Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think "gentle parents" are setting their kids up for a lifetime of friendlessness and struggling to hold down a job?

455 replies

ForestGoblin · 13/08/2023 14:47

You get one chance to build the neural pathways that guide you for the rest of your life and if you don't learn that you're not the centre of anyone else's universe as a young kid you never will.

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 14/08/2023 08:11

LolaSmiles · 13/08/2023 22:07

ChristmasCrumpet
I know they're mislabeling themselves.

Take parenting out of it.

The logic of some posters seems to be like this:
"SuperDietPlan is rubbish. You gain weight on it because you do A, B, C"

Actually, if someone is doing ABC then they're not actually following SuperDietPlan. That's probably why they gain weight instead of losing weight

"but I know 6 people who do ABC and THEY say that's SuperDietPlan"

We know, but it isn't. Actually if you look on SuperDietPlan materials written by people who know what they're talking about, it's quite clear that SuperDietPlan means XYZ, not ABC

"SuperDietPlan doesn't work. I saw Tracey and she's gained half a stone in a week doing ABC, and Dave's gained a stone. People say SuperDietPlan is meant to offer healthy lifestyle change but ABC clearly causes weight gain"

ABC isn't SuperDietPlan. Some people might say it is, but SuperDietPlan means doing XYZ. ABC doesn't work. ABC isn't SuperDietPlan

"This is so confusing! Surely SuperDietPlan is just healthy eating? Everyone eats healthy."

"I know! I know a lot of people who do ABC and say it's SuperDietPlan, so despite lots of information at my fingertips, I'm just going to continue to conclude that SuperDietPlan does mean ABC because it so confusing"

THIS. Except that "SuperDietPlan" doesn't have any materials written by people who know what they are talking about.

Turns out that there are LOTS of people who write about SuperDietPlan, and some of them are very knowledgable/experienced with food and weight loss (some of them are not however!) but they all contradict each other because they all have slightly different, sometimes wildly different, understandings and yet all present with confidence as though they alone know "The true SuperDietPlan". One of them is saying Do XYZ. Another is saying "How XYZ are common myths that harm your weight loss journey". Another is saying "How to do XYZ and avoid ABC" but it's not actually good advice, and following it will lead you to ABC very quickly. One is saying do X and Y, but never ever ever Z because this is completely against SuperDietPlan's core philosophy.

Nowhere is there a "SuperDietPlan Master Resource" or institute, or a book called Super Diet Plan (yes I know people cite Sarah Ockwell Smith but she didn't invent it, there were loads of us on MN doing Gentle Parenting - or talking about a concept that we called this - before she wrote her Gentle XYZ books).

I avoid the term gentle parenting now, even though I still believe in (most of) what I used to post about under that term. It's just too unhelpful and results in circular confusing discussions.

5128gap · 14/08/2023 08:03

That example doesn't work @DinoDough because it would also be abusive if your partner forcibly put your shoes on for you because they didn't want to be late for something you had no interest in.
This false equivalence with adult relationships is inappropriate and makes the concept even more blurry. In adult relationships wielding power through physical strength and control of resources never has a place, whereas in your relationship with your child its unavoidable.
In reality your child has almost no autonomy in many areas of their lives and the parent will be continually excercising control or coercion. Examples can't simply be lifted from adult to adult interactions and plonked into the parent/child ones to illistrate how awful non GP is.

ChristmasCrumpet · 14/08/2023 07:53

Jamtartforme · 14/08/2023 00:03

I saw a thread a while ago where a poster was begging for help with her unruly toddler ‘but please bear in mind when you respond that we are committed to gentle parenting’

It’s like it hadn’t occurred to her that if gentle parenting worked her child wouldn’t be so unruly 🤯

I think this happens a lot in real life and again does not help experiences of what people claim GP is and the results it produces.

Per my PP, the 5 people I know, that label themselves GP, have horrendously behaved DC. I've noticed on this thread, the only people who think GP children behave, are their GP. Or perhaps the GP's mum. In real life, the parents I've encountered are literally delusional.

They definitely think their DC are superior and think this is because their parenting is superior.

In real life though, you have to wonder how they genuinely think this, I mean, they have eyes, that's all you need to see the behaviour...yet they seem not to notice, and will tell anyone who will listen how brilliant and well balanced their child is.

DinoDough · 14/08/2023 07:20

Jamtartforme · 14/08/2023 00:07

But ‘no’ followed by ‘because I say so’ or ‘I think video games are stupid and rot your brain’ wouldn’t be a productive conversation, it makes it all about you and your feelings whilst completely dismissing the child

Children should occasionally be dismissed. Their teachers at school and line managers at work won’t consult them on everything they’re asked to do, they’ll get the instruction then just have to do it. Giving kids endless justifications and choices is a terrible idea, because adult life simply doesn’t reflect this. And it’ll come as a huge shock.

Do you come home and you want to watch something and your partner says ‘no’, gives you no reason, takes the remote away, and says ‘you need to be dismissed sometimes to remind you of how the real world is’ - is that acceptable? Of course not, everyone on here would be screaming LTB. This idea that because children are smaller and younger they need to be pushed about is odd mentality. They need guidance and discipline but you don’t have to be an arse and dismiss them either.

You need to put your shoes on
Why
Because we have to go out to the appointment and we can’t be late
I don’t want to put my shoes on
I get that but we have to go out to the appointment and you cant walk outside without shoes as you’ll hurt your feet. So either you can put them on or I’ll have to put them on for you, which is it?

Call it gentle, call it normal, whatever.

Green777 · 14/08/2023 07:13

Recently seen a 2.5 year old child refusing to put their rain coat on to walk home in the pouring rain. Also refused to get into pram. All the begging and pleading from mum was met with a firm ‘no’.

Mum gave in sighing and shrugging and let him walk home in torrential downpour absolutely soaked.

What would a GP do? To me this is madness, my child would have been put in the pram.

Jamtartforme · 14/08/2023 05:57

BrindleAbyssinianGuinea2 · 14/08/2023 02:05

I didn't say that but one of the PP s on here mentioned a bratty child whose gentle parenting parents spoke calmly to them and the child was a horror. I guess I was trying to say that speaking calmly to a child is a good thing . If gentle parenting means speaking calmly to a child then gentle parenting is good .

She did list other things those parents did like never saying no that I see could be an issue. But I was baffled as to why she includes speaking calmly as though it were an issue?

I'm not saying that those who don't gentle parent are all telling at (abusing in other words) their children .

I don’t think pp meant speaking calmly is inherently a bad thing, more that it’s not always effective and children actually to need to see that they’ve made you cross or disappointed sometimes.

GavinsFace · 14/08/2023 05:45

Pollyputhekettleon · 13/08/2023 23:05

The problem is you and others seem to assume that the alternatives are binary - gentle parenting, a very specific parenting philosophy, or not respecting your child. That's really odd you know? I think the only way to have a conversation about this is to get past all these meaningless platitudes about respecting feelings and meeting needs and get specific about what exactly that looks like in practice.

I agree. The arguments are very binary here. People seem to think only extremes exist. It’s odd.

GavinsFace · 14/08/2023 05:41

SummerSun04 · 13/08/2023 22:26

'Tarquin was GP and never told no, and now he throws books at people in school and wallops them in the head, so GP is terrible'. Completely failing to recognize that if Tarquin were actually GP, then he would have developed an understanding of his own emotions and those of others, and learned how to deal with them appropriately through all the effort and modeling that his GP gave him so far. All those explanations that non-GP find so insufferable and effortful and boring, that's the effort that leads to these emotionally healthy teenagers that actually do not have mental health problems and hate their parents. GP teens are largely respectful, trustworthy, interesting, and fun people to be around. They haven't been scared and shamed into doing as their parents demanded for no reason other than "because I said so". People making comments about 'the world won't be kind/center of the universe' drivel don't seem to understand that the entire premise of GP is to enable children to develop the understanding and skills to be emotionally capable adults. GP is a philosophy rather than simply being softly spoken, it's about the underlying beliefs about children and the role that adults play in supporting them. The children throwing books in school are the ones who received the opposite of GP.

Then there are people saying 'I didn't hit or shout, so I'm a gentle parent (and told them No, Do as you're told, XYZ other NON-GP statement) so it doesn't need a special name'. When seemingly it does, because they don't understand what it is, displayed by their use of terms like being the boss and deliberately naughty.

‘All those explanations that non-GP find so insufferable and effortful and boring, that's the effort that leads to these emotionally healthy teenagers that actually do not have mental health problems and hate their parents.’

I see no need to make it so black and white. I didn’t GP. I said no to my children. But I have gorgeous and happy young adult kids who think I am awesome and don’t hate me. I am not denigrating GP but it’s important to remember that it’s not the only way to raise well-rounded and confident young people.

My brother used a more GP approach. Gave his toddlers lots of choices and explanations every step of the way. His kids are now similar ages to my kids. And all our children now are pretty great young people and you can’t tell who was raised with which philosophy. As I keep saying, kids who are raised with love and boundaries tend to do ok. Whether the parents want to label their own parenting and follow a certain prescribed philosophy or not.

BrindleAbyssinianGuinea2 · 14/08/2023 02:05

Olive19741205 · 14/08/2023 01:27

Another poster talking about "yelling" or "screamed at". Where has this notion come from that if we're not 'gentle parents' we scream, shout at and bully our children? Nearly every single post on here advocating for gentle parenting has mentioned these things.

I didn't say that but one of the PP s on here mentioned a bratty child whose gentle parenting parents spoke calmly to them and the child was a horror. I guess I was trying to say that speaking calmly to a child is a good thing . If gentle parenting means speaking calmly to a child then gentle parenting is good .

She did list other things those parents did like never saying no that I see could be an issue. But I was baffled as to why she includes speaking calmly as though it were an issue?

I'm not saying that those who don't gentle parent are all telling at (abusing in other words) their children .

Codlingmoths · 14/08/2023 01:34

Absolutely. For all of those posters who say you’ve misunderstood gentle parenting, the reality is maybe they gentle parent well but many many ‘gentle parents’ very much misunderstand gentle parenting. I left a Fb group with thousands of members when someone posted that their 7yo was up on their tablet until 3am and what could they do? it was the admin people who explained to me in detail that yes, bedtimes are coercive and gentle parents do not set bedtimes unless their child agrees and supports the bedtime. Like what the actual fuck. So these admin are the people defining gentle parenting and setting the rules for thousands- this is clearly a very very common view of wha gentle parenting is, specifically amongst those who gentle parent. So if someone tells me they are a gentle parent, I wonder if they are a good parent or exactly the parent the op mentions whose children will be disadvantaged from a very young age. Doesn’t mean they won’t turn out ok, plenty of children just about have to bring themselves up, but doesn’t make it good parenting.

one day one of my kids will have friends over, and when they leave I will turn to my husband and say Child X clearly has some of those gentle parents who think bedtimes are coercive, and let’s keep a close eye on that friendship.

Olive19741205 · 14/08/2023 01:27

BrindleAbyssinianGuinea2 · 14/08/2023 00:22

True there must be a middle ground. I don't think it's right that children should never hear the word no. However I would support the validation of feelings and not yelling, speaking kindly and gently . In my experience children who are screamed at or spoken to harshly often become bullies.

Another poster talking about "yelling" or "screamed at". Where has this notion come from that if we're not 'gentle parents' we scream, shout at and bully our children? Nearly every single post on here advocating for gentle parenting has mentioned these things.

BrindleAbyssinianGuinea2 · 14/08/2023 00:22

BigButtons · 14/08/2023 00:10

Neither extreme is good though.

True there must be a middle ground. I don't think it's right that children should never hear the word no. However I would support the validation of feelings and not yelling, speaking kindly and gently . In my experience children who are screamed at or spoken to harshly often become bullies.

BigButtons · 14/08/2023 00:10

BrindleAbyssinianGuinea2 · 13/08/2023 23:59

Same here.

Neither extreme is good though.

Skyblue18 · 14/08/2023 00:08

Jamtartforme · 14/08/2023 00:03

I saw a thread a while ago where a poster was begging for help with her unruly toddler ‘but please bear in mind when you respond that we are committed to gentle parenting’

It’s like it hadn’t occurred to her that if gentle parenting worked her child wouldn’t be so unruly 🤯

I never slapped my children but they were in no doubt as to who was in charge 😁

Jamtartforme · 14/08/2023 00:07

But ‘no’ followed by ‘because I say so’ or ‘I think video games are stupid and rot your brain’ wouldn’t be a productive conversation, it makes it all about you and your feelings whilst completely dismissing the child

Children should occasionally be dismissed. Their teachers at school and line managers at work won’t consult them on everything they’re asked to do, they’ll get the instruction then just have to do it. Giving kids endless justifications and choices is a terrible idea, because adult life simply doesn’t reflect this. And it’ll come as a huge shock.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/08/2023 00:06

Olive19741205 · 13/08/2023 23:59

I'm sorry but this is hilarious. You're saying all that as if YOU are the one who has discovered 'parenting' the right way. What you've written is the way 100% of the people I know parent their children, me included. We don't put a daft name on it though, it's just parenting...common sense.

I also think it's just parenting/common sense, and I never felt the need to put a label on it. However, I parent in a very similar way to how my own mum and dad parented.

I wonder if the "daft labels" are more relevant/meaningful to those who are consciously trying to parent differently from how their own parents did it? I can see how giving it a name might be helpful to those who aren't just following what feels like second nature to them.

It's very easy to repeat the cycles that our parents passed down to us, much more difficult to break away and do something different. I won't stand in judgement of anyone who actively tries to do that, and if a "daft label" helps them to stay on track with it, all power to them!

Jamtartforme · 14/08/2023 00:03

I saw a thread a while ago where a poster was begging for help with her unruly toddler ‘but please bear in mind when you respond that we are committed to gentle parenting’

It’s like it hadn’t occurred to her that if gentle parenting worked her child wouldn’t be so unruly 🤯

Wenfy · 14/08/2023 00:02

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:54

When my eldest daughter started A Levels in September 2020 she choose Biology, P.E and Psychology. In the first two weeks her Psychology teacher told the whole class that the maths part of the course was hard. She came home and told me and I said her teachers from her other school felt confident that she would do well in that subject and I had confidence in her as well. Two weeks later she wants a day off to think about whether she should continue or not or whether she should do sociology. I said fine have a day off I had a right go at her for self doubting herself and all because the teacher said it was hard how dare she do that to herself.

She ended up getting an A* for Psychology she wrote 5 essays in 2 hours in the exam. She is a very capable and bright young lady and if I didn't give her that kick up the arse she would not have got that grade. Now she is at university living it up and kicking the arse out of all her exams.

This was my dd exactly before her 11+ exams. She actually gave me a reasoned argument for homeschooling her - prior to this she’d been getting 100% straight in all the practice papers to the point where a lot of tutors were turning us away in favour of kids who needed them more. I think sometimes kids, girls especially, can let their inner critics get out of control - it’s our jobs as parents to give them a little nudge every now and again.

Skyblue18 · 14/08/2023 00:02

Olive19741205 · 13/08/2023 23:59

I'm sorry but this is hilarious. You're saying all that as if YOU are the one who has discovered 'parenting' the right way. What you've written is the way 100% of the people I know parent their children, me included. We don't put a daft name on it though, it's just parenting...common sense.

This

Olive19741205 · 13/08/2023 23:59

Gerrataere · 13/08/2023 17:43

Of course you can say no, but it’s respectful to explain why in an age appropriate way. Like my eldest has been begging for the game Among Us for a year. I’ve said a hard no, but I always follow it with reasons (it’s online, I feel you’re too young for a game of that nature, we will discuss it again when you’re about 9, etc). I tell him I am not saying no to be mean, but for his own well-being. It is not a situation where finding his own consequences would be useful if that makes sense. But ‘no’ followed by ‘because I say so’ or ‘I think video games are stupid and rot your brain’ wouldn’t be a productive conversation, it makes it all about you and your feelings whilst completely dismissing the child.

I'm sorry but this is hilarious. You're saying all that as if YOU are the one who has discovered 'parenting' the right way. What you've written is the way 100% of the people I know parent their children, me included. We don't put a daft name on it though, it's just parenting...common sense.

BrindleAbyssinianGuinea2 · 13/08/2023 23:59

Circumferences · 13/08/2023 14:58

"gentle parents" are setting their kids up for a lifetime of friendlessness and struggling to hold down a job

Sorry, but I've had a lifetime of friendlessness, joblessness and more because I was abused as a child and live with CPTSD as a result.

I'd have given my left arm for "gentle parenting".

Same here.

Skyblue18 · 13/08/2023 23:58

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:54

When my eldest daughter started A Levels in September 2020 she choose Biology, P.E and Psychology. In the first two weeks her Psychology teacher told the whole class that the maths part of the course was hard. She came home and told me and I said her teachers from her other school felt confident that she would do well in that subject and I had confidence in her as well. Two weeks later she wants a day off to think about whether she should continue or not or whether she should do sociology. I said fine have a day off I had a right go at her for self doubting herself and all because the teacher said it was hard how dare she do that to herself.

She ended up getting an A* for Psychology she wrote 5 essays in 2 hours in the exam. She is a very capable and bright young lady and if I didn't give her that kick up the arse she would not have got that grade. Now she is at university living it up and kicking the arse out of all her exams.

👍😁

Skyblue18 · 13/08/2023 23:54

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:38

Don't care spend a day in my shoes and see how long it takes you to lose the plot.

It's a normal human response to lose the plot occasionally & within reason. We are not robots. My children knew who was boss and they recently said to me it made them feel more secure & protected knowing this. I suppose I was a combination of authoritative and softly softly. It worked for us.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:54

When my eldest daughter started A Levels in September 2020 she choose Biology, P.E and Psychology. In the first two weeks her Psychology teacher told the whole class that the maths part of the course was hard. She came home and told me and I said her teachers from her other school felt confident that she would do well in that subject and I had confidence in her as well. Two weeks later she wants a day off to think about whether she should continue or not or whether she should do sociology. I said fine have a day off I had a right go at her for self doubting herself and all because the teacher said it was hard how dare she do that to herself.

She ended up getting an A* for Psychology she wrote 5 essays in 2 hours in the exam. She is a very capable and bright young lady and if I didn't give her that kick up the arse she would not have got that grade. Now she is at university living it up and kicking the arse out of all her exams.

Carpediemmakeitcount · 13/08/2023 23:38

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/08/2023 23:34

Have you realised that what you're saying makes no sense?Grin

Don't care spend a day in my shoes and see how long it takes you to lose the plot.