Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Working class women and DV = kids removed. Celebrities and people with money - no involvement

152 replies

Redfoxs · 12/08/2023 18:20

I've known of multiple women to lose their children to adoption after failing to stay away from an abusive partner. It happens up and down the country all of the time. We all know that.

So why is it when somebody with money is involved, the services don't seem to care?

Case in point.

Dappy from Ndubz. He has a long history of abusing partners going way back to the mother of his eldest children. Multiple arrests, her posting images of her injuries online.

Fast forward to 2017 he's put in prison for attacking a more recent partner. The mother of his youngest children. In the home they share with their then baby daughter. A knife is involved and he needs to be restrainted by 4 members of the public before threatening to stab the police.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4499994/amp/Dappy-remanded-custody-attacked-partner.html

The girlfriend was all over social media calling him a narcissistic psychopath, drug abuser, violent, a danger..

As soon as Ndubz make a comeback she's moved him back in with her and the kids, is accompanying him on the tours, having spats with another woman who he was seeing in the interim and singing his praises as though he's the best thing since sliced bread.

Who is safeguarding those children then?

If this all happened before the fame then those children would have likely been removed long before the incident for which he was imprisoned.

Social services don't always get it right. There have been times I've completely disagreed with them, I am most definitely not advocating for mass forced adoption but come on.. what's with the disparity?

Risk is risk, isn't it?

Does having money in the bank make it less likely that children will suffer emotional (at the very least) harm?

Why is it OK for people with money to abuse drugs and behave in a domestically violent way and their lives go on uninterrupted but your run of the mill working class couple down the road get hauled into court and their children removed.

AIBU?

Dappy is remanded in custody over allegations he attacked girlfriend

The 29-year-old (pictured in 2013) - real name Costas Contostavlos - appeared in custody today after being arrested on Wednesday for allegedly attacking Imani Campbell in Hatfield, Hertfordshire.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4499994/amp/Dappy-remanded-custody-attacked-partner.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Redfoxs · 12/08/2023 20:23

Freepo · 12/08/2023 19:45

Big assumption that there was no SS involvement with the McCann’s surviving children. We know they weren’t removed. We don’t know what other involvement there may have been - it’s confidential.

OP, as someone who used to work in the child protection sector (legal), I can absolutely promise you there are fuckloads of working class families where there is DV whose children aren’t removed from their care. I agree that there is prejudice against working class parents, but “children are removed from low income families if there is so much of a sniff of somebody returning to an abusive partner” is a total exaggeration because from experience I can think of a fuckkton of cases I’ve been involved with where it hasn’t happened. There may have been a working agreement or some other involvement, but not removal at the mere “sniff” of DV.

Apologies if you feel that comment was an exaggeration, I'm coming from a place of seeing exactly that play out among people I know.

Small town, deprived area, everybody knows everybody.

At the point of writing I know (particularly well) one young-ish mum who has had her 4 children removed because she allowed her ex to have contact. We're not even talking about them getting back together, just contact with the children.

She is a good mother in general, no neglect whatsoever, but she was ordered not to allow contact because the father and his new partner were both violent to each other and there had been police involvement.

Against her better judgement, obviously she should not have done it, she let him have their children overnight.

It's looking as though she will get them back, atleast the older ones, but would somebody like Kate Mccan have the same experience?

Another mum I know has spent the past 10 years meandering purgatory after losing her first and only child to adoption due to domestic violence (against her)

Three other women spring to mind as I'm writing this.

Of course I can only speak about a small (in the grand scheme of things) number of cases I know about personally - but I do know it happens and is definitely not rare.

Unfortunately when it comes to social services it's sometimes a post code lottery IME, and this isn't a 'bashing social services in general' thread as I've had the pleasure of meeting one or two fantastic social workers over the years (and I'm certain there are many more)

Thank you for confirming the prejudice and bias against people from lower socioeconomic backgrounds. I think it's hugely positive that somebody with your professional background and direct experience will acknowledge that.

I did a cursory search on MN to see whether this topic had been discussed before and came across this comment on one thread which made for sobering reading.

(I am middle class. I have left children (lawfully) in the room whilst going to eat at a centre on holiday abroad. The McCanns did nothing wrong. I don't accept criticism of them or me for that matter.)

OP posts:
Freepo · 12/08/2023 19:45

Big assumption that there was no SS involvement with the McCann’s surviving children. We know they weren’t removed. We don’t know what other involvement there may have been - it’s confidential.

OP, as someone who used to work in the child protection sector (legal), I can absolutely promise you there are fuckloads of working class families where there is DV whose children aren’t removed from their care. I agree that there is prejudice against working class parents, but “children are removed from low income families if there is so much of a sniff of somebody returning to an abusive partner” is a total exaggeration because from experience I can think of a fuckkton of cases I’ve been involved with where it hasn’t happened. There may have been a working agreement or some other involvement, but not removal at the mere “sniff” of DV.

stayathomer · 12/08/2023 19:38

There was a researcher into domestic violence on the radio one day, he said sadly kids who live through domestic violence that have mc family are more likely to be left with the family and also guards more likely to not push as hard because at least the parents will feed, clothe and educate them, and will be looking to keep up appearances. The other thing is the person being abused is more likely to stay l, and as he was saying less likely to press charges because they won’t want to face being made homeless

StackBlocks · 12/08/2023 19:34

I had an interesting meeting with my HV whilst pregnant with my first DC when we lived in our old house in the rough part of town. I got a lecture about not shaking the baby if I got angry, I was a bit 🤨 ok, yeah I know. But when we got onto child benefit and I mentioned I was not eligible due to my income (which the HV did not believe at first!) her demeanour completely changed, like somehow I was a more worthy parent due to my income? I noticed a definite shift in attitude.

Bebabelouba · 12/08/2023 19:32

Sadly I think I agree with this. I often wonder how many parents would be able to continue to care for their children if they had access to boarding school and holiday clubs...

OneRingToRuleThemAll · 12/08/2023 19:31

I was referred for asd assessments for my children and provided heaps of support (council funded adaptations and senco support) when they came back positive.

Friends I know who are struggling for the same reason were sent to parenting classes.

BlossomCloud · 12/08/2023 19:29

Reugny · 12/08/2023 19:04

I'm not allowed to go into detail but there is a lot of racial discrimination as well..

SS get shocked if they find they are dealing with well educated black people. These cases don't tend to end up in court even though they make a lot of unreasonable threats.

Such a good point. Hugely unfair and unacceptable

BlossomCloud · 12/08/2023 19:28

PTSDBarbiegirl · 12/08/2023 19:26

'Wine O'clock' with prosecco at 3pm in a sunny garden after school run = middle class frivolity

Can of beer in a high rise after collecting kids from school on summers day = working class 'Alcoholic wasters'

Quite

PTSDBarbiegirl · 12/08/2023 19:26

'Wine O'clock' with prosecco at 3pm in a sunny garden after school run = middle class frivolity

Can of beer in a high rise after collecting kids from school on summers day = working class 'Alcoholic wasters'

Redfoxs · 12/08/2023 19:25

LuvSmallDogs · 12/08/2023 19:14

@Redfoxs the McCann case is disgusting. They and their friends were all at it, leaving their kids and drinking. Any reasonable friend group would suggest some sort of rota for staying in with other couple's kids sleeping over or whatever. No, people shouldn't expect a predator to be snatching kids out their beds, but the kids were the sort of age where they could wander out and drown in a pool or get lost or turn a hob on with something on top etc.

Indeed.

I can't align myself their attitude at all. The thought of my children being left unattended at that age would spark complete panic. How can you have a good time if you know your children aren't safe?

That is one of many questions the authorities should have been asking upon their return.

OP posts:
LuvSmallDogs · 12/08/2023 19:14

@Redfoxs the McCann case is disgusting. They and their friends were all at it, leaving their kids and drinking. Any reasonable friend group would suggest some sort of rota for staying in with other couple's kids sleeping over or whatever. No, people shouldn't expect a predator to be snatching kids out their beds, but the kids were the sort of age where they could wander out and drown in a pool or get lost or turn a hob on with something on top etc.

Redfoxs · 12/08/2023 19:06

Reugny · 12/08/2023 19:04

I'm not allowed to go into detail but there is a lot of racial discrimination as well..

SS get shocked if they find they are dealing with well educated black people. These cases don't tend to end up in court even though they make a lot of unreasonable threats.

I completely believe it.

OP posts:
OP posts:
Reugny · 12/08/2023 19:04

WenchEyeBall · 12/08/2023 18:54

You're absolutely right. Higher levels of education and a professional job also seem to be barriers to intervention.
They don't have the resources to safeguard everyone and prioritise based on stereotypes

I'm not allowed to go into detail but there is a lot of racial discrimination as well..

SS get shocked if they find they are dealing with well educated black people. These cases don't tend to end up in court even though they make a lot of unreasonable threats.

Redfoxs · 12/08/2023 19:00

Ifeelsuchflutterings · 12/08/2023 18:54

My mum got away with abusing my in plain sight my entire childhood because she had a decent office job and a nice house

I've been told on MN recently that that wouldn't happen nowadays but I absolutely don't believe it. I think many abused children slip through the nets if their parents are middle class enough.

You see it on the threads from middle class people who do end up dealing with social services as well. they always start off with how they have professional jobs etc as if somehow that means that they can't possibly be abusive and they are outraged that social services could possibly think they are bad parents.

I'm so sorry.

This is exactly it. Voices like yours are so important when it comes to topics like this one.

If it's not bad enough you had to suffer that abuse you are then insulted by people saying it wouldn't happen now, things have changed.

Things haven't changed at all. Social services are still going after the low income families (rightly so in lots of cases I'm sure) meanwhile the children from more "privileged" backgrounds are forgotten about because, well, money.

The stately homes threads are full of people like you, sadly, and I only wish that it was different.

OP posts:
Redfoxs · 12/08/2023 18:55

Lkahsvtv · 12/08/2023 18:47

I do notice in my job that most people who have long term social services involvement are on a low income; I think it comes down to some people being better at hiding it, money for solicitors to put councils off, money to spend on things like nannies which can act as protective factors for people who have substance misuse problems and simple prejudice as well

I completely agree.

It's blatant classism.

No government led organisation who's sole purpose is to protect the defenceless should have caveats according to income or class.

People on benefits are easy targets and low hanging fruit.

OP posts:
WenchEyeBall · 12/08/2023 18:54

You're absolutely right. Higher levels of education and a professional job also seem to be barriers to intervention.
They don't have the resources to safeguard everyone and prioritise based on stereotypes

Ifeelsuchflutterings · 12/08/2023 18:54

My mum got away with abusing my in plain sight my entire childhood because she had a decent office job and a nice house

I've been told on MN recently that that wouldn't happen nowadays but I absolutely don't believe it. I think many abused children slip through the nets if their parents are middle class enough.

You see it on the threads from middle class people who do end up dealing with social services as well. they always start off with how they have professional jobs etc as if somehow that means that they can't possibly be abusive and they are outraged that social services could possibly think they are bad parents.

Lkahsvtv · 12/08/2023 18:49

I would add that I notice this in health professionals attitude to co sleeping; middle class mums are given the advice how to do this safely whereas lower income mums are criticised for it

Lkahsvtv · 12/08/2023 18:47

I do notice in my job that most people who have long term social services involvement are on a low income; I think it comes down to some people being better at hiding it, money for solicitors to put councils off, money to spend on things like nannies which can act as protective factors for people who have substance misuse problems and simple prejudice as well

Redfoxs · 12/08/2023 18:45

BlossomCloud · 12/08/2023 18:36

The judge literally used the words "middle class" to describe why my ex H could still see the children despite his unspeakably awful behaviour.

It's grim and unfair and leaves children very vulnerable

I'm so sorry, it's just wrong.

One of my good friends has had to deal with the same, bar the judges comments.

Her ex was abusive and takes cocaine but none of that was a factor in awarding him joint unsupervised contact. I can only assume that is because he has a good job and money (neither of which meant he was any less a nasty piece of work)

I really feel for her having to wave off their DD every weekend as she spends the duration worrying whether he will drive under the influence or Lord knows what else.

You have my complete sympathy.

OP posts:
Redfoxs · 12/08/2023 18:40

LuvSmallDogs · 12/08/2023 18:31

Two doctors leaving three preschoolers in a holiday flat in a foreign country to have a meal and get pissed, resulting in one of the children getting abducted - no SS involvement with the surviving children.

Whereas I know of a working class woman who worked nights around her DP's hours so he could look after their baby, not realising he was going to the nearby pub and leaving the baby in her cot until SS came knocking. It took her a bit to shake them off (and yes, she did immediately chuck her DP).

This is a really good comparison to highlight.

The double standard is appalling.

Two well off parents make an absolutely shit choice to endanger their children which results in the abduction and (presumed) death of one. They return to the UK and have no court case against them for neglect.

Vs

One working class mother goes off to work believing that the babies father is caring for the baby as he should, only to then discover he's negligent and promptly chuck him out, as she should, only to then be dragged through a system and likely traumatised for something that was categorically not her fault.

The disparity really angers me.

OP posts:
Redfoxs · 12/08/2023 18:36

TeaKitten · 12/08/2023 18:30

How do you no social services haven’t been involved?

They still have custody of them, for a start.

"Bob and Sue" down the road wouldn't have.

I'm from a very working class background in a deprived area and know of plenty of cases where there has been SS involvement and subsequent removal for much less than what was detailed in the newspaper link above.

I know, with complete certainty, that children are removed from low income families if there is so much of a sniff of somebody returning to an abusive partner, nevermind moving them back in and following them around the country on tours.

OP posts:
BlossomCloud · 12/08/2023 18:36

The judge literally used the words "middle class" to describe why my ex H could still see the children despite his unspeakably awful behaviour.

It's grim and unfair and leaves children very vulnerable

LuvSmallDogs · 12/08/2023 18:31

Two doctors leaving three preschoolers in a holiday flat in a foreign country to have a meal and get pissed, resulting in one of the children getting abducted - no SS involvement with the surviving children.

Whereas I know of a working class woman who worked nights around her DP's hours so he could look after their baby, not realising he was going to the nearby pub and leaving the baby in her cot until SS came knocking. It took her a bit to shake them off (and yes, she did immediately chuck her DP).

Swipe left for the next trending thread