Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother of Star Hobson does not deserve sympathy

312 replies

pumpkinspice87 · 13/08/2023 07:14

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12385875/amp/Family-murdered-Star-Hobson-looking-forward-welcoming-home-mother-allowed-toddler-die-hands-girlfriend-say-victim-tragedy.html

Am I being unreasonable to be absolutely sickened by this article? I get that this man is traumatised by what happened to his family, but how could anyone be so blinded as to see Star's mother as some sort of innocent victim? She was a cruel and neglectful mother who was too infatuated with her new partner to protect her baby daughter. Yes, I know she has a low IQ and learning difficulties. However, to use this as a constant excuse is an absolute insult to the many, many people in this country with learning difficulties (many of whom are parents) who would never, ever think it is acceptable to stand by and watch whilst their child is horrifically abused.

EXCL: Family of tragic Star Hobson will welcome home jailed mother

EXCLUSIVE: The distraught family of tragic 16-month-old Star Hobson say they are ready to welcome her mother back home - three years after her brutal girlfriend killed the toddler.

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12385875/amp/Family-murdered-Star-Hobson-looking-forward-welcoming-home-mother-allowed-toddler-die-hands-girlfriend-say-victim-tragedy.html

OP posts:
Sushibecomesme · 13/08/2023 13:40

It's crackers to talk about compulsory sterilisation. If she has further children they will be adopted.

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 13:39

RivieraVera · 13/08/2023 13:24

Goodness, what a leap.

Stop making the thread about you!

A baby was routinely abused, terrorised and beaten to death yet here you are calling out people who are rightly disgusted and distressed by these facts.

And yes, sterilisation in this case should be a condition of her release.

What are you on about? It’s not about me, I’m replying to someone who is saying people with intellectual disabilities shouldn’t be allowed to have kids.

Maybe you should read comments more carefully before you go spouting off.

Sushibecomesme · 13/08/2023 13:38

I feel sorry for her. It's hard to manage abuse. She's not a fully functioning adult. My overwhelming sympathy is with the tragically murdered child but I do feel for her. Living with the aftermath must be shattering.

panko · 13/08/2023 13:36

RivieraVera · 13/08/2023 13:24

Goodness, what a leap.

Stop making the thread about you!

A baby was routinely abused, terrorised and beaten to death yet here you are calling out people who are rightly disgusted and distressed by these facts.

And yes, sterilisation in this case should be a condition of her release.

That's how some of the comments are reading though. If they mean this particular case because of the crime then that's one thing but bringing the IQ into it is dodgy territory

FatNoMoreSue · 13/08/2023 13:32

Can someone put “IQ of 70” into context please? I mean are we talking “level of a 5year old - probably shouldn’t be trusted to use an oven” or what? Is IQ even relevant when it comes to
something like this?

RivieraVera · 13/08/2023 13:24

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 13:07

You know people used to suggest that people with dwarfism shouldn’t have children? That people with Down’s Syndrome shouldn’t have children? That other various mental and physical disabilities shouldn’t be allowed to have children?

Jeez, this thread is really dodgy. I’m not participating anymore, some really concerning suggestions of eugenics leaking out.

Goodness, what a leap.

Stop making the thread about you!

A baby was routinely abused, terrorised and beaten to death yet here you are calling out people who are rightly disgusted and distressed by these facts.

And yes, sterilisation in this case should be a condition of her release.

SnackSizeRaisin · 13/08/2023 13:23

girlfriend44 · 13/08/2023 12:17

It would be a deterrent to others that's what. As well as sending out a message we don't tolerate adults killing children.

We are seeing more and more of this type of behaviour and sentences are so low.

I doubt you would say this if it was your own child.

These people are lucky they aren't hanged. Seeing whole life sentences is the next best thing.

Ill informed post. Prison sentences don't work as a deterrent. What would work is better support from social services, better community support generally. SS failed in this case but that is probably largely down to them being over stretched, under staffed, under funded, as are all other services under this Tory government.

No one is killing a child just because they would only get 8 years in jail for goodness sake.

I don't really think Frankie Smith should be in jail at all. I don't think she is a risk to the public. Long term contraception and maybe a tag in the community would be more appropriate.

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 13:07

Honestlyy · 13/08/2023 12:49

Have you ever worked with intellectually disabled people? I can think of a very small number of those people that would make adequate parents with an incredible amount of support.
For most, it would be a disaster, an absolute disaster- for them and their children. That was the case for a number of women I supported. Unfortunately they had children before they were diagnosed with a disability.
I can only think of one woman who brought her NT child up OK and was with the help of her family.

You know people used to suggest that people with dwarfism shouldn’t have children? That people with Down’s Syndrome shouldn’t have children? That other various mental and physical disabilities shouldn’t be allowed to have children?

Jeez, this thread is really dodgy. I’m not participating anymore, some really concerning suggestions of eugenics leaking out.

Offyoupoplove · 13/08/2023 13:04

I’ve never understood this. In my job I work with all kinds of people including those who have committed terrible crimes. I almost always feel empathy and sympathy for them.

To feel sympathy for the awful things that have led them to this, is not to absolve them of all responsibility. We can judge and punish people fairly whilst also feeling care for them as a human being. I feel sympathy for the many convicted murderers I’ve worked with who experienced horrific,horrific abuse as kids and neglect in the care system. Whilst also agreeing that they need to experience the consequences of their actions and to understand what they need to change in themselves.
On a purely practical level we can’t incarcerate everyone who has committed terrible crimes for the whole of their lives. It’s a more practical solution to help them to change. That doesn’t make what they did forgotten.

Cornettoninja · 13/08/2023 13:02

"I felt like all I could have done was taken her and run off with her."

given she (her sister) would have been in a whole heap of legal trouble not to mention other societal and personal repercussions I completely understand why she didn’t.

But I really wish she had Sad

itsgettingweird · 13/08/2023 13:00

Girlfriend** it wouldn't be a deterrent though to those with an IQ equal to Frankies.

If you don't have the intellectual capacity to protect yourself you can't see what's happening let alone be deterred from allowing it to happen to you.

That's why we have woman giving birth to 3/4/5 children who are all removed to care on birth. They cannot protect themselves despite knowing they won't be able to keep the baby.

hot2trotter · 13/08/2023 12:57

Unpopular opinion or not. Both the mother and the girlfriend should be locked up for life. They both abused that poor girl, even though it was the girlfriend who ultimately killed her. They are both evil scum and the mother being "thick" essentially is not an excuse to abuse or allow your child to be beaten to death.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 13/08/2023 12:51

I have sympathy in the sense that I understand she was a victim as well as an abuser.

In the sense that she and her daughter were utterly failed by services again and again.

In the sense that I understand how easy it is to manipulate and control someone who is extremely vulnerable.

In the sense that, dismissing her as a monster and lock her up and throw away the key, does not prevent this to happening again and again.

Honestlyy · 13/08/2023 12:49

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 12:20

What are you saying here? Sterilising a child murderer is one thing, sterilising someone because they are intellectually disabled is not an acceptable suggestion.

This thread is getting fucking dodgy.

Have you ever worked with intellectually disabled people? I can think of a very small number of those people that would make adequate parents with an incredible amount of support.
For most, it would be a disaster, an absolute disaster- for them and their children. That was the case for a number of women I supported. Unfortunately they had children before they were diagnosed with a disability.
I can only think of one woman who brought her NT child up OK and was with the help of her family.

LuluBlakey1 · 13/08/2023 12:46

You are not being unreasonable. Her learning difficulties were not severe enough that she did not know allowing someone to physically assault her child, repeatedly over a period of months was absolutely wrong. Not only did she not stop that person, she never removed her child from the situation and continued an emotional and sexual relationship with the person. She is not the victim here.

However, the great grandfather does not sound like he has a high IQ to me either- and is likely to have been taken advantage of by the DM. He does actually say no one else in the family feels the way he does about her - the headline, as ever in the DM, is misleading.

This article is typical DM gutter journalism- taking an horrific, tragic situation, where the criminal is a traveller and a lesbian (two ticks on their list of easy-to -rile up- readers-with-this-one, double hatred from DM readers), the victim a child (another tick on their list), a vulnerable mother involved in the crime (another tick on their list). They contact a vulnerable family member, offer sympathy, pay him for the story (no doubt promising a compassionate piece) and hang him out to dry by writing the piece they intended to from the start. The DM has no interest in really exploring the issues here- its only interest is in whipping up hatred of particular groups (single parents, lesbians, travellers, the underclass) and implying neglect by social services.

The DM has an interest in maintaining the audience of readers it has (the lower middle-classes/upper working classes). These are the people whose votes win elections for either of the big parties. The DM is full of direct and more subtle political messages. This article is no different. There are all kinds of 'political messages' throughout it, intended to sway readers views about issues such as:

  1. Justice- sentences are too low.
  2. Public services- social services always to blame, never do a decent job.
  3. Wokeism- DM is anti-anyone who falls into any group other than 'middle-aged/elderly, white, straight, middle-class+ British male'. They consider anyone else a drain on public resources, disgusting, dangerous and must not be given any status in our society incase they change the power balance away from those the DM supports.
  4. The reality of how the 'underclass' live and how different they are to DM readers. (Always best to maintain the illusion these people have nothing in common with DM readers and must be kept in their place, far away from 'us').
DM has no compassion. Never be fooled by it. It's only interest is in maintaining capitalism as the main political power driving this country- it's reason for existing is to make the already very rich, much richer at the expense of the rest of us.
Busubaba · 13/08/2023 12:43

A damning insight into the social services regarding this family -

Alicia the half sister to Frankie Smith -

. "There were five different people from Star's family or close friends who reported it… that seems like a big failure.

They just thought that all of Frankie's family were being malicious, and they'd just decided they'd taken their side. That's what it felt like, it felt like the social services were against us.
"I think they need to be more on the ball, and time is crucial. Frankie was texting her social worker saying 'we've got a sickness bug, can we rearrange'.
"And she was just replying, 'no worries' - whereas they should be like, 'no, you can't rearrange - this needs to be followed up, I need to see you today.'"
......
For someone with a low IQ, Frankie Smith was very devious.

The more I read, the more I feel that Frankie did a lot more than she is being punished for.

MeadAndPie · 13/08/2023 12:40

I wonder why they chose to turn a blind eye to it five times. In fact no, I can guess..

The article says they seemed to decide that the family was prejudiced against same sex couples and against gypsies - and that seems to have led them to dismiss all the raised concerns.

Not sure what police did maybe they referred to SS don't know.

kinkii · 13/08/2023 12:38

And it would be a step on a very slippery slope. A PP mentioned ADHD.

Unless pp is also responsible for the death of a child, she has nothing to worry about. Long term contraception or sterilisation as a condition for release sound completely sensible.

Busubaba · 13/08/2023 12:36

Family and friends contacted social services on several occasions from January 2020 and up until the month Star diedd_.
Alicia (half sister of Frankie Smith) says she contacted social services three months before the murder, as well as the police, after growing increasingly concerned for Star's welfare.
Alicia has shown Sky News an email she sent to the police, with images of Star's bruised face and testimony in text messages from another sister that she had seen Smith "slap her across the face".

According to Alicia, police never responded and her exchanges with social services were equally unsuccessful.

This is a transcript of the Snapchat conversation sent to police
SISTER: "I've just seen Frankie slap her across the face. X"
ALICIA: "OMG"
SISTER "I'm fuming x"

ALICIA: "Tell nana x"
SISTER: "K x"
ALICIA: "Something bad is going to happen. Why did she hit her?"
SISTER: "Coz she was playing with her shoe."
Around this time, police and social services took the child to hospital to be checked up, but accepted her injuries were accidental.
This was already the second time police had seen Star with bruising. Family and friends made a total of five referralss_, but Alicia now says she wishes she had taken things into her own hands.

"I was just angry, every day, because no one was listening to me," she said.
"I felt like all I could have done was taken her and run off with her."
Alicia gave evidence against her sister in court.
Although they were once best friends, she said: "I just can't ever speak to her again.
"I was literally screaming at Frankie, 'You don't have to be with that girl, we can call the police, we can get a restraining order.'
"I don't know if she didn't believe me, or she didn't want to."

I just feel angry because I think if that was me, if that was my child, I would have got away. I would have got out of that situation, no matter what.
"So, I can't forgive that."
One of the complaints to social services was dismissed as malicious despite bruises being found on tiny Star.
In January 2020, a friend of Smith raised concerns about Star to social services. The case was closed a month later.

In April 2020, Smith took Star back. Just a month later, Anita contacted social services who paid Smith a visit the same day.
Anita had contacted social services in May after she had been told that Brockhill had been 'slam-choking' Star - lifting by her neck and thrown on the bed - in order to 'toughen her up'.
Anita said that, after making the referral, she was not contacted by anyone from social services and was not told when the social services inquiry had been closed.
After she had made the referral, Anita said she David had their access to Star restricted and were only able to see her a couple more times before she died.

During the trial, disturbing details of the toddler's short life emerged, including a clip captured on CCTV of Brockhill repeatedly punching Star in the face and stomach over a three-hour period, nine days before the murder.
The toddler was also filmed being dragged through Bradford city centree_ by Smith and crawling painfully up the communal staircase to her mother's flat.

I have also read that Alicia was banned from seeing her niece by Frankie Smith.

Between February and April, Star was living with great grandparents Anita Smith and David Fawcett where she was content and happy.

MinnieTruck · 13/08/2023 12:34

This is besides the point but just look how ‘regular’ Savannah Brockhill looks. Isn’t it scary to know that these types of people literally walk beside us day to day.

I mean punching a child over and over for 3 hours? What sort of insane, evil, unhinged person would do something like that? Choke slamming a child? I have absolutely no words

Chowtime · 13/08/2023 12:33

Elizadoloads · 13/08/2023 12:19

I remember reading that Stars grandad committed suicide. It's not a position I'd ever want to be in and couldn't say how I'd react so it's easy for me to say I wouldn't forgive my child allowing such horrendous abuse of an innocent baby.
There were so many stories just like this after lockdown. What the hell is wrong with these people it's horrendous to even think about.

I remember that too.

It was the day after it came out in court that Frankie used to wake Star up by screaming "WAKE UP" in her face. Frankie thought that this was an OK thing to do and pointed out in court that it was what her father used to do to her.

The following day he killed himself.

loveandpoprockz · 13/08/2023 12:32

JanieEyre · 13/08/2023 11:28

What on earth would keeping her in prison for 50/60 years achieve? Provided that she is properly supervised and supported, she is not realistically a danger to anyone. Remember, it costs on average over £40K a year to keep a person in prison. Doesn't it make more sense to help her to become a productive member of society?

If it stops another baby suffering the same fate then it’s well worth the cost.

loveandpoprockz · 13/08/2023 12:30

itsgettingweird · 13/08/2023 11:50

So you even begin to have any understanding of how vulnerable someone with learning difficulties is?

They are often coerced into sex and feel loved very easily. Too trusting.

The fact Stars dad stole the money raised for her headstone and bench shows what type of person he is.

No one's debating Star was horrifically failed. It's been pointed out SS failed her on 5 accounts.

But Frankie was failed too. Because if they'd have take the reports from family seriously Star would have been removed and she may have got the support she needed too.

She's not an innocent victim. But she is a victim of failure on behalf of the services who were told of the abuse 5 times

I wonder why they chose to turn a blind eye to it five times. In fact no, I can guess..

LakeTiticaca · 13/08/2023 12:30

UpAndAwayyy · 13/08/2023 08:05

"I live in Keighley where this happened and I don’t understand how she would ever be able to come back. She would be lynched."

Dunno, Mark Feely hasn't been done in yet has he?

I'm fairly local to this as well.
The popular opinion on Mark Feely is that because of his alleged learning disabilities he gets away with being a nonce. There was a rumour a year or 2 back that someone had killed him . Unfortunately it was untrue, although he seems to have gone to ground. Not heard of him for a while

girlfriend44 · 13/08/2023 12:29

Whydoifeellikeaneel · 13/08/2023 11:30

My little 18 month baby is sleeping beside me. I stroked her to sleep and just looked at her soft little face and whisps of baby curls. I just cannot fathom punching her; it's so outside my realm of how I would treat an innocent, precious little human. I saw the cctv footage in the car and it turned my stomach, actually made my blood run cold.

From what I gather, the Savannah told Frankie that she was being too soft with Star and implied that she knew what she was talking about. I don't know if Frankie, with her low IQ considered, took the word of this older woman whom she idolised and thought, ok maybe Savannah knows better than me, and went along with it in that respect. I followed the court case and the judge commented how well Frankie was able to hold her own under question for someone who claimed to be so vulnerable and gullible. I don't know.

The only black and white aspect of this case is that Savannah was a control freak. She was jealous of Star and resented not just the fact she wasn't her biological parent, but also that Frankie had some.form of bond with her that she didn't. Same old story of these 'step parents'. Jealous, inadequate, controlling, manipulative. There is a unique recipe of a person like that getting into a relationship with someone passive, needy and emotional vulnerable which seems to bewitch them into choosing a team, to the catastrophic co sequences for their children who are cast aside for the new partner. These parents often seem to be bobbling along quite nicely, parenting adequately until the new person comes along. A switch is turned off, or on. Maybe the parent becomes evil in a way they wouldn't have done without the partner. Maybe the new partner unleashes a deep selfishness that was there all along. A mix of both, I think. I think everyone is capable of terrible things, given the right circumstances, some more than others, of course. Certain circumstances are the perfect breeding ground for it. The way it seems to creep into relationships is so utterly insidious.

That poor baby, and the other children who also lost their lives in similar circumstances around the same time. Beautiful children who were so badly failed.

If she was jealous of Star why have a relationship with someone witha child.

As a woman she is hardly likely to father a child either. Just date women without kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread