Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel this down about early getups

316 replies

Itsthemornings · 12/08/2023 16:46

So we have a nearly 3 yo and newborn. Nearly 3yo wakes at 5 or half four every single day. Thought this might have got better when he dropped his nap but it hasn’t.

Nothing seems to make any difference, and I don’t really understand it as he’s tired but can’t get him back to sleep. It’s always been tough but now with a newborn the level of sleep deprivation is horrendous.

If you had an early waker, when did it improve? I don’t want him to stay in bed until 9 or anything but 6/half 6 would be fine.

OP posts:
Merrow · 13/08/2023 09:42

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:21

Only about 9 months to go then! And then the other will probably start 😀

If it provides a glimmer of hope DS1 is now a fantastic sleeper - goes down happily at 7pm and doesn't come out of his room until 7.20 (which is admittedly the result of the gro clock, but his natural wake up time has shifted so that 6.30 is unusually early, whereas at 3 5.30 was a lie in for us).

mondaytosunday · 13/08/2023 09:42

Um, no. My son rarely made to 6am. He's 20 now, and even on his days off is up and about by 8am. On a work day he's up at 6 and off to the gym before work. High energy.
My daughter (18) on the other hand will happily sleep til noon, and didn't like mornings much as a baby either.

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:40

@Delatron we have been through this <groan>

@Userhay I am sorry if this has upset you, I genuinely am. But I have also found your posts extremely upsetting. You keep insisting there is all this stuff I could try and haven’t. That isn’t true, and it’s very frustrating because to be very blunt, someone making things up is annoying at the best of times, and when you’re sleep deprived anyway it is very annoying.

I went through your posts last night. You recommended audiobooks for him to listen to, a train set for DS to play with in his bedroom, going for a walk, or CBeebies. I’ve explained these aren’t solutions but for some reason you keep coming back and saying ‘but I have suggested things and you just won’t try them.’

I am not trying to upset you. But I am finding your posts baffling.

OP posts:
TropicalTrama · 13/08/2023 09:40

If you tried it at 19 months and he’s now nearly 3 then that’s so long ago I wouldn’t class that as having tried it at all. He has better speech and understanding now, his naps are different, I’m guessing he’s no longer in the cot, he now has a sibling etc.

Personally so long as I know all their needs are met and they’re safe then I ignore attention seeking tantrums, that goes for all tantrums not just morning ones. So I would go in once to check they’re ok, tell them it’s still sleep time, then leave and not go back in until 6am. They weren’t locked in but there was a tall stairgate on the door so not much difference. I used to watch them on the video monitor too. I know it’s method that isn’t for everyone, a bit like cry based sleep training but it’s a big big stretch to say it’s abusive. And it’s something clearly you haven’t tried since you only did going in at regular intervals or sitting in a dark room with him when he was 1. If you don’t want to that’s fine of course! If you just want a rant because it’s shit and you’re you too knackered with a newborn to try anything new then that’s also fine! Good luck to you, however long it takes it won’t last forever and you really are in the worst of it right now x

Delatron · 13/08/2023 09:35

A 3 year old is not crying because they are helpless. They want your attention. They are safe, warm, - you can check if they’re not hungry and thirsty or need the toilet. And if all those needs have been met then the crying is for your attention.

If you can’t bear to hear your toddler crying for a bit then that’s ok. But the body clock will not shift if you keep getting up at that time. So you need to make peace with that and work around it.

I don’t think it’s healthy for anybody - child or adult to get up at that time and it’s hugely disruptive so would deal with a bit of crying to sort it out.

Userhay · 13/08/2023 09:34

Ok, I really am out. I’m an NHS professional with 25 years experience working with parents. I was posting here as a mum. I’m sure you’re much less rude in real life but you’re sounding like an (overtired) bully here.

There are lots of things you can try (or try again). But this is clearly not what you’re here for.

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:28

Let’s turn that on its head. What are you posting for, then?

OP posts:
Iamclearlyamug · 13/08/2023 09:27

Itsthemornings · 12/08/2023 17:46

I wish people would just accept that the options are

  1. ignore him. He screams and eventually someone rescues him so he’s still learned screaming gets him what he wants.
  2. put him to bed in the garage
  3. just try to cope as best we can.

Sorry I don't really understand what you're posting for then.

If those are (truly) the only options, then you'll have to pick one and deal with it

If you're just looking for sympathy - you have it. It sucks, but it will get better at some point, probably once at school

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:26

I’ve never locked him in @TropicalTrama

What was initially recommended was go in, firmly say it’s night time, lie down. Then keep going back in every two minutes then five.

So duly tried it. DS (then aged 19 months) was standing in his cot smiling and holding his arms out saying ‘mama.’ He sobbed when I said it’s night time lie down. I went out and he wailed and cried and cried. Repeat. Repeat. Repeat. A week later yes, we did knock that on the head.

Second recommendation was to get him up but to sit in a dark room with him. Didn’t work. He was up and raring to go.

And then the adjusting bedtimes and naps and all the tweaks things. Nothings made a difference.

And it is abusive to lock someone helpless somewhere and ignore their cries. Why, do you think it’s not?

OP posts:
TropicalTrama · 13/08/2023 09:22

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:15

@TropicalTrama we have. It isn’t a new problem and I’m so tired of repeating this.

Ah sorry - you were comparing the locking him in his room to elder abuse so I had assumed from that you were horrified by the idea so would never actually try it, certainly not with any consistency. If you’ve done something you personally view as that abhorrent you must really have tried everything. I’m not sure you what you want from this thread really… If genuinely nothing works then that’s that isn’t it. But they grow up and things change so just because brute force or bribery doesn’t work now does that doesn’t mean that it won’t in the future. 2 is quite little for bribes but most 3 year olds really get it! So good luck to you and don’t be afraid to revisit things that may not have worked for you previously.

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:21

Merrow · 13/08/2023 09:20

The big change in DS1 was when he actually started interacting with his peers rather than just playing alongside. There was a big change at around 3 and a half. Physical exertion doesn't seem to do much for his sleep, but the mental exertion definitely does. Moving from nursery to preschool really knocked him out.

Only about 9 months to go then! And then the other will probably start 😀

OP posts:
Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:20

@Userhay i am choosing to. Like you are choosing to reply.

OP posts:
Merrow · 13/08/2023 09:20

The big change in DS1 was when he actually started interacting with his peers rather than just playing alongside. There was a big change at around 3 and a half. Physical exertion doesn't seem to do much for his sleep, but the mental exertion definitely does. Moving from nursery to preschool really knocked him out.

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:20

@Userhay i thought you gave up last night. Neither of us are helping the other. I wasn’t very irritated but having to repeat myself three times, as if you thought I was lying or misunderstood, was exasperating and quite exhausting. Your advice may be well meaning but it’s not very practical or helpful.

OP posts:
Userhay · 13/08/2023 09:20

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:11

Well it is @waterrat but that’s because he’s up at 5. If bedtime is at 8, he’s still up at 5, so that’s where we’re at.

I got a fair bit of stick for supposed rudeness but honestly how many times are posters supposed to type the same message, over and over?

You don’t have to reply again and again to the same points made by different people. Not everyone will rtft.

Goldencup · 13/08/2023 09:18

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 08:50

Sleep consultants can be helpful. We actually had one to break the habit of waking in the night which followed a nasty illness when ds1 (still feels funny writing that) was just over one. Six months later it was still a problem and we (I) got one. It got him sleeping through but it was then the early wakeups started. I have tried what is recommended by them of course and a lot of it is earlier bedtimes which hasn’t given us any joy.

I think a lot of you really didn’t read the OP properly and did miss the fact there is a brand new baby in the house (and the newborn is extremely new indeed.) I was ratty last night but when you say ‘he’s not really interested in CBeebies’ and are met with incredulity or ‘he wouldn’t follow an audiobook’ and are told he’s clearly got special needs when you’re functioning on about 2 hours broken sleep - I think I’d be exonerated by any jury for the unforgivable crime of not following MN helpful advice.

There are kind, supportive and understanding women here but there’s also some who are just unpleasant people. I’m sure this will be met with spluttering and squawking about how rude this is but it’s true.

Yeah, and I’m not locking my child into a bedroom. Honestly, some of the advice on here is both insane or cruel.

You say your newborn is very new. Reading that reminded me that DS went through a shocking early waking phase when Dd was less than 2 months old. Her birthday is October and I remember cutting out paper pumpkins at 6:30. Looking back I think it was when he could get guaranteed 121 time with me. I always did the early starts as DH stayed up to midnight to her Dd her dream feed.

I was lucky that:
a) I am a bit of a lark anyway
and
b) I honestly think Dd only ever had one night feed after her 11pm bottle around 3-4am.

I did go to bed at 8:30 or 9 so had 6 or 7 hours before Dd woke.

I also had an afternoon nap on DS nursery days until she was 10 weeks ish.

💐

Jamtartforme · 13/08/2023 09:18

There are many people out there - childless not by choice - who would give anything to be in your situation with two little ones. Be grateful for what you have

🤦🏼‍♀️

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:18

I remember reading that about bananas. Unfortunately we’re on a banana strike here for some unknown reason!

OP posts:
Userhay · 13/08/2023 09:17

OP, I think you’re missing the point that it’s quite frustrating to be responding to someone who is clearly struggling but shoots down every suggestion with “that doesn’t work” and “you have a comprehension problem.”

You seem to be very irritated that I initially was surprised that a 3 year old didn’t like CBeebies. I wasn’t trying to annoy you. Genuinely don’t meet many children who don’t like it.

If people offer well meaning advice that has tried and failed, try not to shoot them down. I get you’re feeling bad but it’s coming across as quite rude and angry.

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:17

He is @babbscrabbs . But ds1 still wakes me up. I can’t really have earplugs on with a newborn waking to be fed in the night and besides, an elbow in your face is a pretty effective alarm clock.

OP posts:
Tortoisetowers · 13/08/2023 09:16

Or a banana is a great bedtime snack as they have something in which promotea sleep. I've only just remembered about that working wonders with my firstborn, so I'll try it tonight with the younger one who has gone off weetabix 🤣

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:15

@TropicalTrama we have. It isn’t a new problem and I’m so tired of repeating this.

OP posts:
babbscrabbs · 13/08/2023 09:15

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 07:34

Dh is good but DS is so noisy he inevitably wakes both of us up. He also likes to see us both so even if he wasn’t so loud we’d still be aware of his glorious presence. Totally getting revenge when he’s a teenager!

DH needs to get up with DS every day if you're doing night feeds, and get him downstairs asap to minimise you waking. Wear earplugs if you need to or invest in some sound muffling stuff for your bedroom door. Hopefully you'll be able too drop off again if DH is on it.

TropicalTrama · 13/08/2023 09:12

If you don’t want to force him to stay in his room then fine! But equally you can’t dismiss it as not working until you’ve tried it for 2 weeks. I think it took 4 days ish for us to see an improvement and maybe 10 days to get to an acceptable wake up time. I don’t think it has any comparison with an incontinent elderly relative at all (??)- good quality sleep and being well rested is essential for the well being of all the household including him.

Itsthemornings · 13/08/2023 09:11

He’s funny with toast - doesn’t eat it or bread really. Peanut butter sandwich could work: he likes peanut butter.

OP posts: