Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can an 18 year old rent a flat?

111 replies

Freshstarts23 · 12/08/2023 19:25

DD wants to move out, for a variety of reasons I think it’s probably for the best. I know I’m probably being unreasonable but we are where we are.

But is it possible, Will landlords accept her? I’ve no experience of renting. She has a full time job.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RampantIvy · 13/08/2023 07:30

I think some people don't realise how much the rental market has changed in recent years. Millions of renters and not enough properties mean the landlords can, and do, make any demands that they want.

Exactly. It took DD ages to find a flat in Newcastle after she graduated. They would go withing minutes after viewings, and she had loads of cancellations of flat viewings because previous viewers decided to take the flat straight away.

She is on her fourth flat rental since 2020 - two as a student and two after she graduated, and every single landlord has wanted a guarantor and a hefty deposit. For her last two flat rentals she has needed references as well.

I lived alone then, literally just rented a flat didn't need a guarantor.

How long ago was this @NewName122?

nokidshere · 13/08/2023 02:33

We never had to be guarantors when 18 year old moved in with his GF last year, I'm just assuming that they need to know they're both of steady income and can keep up with payments.

Every landlord both my sons have had in the 5yrs have required affordability checks, minimum income levels and a guarantor. And my oldest is 25! They have lived in the south west, the north west and now London.

I think some people don't realise how much the rental market has changed in recent years. Millions of renters and not enough properties mean the landlords can, and do, make any demands that they want.

nokidshere · 13/08/2023 02:28

Sorry, meant to add that they definitely had affordability checks too.

nokidshere · 13/08/2023 02:18

My student son is moving into his new flat this week, also in London, SE1.

He will have an income of 17k. He is 21. He has 3yrs of paying rent under his belt and cracking references. He will be sharing with 2 other adult working friends.

This was his (our) experience.

For every flat they looked at there were 30+ others looking at it
Most flats were gone the same day.
If they liked one they had to show the landlord what they could offer, commit to a lease of 2yrs and some were 3, and in some cases were encouraged to offer above the asking rent. They were turned down for over 20 they offered on.

They had to pay a holding deposit of half a months rent = 500 each
They had to pay 5 weeks rent in advance = 1150 each
They had to pay 1 month rent deposit = 1000 each

They were required to have a combined income of £95k
They were all required to have guarantors (only DS is a student)

The rent is £1k pm each. The bills - gas, electric, water, council tax, Wi-Fi, are going to be £250pm each.

So that's £2650 to secure the flat. £1250 monthly rent/bills. References, guarantors, millions of paperwork, and 6 months from start to finish.

And that's before any daily living costs like food, transport etc

fullbloom87 · 13/08/2023 02:00

It's a shame you can't reconcile as she's earning decent money for her age and if she saved as hard as she works for a couple of years she could end up buying her own flat which would be an amazing advantage to her.
Renting is throwing money away.
If she goes into house share who knows what will happen. She might meet some horrible bastard who messes up her life.
I'd be inclined to do everything I could as her mother to put her on the right track.

NewName122 · 13/08/2023 01:48

I lived alone then, literally just rented a flat didn't need a guarantor.

SuperNewMe · 13/08/2023 01:21

Freshstarts23 · 12/08/2023 19:25

DD wants to move out, for a variety of reasons I think it’s probably for the best. I know I’m probably being unreasonable but we are where we are.

But is it possible, Will landlords accept her? I’ve no experience of renting. She has a full time job.

Yes, they can.
We never had to be guarantors when 18 year old moved in with his GF last year, I'm just assuming that they need to know they're both of steady income and can keep up with payments.

caringcarer · 13/08/2023 00:11

bellac11 · 12/08/2023 19:37

If shes got any sense she would rent a bed sit/house share room, bills included, not liable for council tax, no need for guarantor, no need for massive deposit and rent up front too far in advance

Then she can start saving up for a flat of her own

This. She needs to learn she needs to start at the bottom and work her way up to a flat.

Ace56 · 13/08/2023 00:09

Sorry, you’re in London?
What @crystal1983 said. I’m on nearly 40k and can’t afford to rent my own flat in London (zone 4). There is absolutely no way she will be able to afford this and have enough money left over to live decently.

Start looking at house shares!

coreas · 12/08/2023 23:57

@KajsaKavat

Not all landlords demand a guarantor, I’ve had two consecutive rentals where they were willing to forego this.

Presumably you are not 18 and have a good income?

RampantIvy · 12/08/2023 23:55

Not all landlords demand a guarantor,

Maybe it depends on your income?

KajsaKavat · 12/08/2023 23:34

Not all landlords demand a guarantor, I’ve had two consecutive rentals where they were willing to forego this. And there are professional guarantor companies who charge a percentage or a fee to be your guarantor if you do need it.
also deposit schemes exists.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 12/08/2023 23:29

She's an adult and earning a decent amount so yes, she can rent.

The reality is though that she's unlikely to get somewhere because of the number of applicants on rentals at the minute - but if she's old enough to move out, she's old enough to face up to a change in plans if she doesn't get any of her rental applications, ie, start to consider house shares or even people just letting out a room of their home.

This one might have to be a "learn the hard way" for her.

Lavender14 · 12/08/2023 23:06

In theory yes of course she could but any landlord would want a guarantor so you'd need to identify someone willing to do that. Either that or she'd maybe need to save a double deposit on top of first months rent in advance and offer that as an alternative which some landlords might accept. I would sit down and do the maths with her. Get her to budget out rent/electric/ heating/ Internet/ TV licence/ phone bill/ food and household amenities costs and see what she's left with at the end. Then I'd suggest a flatshare with other young professionals and see what she could be saving each month once the overall costs are split 3/4 ways.

Do you think she has the living/ budgeting/ self management skills to move independently and it go well? If not there are some charities who would oversee flatshares between young people and help them navigate living on their own for the first time but I'm not sure what's available in your area. Might be worth looking into?

I'd also explore with her how she'd manage things like visitors. Most young people at 18 still see their family home as 'home' and there's a good chance they'd see her flat as a place to party and get away from their families boundaries and that could make it hard for her to manage visitors.

I haven't rtft but I'm guessing from what you've said things are maybe difficult between you at home and that's why you think she'd be best moving out- I'm maybe wrong. If this is the case would mediation or trying to agree a contract between you with equal input help her sustain living at home and actually make savings? Presumably she'll need to save up for rent etc and furniture etc before she could move out never mind how long it might take for her to get a place.

Another option is maybe lodging? I did it for a few years in a self contained flat at a family home. All we shared was a garden and it was much cheaper and was fully furnished.

TreesandFish · 12/08/2023 22:50

My 20 year old is on £26k. He has ended up renting a room within a HMO and even that was slightly difficult.

If he had wanted his own flat, we were told by every agency that I had to be a guarantor, and I had to be a homeowner myself

Circumferences · 12/08/2023 22:37

Just let her sort it out and work it out herself.

It's good that you've done some research of your own, but at the end of the day let her go out into the wild and find it all out for herself.
Tell her you'll always be there to support her.

Olivia199 · 12/08/2023 22:35

It will also depend on the type of landlord.

When I was 18 (10 years ago) I moved around 2 hours away from home to Bournemouth. I got my own 1 bed flat for £650 per month and at the time I was a HCA earning, iirc, £18k plus unsocial hours. Don't get me wrong, I had very very little at the end of each month but I made it work. I also changed jobs when I moved there but as I stayed with the NHS, it was a straight move. I just provided the letting agents with my signed contract of employment for the new role.

However, the things to note there are that renting was miles easier and cheaper (though your DD is on more than I was), I rented in a place where there was an abundance of properties, I had a fixed contract (0 hours is tricky - though some will take 6 months payslip and a guaruntor) and honestly I'm fairly sure working in the NHS gave me some credit. Also, I rented from a landlord who had 80+ properties. They weren't a couple renting out their other home and totally reliant on that money. Which I guess made them more lax with regards to who they rented to.

It wasn't easy by any means and I definitely had a learning curve and a half. But I had a really supportive family and the odd £20 tesco voucher in the post really helped me out.

In todays market, she'll likely find it quite difficult to find somewhere, but not necessarily impossible depending on the area.

I'd suggest possibly looking on OpenRent as I found the lack of estate agent helpful at the beginning (though did end up renting off rightmove).

Best she can do is enquire. If she finds somewhere then she'll likely make it work and eat a lot of beans on toast. It's all experience! If she can't find somewhere then it may help her lower her sights to a house share. I imagine she'll find it easier to adjust to that idea off her own back rather than being told she can't do it.

I wish you luck!!

TastesLikeStrawberriesOnASummerEvening · 12/08/2023 22:23

They know everything at that age, she'll figure it out.
I'm kinda glad mine sort of fell on her feet because she was a horror then!

Freshstarts23 · 12/08/2023 22:18

It doesn’t look like she’s going to have much luck getting her own flat. She won’t hear of it, so I’ll have to let her figure it out for herself but it’s looking like she’ll need to find a house share.

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 12/08/2023 21:53

bellac11 · 12/08/2023 19:37

If shes got any sense she would rent a bed sit/house share room, bills included, not liable for council tax, no need for guarantor, no need for massive deposit and rent up front too far in advance

Then she can start saving up for a flat of her own

She will have to pay council tax as she isn't a student, but she will get a 25% discount. she will need a guarantor as well, and have to pay a deposit.

I was wondering if they do affordability checks.

Yes they do. They also want the guarantor’s proof of income.
Most first year students are in halls and university manages halls don’t usually ask for a guarantor, but second and third year students need a guarantor.

DD is 23, but has lived in different students housing for the last three years. Although she earns enough to pay rent they still want a guarantor because she has only lived in each rental property for a year.

I suspect that posters saying they rented at 17/18 aren’t aware of how much the rental market has changed since they first rented. Rental properties are in short supply and it is very much a landlord’s market. They can be far more choosy about who they want as tenants.

KajsaKavat · 12/08/2023 21:50

Nice

TastesLikeStrawberriesOnASummerEvening · 12/08/2023 21:44

I'm talking about Glasgow BTW, not London, and a part with a not great reputation, but perfectly fine for them now, it's why they managed it and got a two bed which gives them a study, great for Covid/WFH.

JaukiVexnoydi · 12/08/2023 21:40

Alphabetica · 12/08/2023 20:51

Am I reading this right? 15 years ago I rented a room for £400 a month. Even at x30, I'd need to take home 12 grand a month. Surely but no one passes that affordability check?

I think it means annual take-home must be more than 30x monthly rent. So taking home £12k per year, £1,000 per month after tax, NI & pension.

User13986509 · 12/08/2023 21:38

I think if it wasn't London or the outskirts it would be a lot more feasible, where I live in the East Midlands, one bed flats are about £600 so perfectly doable. Is her job easily transferable as she mentioned getting another job

TastesLikeStrawberriesOnASummerEvening · 12/08/2023 21:36

KajsaKavat · 12/08/2023 21:28

3 years ago you could rent a 3 bedroom house for £1000-1200 here but now it’s £2000, so it’s probably gone up in your area too. I’m outside of London

Oh I assume it has gone up here, I haven't asked her, but her Bf now has his Masters and is working so their circumstances have changed, financially for the better, as will Dd's when she graduates.
Tbh, I think luck was on their side with their flat, but they were prepared to look outside of the popular student areas.

Swipe left for the next trending thread