Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Closed Practice, for girls aged 10-16.

114 replies

JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 05:06

My DD plays sport on a team (all girls Between 10-16 approx, think sync swimming). She’s been on the team for a year, and it’s time for tryouts and to sign a new contract if she gets a place.

One of the new stipulations on the contract says “Coaches have the right to Closed Practices. This means parents or spectators aren’t allowed in the building during practice.” I’ve attached a screen print of the exact wording.

My DD is 11, and this doesn’t sit right with me. I’m a Brit in the US, so UK law wouldn’t apply. But surely this isn’t typical for a sports team is it? To have some practices where parents are not allowed in, when the gIrls are still quite young. The coaches are 2 women and 1 man, if it makes a difference.

It wasn’t in last years contract. A few other parents have voiced their concerns, but we’ve yet to do anything. Tryouts aren’t until next month, so we have time. My DD adores this sport, and all the parents get along and socialise as well (not Dance Moms) so it’s not something I want to give up without a fight.

I’d really appreciate your thoughts, and even some wording on how to push back on this.

Closed Practice, for girls aged 10-16.
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HollaHolla · 11/08/2023 13:23

JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 09:58

More than half the girls on the team are in Elementary school, age 10, 11 or 12 (if they’ve been redshirted). In the US, I’d say the children are babied more than in the UK, start school later, finish High school later, so the girls are young for their age. I’m British and see the difference between US kids and my UK nieces.
We aren’t pushy parents at all, there’s no avenue for us to demand a team spot, the girls either have the skill set or they don’t.
We sit on the bleachers to watch but it’s not swimming. They fully covered up during practice.

I think @CoffeeBean5 makes a good point. I've been on the sidelines of sports, where parents have screamed and shouted, almost abusively. It's not on.
I suspect it's to stop some of this - and also to stop parents badgering coaches to change decisions, etc., because 'little Johnny definitely played better in practice, then Fred did'....

I wonder if you can flag this with the coaches, and ask them to explain more. I suspect if it's clearer on their rationale, fewer people would be against it. As you say, you trust teachers to work with your kids without supervision from parents!

witheringrowan · 11/08/2023 13:15

It's probably just so they have a way of being able to train if needed without having nightmare pushy parents intervening, but in any case ask the coaches how this new policy will comply with Safesport's Minor Athlete's Abuse Prevention policies. They should have guidelines around all one-on-one interactions between coaches and students being "observable and interruptible", and all of the coaches should have completed Safesport training recently.

https://uscenterforsafesport.org/

Preventing and Addressing Abuse | U.S. Center for SafeSport

The nonprofit Center is committed to ending abuse in sport. Explore this site for training, resources, reporting information and more.

https://uscenterforsafesport.org

grass321 · 11/08/2023 13:01

I have a vision of cheerleading, probably in the same innocently misguided way that Americans think London and Edinburgh are only a short hop away.

I'm still not sure whether your issue is safeguarding or an obstacle to parents socialising. Either way, most of us have said it's perfectly normal, particularly for anyone over 8.

BrunchBunch · 11/08/2023 10:06

And you say that a reasonable explanation "could change your concerns" - it sounds like you've already come down on the side that this is wrong and you don't want it to happen, without really explaining what you think is going to happen, or really considering some of the things people have said about how different children are without parents around, and how the dynamic of the situation can be very different in terms of team bonding and freedom to try things and so on.

I think you risk making it into a bigger deal than it is, and potentially losing the team anyway, if there is this much discussion amongst parents already about it. It doesn't sound like there is much trust in the coaches, and they may well not want to stay in a situation where that is the case.

BrunchBunch · 11/08/2023 10:02

"how we normally do things" sounds like parents might be a little too involved, possibly.

It'll be up to the coaches how they want to run the program, and you can choose to participate or not. I'm not sure that parents really have the right to be consulted on all the changes that happen in schools, extra curriculars, etc in the way that they think they do. Yes an explanation might be nice but it might just make it a much bigger deal, and you aren't going to be told the real reasons if it's things like parents making girls feel self-conscious or changing the dynamic, or someone else needing particular safe guarding, or whatever.

JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 10:01

user1492757084 · 11/08/2023 09:40

Speak to your daughter again about feeling safe and what type of touching, etc is not acceptable.

Ask whether there is CCTV on the practise area and whether any coaches are alone with just one child. I would think not.
Large groups of children in unlocked areas with three coaches should be able run in such a way that the parents are not worried.
Speak about your concerns directly with the female coach. And ask about how to contact them during training in an emergency.

Thanks for this. It’s sound advice.

and thanks for all the comments on the thread. I’m gonna try and sleep now.

OP posts:
JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 09:58

CoffeeBean5 · 11/08/2023 09:38

In the UK she'd be in secondary school because you start year 7 the September after your 11th birthday. I could understand your concern if your child was under 10. Closed practices mean that children aren't distracted by their competitive parents screaming. The coaches also won't be influenced by pushy parents demanding their child to make the team. Also, creeps won't be able to go into the bleachers and watch teen girls in swimming costumes. Any one of those parents could be a creep.

More than half the girls on the team are in Elementary school, age 10, 11 or 12 (if they’ve been redshirted). In the US, I’d say the children are babied more than in the UK, start school later, finish High school later, so the girls are young for their age. I’m British and see the difference between US kids and my UK nieces.
We aren’t pushy parents at all, there’s no avenue for us to demand a team spot, the girls either have the skill set or they don’t.
We sit on the bleachers to watch but it’s not swimming. They fully covered up during practice.

OP posts:
Flossflower · 11/08/2023 09:58

This might be a good thing. My daughter did dance and hated it when other kids parents wanted to watch a lesson.

Beezknees · 11/08/2023 09:57

Seems fine to me. Parents weren't allowed in to watch swimming lessons when DS did it as it distracted the kids.

Toddlerteaplease · 11/08/2023 09:55

I can imagine they've had issues with the parents being present during practice.

JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 09:49

ArcticSkewer · 11/08/2023 07:16

For anyone who doesn't understand why op is concerned btw, which is understandable of your kids are not heavily into sports, have a quick google of 'sex abuse + sport'. If you start with swimming and football, you'll soon see why people are twitchy these days.

Twitchy is a good description of the responses I’ve heard from other parents. It’s the complete turnaround to how we normally do things, without an explanation, that’s made some of us twitch.

Thanks for all the responses, I’m reading them all. I’m hoping that there be a chance some time soon to just ask for the reasons behind the change. A reasonable explanation could change the concerns we had.

OP posts:
JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 09:44

ChrisPPancake · 11/08/2023 09:38

Do you agree that the principle is the same as @Whatajokr is suggesting though, whatever the sport?

The suggestion was that the clothing the girls wear during swimming was part of what could attract the wrong type. I’m my DDs sport they’re very well covered up, so there’s no risk in that regard.

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 11/08/2023 09:40

Speak to your daughter again about feeling safe and what type of touching, etc is not acceptable.

Ask whether there is CCTV on the practise area and whether any coaches are alone with just one child. I would think not.
Large groups of children in unlocked areas with three coaches should be able run in such a way that the parents are not worried.
Speak about your concerns directly with the female coach. And ask about how to contact them during training in an emergency.

CandyLeBonBon · 11/08/2023 09:39

JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 07:14

In my OP I said “think Sync swimming”. It’s not swimming, for privacy I swapped in a similar type sport. It’s a sport that’s typically an individual sport, like swimming, but the sync component makes it a team sport.

I'm guessing cheerleading?

Ponoka7 · 11/08/2023 09:38

Very often in the UK a rule change is in response to something happening, including not necessarily in that LEA. Are you in a state or close to a state were there's been gun crime instances? Or any issues with boyfriends/stalkers etc? This should be a safeguarding decision and as long as safeguarding is happening within, it's acceptable.

ChrisPPancake · 11/08/2023 09:38

JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 09:34

I’ve mentioned it’s not actually swimming

Do you agree that the principle is the same as @Whatajokr is suggesting though, whatever the sport?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 11/08/2023 09:38

My kids go to loads of things that are drop off. Never had any concerns. I think it’s probably easier to teach children without them being distracted by the presence of children.

Are the instructors the equivalent of DBS checked for the US?

CoffeeBean5 · 11/08/2023 09:38

JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 09:33

DD isn’t in secondary school. She’s in elementary school.

In the UK she'd be in secondary school because you start year 7 the September after your 11th birthday. I could understand your concern if your child was under 10. Closed practices mean that children aren't distracted by their competitive parents screaming. The coaches also won't be influenced by pushy parents demanding their child to make the team. Also, creeps won't be able to go into the bleachers and watch teen girls in swimming costumes. Any one of those parents could be a creep.

JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 09:36

PollyPut · 11/08/2023 09:23

@JaneorEleven have parents been distracting students (safety risk) or videoing them during class in the past? This is the usual reason in my experience that practices are closed. Some girls may also be uncomfortable with spectators when they approach puberty and may have asked for no spectators.

Talk to the coaches politely and ask. Peronsally, I would probably do this after the tryouts and you know whether or not a place is being offered.

Thanks for the good advice. We have a while before tryouts so hopefully some of these parents can settle down. The question about why the need for closed practice can be asked once we know if our DD has a spot.

OP posts:
Wife2b · 11/08/2023 09:35

How is this any different to your child attending school? I assume you don’t observe your child in lessons? It’s a non-issue.

melj1213 · 11/08/2023 09:35

YABU, this is such a non issue and the fact you're all arguing and wanting to lobby so hard against it is probably why they've implemented it.

They aren't going from 100% open sessions to 100% closed sessions, they're just reserving the right to occasionally say "Practice in X week is a closed session, no spectators" and there are a myriad of reasons why that might be.

DD has been doing various sports/dance/drama/music/language lessons since she was tiny and other than sports they're all 100% behind closed doors IE parents do not sit in the lesson itself but we are more than welcome to sit elsewhere in the building to wait and the sports were open to spectators but only because they were usually either done outside or in a sports hall where they can't really stop people watching unless they lockdown the whole area, but after about 9/10 most parents would just "drop and go" and the only time parents stayed was when it was for logistical reasons (eg the session was an hour long and they lived 30 mins away, it wasn't worth them leaving and coming back so they'd sit in the cafe at the leisure centre/in their car at the field)

If it's a competitive team, especially for something like swim/gymnastics/cheer/dance etc then there may be concerns of routines being leaked by a spectator posting videos online and as the kids get older it becomes more competitive and as stupid as it sounds it can be a big deal

Or even just something as simple as they want 100% focus in practice so when they have a competition coming up they want to make sure there are no distractions so the last 1/2 sessions before the competition will be closed sessions so that they can guarantee 100% focus from everyone and there is no excuses of distraction.

Or the opposite of when they're starting a new competition routine they want 1/2 sessions at the start where there's no parents or spectators so they can learn the basics of the routine without anyone worrying about being self conscious of they're learning something new/that they haven't done before.

Equally if they're going to be learning something complicated or that has a safety component (eg in cheer if they're starting to learn how to throw and catch a flyer for a big routine or practicing a huge pyramid) then they may want a closed session so they have less chance of distraction and so they can make sure everyone is focussed due to the safety aspect.

It could even be that some of the kids have asked for the option of sessions without parents watching - they might be happy with people watching generally but they want the odd session where they can focus purely on their own performance/routine without anyone watching them.

Ultimately I would not be kicking up a fuss about this because it is so unremarkable a request.

JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 09:34

Whatajokr · 11/08/2023 09:26

My concern is safeguarding

If this is your concern OP, I'd be impressed they're taking this stance.

I know where I'd want to be if I got my kicks from children.

I'd want to be a spectator sitting in the bleachers watching 10-16yr old swimming costume clad girls warming up, getting in and out of the pool, adjusting their costumes. I'd do it weekly, as often as I can, and get my face known as a swimming fan. Just so I could indulge all the more.

Closing the practices stops these people walking in to watch.

I’ve mentioned it’s not actually swimming

OP posts:
JaneorEleven · 11/08/2023 09:33

CoffeeBean5 · 11/08/2023 09:31

I find it odd that OP and many posters feel the need to chaperone their secondary school aged children to all their extracurricular activities, whether that's sports, drama, music etc. The coaches probably want to avoid competitive sports mums kicking off when their little darling isn't chosen. You can just wait in the car so your dd can come out at anytime.

DD isn’t in secondary school. She’s in elementary school.

OP posts:
backtogrey · 11/08/2023 09:33

All the sports I did as a child were closed practices. Parents could attend matches but not practices.

sashh · 11/08/2023 09:31

My concern is safeguarding. The USA gymnastics team abuse has been playing on my mind. Our team is a far cry from an Olympic team, but the breakdown of safeguarding in that sport was shocking, which makes me want to double check I have good boundaries in place for my DD.

The abuse on the Olympic team often took place in front of a parent.