Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother of Star Hobson does not deserve sympathy

312 replies

pumpkinspice87 · 13/08/2023 07:14

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12385875/amp/Family-murdered-Star-Hobson-looking-forward-welcoming-home-mother-allowed-toddler-die-hands-girlfriend-say-victim-tragedy.html

Am I being unreasonable to be absolutely sickened by this article? I get that this man is traumatised by what happened to his family, but how could anyone be so blinded as to see Star's mother as some sort of innocent victim? She was a cruel and neglectful mother who was too infatuated with her new partner to protect her baby daughter. Yes, I know she has a low IQ and learning difficulties. However, to use this as a constant excuse is an absolute insult to the many, many people in this country with learning difficulties (many of whom are parents) who would never, ever think it is acceptable to stand by and watch whilst their child is horrifically abused.

EXCL: Family of tragic Star Hobson will welcome home jailed mother

EXCLUSIVE: The distraught family of tragic 16-month-old Star Hobson say they are ready to welcome her mother back home - three years after her brutal girlfriend killed the toddler.

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12385875/amp/Family-murdered-Star-Hobson-looking-forward-welcoming-home-mother-allowed-toddler-die-hands-girlfriend-say-victim-tragedy.html

OP posts:
HappiDaze · 13/08/2023 16:25

I think the social workers who closed the case the week before as 'malicious' should very much spend time in prison for their negligence and utter incompetence

Honestlyy · 13/08/2023 16:24

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 15:35

Where do you draw the line though? That’s my problem with sterilisation and eugenics. It’s a mine field. The reason why I referenced my ADHD which another poster is seemingly finding so offensive, is that it’s rocky ground because once you declare one condition, where does it end. I find it dangerous.

I'm not suggesting everyone person with LD should be sterilised, it should be on a case by case basis. Most of the time the contraceptive injection is enough. I've worked with women with IQs of around 55-65,it's in their best interests to not reproduce.

Star's mother should definitely be sterilised because she was complicit in the abuse and murder of her daughter and will very likely be abused by a predator again.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 13/08/2023 16:10

Idk. It seems she was the victim of a domestic violence situation. Yes she should have protected Star but we all know thousands of women stay with their abusers out of fear.

She also had learning difficulties which will have made it even harder to recognise what could happen.

I actually think you're a bit weird for making this thread. Dwelling in a story of tragedy and getting your pitchfork out for the mother who was in a terrible situation as though you know anything more than what you've read in a few articles.

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 15:56

kinkii · 13/08/2023 15:52

Where do you draw the line though? That’s my problem with sterilisation and eugenics

This one killed her child (or allowed it to happen) and actively abused a baby. She's not just learning disabled! That's a pretty good line to draw

This has fuck all to do with disability and everything to do with abuse

You have low intellectual capability and have a baby? Either accept support from SS + family or baby is removed

You kill a baby? You go to prison and a condition go release is long term contraception/sterilisation and you can never parent again. That goes for anyone of any intellectual level

Where is the eugenics here?

As I have said, repeatedly, I am not talking about the sterilisation of child murderers!!! I was responding to someone who said low IQ people shouldn’t be allowed to have children.

Stop putting words in my mouth. I am not talking about Star’s mother in particular.

kinkii · 13/08/2023 15:52

Where do you draw the line though? That’s my problem with sterilisation and eugenics

This one killed her child (or allowed it to happen) and actively abused a baby. She's not just learning disabled! That's a pretty good line to draw

This has fuck all to do with disability and everything to do with abuse

You have low intellectual capability and have a baby? Either accept support from SS + family or baby is removed

You kill a baby? You go to prison and a condition go release is long term contraception/sterilisation and you can never parent again. That goes for anyone of any intellectual level

Where is the eugenics here?

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 15:35

Honestlyy · 13/08/2023 15:12

So sterilisation is awful but an intellectually disabled woman having children she can't look after who then face a chaotic and unsafe upbringing and then possible further trauma of being removed from her isnt?

Where do you draw the line though? That’s my problem with sterilisation and eugenics. It’s a mine field. The reason why I referenced my ADHD which another poster is seemingly finding so offensive, is that it’s rocky ground because once you declare one condition, where does it end. I find it dangerous.

lemmein · 13/08/2023 15:35

I've worked with people with LDs, most I can imagine getting caught up in situations like this tbh so I do have a degree of sympathy for Smith. It can be a very frustrating group to work with as they are usually extremely vulnerable yet are deemed to have capacity so are free to make 'poor decisions' whilst those around them are left with very few options to intervene.

However, I'm pretty sure there was evidence of Frankie abusing Star when Savannah wasn't even present and she must've had some understanding that what was happening was wrong as she played a huge role in hiding Stars abuse, so I do think she deserved a lengthy sentence. Ultimately Savannah would not have been able to murder Star without Frankie's willingness, and capacity, to deceive services and her family.

I think there was a 'perfect storm' of lots of factors which led to poor Stars death, but Frankie was very much part of that storm - she's probably safer in prison really.

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 15:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

i said this thread was getting dangerous. And it is. But you keep attacking me for no reason and it’s weird. And rude. I am not going to indulge your silliness any more, you’re being ridiculous m. You’re misquoting be, putting words in my mouth and generally attacking me for no reason.

Have a lovely day, I won’t be reading your responses. Very odd.

Honestlyy · 13/08/2023 15:12

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 14:55

What are you on about?! I’m not taking it personally at all?! I said in my first two messages that whilst I got there was nuance, I couldn’t see Stars mum or partner as anything but awful. I then commented that discussing sterilisation based on intellectual disability was wrong and going down a dangerous path. I said - very clearly - that sterilisation based upon child murder is one thing, but based upon intelligence is very very different. I have not defended Stars mother, quite the opposite.

I don’t know why you’re trying to fight me, but your arguments make zero sense and are not relevant. You clearly haven’t read the full thread, or at least, all of my posts. So please stop trying to argue with me with baseless arguments and pick on someone else.

So sterilisation is awful but an intellectually disabled woman having children she can't look after who then face a chaotic and unsafe upbringing and then possible further trauma of being removed from her isnt?

RivieraVera · 13/08/2023 15:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 14:55

RivieraVera · 13/08/2023 14:35

Honestly, you are taking this way too personally.

Stop having a go at people who think Smith shouldn't ever have the chance to give birth again.

She was complicit - and her own abuse towards Star is documented.

It is extraordinary that you cannot see that this whole conversation is about this woman and safeguarding future babies or rather, preventing them being born.

What are you on about?! I’m not taking it personally at all?! I said in my first two messages that whilst I got there was nuance, I couldn’t see Stars mum or partner as anything but awful. I then commented that discussing sterilisation based on intellectual disability was wrong and going down a dangerous path. I said - very clearly - that sterilisation based upon child murder is one thing, but based upon intelligence is very very different. I have not defended Stars mother, quite the opposite.

I don’t know why you’re trying to fight me, but your arguments make zero sense and are not relevant. You clearly haven’t read the full thread, or at least, all of my posts. So please stop trying to argue with me with baseless arguments and pick on someone else.

Cornettoninja · 13/08/2023 14:50

Not knowing the capital of Japan or the square root of 64, giving a low IQ score seems irrelevant.

An IQ score is indicative of things like logic skills and the ability to transfer life skills to other situations. A very low IQ as reported here is relevant because it indicates that she simply didn’t have the skills and personal tools to deal with the situation she found herself in. That’s precisely what makes her vulnerable.

I’m presuming her IQ score wasn’t low enough to be considered as not criminally responsible (age of criminal responsibility being 10) but there’s not enormously vast ground between the capabilities of a ten year old and, let’s say, a 15 yr old. Neither are particularly well known for making particularly ‘good’ decisions or having universal capabilities to deal with high stress situations.

RightOnTheEdge · 13/08/2023 14:48

The article mentions Smith's grandfather using methadone to kill himself with. What was the wider story with that?
Another article says he was a heroin addict for all of Frankie's childhood and that Frankie went to live with her grandparents, but Frankie's mother used to take her out and they'd go out on the lash together.

So it doesn't sound like she had great parenting role models.
Not that that is any excuse for what she did! It sounds like she had wider family who desperately tried to help and support her and Star.

RivieraVera · 13/08/2023 14:35

DinoDough · 13/08/2023 13:39

What are you on about? It’s not about me, I’m replying to someone who is saying people with intellectual disabilities shouldn’t be allowed to have kids.

Maybe you should read comments more carefully before you go spouting off.

Honestly, you are taking this way too personally.

Stop having a go at people who think Smith shouldn't ever have the chance to give birth again.

She was complicit - and her own abuse towards Star is documented.

It is extraordinary that you cannot see that this whole conversation is about this woman and safeguarding future babies or rather, preventing them being born.

Oatycookies · 13/08/2023 14:25

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/08/2023 13:47

Lowest 2% of the country. Still playing with dolls aged 16. Could be around 8-10 in age terms.

The child's father impregnated somebody with the mental ability of somebody borderline for the equivalent of criminal responsibility.

some men are sick. She was basically a child but because to him she looked like an attractive older teen he probably didn’t care. There’s a few young women like her I’ve seen get pregnant and i always think either the father also has LD or he’s just perverted.

Oatycookies · 13/08/2023 14:21

MeadAndPie · 13/08/2023 12:40

I wonder why they chose to turn a blind eye to it five times. In fact no, I can guess..

The article says they seemed to decide that the family was prejudiced against same sex couples and against gypsies - and that seems to have led them to dismiss all the raised concerns.

Not sure what police did maybe they referred to SS don't know.

no doubt the police were scared. They’re afraid of the traveler community. They knew it wasn’t prejudice but they didn’t want to mess with a traveler IMO. I’ve seen this play out in other contexts

ohfook · 13/08/2023 14:14

@NeverDropYourMooncup I'd be inclined to think you were exaggerating if I hadn't seen this first hand. A friend's father died in quite an unusual way. It was a horrible time made only worse by the fact that the media hounding of the family began immediately and continued for many years. Imagine thinking it's appropriate to interrupt a bereaved and grieving family just to fill a page in a newspaper.

itsgettingweird · 13/08/2023 14:12

MeadAndPie · 13/08/2023 12:40

I wonder why they chose to turn a blind eye to it five times. In fact no, I can guess..

The article says they seemed to decide that the family was prejudiced against same sex couples and against gypsies - and that seems to have led them to dismiss all the raised concerns.

Not sure what police did maybe they referred to SS don't know.

Thing is. If someone is abusive they are often able to be sweeter than sweet in public.

I'm sure if you are so way inclined you can persuade someone that all the reports come from different people because when when fails another tries. But they know they are just upset because they took baby Star back from her great grandparents.

And the family have been vocal about how they don't think and/or agree that Frankie is gay. They've been homophobic. They made comments about her being a gypsy. Throwing the word prejudice into most things nowadays muddies the waters. Especially if it was hinted that the social workers could be accused of the same thing if they pursued it.

What worries me is that one bruise - can see why they believe it may be accidental.

But all those bruises and the reports of abuse. I wonder if any of the previous reports were ever linked or looked at?

drpet49 · 13/08/2023 14:03

Busubaba · 13/08/2023 11:48

She hurt her own daughter.

It's on video.

She hurt and abused her own daughter.

The more brutal abuse for want of a better description was by her girlfriend and resulted in Star being murdered.

Frankie Smith is still responsible for hurting her daughter Star, such cruelty that the judge pointed out deserved at least ten years

Frankie repeatedly lied to social services and her own family.

Repeatedly. Not under coercion. Off her own back.

She is a danger to other children including her own if she goes on to have another. She will, I have no doubt.

This. No doubt she’ll get pregnant as soon as she leaves prison.

Rinoachicken · 13/08/2023 13:56

There is precedent already for sterilisation: https://www.itv.com/news/2015-02-04/judge-rules-woman-with-learning-disabilities-can-be-sterilised#

An IQ of 70 is learning DISABILITY territory.

As a previous person said upthread - this will range from needing 24hr care and can’t be left un-supervised, through to being able to live independently, have a minimum wage type job (stacking shelves etc), able to do food shopping, able to get by with the help
of family/friends/carers who would help
with life admin, managing finances etc.

And everyone in between those two ends.

For people at the more severely impacted end, these people are routinely placed on some method on contraception - either pill, or injection usefully as least invasive - as they do not have the capacity to consent to sex, do not understand that sex leads to pregnancy etc. It is a legal decision taken in the persons ‘best interest’.

For those at the less impacted end, they are still vulnerable, but they may have capacity to consent to sex, may understand that sex leads to pregnancy etc. Therefore contraception is by their choice and consent.

But just because you can consent to sex, and may even want a baby, does not mean that you can care for one.

I used to work with adults with learning disabilities. We had a couple who attended our service, they’d been together for years. Both lived in 24hr care, but they their capacity to consent to sex differed. Female did have capacity and male didn’t. The lady used to talk a lot about she’d like to have a baby with her boyfriend. There would have been no way at all that would have happened. They would have forgotten to feed it after an hour, forgot it existed and left it somewhere, anything could and would have happened as they would not have been capable at all. So she was on birth control, which was a best interest decision and it would have caused her trauma to birth a baby and then have it removed, than to just not have a baby.

Busubaba · 13/08/2023 13:54

@FatNoMoreSue I wondered this about the IQ.

She was clever and bough to deceive family and social services on numerous occasions to cover up the suffering that she and her girlfriend had inflicted on Star.

She also appears in many photos as being able to look after her appearance with her hair done and her make up looking well applied.

The family say that Star was looked after, washed and cared for originally, so Frankie must have been capable of normal hygiene standards for herself and her daughter.

Not knowing the capital of Japan or the square root of 64, giving a low IQ score seems irrelevant.

RobertaFirmino · 13/08/2023 13:52

loveandpoprockz · 13/08/2023 12:32

If it stops another baby suffering the same fate then it’s well worth the cost.

Smith will probably have any future children removed at birth.

I would rather the money is spent on two things:
Investigating Social Service's failings and putting measures in place to ensure they do not happen again and looking into the wider social problems that led to this.

Why was a young woman with such a low IQ allowed to parent unmonitored? Any fool can see that someone with an IQ of 70 probably won't have the greatest understanding of what it takes to parent adequately. Did she think that abuse was part and parcel of a relationship because that's what happened at home? The article mentions Smith's grandfather using methadone to kill himself with. What was the wider story with that? Was he an addict. It's also mentioned that he was 50 years old when Smith was 20. Meaning he became a grandfather at the age of 30. I don't believe for one moment that Smith came from a non-dysfunctional family.

Prison won't do a single thing to change anything. Research and training just might.

Jellycats4life · 13/08/2023 13:47

FatNoMoreSue · 13/08/2023 13:32

Can someone put “IQ of 70” into context please? I mean are we talking “level of a 5year old - probably shouldn’t be trusted to use an oven” or what? Is IQ even relevant when it comes to
something like this?

I don’t know about mental age but I’d expect Frankie to be quite immature and childlike.

An IQ of 70 is quite significantly below average. I suppose you could describe it as being “hard of thinking”. It would cause problems with things like reading and numbers, but also empathy and judgement, plus general life skills like taking care of the home, staying organised, keeping appointments, personal care etc.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 13/08/2023 13:47

FatNoMoreSue · 13/08/2023 13:32

Can someone put “IQ of 70” into context please? I mean are we talking “level of a 5year old - probably shouldn’t be trusted to use an oven” or what? Is IQ even relevant when it comes to
something like this?

Lowest 2% of the country. Still playing with dolls aged 16. Could be around 8-10 in age terms.

The child's father impregnated somebody with the mental ability of somebody borderline for the equivalent of criminal responsibility.

FatNoMoreSue · 13/08/2023 13:42

No. She doesn’t deserve sympathy. She needs sterilising when she gets out and I hope that every day of her life someone recognises her and reminds her what she did. Because, you know, she’s apparently too thick to
grasp it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread