Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think "gentle parents" are setting their kids up for a lifetime of friendlessness and struggling to hold down a job?

455 replies

ForestGoblin · 13/08/2023 14:47

You get one chance to build the neural pathways that guide you for the rest of your life and if you don't learn that you're not the centre of anyone else's universe as a young kid you never will.

OP posts:
Pollyputhekettleon · 15/08/2023 09:16

As you're being polite now, I'll discuss. Psychology as a discipline (and I include educational psychology here) is one of the most left-leaning of all and has been since at least the 1960's. Any survey of the political views of academics in the social sciences broadly will demonstrate that their self-described politics are very far to the left of the rest of the society. One of the consequences of that is extreme bias in the 'science' they produce. Many of them are even quite open about this, because of course they consider their views to simply be the truth, which is terribly convenient. Others simply don't notice the influence of their personal beliefs on their work. This would be treated as a self-evident problem if the political compass of such an influential institution as academia instead skewed to the far right.

It's not an accident that another poster identified your list as intended to be a description of right wing authoritarianism, and that you don't recognize it as such. What you described is absolutely not an objective description of 'different attitudes to hierarchical obedience'. It's a list produced by leftists attempting to analyze their enemies, leftists who have a blind spot about left wing authoritarianism. The social sciences spent most of the 20th century acting as useful idiots for the Soviets and their offspring and have never taken any responsibility for that behaviour, John Dewey being just the most prominent in education.

Way beyond the politically-motivated bias, psychology as a field should have had its reputation largely destroyed by the replication crisis (with some honourable exemptions certainly). It should, if it were an honest discipline, have responded to that by spending a good, long time reflecting on itself, addressing the problems, and taking responsibility for the damage that its shoddy work has caused. The fact that its output is still treated as an authority by the general public, and above all by the education profession, is testament to the irrational faith in scientism of 'educated' 21st century westerners.

Cabotchat · 15/08/2023 09:00

Ridemeginger · 15/08/2023 08:14

I know you think you are describing right wing thinking here, but this describes left wing authoritarianism equally (of which we have numerous current examples). Gentle parenting is not likely to bring about some sort of socialist utopia, you know, if that’s part of the theory behind it.

I'm not sure how you think you know this, but you are projecting. (Wildly).

I was discussing psychological ideas about different attitudes to hierarchical obediance.

Cabotchat · 15/08/2023 08:55

Pollyputhekettleon · 14/08/2023 22:58

Oh it's 'the evidence base' is it? Oh well I couldn't possibly argue with such ever so sciencey science. You know, when I said that gentle parenting is disproportionately attractive to people who avoid conflict, this is the kind of behaviour I mean. This kind of passive aggressive 'ring any bells for anyone?' stuff. Grow a spine and say what you want to say directly.

Ironically, you accidentally have a point. Many people on this thread have said they find gentle parenting attractive because they're dealing with the consequences of being raised by authoritarian or even abusive parents. Others had parents who raised them using gentle parenting as a response to their abusive childhoods. The results seem to be somewhat mixed, but almost all were agreed it's a huge improvement on the alternative. Consciously going to the other extreme is probably a very useful response when you own role models were that bad.

Now, sorry, I think you were trying to passive aggressively call me a fascist while maintaining deniability when challenged. Do carry on, it's entertaining.

Yes, there is obviously a significant evidence base on authoritarianism and parenting,

No, I was thinking about several posts. I was making a general point about authoritarian Vs liberal personal types as for my money one of the most interesting thing about this thread has been the attitudes towards society that people are peparing children for.

I have asked MN to remove my post as it was not my intention to call you a fascist.

Ridemeginger · 15/08/2023 08:14

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

I know you think you are describing right wing thinking here, but this describes left wing authoritarianism equally (of which we have numerous current examples). Gentle parenting is not likely to bring about some sort of socialist utopia, you know, if that’s part of the theory behind it.

Pollyputhekettleon · 14/08/2023 22:58

Oh it's 'the evidence base' is it? Oh well I couldn't possibly argue with such ever so sciencey science. You know, when I said that gentle parenting is disproportionately attractive to people who avoid conflict, this is the kind of behaviour I mean. This kind of passive aggressive 'ring any bells for anyone?' stuff. Grow a spine and say what you want to say directly.

Ironically, you accidentally have a point. Many people on this thread have said they find gentle parenting attractive because they're dealing with the consequences of being raised by authoritarian or even abusive parents. Others had parents who raised them using gentle parenting as a response to their abusive childhoods. The results seem to be somewhat mixed, but almost all were agreed it's a huge improvement on the alternative. Consciously going to the other extreme is probably a very useful response when you own role models were that bad.

Now, sorry, I think you were trying to passive aggressively call me a fascist while maintaining deniability when challenged. Do carry on, it's entertaining.

Cabotchat · 14/08/2023 22:24

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

JJ230 · 14/08/2023 20:59

@Carpediemmakeitcount don't think it has anything to do with so-called yummy mummies, what a bizarre thing to say. I've never watched Jo Frost either. Anyway, sounds like you agree with the gentle parenting principles, even if you're calling it by something else, so don't really know why you're replying at me when we're on the same page about it :)

Carpediemmakeitcount · 14/08/2023 20:05

JJ230 · 14/08/2023 17:48

@Carpediemmakeitcount but whilst treating them with respect, you do put them in their place through establishing boundaries, and steer them in the right direction by helping them understand why certain choices are the right ones. This will serve to help them as a teenager when they're dealing with lots of new and different scenarios, independent of their parents. I really think you've got a misguided view about what gentle parenting actually is.

It's a fancy term for parenting that's it. A new fancy name to make yummy mummies seem more interesting. I have had to listen to all sorts of parenting drivel over the years and you know what I learned to carry on and do what suits us as a family. My children are happy and safe and that's all that matters. Most parents on here do it anyway out of instinct that's why people are confused about the fancy term that is given to normal parenting. Let's call it a new name after Jo Frost Super mummy who will come and save the day.

showntell · 14/08/2023 18:13

There are many things in modern society that make me worry we are "setting kids up for a lifetime of friendlessness and struggling to hold down a job".

Gentle parenting (done properly) isn't one of them, though!

Normalnormal · 14/08/2023 18:12

GenieGenealogy · 13/08/2023 15:03

Sitting (or trying to sit) a tantrumming toddler down and asking them to think about choices. Or when little 2 year old Araminta clobbers Persephone with a toy truck, having a long chat about actions and consequences and how Persephone might feel.

Nope. Gentle parenting would be removing Armainta from play group because she isn’t being kind.

FiveOClockWorld · 14/08/2023 18:09

Wishiwasatailor · 14/08/2023 18:05

That is pretty much the definition of the authoritative parenting style!!

It seems to work anyway. From what I've seen.

Wishiwasatailor · 14/08/2023 18:05

FiveOClockWorld · 14/08/2023 17:51

I think if you give a child boundaries, love and safety they will likely turn out well regardless of parenting style and I guess there's a room for variety in them.

That is pretty much the definition of the authoritative parenting style!!

LolaSmiles · 14/08/2023 17:52

To be fair I should read about GP. I just did what came naturally. When I have time I will do this and for what it's worth get back with my thoughts. fascinating
I think GP is more likely to come naturally for people who were also brought up with respectful relationships between parent and child.
For people raised with authoritarian parents, of different degrees, where the power dynamic was strong, and shame/humiliation/isolation/fear were the driving emotions then it's likely they'll either decide they want to do things differently and break the cycle, or they end up being adults who claim "it never did me any harm" (as they continue to humiliate and shame and bully children into submission).

GP, like many authoritative perspectives, requires the adults to reflect on themselves and their behaviour. That's what I found interesting and liberating. The realisation that many adults, me included at times because we've all been there, pick battles with children based on fear and a need to feel in control was quite eye opening. Then I started to see those kind of views everywhere (eg people dismissing parents who let their children have choices, parents being mocked for choosing to remove their child from a situation to calm down rather than go in all guns blazing, people laughing that if you listen to children's feelings and aim to meet their needs then they're going to grow up thinking the world revolves around them, that you need to do random punishments not because they're logical but because "that'll show them who's boss", lots of manipulation within parent-child relationships e.g. "don't do... That makes mummy/daddy sad ")

FiveOClockWorld · 14/08/2023 17:51

I think if you give a child boundaries, love and safety they will likely turn out well regardless of parenting style and I guess there's a room for variety in them.

JJ230 · 14/08/2023 17:48

@Carpediemmakeitcount but whilst treating them with respect, you do put them in their place through establishing boundaries, and steer them in the right direction by helping them understand why certain choices are the right ones. This will serve to help them as a teenager when they're dealing with lots of new and different scenarios, independent of their parents. I really think you've got a misguided view about what gentle parenting actually is.

Skyblue18 · 14/08/2023 17:44

Wishiwasatailor · 14/08/2023 17:25

So you were an authoritative parent…. which has recently been rebranded as gentle parenting….shock

To be fair I should read about GP. I just did what came naturally. When I have time I will do this and for what it's worth get back with my thoughts. fascinating 😁

Pollyputhekettleon · 14/08/2023 17:36

Wishiwasatailor · 14/08/2023 17:28

The people that say they’re doing gentle, parenting are usually not doing it very well and use it as an excuse for their poor parenting and badly behaved children Because they have actually veered into passive parenting

This reminds me very much of 21st century socialists who respond to anyone pointing to the pretty horrific real world records of socialist regimes of the 20th century with 'but that wasn't real socialism!'.

Wishiwasatailor · 14/08/2023 17:28

The people that say they’re doing gentle, parenting are usually not doing it very well and use it as an excuse for their poor parenting and badly behaved children Because they have actually veered into passive parenting

Wishiwasatailor · 14/08/2023 17:25

Skyblue18 · 14/08/2023 16:45

Typo. Communication

So you were an authoritative parent…. which has recently been rebranded as gentle parenting….shock

Skyblue18 · 14/08/2023 16:45

Skyblue18 · 14/08/2023 16:43

Totally agree with this. My children are adults now. I'd say I leaned towards head mistress style parenting 😂 although I didn't put a label on it. As the 'parent' there to teach, advise, care for and love beyond measure I think I did a pretty good job. Communucstion was extremely important & DH and I encouraged them to speak and articulate their feelings from a very young age. We still made them aware we were in charge and they have said this made them feel more secure and safe. They are well balanced adults in highly respected careers and they make wonderful partners. Oh & if they refused to put their shoes on (as in a previous post) they were promptly ushered to a seat, told why they needed shoes then they were put on their feet there and then, no ifs or buts about it 😁

Typo. Communication

Skyblue18 · 14/08/2023 16:43

Totally agree with this. My children are adults now. I'd say I leaned towards head mistress style parenting 😂 although I didn't put a label on it. As the 'parent' there to teach, advise, care for and love beyond measure I think I did a pretty good job. Communucstion was extremely important & DH and I encouraged them to speak and articulate their feelings from a very young age. We still made them aware we were in charge and they have said this made them feel more secure and safe. They are well balanced adults in highly respected careers and they make wonderful partners. Oh & if they refused to put their shoes on (as in a previous post) they were promptly ushered to a seat, told why they needed shoes then they were put on their feet there and then, no ifs or buts about it 😁

Pollyputhekettleon · 14/08/2023 16:24

BrindleAbyssinianGuinea2 · 14/08/2023 00:22

True there must be a middle ground. I don't think it's right that children should never hear the word no. However I would support the validation of feelings and not yelling, speaking kindly and gently . In my experience children who are screamed at or spoken to harshly often become bullies.

One of the reasons why children who are screamed at or spoken to harshly become bullies is that their parents are bullies. All personality traits and behaviours are partly genetic, including bullying. So children of nasty, bullying, aggressive, disagreeable, manipulative parents are unfortunately more likely than others to grow up to express the same behaviours themselves. And that would be the case even if they had been adopted at birth into a family practising something like gentle parenting. So yes, the environment of being shouted at contributes, but so does biology.

I'd say there are times when speaking gently and kindly is appropriate and times when speaking loudly, firmly and even angrily are appropriate.

Pollyputhekettleon · 14/08/2023 16:10

A wise parenting philosophy would be built around a realistic grasp of what adults are actually like as well as what children need. Gentle parenting in the real world is disproportionately attractive to parents who are conflict avoidant, lazy, have weak boundaries, psychological problems with limits, and are actually unempathetic. By the latter I mean the ones who use long sentences and big words to provide explanations to tantrumming 3 year olds, who give them clearly false psychological explanations for their behaviour and so on. It's also attractive to people who follow whatever the current social trend is because they crave other people's approval and social status among their peer groups and all of that is actually more important to them than what their children really need. They need to be seen as a good person because western culture happens to currently define the good as essentially compassion.

It provides a perfect ideological and philosophical framework for people who can't or won't handle conflict with their children and try to wish it away, so they leave them up until 2am playing on their ipod, let them behave badly in public etc. I know several parents like this. It even has the appeal to authority of 'science' because this is the ideological bent of academia for 60 years now. I think that's what accounts for the gap between much of the theory of gentle parenting and the outcomes, and the fact that there's no doubt some/many kids whose parents say they did gentle parenting do turn out perfectly well.

Jamtartforme · 14/08/2023 15:49

Pollyputhekettleon · 14/08/2023 15:46

The problem is that the rest of us and our children have to live with the consequences of other people's parenting. So yes, we, society, get to criticize those we think are screwing up. If you never feel critical of anyone else's parenting, good for you. You're free to go live your life somewhere other than this thread.

Yes!! It’s society who have to live with the ‘finished product’ that the parents release into the wild at 18. If they’ve done a shitty job and raised a lazy entitled dosser then why should we pick up after them?

Pollyputhekettleon · 14/08/2023 15:46

Cabotchat · 14/08/2023 08:22

It's hardly a 'live and let live' or 'each to their own' mindset, is it?

Plenty of us have considered positions on parenting style, but would not think to start threads about parents who make different choices. There is something intruiging about the mentality of people who do want to criticize other parent's choices.

The problem is that the rest of us and our children have to live with the consequences of other people's parenting. So yes, we, society, get to criticize those we think are screwing up. If you never feel critical of anyone else's parenting, good for you. You're free to go live your life somewhere other than this thread.