Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a house guest shouldn’t be parenting your kids?

312 replies

evuscha · 13/08/2023 17:13

We had my DH’s friend staying with us for a few days, she’s single and childless in her early 50’s though claims that she knows everything about kids because she was a nanny when she was young. The whole time she wouldn’t get off my 4yo DD’s case, constantly reprimanding her for every little thing, saying things like “don’t you ever do that again” then saying it to my DH as a funny story later became of “how terrified” my DD looked at her….constantly throwing little digs like “oh you don’t give her time outs” or “oh she gets to pick which songs you listen to in a car?” (we take turns btw sometimes our music sometimes kids songs, apparently that’s appalling 😀) I’m expecting #2 soon so more digs like “oh I thought that was planned/wanted” whenever I said it will probably be tough or something along those lines.

I did speak up and stood up for my DD but none of my comments helped and I feel like it’s DH’s job to put HIS friend in her place? I would certainly be having stern words if my family/friends did that. I also have friends whose kids in my opinion get away with more than my DD but I would never dream of bossing their kids around (beyond the basic keeping everyone safe) in front of them? AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Loopylemon2 · 12/10/2023 18:42

@sashadjas and @PostItInABook LMAO!

You speak your truth that fits your agenda/narrative as clearly you’ve a lot of time on your hands to wade in on a thread from weeks ago 😂

Off you pop!

PostItInABook · 12/10/2023 18:25

YABU to decide her behaviour is a result of being ‘single and childless’ when in fact it’s quite obvious she’d be a dick whether she had a partner/kids or not.

sashadjas · 12/10/2023 18:17

@Loopylemon2 your comments say WAY more about you and your motives for posting than about OP. I'm so sorry that you feel you have to make these accusations to feel better about yourself and create validation for your batshit theories.
@evuscha I know this is an old-ish thread, but I really feel like I want to say you're amazing, your wee lass sounds awesome (especially her sticky mitts!😂), your DH will get there (sounds a wee bit wet but lovely nonetheless!), and that bint needs to 'do one'! x

evuscha · 23/08/2023 19:38

Anniegetyourgun · 23/08/2023 19:20

Hey, I still feel bad about a few things I did or failed to do when DS1 was small, and he's old enough to have fathered my 3 DGC now so... these things do torture us, it's called mum guilt and I don't think most of us completely get over it! Just keep loving them and bringing them up the best you can. If DD mentions any aspect of that hideous weekend just answer her kindly and as honestly as is age-appropriate (e.g. "Yes, that wasn't very kind, but even grown-ups don't always behave as well as they should", sort of thing).

I wondered whether nasty friend had actually found this thread... some poster a few days ago by name of Loopy Lemon or similar... seemed very adamant that your account of events wasn't how it happened at all. Who would say it like that unless they had actually been there? Not that I'm inclined to disbelieve your perspective, I know one or two people like that and sometimes they genuinely don't realise how very abrasive they come across - sometimes.

Good point!! 😀 But I think Loopy lemon seemed to suggest that I have fabricated the events to make myself look good and my child must be a brat, whereas this friend of DH’s now keeps saying how amazing DD is and doesn’t seem to think she was critical or anything (“I talk too much but I didn’t mean to offend”, “I know I say too much sometimes, that’s how my Italian mother taught me” - 🙄) so I don’t think they’re the same person.

I think this friend does realize her comments were a bit much but just genuinely doesn’t see anything wrong with it. “Tell it like it is” and all that. I’m glad I finally had a chance to tell her this attitude won’t fly with me, she probably just thinks I’m over sensitive but if she keeps pushing with asking if we’re good or similar (assuming she thinks her non apology actually worked) I am now more than happy to explain to her in detail that I think her attitude is wrong and why, and that it wasn’t just a case of me feeling a bit off with my pregnancy hormones.

OP posts:
Anniegetyourgun · 23/08/2023 19:20

Hey, I still feel bad about a few things I did or failed to do when DS1 was small, and he's old enough to have fathered my 3 DGC now so... these things do torture us, it's called mum guilt and I don't think most of us completely get over it! Just keep loving them and bringing them up the best you can. If DD mentions any aspect of that hideous weekend just answer her kindly and as honestly as is age-appropriate (e.g. "Yes, that wasn't very kind, but even grown-ups don't always behave as well as they should", sort of thing).

I wondered whether nasty friend had actually found this thread... some poster a few days ago by name of Loopy Lemon or similar... seemed very adamant that your account of events wasn't how it happened at all. Who would say it like that unless they had actually been there? Not that I'm inclined to disbelieve your perspective, I know one or two people like that and sometimes they genuinely don't realise how very abrasive they come across - sometimes.

evuscha · 23/08/2023 17:45

MargaretThursday · 23/08/2023 17:37

Yes, sounds similar.

In Dh's case he hadn't really known her well-I think they'd been on a couple of kids camps together or similar, and he was quite happy to catch up, but she wanted to totally latch on the whole time. She'd also just had a break up from boyfriend, which she wanted to tell dh in detail (showing how little she knew him because that sort of thing he hates) so I was a little suspicious of her motives too.

I don't think dh was totally standing up though, as I said he's totally naïve round things like that, it was that he was enjoying having time together, as we wanted on holiday.

I do admit to "accidentally" losing the piece of paper she wrote her address on so "he could invite her to stay". I don't think he even noticed.

Edited

Hahaha, genius move with the address 😀 and yeah I suppose that men often don’t see those subtle things that women do or say, but we can spot them a mile away.

Also a good point about her motives…although that isn’t my concern at all in my case, they never dated and they’re sooo different in their lifestyle, personality and just about everything (DH is “too boring” as she likes to point out) that sometimes I wonder why they’re even friends. She has probably been a closer friend with me lately than with DH actually, which is also why I’m not sure why she threw it all away that weekend for a bit of an ego boost - I’m most definitely done with her.

OP posts:
evuscha · 23/08/2023 17:40

MzHz · 23/08/2023 17:17

I reckon H might - just might - cotton on to how he needs to up his game when it comes to backing you and your kids @evuscha

I think/really hope he does! Despite my complaints - and I know he doesn’t come across very well from this thread and I’m still annoyed with him - he does have many great qualities and generally tries to take things on board and learn from situations, even if it sometimes takes a minute. He has gotten much better at nipping any comments from in-laws in the bud (though it’s easier there, in-laws are generally nice and pretty reasonable).

One thing he said, and it’s not an excuse but I do believe him - is that he’s not confident enough in his parenting, not sure what approach is best and what to do in some situations with DD - he generally follows my lead/my way of dealing with things (which is good because we are consistent and back each other up in front of DD). So when someone criticizes his parenting he wouldn’t think “shut up person, that’s none of your business” but he would think “hmm they probably have a point”. I am the default parent (he works long hours) so I have more experience with DD and therefore am more confident that I’m doing things right (well to the best of my ability, I’m not perfect obviously).
He also said that because he had a happy low conflict upbringing, he just doesn’t spot these digs or takes things as criticism. I had my share of situations growing up where my mum wouldn’t back me up or where people were overly critical of me as a small child so I am definitely aware of what that does to one’s confidence. But I also told him that it shouldn’t take a genius to know that not getting off their case with someone else’s small child for 48 hours right in front of their parents just isn’t normal.

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 23/08/2023 17:37

evuscha · 23/08/2023 17:27

That’s funny, this one also liked to point out to DD that “she knows daddy longer than you, and longer than your mummy knows him” 🙄 They see each other once a year and even when they lived in the same city they would usually meet up once in a while and in a group setting anyway, but sure…
Good for your DH to stand up to her!

Yes, sounds similar.

In Dh's case he hadn't really known her well-I think they'd been on a couple of kids camps together or similar, and he was quite happy to catch up, but she wanted to totally latch on the whole time. She'd also just had a break up from boyfriend, which she wanted to tell dh in detail (showing how little she knew him because that sort of thing he hates) so I was a little suspicious of her motives too.

I don't think dh was totally standing up though, as I said he's totally naïve round things like that, it was that he was enjoying having time together, as we wanted on holiday.

I do admit to "accidentally" losing the piece of paper she wrote her address on so "he could invite her to stay". I don't think he even noticed.

evuscha · 23/08/2023 17:27

MargaretThursday · 23/08/2023 17:16

When similar happened to me, (we were on holiday) and she I was fairly sure it was the other woman's way of trying to stamp ownership over the situation. She was someone dh had known (but not seen for around 5 years, nor had particularly known well) before I had met him.
I think she was trying to say that she was so comfortable in his presence that she "naturally" slipped into acting like his partner/dd's mum. She was definitely trying to give off a "we know each other so well vibe and you're the newcomer" to me. She wanted to only talk about people they had known back then/things they had done. Dh is the wrong person to try that with as he's more likely to have forgotten he saw someone yesterday than remember a random conversation he had 7 years ago.
When he said to her that we were just having some quiet "family time" her reaction was firstly along the lines of "fantastic, I'll come in" and when he said no, she suggested taking dd out with him and leaving me behind.
Dh doesn't tend to spot that sort of thing as being anything other than innocent, but he did tell her that wasn't happening.

That’s funny, this one also liked to point out to DD that “she knows daddy longer than you, and longer than your mummy knows him” 🙄 They see each other once a year and even when they lived in the same city they would usually meet up once in a while and in a group setting anyway, but sure…
Good for your DH to stand up to her!

OP posts:
MzHz · 23/08/2023 17:17

I reckon H might - just might - cotton on to how he needs to up his game when it comes to backing you and your kids @evuscha

MargaretThursday · 23/08/2023 17:16

When similar happened to me, (we were on holiday) and she I was fairly sure it was the other woman's way of trying to stamp ownership over the situation. She was someone dh had known (but not seen for around 5 years, nor had particularly known well) before I had met him.
I think she was trying to say that she was so comfortable in his presence that she "naturally" slipped into acting like his partner/dd's mum. She was definitely trying to give off a "we know each other so well vibe and you're the newcomer" to me. She wanted to only talk about people they had known back then/things they had done. Dh is the wrong person to try that with as he's more likely to have forgotten he saw someone yesterday than remember a random conversation he had 7 years ago.
When he said to her that we were just having some quiet "family time" her reaction was firstly along the lines of "fantastic, I'll come in" and when he said no, she suggested taking dd out with him and leaving me behind.
Dh doesn't tend to spot that sort of thing as being anything other than innocent, but he did tell her that wasn't happening.

MzHz · 23/08/2023 17:16

Yeah, exit the chat @evuscha it shows you’re done and cuts off contact so she won’t be able to worm her way in again.

that bloody woman KNEW what she was doing and when you didn’t reply she tried to unsettle you/dh by pushing it and stirring it up with dh, forcing you into a position

she’s given you the perfect out now tbh

billy1966 · 23/08/2023 16:12

OP, in your place I would exit the chat.
Mute her number.
This will make it very clear that you are done.

I think you have done your best in a sad situation.

You are correct that you really need to depend on yourself going forward.

A man who would stand by a woman who would bully his child, and step aside from his wife who was defending his child, is not a man with a moral compass you can depend on.

His priority is himself and what works for him.

I think that history has shown this to be true.

It's not a trait, it is in his DNA.

He made noises to appease you but threw you under a bus the first chance he got.

He is not a good man.
He is a very selfish man, the type that would stand by and allow a coach abuse his child and not step in.

Your children will grow up to see him for who he is.

In the interim you are already losing respect and your love will likely be replaced with disappointment, sadness, distaste and eventually you will be repulsed.

Keep your family and friends close.
Keep working full-time.

I think you assertiveness will only grow as you mature and you will realise that this selfish man simply isn't worthy of you and your children.

evuscha · 23/08/2023 15:35

Oh I definitely don’t care if she’s upset. I kind of hope she’s getting the hint and won’t ask to stay again but who knows… Maybe she really thought this weekend went well, or that it was a perfectly acceptable thing for her to do because everyone has to put up with “her ways”. And to be fair DH always did and if I didn’t put a stop to it, he always would I suppose, so she didn’t have a reason to even consider it. Though I did push back during the weekend a few times - not strongly enough but she did have a chance to notice I wasn’t happy. (just as she noticed I wasn’t happy when I stopped responding to messages) Surely the normal reaction would be to stop that behavior. But I suppose she didn’t expect me to really push back, she thought she was getting away with it as “that’s just her” as usual. I suspect another conversation will need to be had about this down the line because I suspect she will go back to pretending everything is great - she probably thinks her “apology” should be enough.
Anyway, my main concern now is DH, I hope he learned from this and will get better at having our back, despite the discomfort. I sure have learned that I need to speak up if noone else does, just need to work on that assertiveness part (this was definitely a case of waiting too long then blowing up).

OP posts:
MeadAndPie · 23/08/2023 11:10

I suppose the only outcome for me is knowing that I only have myself to rely on, and next time I have to speak up if I don’t like his family or friends doing something to me or DD. And work on that assertiveness for myself.

I found myself there with family and DH - frankly I realised I was one getting stressed and upset and found I cared so much less about upsetting people. If I didn't push back no-one would - it seems to have modeled polite push back to my kids so helpful long term I suppose though at time felt awful - DH did get bit better with time.

I think I'd have replied to her with Your constant unwarranted criticism of my child normal behaviour was disrespectful and rude to myself and DH and potentially damaging to my DD - I'm astounded you claim to lack so much awareness about your own behavior . But then I wouldn't want her back or care if she was upset or frankly if DH was either.

MzHz · 23/08/2023 07:03

God she’s either stupid, or thinks you are @evuscha

how on earth did she expect her behaviour to make you feel? How can she have such a different recollection of the weekend? Even your h acknowledges this fgs.

I reckon though that you have done enough now, she won’t come back and even if she does, YOU can say no to any visit even just broken record “it’s not convenient” if she pushes back- who cares if she’s seeing that it’s an excuse- she doesn’t care about you or your feelings so why waste a second worrying about how she feels being told she can’t stay at yours.

somehow @evuscha i reckon you’ve really been able to turn a corner here and will be far less people please-y in future

evuscha · 23/08/2023 02:30

FictionalCharacter · 22/08/2023 23:40

PS Maybe not right now, but at some point you'll need to tackle him about why he finds this OK, or says he does.
If he's too weak to defend his wife and children against anyone, not just this friend, that's a real long term problem.
If he's so terrified of even mild conflict that he persuades himself that the unpleasant behaviour happening right in front of his eyes isn't happening, that's also a problem. But he needs to be aware that children can see very clearly if a parent doesn't have their back, and it affects how they see that parent very drastically, especially as they get older. Does he want his kids to despise him for being weak and disloyal, or does he want to be a dad they're proud of and respect?

I did explode on DH today, again not the ideal reaction I could have had, but we did end up having a more measured discussion afterwards. He is obviously not perfect but is overall a lovely kind man who loves his family, but a combination of men just not seeing those digs as digs, and him being bad at confrontation in general, led us to this shitshow.
I told him how I really need him to do better by DD, and to get better at setting people straight, and not in a “evuscha feels that x, y, z” way but in a real united front way. He said he will try harder and is genuinely sorry…so I guess only time and future events will tell.

OP posts:
user1473878824 · 23/08/2023 02:26

LolaSmiles · 13/08/2023 17:16

I think it's reasonable for children to learn that family friends, and other trusted adults, will redirect them or challenge them. I find parents who think no other adult should step on their children's toe other than an urgent safety situation to be a little precious.

It's not ok the way your DH's friend has gone about it though. She's being passive aggressive, making digs at your parenting choices and being a bit of an arse in my opinion.

This in spades.

evuscha · 23/08/2023 02:24

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 23/08/2023 02:15

Her sorry, not sorry reaction is rubbish and gaslighting and I don't blame you for not wanting to discuss it further if she's continuing to spout stuff about how much she adores DD. She doesn't deserve more chances to justify how right she is. She's saying adores DD purely for your DH benefit.

Also, sorry for your lost and that you've had such a rotten year

It sounds like you stood up for yourself very well though and that you are not allowing yourself to be gaslighted. Perhaps its good that it came to a head and you've put your foot down so it won't happen again

I hope that this awful visit recedes from memory soon, you have time with your lovely DD and new baby to look forward to.

Thank you so much for your kind words 💐I really appreciate it. I suppose you’re right, it is good that it ended like this, I couldn’t go on pretending like nothing happened and we all had a great time. And her weird reaction just confirmed that my gut feeling to keep DD away from her from now on was correct all along.

OP posts:
DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 23/08/2023 02:16

*loss

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 23/08/2023 02:15

Her sorry, not sorry reaction is rubbish and gaslighting and I don't blame you for not wanting to discuss it further if she's continuing to spout stuff about how much she adores DD. She doesn't deserve more chances to justify how right she is. She's saying adores DD purely for your DH benefit.

Also, sorry for your lost and that you've had such a rotten year

It sounds like you stood up for yourself very well though and that you are not allowing yourself to be gaslighted. Perhaps its good that it came to a head and you've put your foot down so it won't happen again

I hope that this awful visit recedes from memory soon, you have time with your lovely DD and new baby to look forward to.

FictionalCharacter · 22/08/2023 23:40

PS Maybe not right now, but at some point you'll need to tackle him about why he finds this OK, or says he does.
If he's too weak to defend his wife and children against anyone, not just this friend, that's a real long term problem.
If he's so terrified of even mild conflict that he persuades himself that the unpleasant behaviour happening right in front of his eyes isn't happening, that's also a problem. But he needs to be aware that children can see very clearly if a parent doesn't have their back, and it affects how they see that parent very drastically, especially as they get older. Does he want his kids to despise him for being weak and disloyal, or does he want to be a dad they're proud of and respect?

evuscha · 22/08/2023 23:37

FictionalCharacter · 22/08/2023 23:29

"DD is a spoiled brat & you’re a weak mum who can’t set her straight, hahaha”

She really is utterly foul, isn't she? That isn't a joke on any planet! How absurd for her to now say she"adores" your DD. Who says that anyway?!

Vent away as much as you like. You've done incredibly well standing up to her when it doesn't come easily to you. Maybe your determination will encourage your dh to grow a backbone. If not, at least you know you're capable of defending yourself and your children.

Sorry to hear about the awful sickness. I went through that too. 💐

Sorry, she didn’t actually say those exact words, it was just my (clearly irrational according to them 🙄) interpretation of her endless comments of “you should do timeouts” etc and reprimanding her for every move - didn’t exactly scream “DD is amazing and you’re a wonderful mum” like she’s now trying to convince me she thinks.

And sorry you went through HG too - it is absolutely awful.

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 22/08/2023 23:29

"DD is a spoiled brat & you’re a weak mum who can’t set her straight, hahaha”

She really is utterly foul, isn't she? That isn't a joke on any planet! How absurd for her to now say she"adores" your DD. Who says that anyway?!

Vent away as much as you like. You've done incredibly well standing up to her when it doesn't come easily to you. Maybe your determination will encourage your dh to grow a backbone. If not, at least you know you're capable of defending yourself and your children.

Sorry to hear about the awful sickness. I went through that too. 💐

evuscha · 22/08/2023 23:12

MzHz · 22/08/2023 22:55

Have you replied to her @evuscha

if it were me I’d say “thanks for your words, you don’t need to explain, not everyone likes kids and that’s fine, but my family is my priority and I don’t appreciate being criticised or undermined in my own home, so while im not going to get it in the way of DH friendships, it’s a huge effort to host people in my home and I’m only willing to do that for people are kind and loving to us all. Dd included.”

id specifically avoid thanking her for an apology because it wasn’t one and you both know this. She absolutely knows what she’s done and is trying to undermine you again by gas lighting you all.

tell her you know she knows she crossed a line and you’re not stupid enough to make the mistake of having her beat you/dd again.

She still claims she adores DD, and that she had a great time with all of us. 🙄 and no I didn’t thank her for an apology, there definitely wasn’t one, “sorry if you got offended” is a classic isn’t it! In the end I said something like: “You know what, I’m more upset with myself at this point because I should have done more to stand up for DD, especially since DH wouldn’t.” To that she responded “I definitely didn’t want to make you feel that way, very sorry”. I’m kind of done talking to her, not in a sulky way, just not in a mood to talk to her anymore (and most definitely not letting her near DD).

Both of them (her & DH) going on and on about “how that made evuscha feel”, rather than acknowledging that they behaved in a shitty way!

I’m definitely hormonal now and so very upset by this. I’ve also had a really shitty year so far (to cut story short my dad died recently and I didn’t get to see him before, and then I followed with 4 months of being bedridden lying in a dark room all day due to HG/nonstop pregnancy sickness)….they both know about this very well. All I wanted was to have a nice relaxing fun weekend with family and friends. Instead I got a weekend of shitty jokes “DD is a spoiled brat & you’re a weak mum who can’t set her straight, hahaha” - and neither of them even see anything wrong with it! It is absolutely just damage control from both of them in a “just say sorry to her so she can stop going on about it” way.

I’m really sorry about ranting and all that self pity, I’m grateful I can talk to someone though and really appreciate the comments.

OP posts: