather than just knowing what to say “after”) is something I need to work on.

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 20/08/2023 17:37

it’s just her ways
Don’t let him get away with making this excuse for her. That phrase is very often used when people know that someone’s behaviour is unacceptable but they can’t or won’t do anything about it.
Imagine someone behaving badly or doing something incorrect in the workplace - “it’s just her ways” would absolutely not be tolerated as an excuse.

FictionalCharacter · 20/08/2023 17:29

@evuscha You keep saying that you and dh are people pleasers, as though that’s your fate for ever. You don’t have to be. You can break this habit just like any other. The first time you stand up to someone will be a revelation. Then you’ll find it easier. And you’ll be able to teach your daughter to stand up for herself too.
Be kind and helpful to others, sure, that’s a good thing. Allowing yourself to be taken advantage of and letting people treat you like dirt is not.

evuscha · 20/08/2023 17:22

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 20/08/2023 16:32

Has your DH been in contact with her and said something? And this is her response... to re write the script? to prove to DH that she adores DD and that you are actually making a fuss about nothing? (further undermining you with your DH) Why, actually she'd love to spend more one on one time with DD so OP must be completely over reacting?

I think its good that you wrote this thread as it's made you clear on what she did and didn't say. She can say what she likes about her behaviour, you were there and you witnessed it.

She actually reminds me of a horrible relatively distant relation we had visit when I was growing up. Thought he was smarter than everyone else and sooooo amusing. All his comments were gold. Should have been a standup.

Except all his comments were jeering, sneering and usually shit. And I also notice that people like him pick on the youngest. Every time, because its so much easier to pretend that you are cleverer than a young child and make "witty" remarks about everything they say, which establishes them as the superior person of the group.
He moved on from me to my nieces and nephews. If they needed to wipe their noses or if they had stumbled, even if the poor things were happily playing and focusing on a toy with great concentration - all if it was fodder for his comedy stylings.
Your DD will thank you for not putting up with this harpy.

Like I said, I don’t believe DH has told her anything. However, funny you say that, I did get that exact reaction from DH after her message: “See, she likes DD, it’s just her ways, she didn’t mean anything bad”. So she’s definitely still succeeding with having DH on board.

I told DH though that noone is obligated to tolerate “her ways”, not even in a jokey way, which was largely what it was - also exactly like you described your relative. Like it was funny to scold DD and show her her place and making comments like “I’m not holding your sticky hands” or “I wasn’t listening to your song” in some sort of a comedy act. As a part of her “I’m too cool for kids, they’re annoying” persona.

I don’t even think she genuinely thought DD was bad or we’re shit parents. If DD was the opposite of herself, she would be getting digs at how shy/quiet/too mellow she is (like DH is getting from her). I don’t even know if she realizes that her behavior can come across as really rude and toxic! Though the overly loving message of how amazing DD is does suggest some damage control from her side.

OP posts:
evuscha · 20/08/2023 17:11

Thank you so much everyone for your latest extremely helpful comments. I am reading and taking on board all of them! I know my thread has been all over the place and I can’t believe a week later I am still stressing about it, but it is really helping me to stay focused on what’s important (protecting DD) and figure out the next steps.

Just to clarify, the group chat was just with her, me and DH, no other people involved. I don’t think she was in touch with DH separately, if anything she talks to me more than she talks to DH these days. I thought we had a good relationship with her and she really liked seeing us as a family which makes her last behavior really bizarre - why risk throwing away that friendship over a bit of an ego boost? But we are both people pleasers and as far as she knows she got away and didn’t get a lot of pushback, so that’s probably why. “People like her only behave like that because people let her.” is very true.

DH has a long history of avoiding conflict (not even to stand up for himself) and while I feel like he doesn’t necessarily care if he never sees her again (he would be happy making excuses each time and he probably wouldn’t even care about seeing her just the 2 of them, if anything, I was usually the one sorting out plans with her), he just doesn’t want to go into that confrontation. I personally think it’s weird to make the “we’re busy” excuses for years…and besides, she probably will be making an effort to meet the new baby so will be responding with “I can come whenever it suits you guys”…and then years down the line she asks what’s wrong and we awkwardly say “well that one weekend 5 years ago you were mean to DD”? I would much rather just tell her now.

All I know is that no I don’t believe DH would properly back us up if we meet her again, unfortunately, he would probably try very politely with some neutral jokey comments and that would be it. I also agree with the PP saying that they remember similar childhood incidents many years later, I too remember the way that made me feel when a friend/family member was mean to me and my parents didn’t stand up for me. So I am absolutely certain I don’t want her around DD again.

OP posts:
DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 20/08/2023 16:32

Has your DH been in contact with her and said something? And this is her response... to re write the script? to prove to DH that she adores DD and that you are actually making a fuss about nothing? (further undermining you with your DH) Why, actually she'd love to spend more one on one time with DD so OP must be completely over reacting?

I think its good that you wrote this thread as it's made you clear on what she did and didn't say. She can say what she likes about her behaviour, you were there and you witnessed it.

She actually reminds me of a horrible relatively distant relation we had visit when I was growing up. Thought he was smarter than everyone else and sooooo amusing. All his comments were gold. Should have been a standup.

Except all his comments were jeering, sneering and usually shit. And I also notice that people like him pick on the youngest. Every time, because its so much easier to pretend that you are cleverer than a young child and make "witty" remarks about everything they say, which establishes them as the superior person of the group.
He moved on from me to my nieces and nephews. If they needed to wipe their noses or if they had stumbled, even if the poor things were happily playing and focusing on a toy with great concentration - all if it was fodder for his comedy stylings.
Your DD will thank you for not putting up with this harpy.

mbosnz · 20/08/2023 15:09

I had a singular gutsful of a friend who also presumed to backseat parent my kids - or try to. I just said to her, 'yup, I was a perfect parent with perfect kids too. Then I actually had them. If you want to parent kids, you squit 'em out, you're not practising on mine!'

To their credit, they cracked up laughing, and we all cracked on. . .