Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think NHS sickness recording is daft?

38 replies

summergreens · 11/08/2023 17:07

So my NHS Trust like all of them thinks it has a problem with sickness absence and has the usual return to work / ongoing monitoring. Fair enough.

I'm rarely off sick so it mostly passes me by.

But I've discovered today that they are counting calendar days not working days when calculating absences.

I'm not paid to work Friday Saturday or Sunday, or Bank Holidays. Yet if I'm sick those days count towards sickness absence?

I'm worried that if I apply for another job the new employer will get a wrong idea.

For example if I was off off Tuesday & Wednesday with a bad cold is 2 days absent. But in my case if I'm off Thurs and back the following Tuesday that's still two working days missed, but the Trust records it as 5 days.

Am I wrong or are they?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Neverseenbefore · 11/08/2023 21:54

dailymums · 11/08/2023 19:23

@Neverseenbefore no they shouldn't be asking because than you can claim disability discrimination.

People get ill, you shouldn't be asking how many sick days someone has taken.

Well, they can ask, and do, and are completely entitled to ask. There’s no “shouldn’t” about it. There’s no disability discrimination. I speak as someone who is disabled.

Neverseenbefore · 11/08/2023 21:51

WimbyAce · 11/08/2023 20:50

I seem to be confusing people with this. I mean in NHS you have entitlement to paid time off for sickness. Eg if you are off sick you are still paid. This starts from 1 month full pay and 1 month half pay when you start and it goes up to a maximum of 6 months full 6 half when you have completed 5 years of service. Every employee gets the same entitlement whether they are full time or 15 hours a week. Hence when sickness is recorded it will record non working days and weekends etc. Sickness works on a rolling year so will depend on how much you have been off in that year for what you have remaining.

Well, yes, that’s pretty standard - except for the six months’ paid sickness absence. I see now you mean paid sickness absence, not sickness entitlement, which would be something very different.

WimbyAce · 11/08/2023 21:03

For clarity :

Scale of allowances

14.2 Employees absent from work owing to illness will be entitled, subject to the conditions of this agreement, to receive sick pay in accordance with the scale below (see Section 12 for provisions on reckonable service):

during the first year of service – one month’s full pay and two months’ half pay
during the second year of service – two months’ full pay and two months’ half pay
during the third year of service – four months’ full pay and four months’ half pay
during the fourth and fifth years of service – five months’ full pay and five months’ half pay
after completing five years of service – six months’ full pay and six months’ half pay.

WimbyAce · 11/08/2023 20:50

Neverseenbefore · 11/08/2023 19:08

What do you mean by a sickness entitlement? I’ve never heard of such a thing.

I seem to be confusing people with this. I mean in NHS you have entitlement to paid time off for sickness. Eg if you are off sick you are still paid. This starts from 1 month full pay and 1 month half pay when you start and it goes up to a maximum of 6 months full 6 half when you have completed 5 years of service. Every employee gets the same entitlement whether they are full time or 15 hours a week. Hence when sickness is recorded it will record non working days and weekends etc. Sickness works on a rolling year so will depend on how much you have been off in that year for what you have remaining.

dailymums · 11/08/2023 19:23

@Neverseenbefore no they shouldn't be asking because than you can claim disability discrimination.

People get ill, you shouldn't be asking how many sick days someone has taken.

Neverseenbefore · 11/08/2023 19:17

dailymums · 11/08/2023 19:12

@summergreens job references shouldn't be asking for sick days....

Yes, they can. It’s quite a normal request. Employers don’t have to answer, though.

dailymums · 11/08/2023 19:12

@summergreens job references shouldn't be asking for sick days....

Neverseenbefore · 11/08/2023 19:10

summergreens · 11/08/2023 18:55

Thank you @AlexandraJJ that is interesting.

However the fact remains I'm not contracted to work 7 days a week I'm contracted to work 4. The IT system is in error with its assumptions.

If this is how the NHS counts absences ( and it seems it is, and some other employers do the same) then I accept that. I'm really grateful for everyone who has taken the time to explain.

My concern about what it then looks like to non-nhs employers remains though. I would strongly prefer to tell them about working days missed (for example I try so hard to rearrange appointments for Friday when I am not working).

But it’s how all/most companies count absences, private ones too. It’s not just an NHS thing.

Neverseenbefore · 11/08/2023 19:08

WimbyAce · 11/08/2023 18:08

You need to remember you are given sickness entitlement for the whole calendar month it is not pro-rate so yes if you are sick that includes weekends/rostered days off etc. It is v fair in my opinion and actually is a whacking great entitlement compared to some places.

What do you mean by a sickness entitlement? I’ve never heard of such a thing.

summergreens · 11/08/2023 18:55

Thank you @AlexandraJJ that is interesting.

However the fact remains I'm not contracted to work 7 days a week I'm contracted to work 4. The IT system is in error with its assumptions.

If this is how the NHS counts absences ( and it seems it is, and some other employers do the same) then I accept that. I'm really grateful for everyone who has taken the time to explain.

My concern about what it then looks like to non-nhs employers remains though. I would strongly prefer to tell them about working days missed (for example I try so hard to rearrange appointments for Friday when I am not working).

OP posts:
AlexandraJJ · 11/08/2023 18:49

ESR (payroll/hr system) works on the premise that everyone is available for work over a 7 day week, it does not record work patterns. All NHS trusts use this. You will be paid pro rata and any sickness triggers will be unique to the organisation you work for although there will be many commonalities between them for example some will look at frequency within a defined period, some the number of days absent within a defined period and some % absence or a combination of all or using the Bradford factor. Sickness absence has to be managed and it has rocketed since September 2020 across the board. Sick pay falls under national ts&cs however the management of absences are local decisions (policies). Whilst working days and hours may also be recorded, the standard ESR reports calculate absence on calendar days, this will have been in the original ESR contract laid out by central government. Other factors may be used locally in the managing of absence such as sickness %, hours lost or days lost. If you are ill for 2 weeks and work 1 day a week, you are still ill for 2 weeks. You will be paid your FTE regardless until you reach half or nil pay.

Hawkins009 · 11/08/2023 18:32

WimbyAce · 11/08/2023 18:21

I think it is done like this for the NHS as you are given a whole calendar month of entitlement. So it wouldn't make sense to us if you were off sick for 2 weeks to only deduct working days as you can't miraculously recover for the non working days.

But then if your not working on x days even though your still off ill then logically why are they counted,

WimbyAce · 11/08/2023 18:27

As for what employers think, I think they are more concerned about frequency rather than length of sickness so it shouldn't cause any problems. In fact I think it's normally the odd days off eg a Monday or a Friday that would ring alarm bells for someone pulling a sickie.

Oldermum84 · 11/08/2023 18:22

I work for the LA and it doesn't work like that. They count the hours of work missed. Though for self certifying for 7 days that includes the non working days and if I asked for a 2 week sick note from the doctor is would be calendar days.

WimbyAce · 11/08/2023 18:21

GreenMonstersParty · 11/08/2023 18:13

I work for a local authority and it doesnt work like that here.

For example if you are full time and are off for 2 weeks for sickness we will record the sickness absence using a calendar as 14 days but will record you only missed 10 days of work in hours (10 x 7.24 hours = 74 hours). So it is clear that you were sick for 2 weeks but you only missed 10 days of work & at any rtw conversations it will be referenced as you were absent for 10 days.

I think it is done like this for the NHS as you are given a whole calendar month of entitlement. So it wouldn't make sense to us if you were off sick for 2 weeks to only deduct working days as you can't miraculously recover for the non working days.

MajesticWhine · 11/08/2023 18:20

Yeah most people don't know about the calendar days thing, but it makes sense. You need to tell your manager you are fit for work and to expect you in on your next working day - it helps with planning admin cover or cancelling patient appointments.

salindahind · 11/08/2023 18:18

Sorry, I don't mean the weekend days are immaterial, just that they don't have to count unless you tell them you were sick right up until you returned to work.

WimbyAce · 11/08/2023 18:17

summergreens · 11/08/2023 18:13

I don't understand @WimbyAce ? I'm not / nhs staff are not given' any sickness entitlement per month. If we are sick we are sick.

There is an issue of how we are paid during the period of sickness absence. This is contractual. As I said I've been off very rarely so I'd need to check details but I think it's six months full pay and six half pay. To be off for that long though would imply serious illness. I'd be grateful for good terms and conditions in the event something catastrophic occurred to be off sick for 12 months!

Your sickness entitlement is dependent on years service (for substantive staff). The maximum is 6 months full and 6 months half pay. First year you will only have 1 month plus 1. I am part time so if I went sick on a Thursday and returned Monday mine would be 4 days recorded sick. But I have the same entitlement as a full timer.

Xomega · 11/08/2023 18:17

My Trusts asks two questions, a) how many calendar days, and b) how many working days.

So, assuming I work five days a week, if I phones in on Monday morning and returned to work the following Monday I would reporting having 7 days I'll and 5 working days. After 3 episodes or 15 working days, my absence would be escalated to stage two and be monitored for the next year.

salindahind · 11/08/2023 18:16

When you do your back to work paperwork on say the Monday after, you (on your working schedule) would say you were sick on your working days but we're finished and work ready by the Friday. Then only your working days are counted. The fact you don't work on those days are immaterial. This doesn't work obviously if you are off sick over 2 weeks, but then you are sick for all that time so it should count!

summergreens · 11/08/2023 18:15

@GreenMonstersParty that makes so much more sense to me! From previous replies though sounds like your employer is a minority approach.

OP posts:
summergreens · 11/08/2023 18:13

I don't understand @WimbyAce ? I'm not / nhs staff are not given' any sickness entitlement per month. If we are sick we are sick.

There is an issue of how we are paid during the period of sickness absence. This is contractual. As I said I've been off very rarely so I'd need to check details but I think it's six months full pay and six half pay. To be off for that long though would imply serious illness. I'd be grateful for good terms and conditions in the event something catastrophic occurred to be off sick for 12 months!

OP posts:
GreenMonstersParty · 11/08/2023 18:13

I work for a local authority and it doesnt work like that here.

For example if you are full time and are off for 2 weeks for sickness we will record the sickness absence using a calendar as 14 days but will record you only missed 10 days of work in hours (10 x 7.24 hours = 74 hours). So it is clear that you were sick for 2 weeks but you only missed 10 days of work & at any rtw conversations it will be referenced as you were absent for 10 days.

WimbyAce · 11/08/2023 18:12

summergreens · 11/08/2023 18:04

So a fact of life no one ever explained to me.

Ok. If that's normal I'll stop complaining. I see IABU.

But there are no other circumstances where I am required to inform work about things that happen on days Im not working are there? They pay me for four days but I'm responsible to them for 7? What about if I'm too unwell to work after my office hours have finished? If I'm sick on a Saturday.? Is that something I should report too??

You are actually paid for the whole calendar month. If you are part time it is pro rated down for your part time hours. Payroll have no record of what days you work, it doesn't matter.

WimbyAce · 11/08/2023 18:08

You need to remember you are given sickness entitlement for the whole calendar month it is not pro-rate so yes if you are sick that includes weekends/rostered days off etc. It is v fair in my opinion and actually is a whacking great entitlement compared to some places.