Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I tell kids they have half siblings

110 replies

Uniqueusername2 · 11/08/2023 18:17

My ex husband had kids from a previous relationship he lost touch with when they became teens and the mother refused access. He recently had a health scare and reached out to them (now adults) but they didn’t respond.
We have 2 kids together who are now also teenagers. My ex doesn’t want to tell them
about their half siblings. I have told him he should as I don’t like keeping secrets from them, but I don’t feel it’s my place to tell them. But I worry about them finding out, at his funeral or some other way, and my kids being angry I didn’t tell them when he was alive so they could ask him about them.
aibu to want him to tell them, or do you think I should keep the secret as they may never find out ?
yabu - it’s not your place to tell them
yanbu - they have a right to know

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheFormidableMrsC · 12/08/2023 21:52

LocoCocoa · 12/08/2023 21:04

@TheFormidableMrsC I often think of him, I don’t know if he knows he has siblings or if he knows his father is dead. I know his name from the CSA info and have tried to look him up since ex died, out of curiosity, I suppose. I suppose also wondering if contact would be possible, but found nothing.

Unfortunately ds1 doesn’t get any outside support and hasn’t since lockdown, when services eventually restarted he refused to engage. Ds2 is now also on the pathway for diagnosis and also in bereavement counselling atm. They have both been broken since their dad died, I’m terrified to make things worse.

Of course, an absolute nightmare for you. I wonder if this is something you could put to the bereavement counsellor and see if they might be able to offer advice? Is there a school family liaison officer? Ours was absolutely amazing during my own experience. It's worth asking I think?

Uniqueusername2 · 12/08/2023 21:07

That’s ok :-)
it’s something I’ve been struggling with more and more as they get older.

OP posts:
LocoCocoa · 12/08/2023 21:04

@TheFormidableMrsC I often think of him, I don’t know if he knows he has siblings or if he knows his father is dead. I know his name from the CSA info and have tried to look him up since ex died, out of curiosity, I suppose. I suppose also wondering if contact would be possible, but found nothing.

Unfortunately ds1 doesn’t get any outside support and hasn’t since lockdown, when services eventually restarted he refused to engage. Ds2 is now also on the pathway for diagnosis and also in bereavement counselling atm. They have both been broken since their dad died, I’m terrified to make things worse.

TheFormidableMrsC · 12/08/2023 20:52

@LocoCocoa pressed send too soon! Is there anybody you can discuss this with? Does your son get any support outside the home?

TheFormidableMrsC · 12/08/2023 20:51

@LocoCocoa what an awful situation for you. Also for the abandoned child who is only going to face horrible news. I don't know how your begin to navigate that. Ultimately, none of this is your fault and you were very young. No judgement from me with that (I do judge grown ass OW in my case who only wanted her son around and not mine!).

SaraJaneb · 12/08/2023 20:40

It actually is your duty to tell them and his. The kids or their decendents might meet in future so it's important to know who is related to who. Genetic mutual attraction is a thing, so honesty is the best policy.

LocoCocoa · 12/08/2023 20:28

Also, apologies @Uniqueusername2 I don’t mean to impose on your thread, just haven’t seen this topic come up before and sadly relate.

LocoCocoa · 12/08/2023 20:23

TheFormidableMrsC · 12/08/2023 20:10

@LocoCocoa I get it. It's awful that you're in this position. I find this subject very upsetting because my ex husband has abandoned our son who has now been airbrushed out of existence. My son is also autistic and the impact on him has been horrific. Further, my ex husbands father did this too and two adult children appeared years later. It didn't end well. My sympathies lay with them as they had been treated so badly. Perhaps take some advice on how to approach this. I don't have any answers, I've seen both sides. I'm sorry you're having to navigate this Flowers

Thank you for your kind comment, I’m really sorry that your sons father has done this, it must be awful for him.

I was only 16 when I met ex dh, he told me the child wasn’t his and teenage me believed it. It was several years later after ds2 was born that a CSA mandated DNA test proved it was his child. Dh wasn’t interested, I had 2 young children and we lived hundreds of miles away, I admit I put it out my mind. We split up 2 years later and I never thought much of it until last year when ex dh took his own life. It’s not an easy call to make, perhaps it would be easier if ds’s were neurotypical.

TheFormidableMrsC · 12/08/2023 20:10

@LocoCocoa I get it. It's awful that you're in this position. I find this subject very upsetting because my ex husband has abandoned our son who has now been airbrushed out of existence. My son is also autistic and the impact on him has been horrific. Further, my ex husbands father did this too and two adult children appeared years later. It didn't end well. My sympathies lay with them as they had been treated so badly. Perhaps take some advice on how to approach this. I don't have any answers, I've seen both sides. I'm sorry you're having to navigate this Flowers

Blackberriesbob · 12/08/2023 19:38

And obviously you have to tell them. Piss poor parenting to keep secrets like that.

Blackberriesbob · 12/08/2023 19:37

I'm amazed he thinks they would care about his health situation if he abandoned them.

DelphiniumBlue · 12/08/2023 18:37

NewName122 · 12/08/2023 12:32

Also a mother refusing a dad access to 2 teenagers sounds like a pile of rubbish, do you not think?

Absoloutely.
My DC have a great relationship with their Dad. If we had separated while they were teenagers, there was no way they would have gone along with a ban on seeing their father, and it would have been impossible to enforce.
There is social media, mobile phones, other family members....if those teenagers wanted to see their dad, they would have done, even if it meant waiting till 18 to preserve the peace.
I do however know fathers who have flounced off, saying if their wife insists on a separation, they will never see her or the DC again. And stuck to it. I know fathers who have refused to compromise on dates and times, or travel, or money, who lost contact with their children because of their own stupid pride not allowing them to negotiate, the sort of guy who has to have things their way or not at all.
I know which I think is more likely.
OP, tell the children, sooner rather than later. No good will come from lies and hiding the truth.

keffie12 · 12/08/2023 18:26

Uniqueusername2 · 11/08/2023 18:17

My ex husband had kids from a previous relationship he lost touch with when they became teens and the mother refused access. He recently had a health scare and reached out to them (now adults) but they didn’t respond.
We have 2 kids together who are now also teenagers. My ex doesn’t want to tell them
about their half siblings. I have told him he should as I don’t like keeping secrets from them, but I don’t feel it’s my place to tell them. But I worry about them finding out, at his funeral or some other way, and my kids being angry I didn’t tell them when he was alive so they could ask him about them.
aibu to want him to tell them, or do you think I should keep the secret as they may never find out ?
yabu - it’s not your place to tell them
yanbu - they have a right to know

Tell them. I was not told about my late father previous marriage nor the two sons he had.

I'm not going to do the back story as it's too messy and complex.

I found out about my bro's when I was 36. The years of secrets, lies, etc. will destroy you all.

It is every bit their business. The train of destruction my dad left behind would fill a book.

It's what I'd known as "Family Secrets: what you don't know can hurt you"

Reugny · 12/08/2023 18:20

I've heard some upsetting stories from people I know and have met finding out they have one or more half-siblings as adults.

In one case a guy I knew found out he had an older brother about 8 months before the brother died of cancer. The only good thing is that he was there at the end for his brother.

So please tell your children. It is then up to them whether they do anything with this information, and if they do when.

Hellsbellsandspidersankles · 12/08/2023 18:14

Uniqueusername2 · 12/08/2023 18:00

This is partly why I’ve been reluctant to go against his wishes and tell them. I don’t want to spoil the relationship they have that we’ve managed to maintain since we broke up and there have been plenty of other things we’ve had to navigate.
but it’s coming up to the deadline I gave myself to tell them if he hadn’t. I just hope they understand why it took so long to tell them.

It’s going to be infinitely better coming from him, op. But I appreciate you have no control over that.

AvidMerrian · 12/08/2023 18:12

Uniqueusername2 · 11/08/2023 19:48

Thanks for the replies. I don’t even know if they know he had more kids but we live in a different country so the chances of them meeting by chance are small.
Ive brought it up many times but he would get upset or shut the conversation down. I really don’t think it’s up to me to tell them but I don’t think he ever will. I feel caught between two bad options - don’t tell them and be the bad guy if they find out, or tell them and upset everyone for no reason.
it’s good to get some outside perspective.

As someone else alluded to, I’d be wondering who else he is coercing into keeping his secret-cousins, other aunts and uncles, old work colleagues.

It will come out, inevitably at a funeral or some family occasion. Just tell them.

Batalax · 12/08/2023 18:04

You need to tell him he has to tell them or you will, and it would be better coming from him.

They should have grown up always knowing about them so it wasn’t a shock to find out.

Uniqueusername2 · 12/08/2023 18:00

This is partly why I’ve been reluctant to go against his wishes and tell them. I don’t want to spoil the relationship they have that we’ve managed to maintain since we broke up and there have been plenty of other things we’ve had to navigate.
but it’s coming up to the deadline I gave myself to tell them if he hadn’t. I just hope they understand why it took so long to tell them.

OP posts:
TheCyclingGorilla · 12/08/2023 15:32

I know of a family in this situation. I know there's an "eldest son" but the children don't know he exists. All us older people either in the family or older friends of said family know. Ultimately it's the father who needs to fess up, not me or any of the friends/relatives, so we have to keep the secret from the younger children. It's a shitty situation which is why I do my best not to socialise with the father too much, plus the fact I don't like him in general.

BrawnWild · 12/08/2023 14:23

It looks like a pattern. How long before he cant be bothered with your kids and tells a new woman that you wont let him see them?

BrawnWild · 12/08/2023 14:22

Tell them. They are blood relatives and come before your ex husband. Theybhave a chance to build bonds with family.

He probably failed the first set of kids and doesnt want anyone to know.

LocoCocoa · 12/08/2023 14:02

TheFormidableMrsC · 12/08/2023 10:58

You tell him. Obviously. Be prepared for him to be very angry though. I just don't understand why anybody thinks it's ok to airbrush a child out of their life.

It's not a decision I can take lightly, ds is almost 18 but also ASD and although most people cannot tell it definitely affects his understanding. He has taken the death of his father extremely hard and the last year has been awful, things are only just settling down with him. Tbh I'm furious that I've been put in this position as well as everything else.

monsteramunch · 12/08/2023 13:01

My ex husband had kids from a previous relationship he lost touch with when they became teens and the mother refused access.

Then he should have gone to court and fought for access. What a poor excuse for a father walking away because the mother was being difficult. From children whose lives he had been present in for over a decade. Ugh.

NewName122 · 12/08/2023 12:32

Also a mother refusing a dad access to 2 teenagers sounds like a pile of rubbish, do you not think?

zingally · 12/08/2023 12:31

They WILL find out eventually.

It's better to tell them now, under controlled conditions.