Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think "gentle parents" are setting their kids up for a lifetime of friendlessness and struggling to hold down a job?

455 replies

ForestGoblin · 13/08/2023 14:47

You get one chance to build the neural pathways that guide you for the rest of your life and if you don't learn that you're not the centre of anyone else's universe as a young kid you never will.

OP posts:
Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:37

HiAlisonItsCookie · 13/08/2023 23:28

I teach my children not to put up with it and to discuss on themselves and their education.

So you teach them to uphold their boundaries and be confident in articulating assertively when something has upset them without losing control of their emotions.

That's basically the entire point of gentle parenting.

Thank you for that explanation I will bare that in mind I do try to calm my son down when he gets upset and then he tells me. He does get upset with me when I don't hear him and I remind him I am half deaf so he has to speak up. My second daughter struggled and it took a lot of talking and I did lose it with her sometimes but she is fine now and doing what she is meant to be doing.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/08/2023 23:34

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:22

You wouldn't and I understand that it's not for me to explain it to you because even if I tried you probably still wouldn't understand by the looks of it. I will stop posting now. I know what I mean and I don't mean what you think I mean so I will leave it at that.

Have you realised that what you're saying makes no sense?Grin

HiAlisonItsCookie · 13/08/2023 23:28

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:12

I teach my children not to put up with it and to discuss on themselves and their education.

I teach my children not to put up with it and to discuss on themselves and their education.

So you teach them to uphold their boundaries and be confident in articulating assertively when something has upset them without losing control of their emotions.

That's basically the entire point of gentle parenting.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:22

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/08/2023 23:14

I don't recognise any of what you're saying tbh. My dd started school with a good understanding of healthy, respectful relationships and a good level of self confidence. Having been raised with kindness, respect and calm but clear communication, she knew how to interact with others effectively and recognised when others were not behaving appropriately. I think your thinking is completely backwards tbh.

You wouldn't and I understand that it's not for me to explain it to you because even if I tried you probably still wouldn't understand by the looks of it. I will stop posting now. I know what I mean and I don't mean what you think I mean so I will leave it at that.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/08/2023 23:14

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:07

No it's when your child reaches school and your with other children who are unpleasant. Yes be kind but prepare them for the bullies. I have entered threads this week that are shocking to read gentle parents don't know what to do with their chaotic children. They have always spoken to them gently and gone down to their level and as soon as they enter school they mix with lunatics. Then the pressure comes in and they have to look cool so all that positive parenting goes out the window.

I don't recognise any of what you're saying tbh. My dd started school with a good understanding of healthy, respectful relationships and a good level of self confidence. Having been raised with kindness, respect and calm but clear communication, she knew how to interact with others effectively and recognised when others were not behaving appropriately. I think your thinking is completely backwards tbh.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:13

*Focus on themselves and their education.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:12

Gerrataere · 13/08/2023 23:05

So you believe the way to prepare your children for the world is to treat them
as badly as the rest of the world will eventually? Because GP means understanding that the world is a big bad place and that home and parents is a safe haven. No, life ‘isn’t fair’ but if they know one place they won’t get judged, yelled at, told their likes and personalities aren’t wanted, that their achievements are minimal then surely it should be home. The rest of the world doesn’t need to meet your childrens wellbeing on every level, but parents do and there’s no need for the extra negativity of ‘but the world is shit so get used to it.’.

I teach my children not to put up with it and to discuss on themselves and their education.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:07

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/08/2023 23:00

So what are you suggesting, exactly? That parents should treat their kids like shit so that they toughen up a bit? Because that is the logical conclusion of your post.

Your thinking on this is utterly fucked up. Kids do not learn resilience and self confidence from having to cope with parents who don't respect them. Having their needs met and their feelings respected when they're very young enables them to develop the resilience and self confidence that they need to tackle problems when they are older.

No it's when your child reaches school and your with other children who are unpleasant. Yes be kind but prepare them for the bullies. I have entered threads this week that are shocking to read gentle parents don't know what to do with their chaotic children. They have always spoken to them gently and gone down to their level and as soon as they enter school they mix with lunatics. Then the pressure comes in and they have to look cool so all that positive parenting goes out the window.

Gerrataere · 13/08/2023 23:05

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 22:55

Then your child goes out into the real world and realises that other people are not like his mummy they are complete wankers. He will have to learn new skills in order to work his way around so people don't jump on him. Let's hope that he doesn't suffer from anxiety when he learns that people are not nice and you do need a back bone to get on in life.

So you believe the way to prepare your children for the world is to treat them
as badly as the rest of the world will eventually? Because GP means understanding that the world is a big bad place and that home and parents is a safe haven. No, life ‘isn’t fair’ but if they know one place they won’t get judged, yelled at, told their likes and personalities aren’t wanted, that their achievements are minimal then surely it should be home. The rest of the world doesn’t need to meet your childrens wellbeing on every level, but parents do and there’s no need for the extra negativity of ‘but the world is shit so get used to it.’.

Pollyputhekettleon · 13/08/2023 23:05

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/08/2023 23:00

So what are you suggesting, exactly? That parents should treat their kids like shit so that they toughen up a bit? Because that is the logical conclusion of your post.

Your thinking on this is utterly fucked up. Kids do not learn resilience and self confidence from having to cope with parents who don't respect them. Having their needs met and their feelings respected when they're very young enables them to develop the resilience and self confidence that they need to tackle problems when they are older.

The problem is you and others seem to assume that the alternatives are binary - gentle parenting, a very specific parenting philosophy, or not respecting your child. That's really odd you know? I think the only way to have a conversation about this is to get past all these meaningless platitudes about respecting feelings and meeting needs and get specific about what exactly that looks like in practice.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/08/2023 23:00

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 22:55

Then your child goes out into the real world and realises that other people are not like his mummy they are complete wankers. He will have to learn new skills in order to work his way around so people don't jump on him. Let's hope that he doesn't suffer from anxiety when he learns that people are not nice and you do need a back bone to get on in life.

So what are you suggesting, exactly? That parents should treat their kids like shit so that they toughen up a bit? Because that is the logical conclusion of your post.

Your thinking on this is utterly fucked up. Kids do not learn resilience and self confidence from having to cope with parents who don't respect them. Having their needs met and their feelings respected when they're very young enables them to develop the resilience and self confidence that they need to tackle problems when they are older.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 22:55

RosaSkye · 13/08/2023 14:54

You're right, you get one chance. Thats what gentle parenting is all about. Holding firm boundaries with calmness, speaking to the human beings your raising with respect, modelling forgiveness and apologies because children learn by watching what we do not by doing what we say.

Then your child goes out into the real world and realises that other people are not like his mummy they are complete wankers. He will have to learn new skills in order to work his way around so people don't jump on him. Let's hope that he doesn't suffer from anxiety when he learns that people are not nice and you do need a back bone to get on in life.

Pollyputhekettleon · 13/08/2023 22:53

@literalviolence The devil's in the definitions.

Explaining reasons in practice often seems to mean explaining them over and over again because in reality the child is not taking no (or whatever words one uses instead of the dreaded 'no') for an answer and couldn't care less what your reasons are. Not talking down to them in practice often means giving one year olds a long psychobabble explanation for why they're whacking the other child over the head. Not shaming them seems to mean ensuring they never feel ashamed of their behaviour - when in reality there are times when that's the perfectly appropriate emotion to feel.

LolaSmiles · 13/08/2023 22:49

Why do all the 'gentle' parents on here think the rest of us are going round constantly shouting and screaming at our kids? Every one of them has mentioned it. 😂
I don't think everyone is going around screaming. A lot of people I know, whatever they call it, tend to fall broadly into an authoritative approach to parenting, with some using a more authoritarian approach at times with the more Supernanny-style techniques to greater or lesser degree.

I do think that there's a lot more drifting into authoritarianism than some parents would like to admit to. The amount of times on here children are called awful things for being children, babies and young children and considered to be manipulative, that adults need to take on boss mode and show them who's boss, that taking time to be respectful and empathetic to children makes them narcissistic, they think the universe revolves around them if you give them choices etc

literalviolence · 13/08/2023 22:43

HappyAsASandboy · 13/08/2023 14:55

I think you are confusing gentle parenting with indulging your children.

Gentle parenting is about treating your children as actual real people, who deserve respect and autonomy over the things they are ready to handle. It is explaining the reasons for decisions. It is remembering that you shouldn't talk down to them just because they're smaller than you. It is being aware of their skills and limitations and never shaming them. It is many things.

In my experience, giving children respect, independence, autonomy and calm role modelling leads to calm, confident kids who are able to interact with other kids and adults well.

That honestly just sounds like normal parenting to me.

ChevyCamaro · 13/08/2023 22:40

One of the most damaging things to come out of my own ( born late 70s) generation of parents is this absolute obsession with Parenting as a verb. I think, if my own experiences are common, that a lot of my generation were really under "parented" which has led to us feeling like we are desperate to do it better, different, perfect.
My parents were wrapped up in their own world, very little was ever for our benefit directly. We were fed, clothed in hand me downs and sent to school. That was it. No extras, not too much thought to our individual needs or development. It just wasn't a thing.
So now, parents in their 40s at least are trying to redress the balance, and everything is focused on children.
We think every little word, action or mistake will somehow screw them up beyond redemption. But I really think in reality any parent who provides love and security, doesn't go apeshit over tiny problems and tries to teach general respect for others is probably doing a decent enough job.
Endlessly dissecting the impact we have as parents will ( imo) lead to a whole generation of anxious, fragile young people who will in turn obsess over their own parenting, trying to rectify the awful mistakes that they perceive to have ruined their lives.
I wish my own childhood had been a little more focused on me as an individual, but I'm not sure being the centre of the known universe would have led me to being the curious, adventurous resilient person I became.

ChristmasCrumpet · 13/08/2023 22:39

PlanetJanette · 13/08/2023 22:23

If I describe myself as a brain surgeon and stick a knitting needle in your ear to help with your headaches, it’s not the fault of brain surgeons.

Crap parents who call themselves gentle parents aren’t the responsibility of those who actually have taken the time to learn about what gentle parenting actually is.

It's just strange that this is what 90% of people who call themselves GP in real life are though.

Rather a lot.

Gerrataere · 13/08/2023 22:37

scrollinginthedark · 13/08/2023 22:22

Wait until you see what's happening in classrooms!

Pointless statement to be honest. What’s happening in terms of running classrooms is well beyond parenting tactics. The education system is hardly fit for purpose unless you have a child who can hit average or slightly above targets in academic achievement whilst rarely making a peep in class. There’s no funding for much needed TAs and classrooms are overfilled. SEN support is beyond a joke so the children who are most likely to need support aren’t getting it - they are the children most likely to be causing a disruption whilst being labelled ‘naughty’ and the product of weak parenting. If you have an issue with this then perhaps lobby the government to stop running schools like businesses run by Tory mates who’ve never taught a class in their life.

Olive19741205 · 13/08/2023 22:36

Why do all the 'gentle' parents on here think the rest of us are going round constantly shouting and screaming at our kids? Every one of them has mentioned it. 😂

LolaSmiles · 13/08/2023 22:27

PlanetJanette
Well said.
If I came on a thread where brain surgeons were clearly explain that Steve down the pub with his knitting needles isn't a brain surgeon, regardless of what he said, I'd not get half a dozen pages in and be confused because "I've spoken to a lot of people with knitting needles and they said shoving them in your ears does solve headaches and it doesn't work. Brain surgery is rubbish and totally confusing"

SummerSun04 · 13/08/2023 22:26

'Tarquin was GP and never told no, and now he throws books at people in school and wallops them in the head, so GP is terrible'. Completely failing to recognize that if Tarquin were actually GP, then he would have developed an understanding of his own emotions and those of others, and learned how to deal with them appropriately through all the effort and modeling that his GP gave him so far. All those explanations that non-GP find so insufferable and effortful and boring, that's the effort that leads to these emotionally healthy teenagers that actually do not have mental health problems and hate their parents. GP teens are largely respectful, trustworthy, interesting, and fun people to be around. They haven't been scared and shamed into doing as their parents demanded for no reason other than "because I said so". People making comments about 'the world won't be kind/center of the universe' drivel don't seem to understand that the entire premise of GP is to enable children to develop the understanding and skills to be emotionally capable adults. GP is a philosophy rather than simply being softly spoken, it's about the underlying beliefs about children and the role that adults play in supporting them. The children throwing books in school are the ones who received the opposite of GP.

Then there are people saying 'I didn't hit or shout, so I'm a gentle parent (and told them No, Do as you're told, XYZ other NON-GP statement) so it doesn't need a special name'. When seemingly it does, because they don't understand what it is, displayed by their use of terms like being the boss and deliberately naughty.

llamadrama16 · 13/08/2023 22:23

I gentle parent for the most part and tell my kids no all the time. If they hit someone at the park, for example, they are told 'no hitting' and made to check in with the person they hit and to apologise. I would usually keep a very close eye on them then and interject before they had the opportunity to do it again. If they made a move to be violent again I would stop them and say 'if you hurt others park time is done for the day' and made sure they repeated so they understood. Third time I would stop them before they were violent again, but it would be a 'I am not going to let you hurt anyone, park time is finished for today'.

We don't usually talk about feelings etc in the moment because kids are rarely receptive to it then.

PlanetJanette · 13/08/2023 22:23

ShiteRider · 13/08/2023 21:40

Oh my goodness! I’m giving up with this post because it’s just not going in. Some people (in real life) are describing their own parenting as gentle parenting when it doesn’t fit the description given on this thread. That’s why people are basing opinions on a definition which isn’t the one on this thread.

If I describe myself as a brain surgeon and stick a knitting needle in your ear to help with your headaches, it’s not the fault of brain surgeons.

Crap parents who call themselves gentle parents aren’t the responsibility of those who actually have taken the time to learn about what gentle parenting actually is.

scrollinginthedark · 13/08/2023 22:22

ComtesseDeSpair · 13/08/2023 14:52

Most children are pretty myopic until they start school however they’re patented. I suspect that by the time gentle-patented children have been in Reception class for a couple of months they’ll have had a bit of reality knocked into them and realised that what happens at home isn’t how things are going to work with their teacher and it certainly won’t fly with their peers. Most of us turn out alright eventually.

Wait until you see what's happening in classrooms!

MeadAndPie · 13/08/2023 22:17

People coulddo a quick Google, theycouldread at least some of the dozen pages with people talking about the topic, but they won't. They'll just continue to argues it's so confusing and Tarquin has never been told no in his life.

My first google result to gentle parenting:

https://www.verywellfamily.com/what-is-gentle-parenting-5189566#citation-2

Mostly opinion based talks about research but refences 3 papers- but I'd have to read to see if they actually have anything to do with gentle parenting because titles suggest they may not.

  1. Grady JS. Parental gentle encouragement promotes shy toddlers' regulation in social contexts. J Exp Child Psychol. 2019 Oct;186:83-98. doi:10.1016/j.jecp.2019.05.008. PMID:31203109.
  2. Augustine ME, Stifter CA. Temperament, parenting, and moral development: specificity of behavior and context. Soc Dev. 2015;24(2):285-303. doi:10.1111/sode.12092
  3. Kim SY, Wang Y, Orozco-Lapray D, Shen Y, Murtuza M. Does “tiger parenting” exist? Parenting profiles of Chinese Americans and adolescent developmental outcomes. Asian American Journal of Psychology. 2013;4(1):7-18. doi:10.1037/a0030612

https://www.newyorker.com/books/under-review/the-harsh-realm-of-gentle-parenting

Gives impression it base on one book and fairly loosely defined.

https://health.clevelandclinic.org/what-is-gentle-parenting/

Which is more opinion based.

https://www.guidepostmontessori.com/blog/beginners-guide-gentle-parenting

https://www.thecut.com/2023/03/is-gentle-parenting-effective.html

Seems critical not big on definitions or research.

I have read the posts of gentle parenting - seems to basic parenting and anything good is gentle parenting and everything else has clearly negative labels and child must be damaged just because.

It's clearly not well defined or widely well understood - it's clearly really important label/philosophy to some posters but outside that bubble it's just not well understood.

The Harsh Realm of “Gentle Parenting”

The approach flourishes because it caters to a child’s inner life. What does it neglect?

https://www.newyorker.com/books/under-review/the-harsh-realm-of-gentle-parenting