Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother of Star Hobson does not deserve sympathy

312 replies

pumpkinspice87 · 13/08/2023 07:14

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12385875/amp/Family-murdered-Star-Hobson-looking-forward-welcoming-home-mother-allowed-toddler-die-hands-girlfriend-say-victim-tragedy.html

Am I being unreasonable to be absolutely sickened by this article? I get that this man is traumatised by what happened to his family, but how could anyone be so blinded as to see Star's mother as some sort of innocent victim? She was a cruel and neglectful mother who was too infatuated with her new partner to protect her baby daughter. Yes, I know she has a low IQ and learning difficulties. However, to use this as a constant excuse is an absolute insult to the many, many people in this country with learning difficulties (many of whom are parents) who would never, ever think it is acceptable to stand by and watch whilst their child is horrifically abused.

EXCL: Family of tragic Star Hobson will welcome home jailed mother

EXCLUSIVE: The distraught family of tragic 16-month-old Star Hobson say they are ready to welcome her mother back home - three years after her brutal girlfriend killed the toddler.

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12385875/amp/Family-murdered-Star-Hobson-looking-forward-welcoming-home-mother-allowed-toddler-die-hands-girlfriend-say-victim-tragedy.html

OP posts:
JanieEyre · 13/08/2023 11:33

SoShallINever · 13/08/2023 09:59

How the hell did Savannah Brockhill manage to convince social services that she was no risk to Star? I can only conclude that she really must be a master manipulator. On that basis I can possibly understand that Frankie, with her learning difficulties, was maybe in fear of her, but that's being very generous and very lenient.
Maybe Frankie just didn't give a shit about her child? I hope beyond hope that she is not allowed to care for a child ever again.

This, really. If Brockhill managed to manipulate clued-up and experienced social workers into thinking everything was OK, what chance did someone with such a low IQ have against her?

Stressedafff · 13/08/2023 11:30

Catusrusty · 13/08/2023 11:28

Frankie is really stupid, there's no nice was of putting it. She has a low IQ and is really easily led. She's childlike.

Other than that she was normal until she met her partner Savannah, when she became isolated from both friends and family.

There is as always a lot that is not reported on in the press. Especially about Savannah. There's good reasons she got the much heavier sentence.

I am fiercely protective of my child, even now he is an adult. That's because I am capable of being protective and strong. Frankie is and was very vulnerable. She couldn't protect her child, she has lost her child and served a prison sentence because of it, so I'm not in the least bit surprised that her family want her back to help salvage what is left of her life even though the Mumsnet burn the witch mob are out in force.

Should she have done a lot more to protect her baby? Yes.

Could she have done more to save Star given the circumstances surrounding her death. Probably not. Hence her relatively light sentence, the English justice system does, rightly, take mental impairment into account.

This in DROVES. 👏 👏 👏

It begs the question how many other women who are so childlike and vulnerable slip under the radar of SS.

Whydoifeellikeaneel · 13/08/2023 11:30

My little 18 month baby is sleeping beside me. I stroked her to sleep and just looked at her soft little face and whisps of baby curls. I just cannot fathom punching her; it's so outside my realm of how I would treat an innocent, precious little human. I saw the cctv footage in the car and it turned my stomach, actually made my blood run cold.

From what I gather, the Savannah told Frankie that she was being too soft with Star and implied that she knew what she was talking about. I don't know if Frankie, with her low IQ considered, took the word of this older woman whom she idolised and thought, ok maybe Savannah knows better than me, and went along with it in that respect. I followed the court case and the judge commented how well Frankie was able to hold her own under question for someone who claimed to be so vulnerable and gullible. I don't know.

The only black and white aspect of this case is that Savannah was a control freak. She was jealous of Star and resented not just the fact she wasn't her biological parent, but also that Frankie had some.form of bond with her that she didn't. Same old story of these 'step parents'. Jealous, inadequate, controlling, manipulative. There is a unique recipe of a person like that getting into a relationship with someone passive, needy and emotional vulnerable which seems to bewitch them into choosing a team, to the catastrophic co sequences for their children who are cast aside for the new partner. These parents often seem to be bobbling along quite nicely, parenting adequately until the new person comes along. A switch is turned off, or on. Maybe the parent becomes evil in a way they wouldn't have done without the partner. Maybe the new partner unleashes a deep selfishness that was there all along. A mix of both, I think. I think everyone is capable of terrible things, given the right circumstances, some more than others, of course. Certain circumstances are the perfect breeding ground for it. The way it seems to creep into relationships is so utterly insidious.

That poor baby, and the other children who also lost their lives in similar circumstances around the same time. Beautiful children who were so badly failed.

Thegoodbadandugly · 13/08/2023 11:29

It's utterly heartbreaking that this child was let down by social services, I understand that they have a tough job however there were numerous complaints to social services and that baby still died, can't imagine how people felt after having the courage to report them and then have it called malicious.

JanieEyre · 13/08/2023 11:28

loveandpoprockz · 13/08/2023 09:15

I agree with you OP. I also feel the same way about people who choose to kill their innocent young children in murder suicides like the case in Australia recently.

I don’t think the mother of Star should ever be released from prison personally. Star was an innocent little girl who had a whole life ahead of her which she was robbed of. How could her mother just sit back and let it happen? She should never ever be allowed to have children again and I hope social services makes sure that if she does then they are taken away from her.

What on earth would keeping her in prison for 50/60 years achieve? Provided that she is properly supervised and supported, she is not realistically a danger to anyone. Remember, it costs on average over £40K a year to keep a person in prison. Doesn't it make more sense to help her to become a productive member of society?

Catusrusty · 13/08/2023 11:28

Frankie is really stupid, there's no nice was of putting it. She has a low IQ and is really easily led. She's childlike.

Other than that she was normal until she met her partner Savannah, when she became isolated from both friends and family.

There is as always a lot that is not reported on in the press. Especially about Savannah. There's good reasons she got the much heavier sentence.

I am fiercely protective of my child, even now he is an adult. That's because I am capable of being protective and strong. Frankie is and was very vulnerable. She couldn't protect her child, she has lost her child and served a prison sentence because of it, so I'm not in the least bit surprised that her family want her back to help salvage what is left of her life even though the Mumsnet burn the witch mob are out in force.

Should she have done a lot more to protect her baby? Yes.

Could she have done more to save Star given the circumstances surrounding her death. Probably not. Hence her relatively light sentence, the English justice system does, rightly, take mental impairment into account.

RosesAndHellebores · 13/08/2023 11:23

Five times this was reported to Social Services

Five times Social Services dismissed family concerns

Five times Social Services ignores bruising and warnings

Five times Social Services disbelieved family, putting their liberal principles first

Five times Social Services failed to put together the potential risk of learning disabled, vulnerable young woman under the influence of violent and older abusive partner.

Five times Social Services failed to protect a toddler.

Five times over Social Services could have changed the trajectory here.

A child is dead. A family is broken. Whilst the mother and partner rightly went to prison, Social Services could have avoided this.

I wish the gentleman and granddaughter well and I hope they recover and eventually find some peace. I suspect Star's mother will be dead in a few years having turned to alcohol or drugs, possibly prostitution to pay for them.

Social Services are the ones who need to be strung up here for ignoring repeated warnings. It is disgraceful and I hope the professionals involved are disciplined. They are the ones who deserve to be in prison. I can quite imagine they weren't particularly respectful to the people.reporting this either.

Busubaba · 13/08/2023 11:18

Frankie Smith also abused and hurt her daughter Star, it wasn't just the other woman.

"Smith accepted she mistreated Star and her behaviour accounted to cruelty. The maximum charge for this is 10 years.
"There were at least eight instances identified, each captured on video. Having seen these images, we do not accept these are the full picture of this.
"There was a consistent pattern of cruelty by Smith towards her daughter in the months before her death."

....

It's been mentioned that Frankie was obedient and compliant yet she ignored her half sister Alicia who adored her niece Star.

Frankie may have a low IQ but she was devious and manipulative with social services and her family.

CrazyFrogDingDing · 13/08/2023 11:15

I would have locked them both up and thrown the key away with the rest of the scum who beat, torture and kill, but that's just me.

Pandaflop · 13/08/2023 11:11

Wsmi · 13/08/2023 11:08

So now low IQ is an excuse for allowing your child to get murdered? Everyday we hit a new low in this progressive race to the bottom. I thought ‘minor attracted persons’ was bad enough.

The ‘be kind’ brigade will stop at nothing to award themselves with the status symbol of being progressive. Nothing. They will find an excuse for everything.

People aren't saying that though are they? People are saying she was vulnerable and whilst she is responsible for allowing this to happen in her home and to her child it's criminal that social services were alerted 5 times and nothing was done, and that some people are for various reasons vulnerable and the cuts to support services is having an impact. As I asked earlier in the thread, I wonder how different opinion would be if her partner was a man.

Wsmi · 13/08/2023 11:09

RivieraVera · 13/08/2023 10:51

Almost as vile as beating a baby to death eh.

Not to these people.

Honestlyy · 13/08/2023 11:09

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 09:47

Sterilisation is a disgusting thing to suggest. Churchill and his cronies wanted anyone with mental health issues sterilised. That would be me as I have ADHD. It’s vile.

Your having ADHD is quite different to having an intellectual disability.

Although some intellectually disabled people have managed to raise children fine, it's not the norm and it hasn't been without the help of loving and capable relations or social care (sometimes a combination of the two)

Most intellectually disabled women of child bearing age who are being cared for are put on some form of contraception.

Star's mother should certainly be sterilised for her own good and that of her family's.

Wsmi · 13/08/2023 11:08

So now low IQ is an excuse for allowing your child to get murdered? Everyday we hit a new low in this progressive race to the bottom. I thought ‘minor attracted persons’ was bad enough.

The ‘be kind’ brigade will stop at nothing to award themselves with the status symbol of being progressive. Nothing. They will find an excuse for everything.

Busubaba · 13/08/2023 11:06

Star's grave this year at Easter.

Her family have not forgotten her and reported the abuse to social services to no avail.

Frankie only got eight years. Her daughter suffered terribly and was brutally murdered.

Mother of Star Hobson does not deserve sympathy
Stressedafff · 13/08/2023 11:03

The problem is it’ll keep happening. Frankie Smith is a perfect example of a prime target of these abusers: lone young mum, learning difficulty/vulnerable, no SS involvement.

I feel sorry for her grandad, they looked after Star for a while and Frankie’s family kept phoning social services on her.

MeadAndPie · 13/08/2023 11:02

Username2101 · 13/08/2023 07:54

I live in Keighley where this happened and I don’t understand how she would ever be able to come back. She would be lynched.

I suspect this is why he did the article (possibly some pressure from paper too) - to make it clear family had concerns and did try and raise the alarm.

I suspect they hope that few family members still in contact - seem like him and occasional phone calls to her Mum- that perhaps she can come out and have their limited support - they probably still love her see the child she once was and want to help her move forward best she can and worry about future exploitation of her as with IQ of 70 they are probably painfully aware of her limitations and vulnerabilities - it's clearly torn the entire family apart.

I think her behavior was bloody awful and she could have done so much more to protect her child - I honestly can't see any SS department letting her keep another child - but she is coming out of prison at some point.

I didn't get him minimising or even forgiving her for her crimes more accepting, from someone who knew her well, she had vulnerabilities and who thinks her life could have gone a very different way, and is at minute refusing to turn his back on her despite his clear upset and anger at what Star endured.

WickedSerious · 13/08/2023 10:58

LakieLady · 13/08/2023 09:41

I used to work in the legal dept of a local authority. They had a case where a couple had child after child taken into care at birth. I left when the mother was in her eleventh pregnancy, and they were getting ready to remove that child from her care as well.

She had a baby every year, save for the year her partner was in prison - for threatening to kill one of the social workers involved in the case. It made me understand why some people are in favour of compulsory sterilisation.

There was no partner on the scene in this case but the woman did go on to have a second child four years later.
The mother was allowed to keep him because she was living with her parents when he was born but Social Services remained heavily involved for a long time.

Angrycat2768 · 13/08/2023 10:51

kinkii · 13/08/2023 09:05

Why shouldnt she have been 'allowed' a child, as far as has been reported she didnt have a violent past or anything? Are you suggesting women with low IQs shouldn't have babies?

She'd been reported multiple times and wasn't protecting her child of 1 year who had a massive bruise on her face.

I'm quite happy to say that she should not have any child.

I worked with people with learning difficulties and often their babies are removed. Its sad for them, but the child's welfare needs be paramount. The particular person I am thinking of had clearly been taken advantage of as there was no way she would have been able to have consented to sex.

RivieraVera · 13/08/2023 10:51

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 09:47

Sterilisation is a disgusting thing to suggest. Churchill and his cronies wanted anyone with mental health issues sterilised. That would be me as I have ADHD. It’s vile.

Almost as vile as beating a baby to death eh.

Parsley1234 · 13/08/2023 10:43

That family has been blown apart by what happened they look like good people who took in a great grand child and for that to happen just beyond belief. Social services were too keen to appear non racist to travellers than protecting that beautiful child. I too read the whole of the court transcripts and was shocked- Frankie wasn’t in the car when Brockhill took Star to her work and repeatedly punched her. Worse bit for me was when Brockhill went to Styal on remand to meet with her cousin she was running the prison very quickly

Rinoachicken · 13/08/2023 10:42

An IQ of 70 is very low - that’s not just a learning difficulty that’s learning disability territory.

She was (and is) extremely vulnerable. I agree with the PP that this was a massive SS/healthcare failure from the moment she was pregnant. She should have been receiving far more intervention and support which would have given her (and Star) more protection from predatory people.

She is totally unable to care for a child, attend to the needs of the child, put a child first - and this is the tragic outcome and it was totally avoidable with proper support from services.

She is responsible for allowing Stars death absolutely - I would struggle to ever get past that if she was my family. I’m not sure I could tbh. But the services that failed them both are also share responsibility for allowing it to happen imo.

Savannah - well she can just go rot as far as I’m concerned.

Frogmila · 13/08/2023 10:35

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/08/2023 10:21

Have you ever been the subject of interest for a shit rag? One of DP's friends has. It's over 25 years later and he still gets them emailing, calling, contacting his friends and family, threatening him with 'Well, we're going to run with it anyway, so you might as well have your side presented/oh, so you're happy with this - we'll publish that you don't care and it was their own fault, then'. Or if he is struggling and goes to a pub, a stranger is friendly to him, offers to buy him drinks and after a couple, it's straight to the 'have you ever lost somebody you loved?' to try to get him sobbing and crying about it.

There's also some cunt that's been wanting to make money by making a crime documentary about the case to show on Channel 4 for the last decade. She's not happy about the refusal to give her a filmed interview so she can make shitloads and he can switch on satellite TV to see his trauma every couple of weeks for the next twenty years, read about randoms discussing how there 'must to be more to it', etc. She's broken up at least one relationship by the pressure she's put on the partner's parents and siblings.

They're shit stains on humanity looking for things to thrill the punters' outrage and wish for salacious gossip.

Christ this is awful.

It's partly why I find true crime stories quite distasteful. How can viewers be sure that all close relatives are happy having the case raked up again.

Goldcircle · 13/08/2023 10:28

Of course she should be sterilised, she must never be allowed to care fir a child again. It would be kinder to her anyway as the baby would be taken away.

Elaina87 · 13/08/2023 10:21

A victim, but not one bit of me feels sorry for her. Why couldn't she have just left the baby with her Grandparents where she was safe and loved, if she wanted to stay with that monster? Utterly heart breaking. The fact that social services did not stop this is a catastrophic failure on their part and I just pray lessons have been earned.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/08/2023 10:21

Busubaba · 13/08/2023 08:14

@NeverDropYourMooncup - grandad sells his story for money to the Daily Mail. That's why the story is in the news again.

Have you ever been the subject of interest for a shit rag? One of DP's friends has. It's over 25 years later and he still gets them emailing, calling, contacting his friends and family, threatening him with 'Well, we're going to run with it anyway, so you might as well have your side presented/oh, so you're happy with this - we'll publish that you don't care and it was their own fault, then'. Or if he is struggling and goes to a pub, a stranger is friendly to him, offers to buy him drinks and after a couple, it's straight to the 'have you ever lost somebody you loved?' to try to get him sobbing and crying about it.

There's also some cunt that's been wanting to make money by making a crime documentary about the case to show on Channel 4 for the last decade. She's not happy about the refusal to give her a filmed interview so she can make shitloads and he can switch on satellite TV to see his trauma every couple of weeks for the next twenty years, read about randoms discussing how there 'must to be more to it', etc. She's broken up at least one relationship by the pressure she's put on the partner's parents and siblings.

They're shit stains on humanity looking for things to thrill the punters' outrage and wish for salacious gossip.

Swipe left for the next trending thread