Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Closed Practice, for girls aged 10-16.

114 replies

JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 05:06

My DD plays sport on a team (all girls Between 10-16 approx, think sync swimming). She’s been on the team for a year, and it’s time for tryouts and to sign a new contract if she gets a place.

One of the new stipulations on the contract says “Coaches have the right to Closed Practices. This means parents or spectators aren’t allowed in the building during practice.” I’ve attached a screen print of the exact wording.

My DD is 11, and this doesn’t sit right with me. I’m a Brit in the US, so UK law wouldn’t apply. But surely this isn’t typical for a sports team is it? To have some practices where parents are not allowed in, when the gIrls are still quite young. The coaches are 2 women and 1 man, if it makes a difference.

It wasn’t in last years contract. A few other parents have voiced their concerns, but we’ve yet to do anything. Tryouts aren’t until next month, so we have time. My DD adores this sport, and all the parents get along and socialise as well (not Dance Moms) so it’s not something I want to give up without a fight.

I’d really appreciate your thoughts, and even some wording on how to push back on this.

Closed Practice, for girls aged 10-16.
OP posts:
CoffeeBean5 · 11/08/2023 09:31

I find it odd that OP and many posters feel the need to chaperone their secondary school aged children to all their extracurricular activities, whether that's sports, drama, music etc. The coaches probably want to avoid competitive sports mums kicking off when their little darling isn't chosen. You can just wait in the car so your dd can come out at anytime.

GoodChat · 11/08/2023 09:26

Maybe they just want to do closed practices around event times to minimise distractions?

Whatajokr · 11/08/2023 09:26

My concern is safeguarding

If this is your concern OP, I'd be impressed they're taking this stance.

I know where I'd want to be if I got my kicks from children.

I'd want to be a spectator sitting in the bleachers watching 10-16yr old swimming costume clad girls warming up, getting in and out of the pool, adjusting their costumes. I'd do it weekly, as often as I can, and get my face known as a swimming fan. Just so I could indulge all the more.

Closing the practices stops these people walking in to watch.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 11/08/2023 09:25

I wouldn’t expect parents to supervise most sports practices at that age. You seem to be going very over the top about it.

PollyPut · 11/08/2023 09:23

@JaneorEleven have parents been distracting students (safety risk) or videoing them during class in the past? This is the usual reason in my experience that practices are closed. Some girls may also be uncomfortable with spectators when they approach puberty and may have asked for no spectators.

Talk to the coaches politely and ask. Peronsally, I would probably do this after the tryouts and you know whether or not a place is being offered.

CherryCokeFanatic · 11/08/2023 09:17

Hard to know without you saying the sport. Which gives nothing away. Especially on a UK based site when you live in the ginormous US

LittleMonks11 · 11/08/2023 09:17

CapEBarra · 11/08/2023 09:01

My DS does MMA and they implemented closed practice for a number of very good reasons. These included:

  • Parents sitting round the edge talking to each other - and bringing their other kids who would get bored and start crying or running around the venue.
  • Parents shouting over the instructor to tell their child what they should be doing,
  • Parents complaining because they didn’t feel Little Johnny was getting enough airtime.
  • Parents commenting on other people’s children to their faces and behind their backs.

It was like a social club sometimes and very distracting for the kids. I was glad when they used COVID as a reason to get rid of the parents. It’s much safer for the children to just be with the instructors than having a load of people you don’t know and who haven’t been vetted gawping at them. Instructors will be trained in safeguarding and will likely have the equivalent of a DBS check meaning the organisation can be as sure as they can be that the coaches are safe to work with children.

Wise post. But what's MMA?

speakout · 11/08/2023 09:12

OP do you sit in when your DD attends school?

CapEBarra · 11/08/2023 09:01

My DS does MMA and they implemented closed practice for a number of very good reasons. These included:

  • Parents sitting round the edge talking to each other - and bringing their other kids who would get bored and start crying or running around the venue.
  • Parents shouting over the instructor to tell their child what they should be doing,
  • Parents complaining because they didn’t feel Little Johnny was getting enough airtime.
  • Parents commenting on other people’s children to their faces and behind their backs.

It was like a social club sometimes and very distracting for the kids. I was glad when they used COVID as a reason to get rid of the parents. It’s much safer for the children to just be with the instructors than having a load of people you don’t know and who haven’t been vetted gawping at them. Instructors will be trained in safeguarding and will likely have the equivalent of a DBS check meaning the organisation can be as sure as they can be that the coaches are safe to work with children.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 11/08/2023 09:01

It’s likely to protect routines. As they get older competition will be taken more seriously. Nobody in the building means no one sees the routine. No parents means Sarah’s mum doesn’t put it on Facebook and Becky’s dad doesn’t put the highlight on TikTok.

It’ll also help the coaches not have to deal with any nightmare parents.

Kids also often behave very differently when their parents are around. The coaches will get a better picture of how things will be in competition settings. Kids are often much better behaved when their parents aren’t around in my experience.

Sugarfree23 · 11/08/2023 08:57

TBH some parents can be a PITA, shouting instructions at kids. Get ready, do this, don't do that.
So distracting for everyone.

You wouldn't be allowed to spectate from the side of your kids school class, why would sports or dance be any different ?

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 11/08/2023 08:52

GoodChat · 11/08/2023 05:54

I'd be more comfortable with an 11 year old being in a closed practice than an open one where anyone can turn up and spectate

This is very true actually.

I would feel a bit uncomfortable about my 11 y/o being without me but this happens everyday at school and so it’s no different really.

My DD actually stopped playing a sport because the parents would get so competitive.
The kids playing (about 8 y/o at the time) would have parents screaming at them, swearing and the ref and talking/laughing behind their backs because of a mistake they made.

If no parents were allowed then my DD would definitely still be playing.

CurlewKate · 11/08/2023 08:45

My dp used to coach youth football and if he could have excluded parents he would have done!
(He couldn't because it was in the park-not because there was a rule...."

thaegumathteth · 11/08/2023 08:44

I honestly don't understand why this is an issue. What about things like guides and cubs or even just holiday clubs or whatever. We can't supervise them 100% of the time. It isn't good for them
Imo.

If you don't trust the coaches that's a separate and more serious issue but you have to let your kids be in a group setting with other adults.

LittleMonks11 · 11/08/2023 08:42

I wonder if it's come up during conversations with the girls. They might want closed practice some of the time. It says 'some'.

My niece did ballet for many years when she was little and parents were never allowed in to watch.

Suggest you just ask the question and ho from there. The flouncing mums sound like hard work - and have you even discussed it with the girls to see how they feel?

They are preteen and it's a very awkward time - I know as I have one.

Soapboxqueen · 11/08/2023 08:41

I think this very much depends on what specifically they mean and the layout of the buildings.

Yes it's very common to not be in the area where the activity is happening. Space and safety are usually big factors. However, that usually means you can be waiting in a corridor or other room just outside the activity room.

I would not be happy being told I wasn't even allowed in the building.

A DBS or equivalent just means they have a clear record not that they are 100% safe. Yes abuse happens in schools too but it's harder to keep quiet due to the large number of people in schools and relative lack of privacy. A whole school conspiracy would be incredibly rare and hard to set up but a small number of people not so much.

Grown adults find it difficult to talk about/report sexual assaults or situations that made them feel uncomfortable so I don't understand why anyone thinks young girls will just come and tell.

Have a chat with the coaches to find out specifically what they mean before going forwards with any decisions.

Genevieva · 11/08/2023 08:37

Children go to school unaccompanied by their parents. Presumably the club has safeguarding rules snd procedures in place.

Serendipitoushedgehog · 11/08/2023 08:36

Spirallingdownwards · 11/08/2023 08:26

My view - let the other parents flounce and deprive their kids of taking part in the sport or find another team. Other kids may welcome the chance of getting a place.

Parents don't need to be present. As another, more sensible parent has said they aren't in class at school with them.

If your 11 year old isn't mature enough to be in a group sport for 11-16 year olds alone with the team and coaches then perhaps she shouldn't participate until she is a bit older.

If parents want to socialise drop and meet at a nearby cafe.

My view - let the other parents flounce and deprive their kids of taking part in the sport or find another team. Other kids may welcome the chance of getting a place.

Yeah that’s basically what I was trying to say. Some adults need to learn that they can’t always get what they want in life by throwing a strop.

Serendipitoushedgehog · 11/08/2023 08:34

Could it be a safeguarding issue the other way round from the way you are thinking about it? So they don’t want so and so’s uncle or brother coming and watching all the girls doing the practice, taking photos etc? So it’s better just to have a straight ban?

a lot of parents have mentioned to me that they won’t return, because of the Closed Practice, without even approaching the coaches and sharing this concern. More than half the team would be gone, and without them, there is no team

This sounds like unnecessary drama causing to be honest. I’ve come across this situation a couple of times in my life, where apparently half the class in a private school are threatening to leave, or most of a choir etc. In reality it’s just the ringleaders threatening to quit and making a lot of noise and when they quit actually most of the rest of the group quietly stay on. Or even if they leave, the group can rebuilt and find new members. This really isn’t the flex you think it is.

continentallentil · 11/08/2023 08:32

I think it’s quite normal - it means parents turn up and are a PITA and a distraction.

Chat to some parents / coaches if you are concerned

zurala · 11/08/2023 08:31

I think this is really normal. I wasn't allowed in to watch my DD so basket even at age 3. My children have done all the following with parents not allowed in:
Ballet. Gymnastics. Karate. Cubs. Guides. Brownies. Beavers. Drama. All after-school clubs.

They will be DBS checked. It's really normal for parents not to be present, and from a young age.

You don't go too school with them do you!

BrunchBunch · 11/08/2023 08:31

Children often behave differently when parents are around, even if it's subtle. They might be less likely to try things, or be more inhibited/self-conscious if parents or other adults are watching. They might interact differently with the group, which can affect things in a team.

I know parents wanting to stay for lessons (in a different context) who insist that their child is not distracted by them, that they act exactly the same, etc but they really don't know because they've never seen the child interacting without them. Sometimes it's good for children to have that freedom to be who they are without scrutiny. And parents even subconsciously do let the child know they're being watched.

It can be uncomfortable for the teachers, too, knowing that everything they do is scrutinised, every time they choose someone else's child, criticise a child, praise someone else's more, etc., it's all being watched and potentially questioned afterwards, even the most trivial things.

Your child will have to do things without you eventually, so working now on good boundaries is helpful - yes there have been scandals in the past where athletes didn't feel able to speak up, but that is changing, and people are more aware of it now. Making sure a child feels able to speak up in situations is important.

I think the coaches may feel a bit pressured to take this clause out, if people complain, and if they've done it for good reasons, you might find that they quit or the team ends up folding anyway, if they feel that the parents are against them somehow.

Thehop · 11/08/2023 08:30

My dd6 does ballet and we've always just had one lesson a term we're allowed to watch. I'm surprised you've been so welcome for so long.

KittensandPerverts · 11/08/2023 08:30

Having seen Soccer Moms and Beauty Pageant parents I bet they have had some right pain in the arse parents in the past.

UndercoverCop · 11/08/2023 08:29

My 4 year old goes to gymnastics and parents can't stay and watch, there's no space it's needed for the activity, and there's no viewing gallery. Once every half term they do a demo session where they put out soft play type blocks in certain areas for parents to sit on and the children demonstrate the different pieces of equipment. There are usually 5/6 instructors there, mainly female and several small groups age 4-6 running concurrently. They don't change etc there and it's one huge open gym space. Parents pick up and drop off to the door