Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think "gentle parents" are setting their kids up for a lifetime of friendlessness and struggling to hold down a job?

455 replies

ForestGoblin · 13/08/2023 14:47

You get one chance to build the neural pathways that guide you for the rest of your life and if you don't learn that you're not the centre of anyone else's universe as a young kid you never will.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BertieBotts · 17/08/2023 23:03

"Mainstream" parenting, including advice given on courses run by Sure Start centres and early intervention workers, such as Triple P and 1, 2, 3 Magic, uses things like reward charts and naughty steps and grow clocks and sleep training to disciple/control/guide young kids. I choose not to, and the term most closely matching how I choose to parent is Gentle Parenting.

The thing is though, that there is a lot more overlap with those programs and your definition of gentle parenting than you would expect if you go by purely GP resources (which tend to be quite anti "anything mainstream", which is a weird distinction).

I used to think this too, but then I actually learned a bit about modern behaviourism. I thought that behaviourism = associate unwanted behaviour with something unpleasant (punishment, disapproval, shame) so that the child/person/animal/etc doesn't want to do it, and associate wanted behaviour with something desirable (approval, praise, reward) so that they do have reason to want to do it, but it turns out that is just outdated. Like really outdated, as in, nobody should have been teaching that for at least the last 30 years, and anyone who has been is just wrong/out of date.

Modern behaviourism says that for every unwanted behaviour, it is possible to identify what they call a "positive opposite" behaviour, which is defined as something that replaces or is incompatible with the behaviour that you do not like. The focus is then on coaxing that behaviour, through a combination of using the right wording, playful invitations, descriptive praise, recognising small improvements/steps towards the wanted behaviour, helping the child build skills and practice related skills to that behaviour, making sure that YOU as the adult role model, are modelling that behaviour (and especially not the behaviour you don't want). And yes, rewards. Sometimes, for a limited time for specific goals towards a wanted behaviour. And with all this, in theory you never need to even do anything towards the unwanted behaviour, because it will disappear all on its own through you doing this.

This is also a really huge concept in gentle parenting. As in, one of the main concepts. So I think some people claiming gentle parenting is so different to "these mainstream programmes" would be really surprised to note that there is such an overlap here.

Secondly, most of these positive programs have a huge emphasis on relationship and connection with the child, which again is a large part of gentle parenting, along with predictable routines/rhythms and stability. The parent being a calm influence rather than chaotic.

In fact, the only real difference that I can see between positive parenting/modern behaviourism and gentle parenting is that gentle parenting explicitly puts emphasis on the role of emotion in children's behaviour and encourages the validation of emotions and practices of co-regulation, and explicitly says do not worry that comforting your child is going to reward their unwanted behaviour, particularly if that behaviour is actually a physical manifestation of an overwhelming emotion. I can't find this in any of the positive parenting/behaviourist/evidence based programs, and I don't know whether that is because it has been studied and found to be ineffective, or whether it is that there is no evidence supporting it, or whether it is simply considered to be irrelevant because behaviourism is concerned only with behaviours, so feelings do not matter. (The behaviour might be crying, or jumping up and down, or talking at a fast pace). And actually, behaviourism (even modern) DOES actually say that giving a hug/attention/trying to talk to a child while they are engaging in the behaviour that you do not want is incorrect, positive reinforcement and will unwittingly reinforce the behaviour that you do not want.

I do think this is a weakness of behaviourism. I find it a bit cold. I think that it is often worth looking to the root of behaviours instead of simply responding to what is happening on the surface - this is also really key in attachment research - children must have attachment figure(s) who listen to them and see them as an individual rather than a collection of behaviours. I think (especially young) children CAN be overwhelmed by their emotions and they are not necessarily engaging in consciously manipulative behaviour in those moments, so I do not think that sympathy, trying to talk to them etc is reinforcing the behaviour in the way that behaviourism as a theory suggests that it is, and I actually think that denying them comfort or support with their feelings, because they expressed those feelings in a way that you did not like, because they are little, is cruel. (But I'm not a behaviourist; maybe I have misunderstood this).

To the question of punishment this is interesting, modern behaviourism/positive parenting does not actually need it, in theory, and emphasises that it should be minimised and only used "when absolutely necessary". But the problem that a lot of parenting programs face is that they are written for parents who are starting from a point of being much too punitive, possibly even abusive - this is especially true for the ones run/funded by government organisations, they are one aspect of social care and trying to improve circumstances for children in homes where it's not quite bad enough to remove them, or as a last ditch attempt before children are removed since it is better if children can stay with their parents if it is safe to do so. So if parents are ALREADY relying a lot on punishment, or threats, or violence even, it's ineffective to just say well don't do that then. Like when you're dealing with child behaviour, you need a positive opposite to encourage in the parents. Otherwise, they tend to fall back on hitting, screaming, threatening etc. And that is where generally these programs use time out, because it's extremely minor - no child is traumatised by being told calmly to sit on a chair or a spot or a step. It is also simple and can be implemented anywhere so a parent is not stuck without access to their coping mechanism. It's non violent and it is formulaic. The other options offered (given generally as a fallback if time out is proving conflict-inducing) are again mild and do not require cooperation from the child so they remove conflict from the moment - removal of privileges, or removal of points from a points/token system (which is otherwise used as a purely positive motivational tool). But the point is very much not to use these as a primary method, because the primary method of behaviour change is positive reinforcement, and building of relationship, and predictable routines, and the way that you ask for behaviour, and having reasonable expectations (with the steps from the unwanted to wanted behaviour) and so on.

Being formulaic is something that gentle parents do not like very much. So you get a weird dance in a lot of gentle parenting spaces where "natural, or logical consequences" are okay, but "generic punishments" are totally out and I used to think that this made sense, but I now think this is a total fallacy and a guilt assauger. Because what you actually see is parents twisting absolutely anything in a knot to convince themselves that it is a "natural consequence" when really they want to associate an unwanted behaviour with an unpleasant outcome for the child, ie, they want to punish.

That is natural because it seems logical. But it is not evidence based and it is not an effective way to change behaviour. And if you really want to be nitpicky, it's not in any way gentle! What would be more gentle is recognising that as parents, sometimes it's really hard not to react to something punitively, therefore I should have something token and harmless and basically neutral in my pocket to pull out at times when I want to punish but I know that I should not. Know that that does not actually change the behaviour, but it stops me from doing something worse in the moment.

Southlondoner88 · 16/08/2023 10:33

Gentle parenting is not a name widely recognised in development research @NorfolkSunset

NorfolkSunset · 16/08/2023 10:10

Southlondoner88 · 16/08/2023 09:12

https://www.developmentalscience.com/blog/2015/6/28/the-only-parenting-model-you-need

OP you might find this interesting. There’s three main parenting styles which have been developed over decades of research, this one (authoritative parenting) is the one that predicts positive child outcomes. Permissive and authoritarian parenting have negative child outcomes.

Gentle parenting is a fad I’m afraid.

@Southlondoner88 you don't seem to have read your article though. It describes gentle parenting to a tee!

NorfolkSunset · 16/08/2023 09:51

HappyAsASandboy · 13/08/2023 14:55

I think you are confusing gentle parenting with indulging your children.

Gentle parenting is about treating your children as actual real people, who deserve respect and autonomy over the things they are ready to handle. It is explaining the reasons for decisions. It is remembering that you shouldn't talk down to them just because they're smaller than you. It is being aware of their skills and limitations and never shaming them. It is many things.

In my experience, giving children respect, independence, autonomy and calm role modelling leads to calm, confident kids who are able to interact with other kids and adults well.

I love this ^^

Southlondoner88 · 16/08/2023 09:12

https://www.developmentalscience.com/blog/2015/6/28/the-only-parenting-model-you-need

OP you might find this interesting. There’s three main parenting styles which have been developed over decades of research, this one (authoritative parenting) is the one that predicts positive child outcomes. Permissive and authoritarian parenting have negative child outcomes.

Gentle parenting is a fad I’m afraid.

The Only Parenting Model You Need — Developmental Science

Do these scenarios sound familiar?  A four-year-old has a meltdown because he refuses to wear his fancy new clothes to his cousin's wedding. Or a middle-schooler quits basketball after an altercation with the coach and announces she want...

https://www.developmentalscience.com/blog/2015/6/28/the-only-parenting-model-you-need

Carpediemmakeitcount · 16/08/2023 00:24

As you're being polite now, I'll discuss. Psychology as a discipline (and I include educational psychology here) is one of the most left-leaning of all and has been since at least the 1960's. Any survey of the political views of academics in the social sciences broadly will demonstrate that their self-described politics are very far to the left of the rest of the society. One of the consequences of that is extreme bias in the 'science' they produce. Many of them are even quite open about this, because of course they consider their views to simply be the truth, which is terribly convenient. Others simply don't notice the influence of their personal beliefs on their work. This would be treated as a self-evident problem if the political compass of such an influential institution as academia instead skewed to the far right.

@Pollyputhekettleon what you posted above does worry me. How they analyse children or people and their word is right rather than just an opinion could that be dangerous and harmful to who they are analysing?

Age and experience helps people to grow and mature.

Pollyputhekettleon · 15/08/2023 21:26

No I don't think the Soviet Union was particularly sympathetic to psychology. I'm pretty sure I didn't say or imply that. Although, it should be said that Stalin is not the Soviet Union, and I also referred not just to the Soviet Union but also to its many copycats and satellite states. I was talking about the wilful ignorance, apologism and complicity of western academics, particularly those in the social sciences, not how academics inside the Soviet Union lived.

ToWhitToWhoo · 15/08/2023 19:37

Pollyputhekettleon · 15/08/2023 09:16

As you're being polite now, I'll discuss. Psychology as a discipline (and I include educational psychology here) is one of the most left-leaning of all and has been since at least the 1960's. Any survey of the political views of academics in the social sciences broadly will demonstrate that their self-described politics are very far to the left of the rest of the society. One of the consequences of that is extreme bias in the 'science' they produce. Many of them are even quite open about this, because of course they consider their views to simply be the truth, which is terribly convenient. Others simply don't notice the influence of their personal beliefs on their work. This would be treated as a self-evident problem if the political compass of such an influential institution as academia instead skewed to the far right.

It's not an accident that another poster identified your list as intended to be a description of right wing authoritarianism, and that you don't recognize it as such. What you described is absolutely not an objective description of 'different attitudes to hierarchical obedience'. It's a list produced by leftists attempting to analyze their enemies, leftists who have a blind spot about left wing authoritarianism. The social sciences spent most of the 20th century acting as useful idiots for the Soviets and their offspring and have never taken any responsibility for that behaviour, John Dewey being just the most prominent in education.

Way beyond the politically-motivated bias, psychology as a field should have had its reputation largely destroyed by the replication crisis (with some honourable exemptions certainly). It should, if it were an honest discipline, have responded to that by spending a good, long time reflecting on itself, addressing the problems, and taking responsibility for the damage that its shoddy work has caused. The fact that its output is still treated as an authority by the general public, and above all by the education profession, is testament to the irrational faith in scientism of 'educated' 21st century westerners.

You think that the Soviet Union was particularly sympathetic to psychology, including the study of child development? Only for brief periods at most. Stalin had pretty much the same attitude to psychology, or indeed any academic study, that didn't follow his supremacy and caprices, as religious fundamentalists have to 'secular humanism'. Most academic psychologists, even those who started out in his favour, ended up censored at best, purged at worst. The writings of L.S. Vygotsky, probably the most famous Russian developmental psychologist, were suppressed for decades.

Yes, authoritarianism is authoritarianism; and there was nothing gentle about the Soviet leaders, any more than their current successor Putin.

HappyAsASandboy · 15/08/2023 17:58

@charlotte361 I didn't invent any term at all, for anything.

I have read parenting information, advice, books, forums etc, probably much like anyone else, and I like the things that are associated with gentle parenting. In my experience, the things I describe are NOT how "most" people parent; my parents certainly didn't, my DH's parents certainly didn't, and most of my friends seem to use a mixture of authoritative punishments combined with bribery to parent their children.

"Mainstream" parenting, including advice given on courses run by Sure Start centres and early intervention workers, such as Triple P and 1, 2, 3 Magic, uses things like reward charts and naughty steps and grow clocks and sleep training to disciple/control/guide young kids. I choose not to, and the term most closely matching how I choose to parent is Gentle Parenting.

I am just doing what feels right to me, and am happy for others to do the same. I commented because the OP asked for opinions on whether Gentle Parenting was causing struggling entitled kids who are unprepared for the world. I answered because I thought she was describing very permissive parenting rather than gentle parenting, and to disagree that actual gentle parenting was unlikely to lead to the type of kids she described.

pointythings · 15/08/2023 17:54

So by 'gentle parenting', you mean basically you have invented a term for what about 99% of people do out of instinct ,common sense and normal parental love for their children

Pretty much, though I'm not sure it's 99%. That's the problem with this debate. Gentle parenting = practical, common sense parenting with good boundaries.
Other methods are available, but they're a bit shit.

charlotte361 · 15/08/2023 17:46

HappyAsASandboy · 13/08/2023 14:55

I think you are confusing gentle parenting with indulging your children.

Gentle parenting is about treating your children as actual real people, who deserve respect and autonomy over the things they are ready to handle. It is explaining the reasons for decisions. It is remembering that you shouldn't talk down to them just because they're smaller than you. It is being aware of their skills and limitations and never shaming them. It is many things.

In my experience, giving children respect, independence, autonomy and calm role modelling leads to calm, confident kids who are able to interact with other kids and adults well.

So by 'gentle parenting', you mean basically you have invented a term for what about 99% of people do out of instinct ,common sense and normal parental love for their children

Cabotchat · 15/08/2023 17:40

pointythings · 15/08/2023 17:36

In real life you need a balance of doing both in any case - it's about raising individuals who can function in society and also act as strong individuals when it's needed. That's pragmatism, not rocket science, and it isn't political.

(This is me agreeing with you).

Thank you.

pointythings · 15/08/2023 17:36

Cabotchat · 15/08/2023 17:28

You said you know what I think. You demonstrably don't.

I was teasing out differences between socialising to individuate Vs socialising to acheive compliance within social hierarchies.

I haven't said anything whatsoever about mapping this to left or right wing values - that is entirely your projection.

In real life you need a balance of doing both in any case - it's about raising individuals who can function in society and also act as strong individuals when it's needed. That's pragmatism, not rocket science, and it isn't political.

(This is me agreeing with you).

Cabotchat · 15/08/2023 17:28

Ridemeginger · 15/08/2023 09:20

Not sure what you think I am projecting. Do you think I'm right wing with hurt feelings about being called authoritarian? Sorry, you are wrong. Right wing = authoritarian, left wing = love and peace for all men is a common political trope. GP, from how it is described as an ideological way of parenting on this thread, seems to be rooted firmly in a socialist idyll. And just like socialism, it's great on paper, but doesn't necessarily work in practice, because human nature tends to get in the way, and even liberal ideas can be imposed on others in an authoritarian manner, as history has thrown up time and time again.

You said you know what I think. You demonstrably don't.

I was teasing out differences between socialising to individuate Vs socialising to acheive compliance within social hierarchies.

I haven't said anything whatsoever about mapping this to left or right wing values - that is entirely your projection.

pointythings · 15/08/2023 14:18

I'm not a psychologist and haven't said I am. I just asked why the politely worded rant against the entire field of psychology and how that was relevant to this discussion on parenting with all its typical conflation of gentle parenting and permissive parenting.

Jamtartforme · 15/08/2023 13:57

pointythings · 15/08/2023 13:48

I do not understand what you consider dishonest about my question. You seem very angry, so it's probably best not to pursue this discussion.

As a psychologist I would’ve thought you know anger is a totally normal and healthy emotion for women, but no she doesn’t sound angry at all.

pointythings · 15/08/2023 13:48

I do not understand what you consider dishonest about my question. You seem very angry, so it's probably best not to pursue this discussion.

Pollyputhekettleon · 15/08/2023 13:38

Apologize for saying your question was dishonest? Absolutely not. It was. Apparently you're not intending to acknowledge that, yet you expect me to engage in further discussion with you. Intriguing.

pointythings · 15/08/2023 13:22

@Pollyputhekettleon well, that's the longest non answer I've ever had.

Come on, your screed about psychology was full of loathing. I just wonder why. I also wonder what parenting methods you support. I apologise for jumping to conclusions, but my questions stand.

Are you now going to apologise for your personal attack against me?

Pollyputhekettleon · 15/08/2023 12:43

@pointythings As someone who deeply loathes dishonesty I do wonder what the root cause is of your dishonest question: 'Is @Pollyputhekettleon saying that current best practice on parenting must be wrong because psychologists can be left wing and that therefore we should return to harsh methods?'. You've followed it up with a few more disingenuous questions for good measure.

Your attempt to change the subject to psychoanalyzing my motives is really telling here, as is your ascription to me of intense feelings of loathing. Are you suggesting that people who point out your dishonesty must be motivated by some kind of deeply rooted psychological issue? I'd like to say I'm intrigued by that, because I'm a very curious person, but I'm not.

As an aside, there are very few people who are capable of having an objective discussion about their chosen field of work and you're demonstrably not one of them. As the famous saying goes, it's difficult for a man to understand something when his salary depends on his not understanding it.

pointythings · 15/08/2023 11:26

@Pollyputhekettleon as someone who works in mental health (non clinical) I do wonder what the root cause is for your deep loathing of psychology. I don't know any psychologist who claims it's an exact science either.

Your use of the word 'leftists' is really telling here. Are you suggesting that right wing people in research are able to be unbiased, but left wing people are not? Why is left worse than right (extremists of either flavour aside)? What exactly do you see as 'left wing' about the current psychological establishment, and do you think people working in the sciences shouldn't have political leanings at all? I am intrigued at the intensity of your loathing for psychology and where it's coming from.

Pollyputhekettleon · 15/08/2023 10:14

pointythings · 15/08/2023 09:39

I think it's naive to think authoritarianism doesn't exist on both sides of the political spectrum; the horseshoe model applies. What I don't see is the relevance to this discussion. Is @Pollyputhekettleon saying that current best practice on parenting must be wrong because psychologists can be left wing and that therefore we should return to harsh methods? That doesn't stack up. Permissive parenting is bad. Harsh parenting is just as bad. There is plenty of evidence that a happy medium is good. That shouldn't be controversial.

If I had wanted to say that 'current best practice on parenting must be wrong because psychologists can be left wing and that therefore we should return to harsh methods?' don't you think I would have said that? Have you noticed that I tend to say exactly what I think, as clearly as I can? Of course in reality you don't believe for a moment that that's what I was saying. Because I know you can read perfectly well, if you wanted to. I said exactly what I said and nothing else, and that's what I meant. You should try it.

Skyblue18 · 15/08/2023 10:09

SomewhereWithSomeone · 13/08/2023 15:23

Reading through examples of gentle parenting, we probably did lots of it although didn’t realise it had a term. It seems normal to me to listen and respect your children, not shout at them, teach them to think of others, explain reasoning instead of just being the ‘behave this way because I said so’ type.

I think explaining things, listening to them, respecting their opinions, is much more time consuming but really pays off in the teen and adult years. Our kids know we are reasonable, and that they’re important, so they respect us because they like us. My kids are really lovely people who think of others l, the teen years were/are very easy. They have great friends and older ones have worked part time whilst studying from 17.

All my friends have parented similarly and their kids are all doing well in their studies, work and relationships.

Having read more about GP and with now grown up successful well balanced children I now feel I did practice GP naturally. There were differences such as they were in no doubt I was in charge in a Teacher type way. I also had no issue with raising my voice if pushed, always with an explanation as to why. My children were always encouraged to talk from an early age and express themselves. Above all we laughed & had fun.

On a totally different topic, I fear many young children today become 'locked in' with the incessant use of online entertainment to the point of becoming addicted & staring ahead as if hypnotised when the device is removed. I agree there are many advantages, especially as a learning tool although we have yet to see the future consequences.

pointythings · 15/08/2023 09:39

I think it's naive to think authoritarianism doesn't exist on both sides of the political spectrum; the horseshoe model applies. What I don't see is the relevance to this discussion. Is @Pollyputhekettleon saying that current best practice on parenting must be wrong because psychologists can be left wing and that therefore we should return to harsh methods? That doesn't stack up. Permissive parenting is bad. Harsh parenting is just as bad. There is plenty of evidence that a happy medium is good. That shouldn't be controversial.

Ridemeginger · 15/08/2023 09:20

Not sure what you think I am projecting. Do you think I'm right wing with hurt feelings about being called authoritarian? Sorry, you are wrong. Right wing = authoritarian, left wing = love and peace for all men is a common political trope. GP, from how it is described as an ideological way of parenting on this thread, seems to be rooted firmly in a socialist idyll. And just like socialism, it's great on paper, but doesn't necessarily work in practice, because human nature tends to get in the way, and even liberal ideas can be imposed on others in an authoritarian manner, as history has thrown up time and time again.