Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not let daughter meet dad's partner?

60 replies

rach971 · 13/08/2023 11:00

Okay so some background for context...

Daughter is 8. Me and her dad broke up before I found out I was pregnant. We get along okay, never been any major dramas or anything.

I was single up until just under two years ago when I started dating my partner (who I've known 11 years). I introduced my daughter to him around the 5 month mark and we now have a daughter together.

Daughter's dad wasn't happy about me being in a relationship at first (he'd always clung onto hope maybe one day he'd get me back). But I basically gave him some stern words and then he calmed down a bit. He kicked off a bit again when I wanted to introduce daughter and partner but I said it's been 5 months now and I've known him for years... Partner was also looking into moving down here as he lived a couple of hours away so didn't want him to move and not have met my daughter yet.

Now fast forward to yesterday (daughter is at her dad's for a couple of nights) and he messages me saying he's got a new girlfriend, he's told our daughter, and can they both meet.

Bare in mind they've apparently only been in a relationship since June he said, he's only met her 5 times, I don't know her name, age, who she is, what she does, literally nothing. It was only late last night I actually saw a photo of her and even then the phone was in front of her face 🤦‍♀️ This is the man who had an issue when I wanted my daughter to meet my partner 5 months into the relationship, after knowing him 11 years. And daughters dad knew about him and who he was etc.

AIBU to say no to her meeting our daughter at this stage? I did say no and luckily he hasn't kicked off about it or anything but I'm shocked he even asked at this stage! Or how he even thinks that's reasonable.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NewFriendlyLadybird · 10/11/2023 13:34

rach971 · 13/08/2023 11:51

Haha, I just expected mixed opinions to be honest, not quite such an overwhelming 'you are WRONG' 🤣

Given that ex wasn't happy about me introducing my partner at 5 months and kicked off over it, I was surprised he wanted to introduce his girlfriend so soon.

I just don't see why he can kick off with me when I waited what I thought was a reasonable time yet I can't be cautious over my daughter meeting someone he's met 5 times and I know nothing about. I don't want to know her shoe size and height 🤣 Just some basic details would be nice that was all

Suppose he has realised that he was being unreasonable when he kicked off about introducing your partner? It’s worked out OK; maybe that’s made him optimistic? And you didn’t change your behaviour when he questioned it, so why should he?

Beezknees · 13/08/2023 14:49

abigailsnan · 13/08/2023 13:26

My son works 5 permanent night shifts 8am-8pm including week-end nights little one goes to school full time and mum works 16hrs a week she decided Thursday would be the best day for access so she has childcare after school he has offered to have her more days after school but mum has her signed up for after school activities 3 times a week after school she goes to her other nana on the Monday all decided by mum.
My son does not see his girlfriend more than twice a week she also works shifts does that help with the question. ??He would love to see more of my GD and hopefully he can adjust his work schedule or he could go unemployed and not pay the massive amount he pays to the mum and he certainly does not complain about the amount its a given as far as he is concerned

I'm a lone parent working full time and I manage to see my son 7 days a week. Poor excuses from men as usual.

gogomoto · 13/08/2023 13:55

Not your decision. Anyway meeting her doesn't have to mean that it's a particularly long meeting - I actually thing a laid back low key meeting early on is a good idea because if the person you are dating and your child do not get along there's no point that relationship proceeding.

Pinkdelight3 · 13/08/2023 13:46

Well, it's always tricky to generalise, but it's also naive to treat male and female partners the same in these situations as there is a difference with having new male partners moving in with young girls and a reason for more caution about it. Not saying your ex's new girlfriend can't have her drawbacks, but that set-up is generally less risky in people's minds. However it's good that you know your new DP from way back, but at the same time you can't expect him only to go out with people he's only known for a decade and to wait an equivalent time before introducing them. Dad's girlfriend is also less of a big deal than mum's DP who moves a distance to join her then moves in and has a baby with her. So overall I don't see the value in equating your situation with his and it seems like point scoring for no real reason that's good for the DC.

BigPussyEnergy · 13/08/2023 13:30

As much as you might not like the implication, him introducing a new woman into his DD’s life is much less risky than you introducing a man. It just is.

If she’s the sort of woman happy to be introduced to her BF’s child within a few weeks then she’ll hopefully be the type to make an effort and do nice things to build a relationship with her, which can only be a good thing. If it backfires then I’m sure she’ll bail long before your DD gets attached so don’t worry about it.

My DCs met a couple of their dad’s GFs over the years. One was quite serious and they all liked her while she was around but didn’t exactly miss her when she was gone.

My XP was around as a step dad figure for them for nearly 10 years. They loved him and spent lots of time with him, but again, weren’t heart broken when we split up. Kids are resilient, so the emotional impact of a relationship won’t really be an issue. The bigger risk by far is that of an unrelated male living in the home of a young girl, but as you know him well and now have your own DCs with him I’m sure you feel confident that this isn’t an issue.

abigailsnan · 13/08/2023 13:26

AnotherVice · 13/08/2023 11:50

@abigailsnan so your son has 6 child free days a week for his new relationship? Why does he need to introduce Abigail (presumably) so soon?

My son works 5 permanent night shifts 8am-8pm including week-end nights little one goes to school full time and mum works 16hrs a week she decided Thursday would be the best day for access so she has childcare after school he has offered to have her more days after school but mum has her signed up for after school activities 3 times a week after school she goes to her other nana on the Monday all decided by mum.
My son does not see his girlfriend more than twice a week she also works shifts does that help with the question. ??He would love to see more of my GD and hopefully he can adjust his work schedule or he could go unemployed and not pay the massive amount he pays to the mum and he certainly does not complain about the amount its a given as far as he is concerned

Troubledwaters2502 · 13/08/2023 13:19

You may have waited 5 months but then moved him in pretty quickly in my honest opinion that’s worse than her having a brief meet with a girlfriend of 2 months. Let him get on with it

ActDottie · 13/08/2023 13:16

It’s up to him who she meets when she is spending time with him. So yes yabu

Beezknees · 13/08/2023 13:02

Also no matter how much you think you know a person, you really don't. How many women here are blindsided when their partner cheats as they never thought they would be capable of that.

Honestly, I'd trust a female partner around my child more than I'd ever have trusted a male partner. Men are more prone to violence and predatory behaviour.

Amberjane41 · 13/08/2023 13:01

and the fact that he raised concerns and you ignored him and moved your boyfriend in anyway after 5 months, he probably feels that it is absolutely fine then for him to meet a partner after 2 months (she isn't moving in I presume) I'm actually surprised he even asked you in this scenario

Beezknees · 13/08/2023 12:59

You have to trust your ex if you want a decent co parenting relationship. This isn't your call. And it's not his call to decide things for you either.

ManchesterLu · 13/08/2023 12:58

I understand 100% how you're feeling, and it's so difficult to deal with. But as others have said, you can't dictate how he parents his child when she's in his care. However much you might want to protect her.

pinkyredrose · 13/08/2023 12:54

It's not your decision to make.

Amberjane41 · 13/08/2023 12:52

I suppose the fact that he asked you if it was ok kind of justifies why he was annoyed when you introduced your daughter to someone without his approval. He didn't need to ask you. He wanted them to meet and could have just done it anyway but chose to run it by you first. I'm with the majority though, its up to him how he parents when he has her and who he introduces her too.

skinnytobe · 13/08/2023 12:49

As annoying as it is you can't control what he does.

You're daughter is also older now so if a more understanding age :)

I'd have argued with my ex had he tried to dictate who my kids could meet and they accidentally met my then new DP 5 weeks in 😂 my youngest (11 at the time was in his car window having a good old chat whilst he was waiting outside to pick me up for a date.

Ladyj84 · 13/08/2023 12:44

I would say you shouldn't be making the decision and leave it to her dad. It's not like your daughter is tiny either which is also a big difference tbh

GiveOverRover · 13/08/2023 12:43

You're right that it was unreasonable of him to think that when and who you introduce your daughter to is his remit, as long as there are no obvious safeguarding concenrs. You're wrong to try to exert the same level of involvement and control over him in return, seeing a photograph of her face makes no difference.

It's not necessary for him to ask permission, and you don't get to allow it or disallow it.

I personally feel that five dates/five months are both far too short a period after which to introduce children to mum/dad's new girlfriend/boyfriend, but that again is personal choice.

You sound overinvolved in each other's lives and it might be a good point to put in some healthy boundaries, which work both ways.

ntmdino · 13/08/2023 12:40

rach971 · 13/08/2023 11:51

Haha, I just expected mixed opinions to be honest, not quite such an overwhelming 'you are WRONG' 🤣

Given that ex wasn't happy about me introducing my partner at 5 months and kicked off over it, I was surprised he wanted to introduce his girlfriend so soon.

I just don't see why he can kick off with me when I waited what I thought was a reasonable time yet I can't be cautious over my daughter meeting someone he's met 5 times and I know nothing about. I don't want to know her shoe size and height 🤣 Just some basic details would be nice that was all

The thing is, you persuaded him to come round to your way of thinking in the first instance, which is why it's unreasonable - he's just continuing down that path. "I knew my partner longer" is just playing Top Trumps with it, and by that standard he'd have to spend a decade getting to know someone before introducing them.

"But he kicked off when I did it..." - that just makes it sound like you want to get revenge for him objecting, which is probably why you got the stronger replies to begin with ;)

rach971 · 13/08/2023 12:38

Also to clarify just because there's been some mention of it - it was a long distance relationship between me and my partner yes, but he came and stayed down here for one or two nights every week. His job at the time meant he was pretty flexible to be able to do that.

OP posts:
cryboutit · 13/08/2023 12:35

He doesn't need your permission like you didn't need his.

I mean you can say "no" if you like but he wouldn't be unreasonable to ignore you and do it anyway on his time if he wanted to. He's an equal parent, who he introduces his child to on his time really is nothing to do with you providing you don't have any genuine safeguarding concerns about his decision making.

liveforsummer · 13/08/2023 12:33

He's not behaving exactly like me. I'd known my partner 11 years and dated him 5 months. Maybe it's irrelevant to you how long I'd known him but to me, knowing someone for that long gives you a pretty good idea what they're like. Hence me feeling more comfortable introducing them.

Tbf 5 months for a long distance relationship really is no time too. It is irrelevant that you knew them before as you still didn't know them in a relationship or know that it would last long term or work so well once you were closer and seeing each other more often. I don't see what you did as massively better but it was absolutely your prerogative just as this is now his

rwalker · 13/08/2023 12:32

Kids are quite matter of fact it’s dads GF but there new mum

nevynevster · 13/08/2023 12:31

Why don't you simply say, "you were keen that I didn't introduce my DP too early and so we waited 5 months, why don't you do the same?"

CandyflossKaren · 13/08/2023 12:30

The 'knowing him for 11 years' is irrelevant

rach971 · 13/08/2023 12:29

Thanks for the further responses and those being a little gentler in their replies 🤣❤️

Also I appreciate a couple of people's concern for my daughter and the upheaval but she's absolutely fine. We previously lived with my parents and since moving here she's so much calmer and better behaved. Her and my partner get on great and she adores her new baby sister (though she doesn't have much patience for the crying sometimes 🤣)m

OP posts: