Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother making her child's mother tongue a language she herself hardly knows

114 replies

AdoraLovesCake · 13/08/2023 09:34

I have never done an AIBU before.

This morning I went to a cafe in the UK (where I live) with my 5 year old daughter.
A woman in front of me in the long queue turns around and asks my daughter how old she is. DD replies that she is five then goes to look at the cakes.
I then crouch down to the boy holding the woman's hand (he looked age 2 or 3) and I say "Hello little one, how old are you?"
He stares blankly at me and his mother says, "Oh no. He doesn't speak English." And I think "Ok, he doesn't speak at all."
But then his mother says, "He doesn't speak ENGLISH. He speaks Spanish. Even though my partner and I don't speak Spanish very well, and we intend to live in England forever. Our friend said Spanish was easy so we taught our son that. Then when he's older, he can learn English. He'll have a bigger brain by then.
She then was about to order and I saw her type into google translate for her son, "Do you want a cookie?"

Poor boy. Why would you teach your child as their first language a language that you don't know? He's going to turn into a five year old, not understanding anything anyone is saying, having to learn English, a very hard language. Babies will pick up their first language much easier won't they.

YABU: This is normal and a good approach to parenting
YANBU: Agree with OP, this is weird

xxxx Cora

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Poorlilthing · 13/08/2023 16:41

So you think everyone fluent in a language had family speaking it in the home?

I started young (6) and no family
member ever spoke it at home or indeed anywhere

And I am pretty much fluent and have been since university

Poorlilthing · 13/08/2023 16:39

Sugargliderwombat · 13/08/2023 16:05

Did you learn it age 3 and never speak it again beyond 4 ?

how do you know that this mother, who has taken the decision to send her child to a Spanish speaking nursery, won’t continue it? Very bizarre

Caprisunny · 13/08/2023 16:11

Sugargliderwombat · 13/08/2023 16:08

Stalking haha, she is a medium / big influencer...I follow her... have you not used instagram ?

Children who don't keep speaking/ hearing a language once they start school don't retain it. That's why we advise parents who speak other languages to continue to speak this at home. Once they are in a mainstream school they can rapidly lose language. So sending a child to nursery a couple of times a week might seem like a good idea, it's pretty pointless unless you are planning to privately educate them in Spanish beyond age 4.

Except plenty of schools do teach Spanish from starting, so the child will already have a good grasp and continue to learn.

Why would the only other option be to teach it privately?

Sugargliderwombat · 13/08/2023 16:08

Poorlilthing · 13/08/2023 15:56

And @Sugargliderwombat

Short of you stalking this insta mother… how do you know that “no one” in the family speaks Spanish?

Stalking haha, she is a medium / big influencer...I follow her... have you not used instagram ?

Children who don't keep speaking/ hearing a language once they start school don't retain it. That's why we advise parents who speak other languages to continue to speak this at home. Once they are in a mainstream school they can rapidly lose language. So sending a child to nursery a couple of times a week might seem like a good idea, it's pretty pointless unless you are planning to privately educate them in Spanish beyond age 4.

Sugargliderwombat · 13/08/2023 16:05

Poorlilthing · 13/08/2023 15:55

@Sugargliderwombat

i am very very competent in French

no one in my family knows a word of it

Did you learn it age 3 and never speak it again beyond 4 ?

Poorlilthing · 13/08/2023 15:56

And @Sugargliderwombat

Short of you stalking this insta mother… how do you know that “no one” in the family speaks Spanish?

Poorlilthing · 13/08/2023 15:55

@Sugargliderwombat

i am very very competent in French

no one in my family knows a word of it

Poorlilthing · 13/08/2023 15:53

Sugargliderwombat · 13/08/2023 15:47

But she won't retain that language at school as noone else in the family speaks it?

It doesn’t work like that with language

Young children are sponges, so if she attends a Spanish speaking nursery from a toddler until school… she will absorb a great deal depending on how often at the nursery

and if she goes to prep school - Spanish may be one of the options. If it’s not, no doubt the parents will pay for a tutor.

and then almost certainly will be available at secondary

Caprisunny · 13/08/2023 15:52

Sugargliderwombat · 13/08/2023 15:47

But she won't retain that language at school as noone else in the family speaks it?

Depends. My kids just spent to a normal primary and learned Spanish from reception. Ds (13)is pretty fluent in it. Dd (19) not so much but she can speak Korean. I can’t speak either Spanish or Korean. I speak English, French and am learning Greek.

If this child goes to a school that does languages from early on, it will carry through.

Sugargliderwombat · 13/08/2023 15:47

Poorlilthing · 13/08/2023 09:56

aside from… you know… the benefits of learning another (very very widely spoken language) from a young age?

But she won't retain that language at school as noone else in the family speaks it?

PriamFarrl · 13/08/2023 13:18

So if she doesn’t know ‘would you like a …..’ in Spanish then how the fuck is she talking to this child at home in Spanish? Surely ‘do you want/would you like’ are phrases used most days by parents to small children.

And if this utter nonsense was true then it’s not in usual for a child to start school without a word of English. Children pick up language very quickly.
When a child is in a home where the home language isn’t the local language the advice is always for the parent to speak their first language as they need one language they are confident in before trying to learn another.

I have a friend who is English, her partner is a different European nationality but brought up in another European country. They lived in Wales and their child spoke Welsh at school, English with mum, one language with dad and then another language with grandma. They now like in England so I don’t think he speaks much Welsh now.

But all that aside this is utter rubbish.

CharlotteBog · 13/08/2023 13:18

Sugargliderwombat · 13/08/2023 09:51

I have seen an instrgrammer who sends their child to a Spanish speaking nursery for no real reason. Very odd.

Not odd at all. Most of our early education is "for no real reason".

I would have loved to have sent my children to such a nursery. I would have chosen german as I lived there for a few years and speak it pretty well. My boys picking it up in such an early age would have benefitted us all.

PriamFarrl · 13/08/2023 13:03

PonyPatter44 · 13/08/2023 10:02

Is this what happens when you order ChatGPT from Wish?

Ha. I love that.

Hummingbird89 · 13/08/2023 13:01

What’s with all the troll threads this morning?? 🙄

TeamsInterview · 13/08/2023 13:00

Righto

JFDIYOLO · 13/08/2023 12:57

It's not possible for two people who don't know a language to teach it to a child in a country that doesn't speak it, or for that child not to pick up English in an English speaking family home. That's a no from me.

DameCurlyBassey · 13/08/2023 12:52

Wouldn’t the child pick up English just by playing with other kids, hearing TV and radio?

MhairiLynette · 13/08/2023 12:51

I’m calling Bull OP. I have a friend whose children are bilingual but DF was born in Germany and moved to the uk in her mid twenties for work. DF met and married a British man and decided to stay in Britain so their DC speak both English and German fluently. I cannot imagine teaching a child a language that neither parent speaks as their first language though.

GreenKimono · 13/08/2023 12:50

ManchesterLu · 13/08/2023 12:46

What rubbish. If the parents are speaking English that's what the child would speak.

In fairness, if the parents are imaginary, they don’t really speak anything.

QuestionableMouse · 13/08/2023 12:50

This is not remotely how childhood language acquisition works. Try harder OP.

Crossstich · 13/08/2023 12:50

I can't believe this is true.

Children learn to speak by listening to others speak. If they live in the UK, the parents speak English to each other and he hears English all around him he will speak English. If no one speaks Spanish around him Spanish won't be his native language!
It's nonsense about Spanish being easier to learn too. Maybe for a non native speaker Spanish is easier to learn than English . But to someone brought up in the UK with English speaking parents of course English would be easier to learn . Just as for a child brought up among Spanish speaking people surrounded by others speaking spanish,spanish is easier

LateSummerLobelia · 13/08/2023 12:46

I wish I had the ability to send my Dcs to a bilingual nursery.

I did study another language at university but actually am far from fluent as I am pretty shit at languages. I do talk to them in that language sometimes (badly) but tends to be some phrases and just to sort of them get used to the sound of it. If I were properly bi-lingual I would have tried really hard to bring them up bilingual. Mind you my 13 year can say 'Oh MY GOD!!!!' in that language and employs it liberally.

[random inconsequential musing]

ManchesterLu · 13/08/2023 12:46

What rubbish. If the parents are speaking English that's what the child would speak.

AlwaysJumping · 13/08/2023 12:46

Bonkers

Dontcallmescarface · 13/08/2023 12:41

Que monton de estupideces...or to put it another way....what a load of bollocks