Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother of Star Hobson does not deserve sympathy

312 replies

pumpkinspice87 · 13/08/2023 07:14

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12385875/amp/Family-murdered-Star-Hobson-looking-forward-welcoming-home-mother-allowed-toddler-die-hands-girlfriend-say-victim-tragedy.html

Am I being unreasonable to be absolutely sickened by this article? I get that this man is traumatised by what happened to his family, but how could anyone be so blinded as to see Star's mother as some sort of innocent victim? She was a cruel and neglectful mother who was too infatuated with her new partner to protect her baby daughter. Yes, I know she has a low IQ and learning difficulties. However, to use this as a constant excuse is an absolute insult to the many, many people in this country with learning difficulties (many of whom are parents) who would never, ever think it is acceptable to stand by and watch whilst their child is horrifically abused.

EXCL: Family of tragic Star Hobson will welcome home jailed mother

EXCLUSIVE: The distraught family of tragic 16-month-old Star Hobson say they are ready to welcome her mother back home - three years after her brutal girlfriend killed the toddler.

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12385875/amp/Family-murdered-Star-Hobson-looking-forward-welcoming-home-mother-allowed-toddler-die-hands-girlfriend-say-victim-tragedy.html

OP posts:
Iwasafool · 14/08/2023 20:47

Lemieux7 · 14/08/2023 11:03

Someone else mentioned Baby P murder was carried out again by someone with severe learning disabilities.

Someone who will commit murder is a danger to society though.

Frankie didn't murder her daughter - she failed to protect her from a murderer. It is clearly not the same thing.

If FS had never met Savannah Brockhill, Star would still be alive today.

If anything I think allowing your partner to murder your innocent baby is worse than murder. A mother who colludes with the abuser is as low as you can get. She knew what was going on was wrong and she went along with it. I have no sympathy for her. A young child could tell you that punching a baby is wrong.

FiveOClockWorld · 14/08/2023 20:36

DysonSpheres · 13/08/2023 09:44

Forced sterilisation would make us a draconian state. One step behind forced abortion.

People like that need help, family and community.

I wonder if she had a low IQ naturally.

I wonder if she had a low IQ naturally

What do you mean by that ? Do you mean was it caused by Foetal Alcohol Syndrome as opposed to being caused by a chromosome disorder or some congenital defect? We do know that she was brought up by her grandparents so maybe there were issues with drugs or alcohol. We don't know for sure. If someone lacks capacity to care for their child and protect them from abuse I am not sure if the cause of her learning impairment makes a huge difference. I don't know though as my knowledge on LD is limited. Mental health I do know about but not so much LD.

FiveOClockWorld · 14/08/2023 20:28

Lemieux7 · 13/08/2023 09:31

Frankie was both a victim and a perpetrator. She should have protected Star but she was being manipulated by a much older sociopath. And an IQ of 70 is extremely low.

Social services didn't bother to do anything despite being called multiple times, they kept closing the case. Why??

I think social services do bear a lot of the responsibility here. It's like Maria Colwell all over again....

DVL · 14/08/2023 20:20

This is horrific, that photo of the bruise on her little face :(

Being infatuated and ‘losing interest’ in your daughter is low but letting her get abused is absolutely next level. It’s basic human decency to look after any child not just your own, regardless of IQ.

Lemieux7 · 14/08/2023 20:01

Momof3000 · 14/08/2023 19:56

Ew all this talk that she is a victim is disgusting 🤢 Love your kids protect your kids the shop keeper tried to tell mine off I told him to shut the duck up don’t know one tell my kids off or put your hands on them about having a low iq what’s that got to do with anything ew and how she only got 8 years just mysterious bruises she should be serving life I feel sad for the grandparents because they love star ⭐️ a lot she was a beautiful baby who didn’t deserve that as her mother to allow such filth round her own precious baby

Her sentence was increased to 12 years. So she's likely to serve about 6.

Lemieux7 · 14/08/2023 20:00

Sociopaths like Savannah Brockhill think that they will be able to get away with heinous crimes because of their belief that they are cleverer than everyone else and won't be found out. A lot of killers are like this.

I found it so hard to imagine how Star spent her nights in Savannah's car whilst she was at work when she should have been at home, tucked up in bed like any other child.

I don't doubt that FS may also have sociopathic tendencies. She clearly didn't have any empathy for Star. But I don't think Star would have come to harm if FS hadn't met SB.

Momof3000 · 14/08/2023 19:56

Ew all this talk that she is a victim is disgusting 🤢 Love your kids protect your kids the shop keeper tried to tell mine off I told him to shut the duck up don’t know one tell my kids off or put your hands on them about having a low iq what’s that got to do with anything ew and how she only got 8 years just mysterious bruises she should be serving life I feel sad for the grandparents because they love star ⭐️ a lot she was a beautiful baby who didn’t deserve that as her mother to allow such filth round her own precious baby

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 14/08/2023 19:24

Summerwashout · 14/08/2023 19:20

Brockhill was a bouncer, fighter and traveller. She mentioned her down culture and what they do. I'm not saying what she did is what all travellers do but her culture is clearly very important to her and they whole toughing up Children.

Each time she hurt poor star, star was OK in the sense she didn't die or need attention.

So one can imagine it just escalating and her sort of becoming immersed in that world.

When I was 16 a very dodgy bloke fancied me and I sort of fancied him. Our date was hanging out in town looking at cars to steal. He was literally trying to open them as we walked along.

For a few hours I felt cool, walking on the wild side.

I think I saw him a couple more times before I came to my senses.
Strange as it may sound I think Brockhill was so so confident and assured that Smith did fall in with it.

I actually have noticed quite a lot in life just how powerful these incredible self assured people are esp when they talk in a certain way.

There is one at work, definitely not nasty or a killer liked Brockhill but definitely not that bright and yet very bright colleagues (some) really think she's something... I've got a relative like this also.

And with every "case closed/malicious allegation" it would cement her position even more and make it seem "not that bad".

Mesoavocado · 14/08/2023 19:23

I will not read the article. The biggest issue here is clearly the Daily Fail and their awful so called “journalism”

Summerwashout · 14/08/2023 19:20

Brockhill was a bouncer, fighter and traveller. She mentioned her down culture and what they do. I'm not saying what she did is what all travellers do but her culture is clearly very important to her and they whole toughing up Children.

Each time she hurt poor star, star was OK in the sense she didn't die or need attention.

So one can imagine it just escalating and her sort of becoming immersed in that world.

When I was 16 a very dodgy bloke fancied me and I sort of fancied him. Our date was hanging out in town looking at cars to steal. He was literally trying to open them as we walked along.

For a few hours I felt cool, walking on the wild side.

I think I saw him a couple more times before I came to my senses.
Strange as it may sound I think Brockhill was so so confident and assured that Smith did fall in with it.

I actually have noticed quite a lot in life just how powerful these incredible self assured people are esp when they talk in a certain way.

There is one at work, definitely not nasty or a killer liked Brockhill but definitely not that bright and yet very bright colleagues (some) really think she's something... I've got a relative like this also.

EdgeK · 14/08/2023 19:15

Awful. They’ll be married within the year I bet

Elizadoloads · 14/08/2023 19:10

Startyabastard · 14/08/2023 18:55

Where can the court transcripts be found/ deeper information about the case, such as text messages? thanks

This documentary explains a lot.
Startyabastard · 14/08/2023 18:55

Where can the court transcripts be found/ deeper information about the case, such as text messages? thanks

Blueink · 14/08/2023 18:36

I don’t understand how the mother was allowed to keep her child after details of the attacks were disclosed and the evidence of bruising to her face seen.

Very sad and especially as looking at the timeline, her death should have been prevented.

It doesn’t seem the child’s mother had much capacity to look after her, having said that the courts obviously found her culpable.

I haven’t voted either way OP.

lindyloo57 · 14/08/2023 18:36

So so sad why do the social services always believe the abuser, its about time the law is tightened

CantFindMyMarbles · 14/08/2023 18:05

I read all the court transcripts as it was happening.
she knew what she did. You don’t get rehabilitated from willingly neglecting your child for such an extensive period of time. She’ll be reminded every day by those around her of what an awful person she is.

RavenhairedRachel · 14/08/2023 18:04

I hope they both get the same treatment in jail as that poor child and if they are ever released should live in fear. They're disgusting.

FiveOClockWorld · 14/08/2023 18:04

JanieEyre · 14/08/2023 15:53

The problem here was that support from SS wasn't being offered. If it had been, it's reasonable to assume the abuse would have been discovered much sooner.

Frankie didn't kill the child but she did allow it to happen and she has rightly been punished for that. Where people suggest she actively colluded with keeping SS etc away, it seems clear that much of that was on the girlfriend's instructions and indeed some of it may well have been the girlfriend using Frankie's phone to text.

Our neighbour's son has an IQ of 70 and is in sheltered accommodation with quite a lot of independence. He didn't have an abusive childhood and is a nice lad, but I still shudder to think what would happen if he came under the spell of a manipulative, controlling psychopath like Savannah, because he would be very easily influenced, and would simply have no clue how to begin to save himself or look after someone else.

Yes, it has been said that many people have sociopathic tendencies (possibly Frankie had this as well as low IQ) but a dysfunctional childhood or being easily led by another sociopathic person could be the trigger for them behaving in a criminal fashion. Some very successful people from good educational backgrounds and childhoods where they were taught right from wrong actually can score highly on the Hare checklist for sociopathy; they have those innate traits but they have no need to turn to crime or become antisocial. Nurture makes a huge difference.

FiveOClockWorld · 14/08/2023 17:57

Lemieux7 · 14/08/2023 11:01

I don't agree that a 10 year old should be imprisoned for life and the key thrown away- clearly one of them was successfully rehabilitated.

Yes. I find it interesting that the one which was successfully rehabilitated was the boy with the worst background of the two of them, lots of abuse and dysfunction. I also think of Mary Bell who came from a background like that and went on to kill two children and attempt to strangle a third and yet has been rehabilitated back into society very successfully. It can happen.

Elizadoloads · 14/08/2023 16:35

Regardless of Iq I don't believe Frankie deserves any sympathy. She sat back and watched her baby daughter die in horrific pain, she at times abused her daughter herself, she didn't try and get help she covered up and facilitated her baby's death. Unforgivable and my sympathy lies solely with Star. I think Frankie is a disgusting excuse for a human being and I'd rather these people didn't exist in society but if they have to then that should be behind bars.
I also hope that footage of Star haunts her for the rest of her miserable life.
I'm not judging her great grandfather for taking her in, he's more forgiving than I could ever be.

JanieEyre · 14/08/2023 16:00

Elizadoloads · 14/08/2023 09:53

Where do we draw the line though.
James Bulger for example was murdered by 10 year olds. They were still imprisoned (and in my opinion still should be)

Another well documented case was Nicholas Godejohn and Gypsey Rose, He had a similar iq to Frankie Smith but still got life imprisonment.

Someone else mentioned Baby P murder was carried out again by someone with severe learning disabilities.

You could argue in all of these cases that with the right support none of these people would have gone on to abuse and murder but they did. They carried out unforgivable crimes and have no pay for them.

The Godejohn case happened in the US, and he was convicted of actively committing homicide - a very different charge. It's not really comparable.

The killers in the Bulger case weren't imprisoned, but were of course held in custody. Again, they actively committed homicide, and neither had a particularly low IQ, so again it's not comparable.

JanieEyre · 14/08/2023 15:53

kinkii · 13/08/2023 15:52

Where do you draw the line though? That’s my problem with sterilisation and eugenics

This one killed her child (or allowed it to happen) and actively abused a baby. She's not just learning disabled! That's a pretty good line to draw

This has fuck all to do with disability and everything to do with abuse

You have low intellectual capability and have a baby? Either accept support from SS + family or baby is removed

You kill a baby? You go to prison and a condition go release is long term contraception/sterilisation and you can never parent again. That goes for anyone of any intellectual level

Where is the eugenics here?

The problem here was that support from SS wasn't being offered. If it had been, it's reasonable to assume the abuse would have been discovered much sooner.

Frankie didn't kill the child but she did allow it to happen and she has rightly been punished for that. Where people suggest she actively colluded with keeping SS etc away, it seems clear that much of that was on the girlfriend's instructions and indeed some of it may well have been the girlfriend using Frankie's phone to text.

Our neighbour's son has an IQ of 70 and is in sheltered accommodation with quite a lot of independence. He didn't have an abusive childhood and is a nice lad, but I still shudder to think what would happen if he came under the spell of a manipulative, controlling psychopath like Savannah, because he would be very easily influenced, and would simply have no clue how to begin to save himself or look after someone else.

Elizadoloads · 14/08/2023 15:53

Lemieux7 · 14/08/2023 11:01

I don't agree that a 10 year old should be imprisoned for life and the key thrown away- clearly one of them was successfully rehabilitated.

Rehabilitated or not there's no undoing the horrific crime they committed. From what I've read both children should have been taken into care at birth instead they were dragged up and left to roam the streets. How that turned into murdering a two year old I don't know. Nature or Nurture. I doubt it makes much of a difference to James Bulgers family.
As for baby P nobody knows who was to blame for his Murder they all blamed each other and it's why they got such low sentences.. some one killed him though and while others watched on and ignored it.. just like Frankie Smith. Like I said it's unforgivable. I don't think she deserves her freedom but that's not up to me. I hope she realises the suffering she allowed her daughter to endure and enflict herself makes her a monster.

JanieEyre · 14/08/2023 15:38

loveandpoprockz · 13/08/2023 12:32

If it stops another baby suffering the same fate then it’s well worth the cost.

For the reasons I've given, it's obvious it wouldn't stop another baby from suffering the same fate.

JanieEyre · 14/08/2023 15:35

girlfriend44 · 13/08/2023 12:17

It would be a deterrent to others that's what. As well as sending out a message we don't tolerate adults killing children.

We are seeing more and more of this type of behaviour and sentences are so low.

I doubt you would say this if it was your own child.

These people are lucky they aren't hanged. Seeing whole life sentences is the next best thing.

It blatantly wouldn't be a deterrent. If you are a person with an IQ of 70 completely under the control of your psychopathic, manipulative girlfriend, you won't even know about another woman in a similar position who is in prison all her life. If you do find out about it, you will be incredibly easy to manipulate into believing it can't happen to you. It is no deterrent at all.

What keeps children safe is offering the right support to people in this situation and ensuring they get it. Why do you apparently discount that option?