Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do so many mums bang on about their parenting styles?

87 replies

hungrycrocodile23 · 13/08/2023 08:23

This is a thing I've noticed a lot lately. It's not just the stealth boasting about holidays and days out anymore, it's actual monologues about parenting styles.

I have a few people on my socials who do it. Just this week I've seen someone put up a long winded post about car seats and why rear facing are so important and why her son won't be forward facing until he's 11 and how she 'can't believe other parents allow it'.

Another one who is into gentle parenting and constantly posting about the benefits of contact naps and allowing kids the freedom to express themselves. Often closeted digs at those who do things differently.

I even saw someone write a FB post about Santa and how her daughter would not be taught to believe that she had to be good in order to get presents because she is free to express herself how she wants to and will be rewarded regardless. That one created a bit of a debate.

I suppose you could argue that the car seat stuff and things like breastfeeding posts are raising awareness but honestly...it just seems like everyone wants everyone else to know just how much of a superior parent they are these days.

Yes, I know the option to unfollow is there but these are otherwise nice people. I just don't understand the constant need to wax lyrical about your own parenting styles and values. We all parent our own way, why does anyone else need to know about it?

OP posts:
JenniferBarkley · 13/08/2023 10:40

PeachesoutinGeorgia · 13/08/2023 10:31

Could someone clarify on the rear facing thing? Our 17m old hates it and cries until he throws up every time. It gets to a point where honestly I’d rather have him happy and dead than hysterical and covered in vomit every time we travel. Judge me as you see fit though. He’s quite big for his age so it’s very cramped. He’s 86cm and 30 lbs but I’m not sure that makes a difference? Is this even legal I’m just so confused at this point

This is one where you need to do your own research (from reputable sources). RFing will be safer in a collision, but the chances of being in a serious enough collision for that to matter are reasonably slim. So you need to weigh up the nightmare scenario Vs the day to day unhappy vomiting child. We chose FFing but you might not and that's fine.

Parenting has loads of these judgement calls - our latest is a child diagnosed with a peanut allergy and deciding whether to let her have products that say "may contain...". Obviously we spoke with her specialist but ultimately the decision was on us, and another family with the same allergy and the same info from the doctor may have made a different decision as it was right for them.

None of these big decisions can be easily summed up in a meme or slogan to be posted and reposted on FB. Life is more nuanced than that.

YukoandHiro · 13/08/2023 10:35

@Goingsomewhere oh I read that as hyperbole for comic effect... batshit if it's true

Clefable · 13/08/2023 10:34

PeachesoutinGeorgia · 13/08/2023 10:31

Could someone clarify on the rear facing thing? Our 17m old hates it and cries until he throws up every time. It gets to a point where honestly I’d rather have him happy and dead than hysterical and covered in vomit every time we travel. Judge me as you see fit though. He’s quite big for his age so it’s very cramped. He’s 86cm and 30 lbs but I’m not sure that makes a difference? Is this even legal I’m just so confused at this point

Have you tried him in front passenger seat with air bags off? It might help if he can see you. Do you know it's the RF that upsets him or just being in a car seat full stop? As the latter is quite common generally.

But yes it's legal to FF him at this point and up to you.

JustACountryMusicGirlInCowboyBoots · 13/08/2023 10:32

There's a mum at school who tells me every day about how she read about sleep training for autistic children and how marvellous it is and how much less tired she feels. She'd be less tired if her useless partner did some parenting. She always gives me a run down of her day and night as though she has to justify everything she does and any time she spends on herself. It's very sad and I suspect her partner is an utter shit to her. I object to the autism stuff because I'm autistic as are my dc but she says I don't look autistic Hmm and it's all about how little Bobby has to be pandered to and gently parented. Little Bobby needs parenting before he ends up an absolute terror in his teens because she's too afraid to say no to him. I've got 3 children from 8 to 16 and don't need her parenting advice when she has a slightly younger child and I've been through those stages already. She's full of ideas about how to fix my very damaged by her dad 16 year old too as though I hadn't thought about them. Needless to say I've distanced myself. Our dc will be in separate areas of the school this coming academic year so I won't have to endure the repeated advice and conversations. I think it's PFB syndrome and she means no harm but I can't deal with it.

PeachesoutinGeorgia · 13/08/2023 10:31

Could someone clarify on the rear facing thing? Our 17m old hates it and cries until he throws up every time. It gets to a point where honestly I’d rather have him happy and dead than hysterical and covered in vomit every time we travel. Judge me as you see fit though. He’s quite big for his age so it’s very cramped. He’s 86cm and 30 lbs but I’m not sure that makes a difference? Is this even legal I’m just so confused at this point

Clefable · 13/08/2023 10:28

I mean their legs just bend, they don't 'go' anywhere. We just switched DD FF at 4.5 and she's been complaining that her legs are dangling as she's been used to sitting with them crossed and resting on back of seat!

But I think people post about what they are passionate about and when people are in the thick of parenting young kids then they often find something there to be passionate about and it can consume their interests for a times

It's like when someone suddenly discovers running and then every day it's posts of running routes or best times or whatever. I don't care about it so I just stroll past. Inevitably they stop running at some point or realise that they've been a bit OTT about it and it all stops.

hungrycrocodile23 · 13/08/2023 10:23

The RF until 11 comment was tongue in cheek, sorry for confusion, but her son is 5 and still RF and yeah I don't get how that works. Where do the legs go?

It's totally fine to have your beliefs and preferences as a parent. I actually think it's ok to try and raise awareness on certain things too....if that's your actual goal, to raise awareness. I have a friend who posts a lot of photos of her breastfeeding and I kind of get her reasons - normalise it, show others that it's ok to do it in public, whatever.

But I don't need to know your justifications on Santa. Or your bedtime routine. Or why contact napping is sooooo precious. Some of this is just blatant bragging and trying to convince others that they have got the best approach to parenting and are some kind of expert.

OP posts:
mondaytosunday · 13/08/2023 10:22

Well it is odd preaching about this or that as if they've found the holy grail of parenting and need to spread the word - how did any child make it before!
And I was 5' 8" at 11 so that would have been amusing!

EntreMummy · 13/08/2023 10:21

This ridiculous competitive parenting “styles” being paraded and debated on social media (btw Mumsnet is also social media)
has been going on for years. My eldest is 12 and neither the conversations nor the evangelical boasting have moved on much since he was born.
so much of what works for individual parents is down to luck or accident. If you’re caring about your kids and doing your best then that is enough and ignore the rest.

ThePitsofDespair · 13/08/2023 10:17

Do not worry about navel gazing wankers on social media is my top tip for you.

I think people that follow a parenting style are not confident, I make my own mistakes. I know DH Mother used that Benjamin Spock book and Gina Ford was in fashion when I had DS. I remember my SIL gave me a parenting book. I didn’t read a page.

It’s like this baby lead weaning malarkey, I fed DS from a spoon and also put food on his high chair table, like you would feed a chicken with feed and the little sod smeared it everywhere whilst eating some. Was some of that baby led weaning? I bet our ancestors who had to wash everything by hand and really did cook everything from scratch didn’t have the time for all this chuffing nonsense,

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 13/08/2023 10:16

Elephantsdontlikechocolate · 13/08/2023 09:58

...co-sleeping till 23 or older, only feeding them breastmilk ice cream and sweets, let them pooh on a whim in the living room etc
There is a small chance your post wasn't tongue in cheek in which case you are practicing emotional, physical and sexual abuse and damaging your children greatly.

What. The. Actual. Fuck??

Sazza26xx · 13/08/2023 10:15

I'm strongly in the rear facing brigade however I don't make goady posts on social media or even talk about it really

Parker231 · 13/08/2023 10:11

DaisyAndDonaldDuck · 13/08/2023 08:27

It sounds like you’re feeling insecure about the way you parent if these posts are getting to you so I would have a think about why that might be.

In the case of ERF it is very important to spread that information far and wide because it unfortunately hasn’t hit the mainstream yet, but it’s getting there and this is how it does that.

It’s important parents are made aware of what is safest for their child even if they choose to ignore it, because at least then they’ve made an informed choice.

We moved DT’s into forward facing seats when they were about 14 months. Happy with our choices but it’s our choice and not something I expect anyone else to comment on.

Clefable · 13/08/2023 10:09

@Elephantsdontlikechocolate That poster is practising sexual abuse??? What the fuck are you on about? 

HR313 · 13/08/2023 10:08

I have noticed this a lot too recently. I was talking to a ‘mum friend’ the other day and she has bf both her children, I couldn’t for various reasons and I think she knows deep down I would have loved to but she brought it up again the other day (she’s still bf her nearly two year old) and said that it’s expected that formula fed babies sleep through and she is amazed that my formula fed youngest child doesn’t sleep through. She certainly isn’t the first and last one to bf a child, but I’m getting to the point of just not bothering with mum friends anymore. The constant digs etc on parenting styles - id rather have no mum friends and be happy just doing whatever with my children. I’ve been let down by a couple of mum friends too these past few months so I think that’s swaying my decision to get rid of them in my life! I clearly don’t mean much to them!

JenniferBarkley · 13/08/2023 10:06

My pet peeve is when slogans or "facts" get posted and reposted on an image with some flowers or other shit, making people think it's real and to be followed at all costs without any research into where this has come from. But they've seen it regularly so it must be true and followed At All Costs. Typical example "food before one is just for fun". A phrase to reassure parents of reluctant weaners is used to justify one year olds existing purely on breast milk with non existent iron stores.

Another is the FACTS about RFing being 1000% (or whatever large seeming number) safer - but it's in one particular type of collision, and it's 1000% of a tiny tiny number. No nuance that allows people critically evaluate it and conclude that actually in their case their kid screams and vomits when RFing and the vast majority of their trips are low speed anyway so the 1000% isn't actually worth it for them. They are Bad Parents who Do Not Care About Safety. INTERNAL DECAPITATION!!!!1!!

Mefe92427 · 13/08/2023 10:04

What is beneficial to some may not be beneficial to you or your children so do what works best for you and them.

Neither one of my boys were breastfed (couldn't/struggled) and they are no differences between them and the other children.

People need to focus on their own kids and stop posting everything on FB, telling e rryone how to be "better". There is no one size fits all when it comes to children and parenting.

You do you x

Elephantsdontlikechocolate · 13/08/2023 09:58

Wenfy · 13/08/2023 09:36

I just quiety do my own thing with DC - babyled weaning, breastfeeding until 4, sports / exercise everyday, eating family dinners at the table, strict bedtimes etc etx. But my siblings still take offence even when I don’t really talk about what I do. Just mute or unfollow them, jealousy helps no one.

...co-sleeping till 23 or older, only feeding them breastmilk ice cream and sweets, let them pooh on a whim in the living room etc
There is a small chance your post wasn't tongue in cheek in which case you are practicing emotional, physical and sexual abuse and damaging your children greatly.

RudsyFarmer · 13/08/2023 09:55

They are ‘educating’ the unclean. Same with all the influencers and activists. There’s a right way to do it and the way everyone else does it. I see it as no different from television evangelists.

Choice4567 · 13/08/2023 09:50

Ha I’d love to see my 5’1, 10 year old try and squash into a rear facing seat

Anxioys · 13/08/2023 09:45

They have no lives of their own and are washed up? See also life coaching etc

Kids haven't read these books, and this stuff is for the clueless.

ploverq · 13/08/2023 09:44

Wenfy · 13/08/2023 09:36

I just quiety do my own thing with DC - babyled weaning, breastfeeding until 4, sports / exercise everyday, eating family dinners at the table, strict bedtimes etc etx. But my siblings still take offence even when I don’t really talk about what I do. Just mute or unfollow them, jealousy helps no one.

Not that quietly 😄

cornflakesandtea · 13/08/2023 09:41

I once got handed two books on gentle parenting by a "friend" who thought my parenting wasn't up to scratch. I didn't read them. My kids are young teens now and they seem to be doing well!
This was 10 years ago so evangelical parenting is not even a recent thing!

Wenfy · 13/08/2023 09:36

I just quiety do my own thing with DC - babyled weaning, breastfeeding until 4, sports / exercise everyday, eating family dinners at the table, strict bedtimes etc etx. But my siblings still take offence even when I don’t really talk about what I do. Just mute or unfollow them, jealousy helps no one.

WandaWonder · 13/08/2023 09:36

If I am not interested in someone I don't have them on my social media

Swipe left for the next trending thread