Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

unfair of me to ask ex for more money?

129 replies

bluestarrsy · 13/08/2023 08:53

We have a 20 month DD. Ex DP has a lot of issues and we parted on amicable terms. He struggles very much with his mental health and since the split four months ago he hasn’t seen DD. I’ve not pushed it, I know he’s got problems and isn’t coping too well.

However, he earns well. I earn ok and he’s on almost double that. When we split he agreed to pay me 800 a month to cover costs for DD. This seemed like a lot at the time and I was grateful (the maintenance calculator comes up with 30 quid less). But I’m suddenly realising that it doesn’t go far with nursery fees (currently 1,200 a month full time).

Would I be unfair to ask for more money? He has recently been sent to a v v expensive area for work and accommodation is not subsidised so I know he is now paying around 1,800 a month purely on rent costs (he sent me the link on Rightmove and it’s not even that nice!!).

I am not sure what to do. On the one hand I feel like he’s left me to cope alone but also I know he’s not a bad person he’s just got a lot of struggles. I can afford our life as it is but part of it feels unfair that I’m managing everything and will have to deal with all increased living costs alone.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BibbleandSqwauk · 13/08/2023 23:52

@Whattodo112222 maintenance is for whatever the RP uses it for. Mostly it goes into the household pot and isn't earmarked for particular things. Lots of NRPs have this idea that an RPs income in its entirety should be used for the children and if the RP dares to have a new car, or haircut, then it's "their" maintenance being spent. The idea that an NRP should contribute sufficient funds that the RP might have some of their own money left for themselves is anathema.

The CMS is exceptionally vague on what it is "meant" to contribute toward (they never use "cover" as there's no expectation that it would be enough on its own to cover anything). This leaves RPs and to be fair, sometimes NRPs in a difficult position of conflicting ideas with many saying it's the bare minimum and "extras" such as hobbies, uniforms, school trips, phone contracts etc ought to be split and others saying that's it, not a penny more.

Childcare is the huge, huge issue because it is such a large chunk of money, even after any gov contributions and tax free allowances and it does, in reality allow BOTH parents to work. I think it should absolutely be accounted for outside of the CMS calculation and billed separately. If the NRP doesn't like that, they can take up more responsibility and contact time themselves.

Soontobe60 · 13/08/2023 19:14

The thing is, if you decided to pack your job in, you’d have no nursery fees, probably a fair amount in benefits and still get £800 from him. That’s why the courts would not make the NRP pay a specific amount for nursery fees.

fullbloom87 · 13/08/2023 19:07

@LoveThisUsername

So should op hand her baby over to him and just pay half the nursery fees?
Get a grip!

fullbloom87 · 13/08/2023 19:06

He's too mentally unwell to see a baby HIS baby but he's well enough to hold down a well paid job??.

Yanbu ask him for more money. He doesn't get to walk away and abandon his child that easily. Presumably if you were still together he'd be paying half her nursery fees and half of everything else anyway.

BCBird · 13/08/2023 18:58

If he is such a high earner,I don't think supplements should be made via benefits

Whattodo112222 · 13/08/2023 18:54

bluestarrsy · 13/08/2023 15:26

Thanks for the replies. Those saying I’m on loads of money, actually 60k and still paying student loans is not that much take home.

@Thatladdo i would think the usual maintenance plus 50% of childcare? (Maintenance is for day to day costs not childcare)

You're wrong. Maintenance can be used towards childcare. Look it up.

Dutch1e · 13/08/2023 18:37

OP, I don't think you're being unreasonable.

Although I'd think about approaching it slightly differently seeing as you are on amicable terms, by doing a quick summary of child-related expenses and also lost time.

If you were still a couple he would be contributing a higher percentage of costs as the higher earner and a MUCH higher percentage of his time (i.e. more than zero) to parenting.

Show him what you're losing and let him know he's not the only one struggling as a result of the break-up.

As well as clarifying your own thoughts around what you want to get out of the conversation, seeing it in black-and-white may prompt him to come up with a reasonable offer. Whether that's money, or time, or some other solution that lightens your load.

I really feel for you, it's exhausting to be a lone parent.

PeaceGoodMercutio · 13/08/2023 16:23

BananaSlug · 13/08/2023 16:10

Flat rate if on benefits

Fuck, I'm sorry.

BananaSlug · 13/08/2023 16:10

PeaceGoodMercutio · 13/08/2023 16:09

How is it that low!?!?

Flat rate if on benefits

difficultspaghetti · 13/08/2023 16:09

@Bellyblueboy I haven't suggested a thing, I was just surprised to see someone getting so much compared to myself. Christ.

PeaceGoodMercutio · 13/08/2023 16:09

BananaSlug · 13/08/2023 15:55

I get £28 a month 😅 can’t imagine getting £800

How is it that low!?!?

Bellyblueboy · 13/08/2023 16:04

BananaSlug · 13/08/2023 15:55

I get £28 a month 😅 can’t imagine getting £800

Your focus should be how pathetic a contribution this is from a grown adult o his child.

BananaSlug · 13/08/2023 15:55

difficultspaghetti · 13/08/2023 15:44

800?! I get £126 a month. I'd have a great life with 800!

I get £28 a month 😅 can’t imagine getting £800

Bellyblueboy · 13/08/2023 15:49

difficultspaghetti · 13/08/2023 15:44

800?! I get £126 a month. I'd have a great life with 800!

Why is this relevant to OP and her ex?

are you suggesting that a man earning c£100k should only pay £126 a month because you are satisfied with that lifestyle?

difficultspaghetti · 13/08/2023 15:44

800?! I get £126 a month. I'd have a great life with 800!

GabriellaMontez · 13/08/2023 15:30

bluestarrsy · 13/08/2023 15:26

Thanks for the replies. Those saying I’m on loads of money, actually 60k and still paying student loans is not that much take home.

@Thatladdo i would think the usual maintenance plus 50% of childcare? (Maintenance is for day to day costs not childcare)

I think that's reasonable. Then you're both able to work full time, reasonably comfortably, until you're no longer paying this childcare.

Or suggest he works 4 ddaysto save on childcare.

gogomoto · 13/08/2023 15:29

I'd put it that he pay 50% of nursery then £350 as you have dc 100% of evenings and weekends and provide everything, but stress when he feels able to take on more responsibilities you should reduce it by £50 for each day per week he has her overnight. (Maths is easy this way)

bluestarrsy · 13/08/2023 15:26

For context my mortgage is 1k a month.

OP posts:
bluestarrsy · 13/08/2023 15:26

Thanks for the replies. Those saying I’m on loads of money, actually 60k and still paying student loans is not that much take home.

@Thatladdo i would think the usual maintenance plus 50% of childcare? (Maintenance is for day to day costs not childcare)

OP posts:
Thatladdo · 13/08/2023 15:23

Out of interest, how much more per month would you like?

TheNorthWind · 13/08/2023 14:52

PenguinPete · 13/08/2023 14:00

She is being unreasonable.

Live within your means. End of story. That's what rich folk say to poor folk. It goes both ways.

She's already getting £800 a month. On top of 3.5k she earns a month. If you can't raise a child on this money you must be an embecile. Many raise their kids on universal credit 😴

That's not how you spell imbecile.

And she is paying for everything necessary with the money available, but it's a bit tight.
The father surely has money left over at the end of the month. She doesn't.

Why should ALL the strain be felt by the mother?
Why should she suffer for his choices?
Why should the child have a lower standard of living than its parents are jointly able to provide?
Why shouldn't the father do the best he can for his child?

Why must the mother provide everything, to the absolute limit of her means, while the father provides only a financial minimum?

And at this level of wealth, that £30 is negligible, an absolute red herring. I know very well that it's the difference between money on the metre and sitting in the dark for many, but if your income is this high, there's just no difference between £770 and £800. He offered £800, not her. How do you think he came up with that figure? I'd bet money it was the CMS calculator and he just remembered the result it gave as "about £800."

This man has walked out on his family and is now providing as little as he can get away with.

PeaceGoodMercutio · 13/08/2023 14:38

I am baffled by the replies here.
He made a decision to have a child.
He made a decision to leave and not see his child.
I would be asking for more. A lot more. He can afford it.
Why does he get to opt out?
You carried that baby for 9 months, you gave birth. What has he contributed?
What would happen if you decided to opt out?
Take as much as you can get from him. What else use is he?!

Tiqtaq · 13/08/2023 14:16

This is an unusual one because both parents seem to be high earners.
The OP doesn't qualify for child benefit so presumably earns >£60k.
The ex presumably earns £100k or more.

For a lower earning mother childcare would be largely paid for via the benefits system but this is not the case here.

I think it is reasonable for the father to pay more than 50% of the childcare costs and other child related costs (accommodation, food, clothes etc) as the father is the higher earner.

I think OP is fully justified in asking for more money.

Bellyblueboy · 13/08/2023 14:08

PenguinPete · 13/08/2023 14:00

She is being unreasonable.

Live within your means. End of story. That's what rich folk say to poor folk. It goes both ways.

She's already getting £800 a month. On top of 3.5k she earns a month. If you can't raise a child on this money you must be an embecile. Many raise their kids on universal credit 😴

its not a race to the bottom. Dads should contribute commensurate with their lifestyle and earnings.

the child of a high earner should have a lifestyle that reflects this.

we Don’t live in a communist country - we don’t all have to have the same lifestyle as dictated by government benefits.

CornishGem1975 · 13/08/2023 14:00

OP, you say you've not pushed it but why don't you insist that he needs to see his child and take on some responsibility?

Swipe left for the next trending thread