Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think "gentle parents" are setting their kids up for a lifetime of friendlessness and struggling to hold down a job?

455 replies

ForestGoblin · 13/08/2023 14:47

You get one chance to build the neural pathways that guide you for the rest of your life and if you don't learn that you're not the centre of anyone else's universe as a young kid you never will.

OP posts:
FixUpLookSharrp · 14/08/2023 09:38

Skinthin · 14/08/2023 09:27

100% this.
This is exactly it:
In the example of the shoes, I'm sure there are parents who would allow their child to be bare foot or cancel the appointment as the lesser evil than what they would see as being coercive or controlling
And the more trite gentle parenting gurus refuse to address these conundrums because they don’t fit into the approach. The implication is that if your child choses the third option (rebellion) it’s because you are not doing gentle parenting right, or your child isn’t as perfect and well behaved as mine. It’s a necessary presumption of the way the approach js applied that children of gentle parents are always so respectful and well behaved and it’s because of their superior parenting approach. Like the pp who says of course she never forces on the shoes, the child always chooses 🙄.
The reality is children aren’t always like this and they don’t always comply and the gentle methods don’t always work as well as they do in practice as they do in theory. That’s when the lazy , permissive parenting comes in, because these middle class parents following the gospel of Sarah orkwell smith have no other ideas and no other tools.

What has this got to do with middle class people? Why is MN so classist?

Confusinglyconfused · 14/08/2023 09:36

Skinthin · 14/08/2023 09:22

Yes, that was the point if you read the thread.

I have read the thread and understand the thread thank you. Gentle parenting isn't about treating a child like an equal it's about treating them with the respect your afford any other human being - but in an age appropriate manner.

Children like choice, if the choice is between 2 things you are happy with being the outcome botj parties are happy. If the choice is all about one person not the other the power dynamic shifts, one party feels aggrieved and digs their heels in.

Put your shoes on
No
Where do you go from here?

Shoes on time, am I helping you today or are you being a big girl and putting them on yourself?
Don't want shoes on
Ok well we are going out, you'll just get wet/cold/sore feet then, come on.
No
Come on then sit down and we'll do it together

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 14/08/2023 09:36

I think someone should re-name gentle parenting because it always seems to cause a lot of confusion.

JJ230 · 14/08/2023 09:34

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 13/08/2023 15:31

There is no such thing as showing too much love or support.
Your kids will turn out more resilient and well adjusted than a parent who tries to teach them a lesson.

Obviously, it depends on your definition of gentle parenting.
If it’s letting your kids do whatever they want, then no that’s not good but that’s not what gentle parenting is, that’s just neglect.

I would say I’m a gentle parent.
I don’t hit, I’m not strict, I rarely shout etc but that’s because I don’t need to.

The more strict and harsh you are, the more your kids will rebel and struggle at life.

Agree with you completely

JJ230 · 14/08/2023 09:32

I don't think you understand what gentle parenting is at all. It still involves 'no' and firm boundaries, but done in a way that treats the child with respect. Look at 'big little feelings' on Instagram if you want to educate yourself.

Skinthin · 14/08/2023 09:27

5128gap · 14/08/2023 08:59

I'm not criticising the parenting approach. My point is simply that comparisons to adult to adult relationships are not helpful.
You didn't say you would forcibly put your child's shoes on, but "either you put them on or I do...."
well the child has a third choice don't they, which is to refuse them being on altogether. You can't have that, so if they refuse you will ultimately have to use force.
I completely understand that the use of physical power isn't the first resort and that other persuasive methods are used first. But ultimately if they didn't succeed you would have no option but to resort to measures that in adult relationships would be abusive. Which is why the comparison doesn't work.
In truth I think the misappropriation of terminology such as coercion and control to the parent child dynamic is part of the reason GP slips for some into permissive parenting. In the example of the shoes, I'm sure there are parents who would allow their child to be bare foot or cancel the appointment as the lesser evil than what they would see as being coercive or controlling.
I'm not criticising anyone here BTW. Its more a reflection on why what is actually a very straightforward idea causes such a lack of consensus to its meaning and often presents itself rather differently.

100% this.
This is exactly it:
In the example of the shoes, I'm sure there are parents who would allow their child to be bare foot or cancel the appointment as the lesser evil than what they would see as being coercive or controlling
And the more trite gentle parenting gurus refuse to address these conundrums because they don’t fit into the approach. The implication is that if your child choses the third option (rebellion) it’s because you are not doing gentle parenting right, or your child isn’t as perfect and well behaved as mine. It’s a necessary presumption of the way the approach js applied that children of gentle parents are always so respectful and well behaved and it’s because of their superior parenting approach. Like the pp who says of course she never forces on the shoes, the child always chooses 🙄.
The reality is children aren’t always like this and they don’t always comply and the gentle methods don’t always work as well as they do in practice as they do in theory. That’s when the lazy , permissive parenting comes in, because these middle class parents following the gospel of Sarah orkwell smith have no other ideas and no other tools.

5128gap · 14/08/2023 09:23

Apologies @DinoDough I have rambled and I entirely understand your points.
I was largely rambling off at a tangent about the GP/PP thing, as the tendancy to say PP is just lazy doesn't sit right, given all the effort parents make only to end up being permissive. It led me to wonder if the permissiveness is rooted in trying to avoid negative traits that are inappropriate in adult relationships but are actually unavoidable in parent child relationships, and your example was the mental spring board to that.
Its very loosely related to your points and you have been patient in responding to me.

Skinthin · 14/08/2023 09:22

Confusinglyconfused · 14/08/2023 08:42

Because you're an adult and not being parented

Yes, that was the point if you read the thread.

DinoDough · 14/08/2023 09:16

5128gap · 14/08/2023 08:59

I'm not criticising the parenting approach. My point is simply that comparisons to adult to adult relationships are not helpful.
You didn't say you would forcibly put your child's shoes on, but "either you put them on or I do...."
well the child has a third choice don't they, which is to refuse them being on altogether. You can't have that, so if they refuse you will ultimately have to use force.
I completely understand that the use of physical power isn't the first resort and that other persuasive methods are used first. But ultimately if they didn't succeed you would have no option but to resort to measures that in adult relationships would be abusive. Which is why the comparison doesn't work.
In truth I think the misappropriation of terminology such as coercion and control to the parent child dynamic is part of the reason GP slips for some into permissive parenting. In the example of the shoes, I'm sure there are parents who would allow their child to be bare foot or cancel the appointment as the lesser evil than what they would see as being coercive or controlling.
I'm not criticising anyone here BTW. Its more a reflection on why what is actually a very straightforward idea causes such a lack of consensus to its meaning and often presents itself rather differently.

But again, this wasn’t my point!!! My point was about talking disrespectfully to children and saying things like ‘because I said so’ and ‘because you need a reminder of things in the real world’. And giving an alternative of how you can be respectful in a tricky situation without giving in and with offering choice and some autonomy without offering ‘endless choices’.

My point was that children are not there be be pushed around just because they’re kids. It’s about treating them with the same respect that you afford others. Part of that respect IS giving them boundaries and instructions and sometimes making choices for them. Same as we sometimes do for other adults. We live a life defined by boundaries for our own and others safety, that’s what our society largely dictates. But there are ways of doing this. I stand by my point that I give my DC the same respect that I give other adults.

You’re missing the point of what I’m saying and I’m not going to reiterate it again. Please reread the original opening part of my post with the adult comparison and how I describe it. It’s about how to handle things, how you talk. I’m not saying I’d tell my husband to put his shoes on. Like if you need to turn the television off you don’t just walk up and switch it off. You tell your child and manage their expectations ‘after this episode has finished I am going to turn the tv off’. It’s about how you treat a situation and how you talk to someone, you give them the same respect you’d give another adult, not that you would treat them exactly the same. I’m rambling now.

Wishiwasatailor · 14/08/2023 09:06

Skyblue18 · 14/08/2023 00:02

This

jeez It’s just the name of a parenting style that a psychologist who studied parenting called it.

What do you think childcare professionals/psychologists/teachers study?

parenting styles, all have distinct characteristics that have names otherwise how can anybody actually understand how someone was parented.

Unfortunately for a lot of children they may be patented in an authoritarian or uninvolved style, I would say gentle parents start off wanting to be authoritative (which is different to authoritarian) and slip into passive.

authoritative parenting is what most parents aspire to

LolaSmiles · 14/08/2023 09:03

BertieBotts
I feel the same about BLW.

BLW is a method.

Lots of parents, me included, did a mix of finger food and spoon fed purées, and just got on with it. That's not BLW though and no amount of sitting at playgroup/on Facebook is going to make a mix of finger foods and purees BLW.

But there's always idiots on Facebook claiming that their version of (insert weaning method/parenting method/sleep approach) is (insert name here that it isn't actually).

The lesson is to look at decent resources if interested in parenting approaches/sleep approaches/weaning approaches and getting informed about what they actually are, not saying "Sandra at playgroup let her child smack mine over the head so gentle parenting is rubbish/some random person on Facebook said you can never say no".

5128gap · 14/08/2023 08:59

DinoDough · 14/08/2023 08:26

Where does it say anything about forcibly putting shoes on? I give my youngest the choice between me or him and he chooses. I’ve never forcibly put his shoes on.

And you’ve not understood the point of my post. I said that the dialogue was disrespectful. My point wasn’t about discipline, I said they need guidance and discipline and of course that means us making choices for them at times, it was about saying ‘because I said so’ and giving an alternative to ‘because I said so’ that involved a brief explanation. And showing how you can give a choice without giving ‘endless choices’ and ‘giving in’. And actually, I think my DC have a fair bit of autonomy in their lives, it’s surprising how much you can let them have if you balance things out. Because that’s what parenting is to me, it’s about raising them to find their own way in the world with boundaries.

And you’re using hyperbole by saying ‘plonked in to illustrate how awful non GP is’.

I'm not criticising the parenting approach. My point is simply that comparisons to adult to adult relationships are not helpful.
You didn't say you would forcibly put your child's shoes on, but "either you put them on or I do...."
well the child has a third choice don't they, which is to refuse them being on altogether. You can't have that, so if they refuse you will ultimately have to use force.
I completely understand that the use of physical power isn't the first resort and that other persuasive methods are used first. But ultimately if they didn't succeed you would have no option but to resort to measures that in adult relationships would be abusive. Which is why the comparison doesn't work.
In truth I think the misappropriation of terminology such as coercion and control to the parent child dynamic is part of the reason GP slips for some into permissive parenting. In the example of the shoes, I'm sure there are parents who would allow their child to be bare foot or cancel the appointment as the lesser evil than what they would see as being coercive or controlling.
I'm not criticising anyone here BTW. Its more a reflection on why what is actually a very straightforward idea causes such a lack of consensus to its meaning and often presents itself rather differently.

arbitraryarsehole · 14/08/2023 08:56

The OP didn't return? So they don't actually give a 💩...

arbitraryarsehole · 14/08/2023 08:52

The indomitable black man explains gentle parenting well - for anyone who doesn't understand what it is.

BertieBotts · 14/08/2023 08:52

There was a brilliant post on reddit the other day actually by a user called LittleBananaSquirrel. She said this:

I had my first baby over a decade ago. Back then everyone was talking about how gentle parenting, anti sleep training, baby led weaning, extended rear facing, cloth diapering ETC were these against the grain, revolutionary things that new parents of that era were pioneering and going to change society with. I had another child soon after and then was out of the baby verse for like 8 years. I get pregnant with my 3rd baby and of course my socials all start targeting me with the new generation of parenting experts and influencers, many of whom are first time parents to babies or young toddlers and lo and behold we have a whole new generation of Moms who think they are revolutionizing gentle parenting, carseat safety, anti sleep training, cloth diapering ETC like nobody has before, they are breaking new ground and scandalising older parents who obviously did everything completely the opposite to them. I'm just here like... Why is everyone pretending this is anything new at all? Just because you weren't a parent until recently and therefore probably didn't think much about any of these topics at all doesn't mean they weren't very much alive and well before you came along. My sister's eldest is 20 and besides the extended rear facing, it was all the exact same stuff back then too, nobody is revolutionizing anything 🤣

The only thing that has actually changed between my 1st and 3rd are some cool new gadgets, like a shnuggle pod bath I would have LOVED with my older kids or my newborn sized ergo instead of having to use the annoying inserts with my ergo original.

Having had babies in 2008, 2018, 2021, I absolutely concur!! I think there is a huge aspect of this in gentle parenting. And I know I was guilty of it too. It was actually one of these MN threads where someone said "So you treat children with respect, have reasons behind rules, don't hit/try not to shout, talk to them, see their point of view....... that's just parenting then?"

And I said YES, YES, now you finally get it!! (my point at that time being that GP was not some magical special unattainable thing, it was just normal) And then I realised that I was the one who had something to realise Grin

I think there are lots of parents who read and use "gentle parenting" advice and think it is useful and quietly get on with it without making much of it at all - they are probably the ones who gentle parenting works well for (and maybe they get a bit fed up/confused on threads like this but they aren't the loudest voices) and if it didn't work then they just try something else since they haven't hung their entire identity on an internet buzzword.

It might be less the gentle parenting mindset in general (which, as said, not one specific mindset, much too broad) and more the tendency for people to jump onto a bandwagon and think that they have discovered something new and revolutionary, and become an evangelist about it.

I do disagree slightly with the reddit poster on one point. I think the parenting internet of 2023 is a much more divided, polarised, tribal-thinking place compared with the parenting internet of 2008/09 (maybe up to about 2013). Or maybe I was just lucky in that I had mumsnet, where we used to have bunfights but everyone shared the same space and could have a discussion and there was some balance, even if you thought others were totally wrong. Now there is a FB group for everything and the FB groups are a totally unregulated space which seem to spawn their own kind of special weirdness where people pick a stance and then get competitive about how stancey they are. So you get people proclaiming all kinds of made up rubbish in experty tones, even though they are just parents, and people somehow go along with this even when the original info gets distorted beyond any reasonable sense. Old hats on MN might remember the Baby Led Weaning forum that Aitch set up, and the "vicious debates" about whether it counted as BLW if you sometimes used spoons. There was occasionally someone pointing out that really, purees teach them to swallow first and chew later, whereas BLW teaches them to chew first and swallow later. Neither of these things are absolutely true, but it was quite an interesting thought/useful way of looking at it. But if you go onto the BLW facebook groups today, there is a whole list of rules and a load of lore about this idea, to the point that if you have a baby that you have ever given spoon feeds to you are supposed to totally stop weaning them for 2 months in order for their palate instincts to reset in case the combination of self-feeding and spoons causes them to choke because they got confused about which order to do it in. This is BONKERS and has no basis in reality. It's not in the original BLW book (of which at least there is one). I'm not aware that babies' palates will reset. I don't think it's even a good idea to stop weaning for months at a time, unless you've started much too early.

I think probably the parenting internet of the 00s did start this with all the terms (BLW, EBF, ERF, NCSS, etc etc) and the camps but it seems to have reached a whole new level of unhealthy/ridiculous today.

Confusinglyconfused · 14/08/2023 08:42

Skinthin · 14/08/2023 08:30

But the”choice” you are giving him is who puts on his shoes isn’t it? I’d certainly find it abusive if my partner said either me or him was to put on my shoes but my shoes were going on! 😂

Because you're an adult and not being parented

DinoDough · 14/08/2023 08:41

Skinthin · 14/08/2023 08:30

But the”choice” you are giving him is who puts on his shoes isn’t it? I’d certainly find it abusive if my partner said either me or him was to put on my shoes but my shoes were going on! 😂

Again, you’re missing the point of my post. It’s not about letting them do what they want, it’s about the approach and the level of respect. The shoes have to go on for their own safety, but you don’t have to hold them down and say ‘because I said so’ and you can give them some autonomy in the process.

Skinthin · 14/08/2023 08:33

PlanetJanette · 14/08/2023 08:29

Maybe you just know some particularly shit parents?

Either way, crap parenting by your social circle isn’t the fault of people who actually practice gentle parenting.

Maybe, my experience is unusual but I don’t think so.
And I do think the gentle parenting movement is somewhat to blame. There are some wonderful resources out there of gentle parenting (eg I follow LRKnost) but there’s also a lot of sanctimonious trite (Sarah ork smith) that is understandably interpreted in the way I see it being applied by middle class parents everywhere.

Skinthin · 14/08/2023 08:30

DinoDough · 14/08/2023 08:26

Where does it say anything about forcibly putting shoes on? I give my youngest the choice between me or him and he chooses. I’ve never forcibly put his shoes on.

And you’ve not understood the point of my post. I said that the dialogue was disrespectful. My point wasn’t about discipline, I said they need guidance and discipline and of course that means us making choices for them at times, it was about saying ‘because I said so’ and giving an alternative to ‘because I said so’ that involved a brief explanation. And showing how you can give a choice without giving ‘endless choices’ and ‘giving in’. And actually, I think my DC have a fair bit of autonomy in their lives, it’s surprising how much you can let them have if you balance things out. Because that’s what parenting is to me, it’s about raising them to find their own way in the world with boundaries.

And you’re using hyperbole by saying ‘plonked in to illustrate how awful non GP is’.

But the”choice” you are giving him is who puts on his shoes isn’t it? I’d certainly find it abusive if my partner said either me or him was to put on my shoes but my shoes were going on! 😂

PlanetJanette · 14/08/2023 08:29

Skinthin · 14/08/2023 08:20

Often it is these three things in practice though:

-no boundaries;
-no consequences;
-allowing your child to behave however they please.

I know that’s not the theory, but it’s the type of approach adopted by most middle class parents I know these days, in the name of “gentle parenting”.

Maybe you just know some particularly shit parents?

Either way, crap parenting by your social circle isn’t the fault of people who actually practice gentle parenting.

DinoDough · 14/08/2023 08:26

5128gap · 14/08/2023 08:03

That example doesn't work @DinoDough because it would also be abusive if your partner forcibly put your shoes on for you because they didn't want to be late for something you had no interest in.
This false equivalence with adult relationships is inappropriate and makes the concept even more blurry. In adult relationships wielding power through physical strength and control of resources never has a place, whereas in your relationship with your child its unavoidable.
In reality your child has almost no autonomy in many areas of their lives and the parent will be continually excercising control or coercion. Examples can't simply be lifted from adult to adult interactions and plonked into the parent/child ones to illistrate how awful non GP is.

Where does it say anything about forcibly putting shoes on? I give my youngest the choice between me or him and he chooses. I’ve never forcibly put his shoes on.

And you’ve not understood the point of my post. I said that the dialogue was disrespectful. My point wasn’t about discipline, I said they need guidance and discipline and of course that means us making choices for them at times, it was about saying ‘because I said so’ and giving an alternative to ‘because I said so’ that involved a brief explanation. And showing how you can give a choice without giving ‘endless choices’ and ‘giving in’. And actually, I think my DC have a fair bit of autonomy in their lives, it’s surprising how much you can let them have if you balance things out. Because that’s what parenting is to me, it’s about raising them to find their own way in the world with boundaries.

And you’re using hyperbole by saying ‘plonked in to illustrate how awful non GP is’.

Cabotchat · 14/08/2023 08:24

*intriguing even. Gah.

Cabotchat · 14/08/2023 08:22

It's hardly a 'live and let live' or 'each to their own' mindset, is it?

Plenty of us have considered positions on parenting style, but would not think to start threads about parents who make different choices. There is something intruiging about the mentality of people who do want to criticize other parent's choices.

Skinthin · 14/08/2023 08:20

PlanetJanette · 13/08/2023 19:19

I swear the regular ‘let me demonstrate that I don’t understand gentle parenting’ threads come around earlier each year.

Things gentle parenting is not:
-giving your child everything they ask for;
-no boundaries;
-no consequences;
-never expressing anger or frustration;
-allowing your child to behave however they please.

Things gentle parenting is:
-relying on actual reasons and logic for boundaries rather than just making it up as you go along;
-explaining what the boundaries are and why they exist;
-applying natural and logical consequences when boundaries are broken;
-recognising that a child - and a parent - has emotions, helping them to recognise them, and talking through acceptable and unacceptable ways of showing those emotions;
-recognising that your child can see when you get things wrong, and are as entitled to an apology as any adult would be if you mess up.

Often it is these three things in practice though:

-no boundaries;
-no consequences;
-allowing your child to behave however they please.

I know that’s not the theory, but it’s the type of approach adopted by most middle class parents I know these days, in the name of “gentle parenting”.

Cabotchat · 14/08/2023 08:14

GavinsFace · 14/08/2023 05:45

I agree. The arguments are very binary here. People seem to think only extremes exist. It’s odd.

I don't think this is about the general spread of opinion.

I think this is about the profile of people who start threads to complain about gentle parenting in hostile and perjorative terms. A type?