Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want DD's 16 & 18 hanging out with a 25 year old woman?

120 replies

Duckingella · 11/08/2023 03:07

DD's have recently in the last few months starting going to a youth & young persons group that in our home town;they do arts there;in this case they perform music at this group.

Elder DD will be 18 next month and is autistic which makes her vulnerable;younger DD has just finished GCSE's and has not long turned 16.

They've made new friends there;they've started spending time with these new friends;I was happy they had made new friends especially elder DD as she struggles with making friends.

However today I've discovered one of these new friends "Jane" is 25;elder DD seems to be spending alot of time with "Jane" and is quite taken with her.For context DD nearly is Gay.

I'm really not happy that "Jane" at 25 is loitering about with a bunch of teenagers that aren't quite adults yet;this is ringing alarm bells for me,at 25 I was married with kids;I certainly wouldn't have been hanging out with girls my daughters ages.

I'm debating wether to contact this youth group and speak with whoever runs it and ask them to speak with Jane and ask her to stay away from my DD's outside of this group's sessions.

*Asking DD's directly to stay away from "Jane" will probably result in an argument.

OP posts:
6WeekCountdown · 11/08/2023 10:15

Seaweed42 · 11/08/2023 10:07

What are they doing outside of the group meeting times?
This 25yr old may act much younger for a variety of reasons.

If I was you I'd find time to get to know 'Jane'.
She might just be immature but otherwise lovely and have zero intentions towards your DD.
Offer them a lift somewhere/a lift home or offer to take them out for the day shopping to a different town, something like that?
Or ask if some of the youth/music group want to come over to yours for a movie and order pizzas, something like that? Just try to be subtle about it.

They are 18 and 25 not 13 🤣. I'm sure at 25 this woman can drive, if she wanted to go anywhere with the daughter such as shopping she'd drive herself.

RestingMurderousFace · 11/08/2023 10:12

JudgeAnderson · 11/08/2023 09:36

I'm really not getting the issue at all here.

Me neither. Maybe we need to try harder?

6WeekCountdown · 11/08/2023 10:08

Lesbian relationships tend to have a big age gap, my friend was 32 when she started dating a 21 year old, to be fair we did raise eyebrows at the time. My friend had been with her husband since she started uni at 18 up until they broke up. He was 6 years older, so she was in a similar position when they met she was 18 and him 24, he was doing higher degrees and then got a job at the uni. They broke up and she decided she was bi. She was dating women around aged 20 when we were all 31/32 I found this all kinds of weird truth be told. I think because my friend was so inexperienced in gay relationships she went for young women who were in the same boat. Anyway she married the girl 11 years younger last year, she's 39 and the wife is 28 now. I wouldn't be surprised if it does turn into something romantic, your daughter is 18 soon so can date who she likes, even if you don't like the age gap, you can't micromanage her relationships once she's an adult.

Seaweed42 · 11/08/2023 10:07

What are they doing outside of the group meeting times?
This 25yr old may act much younger for a variety of reasons.

If I was you I'd find time to get to know 'Jane'.
She might just be immature but otherwise lovely and have zero intentions towards your DD.
Offer them a lift somewhere/a lift home or offer to take them out for the day shopping to a different town, something like that?
Or ask if some of the youth/music group want to come over to yours for a movie and order pizzas, something like that? Just try to be subtle about it.

monsteramunch · 11/08/2023 09:47

@Coyoacan

I had a male friend who was 25 when I was 16. I wasn't vulnerable and he wasn't a romantic interest.

So you wouldn't be concerned if your 16 year old daughter told you she had made a new friend and they were a 25 year old bloke?

I think most people would quite rightly see a 25 year old bloke making friends with a 16 year old girl as troubling and a red flag. It's very unusual not to.

ManateeFair · 11/08/2023 09:46

Your DD is 'quite taken' with Jane. So what? Is there actually anything to suggest that Jane is equally 'quite taken' with your DD? Has anything happened to suggest that Jane has done anything untoward?

The language you use in your post is really weird - 'loitering about' for example. She's a member of a music group for young people. She's not 'loitering about'.

You've basically decided a 25-year-old woman must be some kind of weird predator with zero evidence.

When I was 18 I had part time jobs and I was at university and I had lots of friends in their 20s, both colleagues and students. There were mature students on my course and there were MA students and overseas students in halls with us who were mid-20s and older. Plenty of 18-year-olds are in full-time work and meeting friends and colleagues of all ages.

You mention that you were married with children at 25. Most people, however, are not. I don't know any 25-year-olds who are. You can't assume that the lifestyle you had at 25 is indicative of the mindset of the average 25-year-old.

Iwasafool · 11/08/2023 09:43

GoodChat · 11/08/2023 05:34

I was working at 16 and had friends in their 40s.

I think that is a good thing. Through school they just know people the same age, GS who lives with me is 18 and just started work and I can see some positive things from him now having colleagues who are older. Gives him a bit of a different perspective and it isn't mum/gran who obviously know nothing.

frami · 11/08/2023 09:43

I am 60 and one of my closest friends is only 8 years older than my eldest DC. Frend is also gay.
Is there any romantic interest? No.
We are just great friends brought together through our mutual love of dogs and working in the same field.

Incidently we both work with young people with learning difficulties. The term applies young people up to the age of 26 and there will be quite an age gap between members of groups, especially in social settings and friendships will not be interfered with. However this would not be the case if the elder friend is one of the youth workers. It would then be a safeguarding matter and you would have the right to express your concerns OP.

nidgey · 11/08/2023 09:42

Maybe the OP is uncomfortable as their elder DD is autistic and might be more easily taken advantage of. It's not that unusual for parents of 18 year old autistic children to keep a close eye on their social life as sometimes they (the children) may need some guidance.

MeridianB · 11/08/2023 09:41

Yolkpoker · 11/08/2023 09:19

If they met in a work context waitressing or such I’d be totally ok with it. At a ‘youth group’ I’d be looking carefully at what kind of youth group it was , and why people are there.

For me, this is exactly the point.

So many people giving lovely examples of work colleagues, theatre groups, foreign exchange students, family friends, organised group hobbies. This is none of those, so it stands out and the OP is worried because her DD is more vulnerable. Doesn't hurt to find out more.

MrsMarzetti · 11/08/2023 09:41

You need to let your 16 and 18 year olds live. How long do you plan on keeping them as children ?

Onelifeonly · 11/08/2023 09:41

During the pandemic my dd aged 19 made friends with a 25 year old woman - initially online but they soon started meeting up. My dd had never at that time expressed much interest in either boys or girls, and all her friends had been female (though now has had the same boyfriend for over 2 years). I considered it could be a sexual / romantic relationship since they generally spent whole weekends together at the woman's place (not allowed technically by pandemic rules) but dd said it wasn't sexual and the woman was grieving a break up with a boyfriend.

My concern was initially about the age gap as dd was quite young for her age and this woman took a lot of control over dd's life - got her a job, ordered meals to be delivered for her to our house etc.

But I accepted it since dd was technically grown up and it didn't feel like she would come to any harm (I met the woman etc.) As she became more controlling, dd would confide in me but for a while wanted to continue the friendship. But eventually she saw the manipulation and gas lighting for what it was, and reacted against it, thus ending the friendship.

To be honest it seemed like a good learning experience for dd! (But even typing this still makes me think it was a romantic, albeit emotionally abusive, relationship for the woman.)

JudgeAnderson · 11/08/2023 09:36

I'm really not getting the issue at all here.

Pinkdelight3 · 11/08/2023 09:25

I went to a theatre group in my early to late teens where I hung out with members aged in early/mid 20s and we were great mates and are still friends today, 20-odd years later. It's about the activities you're doing together and arty folk tend to be more broad-minded and not see the differences so much, which is great for your DDs if they lack confidence/social skills/friendships. You sound like you're coming from a much more trad place, being married with kids at 25, but as PP said, that's not the norm for most people in their 20s now and they're still 'young people' in a way that's changed a lot since you were 25. Rather than worrying about some nefarious grooming situation (can only assume this is why the gay element was mentioned), try to stay more open and let them make their own way - even if they happen to make some mistakes. It's hardly the most threatening situation, they're not children and she's not an old perv. Let them build their friendships and enjoy themselves without you getting involved.

KrisAkabusi · 11/08/2023 09:25

At 18 I was at university and joined a couple of clubs, one in particular I spent a lot of time in, socialising after activities. Some of the members were mature students, anything from 25-45 years old. I never considered anything wrong with different ages being part of the club. I'm still friends with a couple of them now, 30 years later!

And you absolutely cannot ask the club leader to tell Jane what to do outside the club. He has no authority over her outside the club, and she's an adult, she can do what she wants. It's only a five year age difference. I'd be surprised if other 18 year olds don't have friends of the same age through work or college or sport or whatever.

Yolkpoker · 11/08/2023 09:19

If they met in a work context waitressing or such I’d be totally ok with it. At a ‘youth group’ I’d be looking carefully at what kind of youth group it was , and why people are there.

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 11/08/2023 09:17

The age is irrelevant.

Surely if your DD is autistic you understand that some people are socially and emotionally younger than their peers of a same age.
Its very possible that this women is socially much younger.

Your DDs joined this club I’m assuming yi socialise and make friends, which they’re doing.

Why not tell them they can invite Jane over and just get to know her a bit more.

You absolutely cannot tell them not to see her as they are adults and will probably see her more.

It sounds like you’re worried that your DD is going to start having s sexual relationship with her but I would say it’s quite common for an 18 y/o to be in a relationship with a 25 y/o.

Polik · 11/08/2023 09:12

My 18yo (nearly 19) DD plays for an adult ladies football team. The majority of the team are 23-30 (finished uni age). They socialise a lot. My DDs closest friend in the group is 24. She's often at ours for overnight/dinner before they go drinking. Or DD at hers. It's really no big deal. But then, by DD isn't vulnerable and has always been fairly mature for her age.

user1469908434 · 11/08/2023 09:12

When I was 18 I joined a club that was 18-25 age group. I’m now in my 40’s and these people are still my friends.
And probably not what you want to hear, one of them, who was 6 years older, became my boyfriend and we’ve now been together 29 years.

There is no other situation apart from school, that you are expected to be friends with only people born within 12 calendar months of you. I’ve friends now from early 20’s to their 70’s and life is better for it!

determinedtomakethiswork · 11/08/2023 09:09

I would want to know why a 25-year-old was going to a club like this. Does she work there?

RedHelenB · 11/08/2023 09:01

vodkaredbullgirl · 11/08/2023 03:41

Meet up with this Jane person.

Why? I haven't met up with any of my kids friends past primary age. OP is being very controlling.

LocoCocoa · 11/08/2023 08:58

My son attends a youth club, he is autistic. The club is for anyone and goes up to age 25, however the sessions are, 12-18 and then 18-25

I wouldn’t have a problem with my 18 year old daughter being friends with a 25 year old, this is something likely to occur in the workplace anyway. I made work friends at 18 that were in their 20’s who I still speak to now and I’m approaching my 40’s.

And imo it wouldn’t be the same if it was a male no, but that’s just living in reality.

WhatNoRaisins · 11/08/2023 08:58

I wonder if the age silo is almost a follow on from stranger danger. As a young person who grew up being told not to talk to strangers, which basically means treat any adult who isn't a family member or teacher like a personal threat, I didn't just shake it off when I turned 18. In fact it wasn't until I was mid 20s with my own home that I shook it off and had older adult friends.

Lindy2 · 11/08/2023 08:58

I'd suggest that you meet Jane and find out a bit more about her.

It's not that big an age group for young adults sharing a particular hobby.

You also say that your DD struggles with friendships due to her ASD (so does mine). Often to get along with someone who is neuro diverse it takes a greater level of understanding and tolerance of social mistakes than most teenagers have. Your DD may be finding the friendship easier because of Jane's maturity.

borntobequiet · 11/08/2023 08:49

I don’t get this “age silo” thing. It appears to be fairly recent. When I was in my late teens I had friends in their twenties and thirties, met socially or through work. It was normal.
Now, I have friends up to forty years younger and twenty years older. We have shared views and interests, so we get on well.