Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

7 police officers versus 1 autistic girl

242 replies

Green777 · 10/08/2023 22:14

https://metro.co.uk/video/teen-girl-autism-arrested-telling-officer-looks-like-lesbian-nana-2995683/

AIBU to think these Police officers should be disciplined for arresting this autistic

girl for a ‘hate crime’ then dragging her out of her home kicking and screaming?

The police officer who the girl said looked like her ‘lesbian nana’ seems very unprofessional.

Teen girl with autism arrested for telling officer she 'looks like my lesbian nana'

West Yorkshire Police's professional standards panel is investigating video footage of the incident involving an autistic 16-year-old girl following a complaint by her mother.

https://metro.co.uk/video/teen-girl-autism-arrested-telling-officer-looks-like-lesbian-nana-2995683/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
HatFamster · 11/08/2023 08:22

Livinginanotherworld · 11/08/2023 01:49

what the hell is a vulnerable young teenager doing out at 1am in the morning pissed out of her mind in the first place ? Where were the parents ? There is more to this, i think she is already known to the police.

She’d followed her 18 yr old sister, who was going on a planned night out.

Teens go out, get drunk, even those with lovely engaged parents. It’s too easy to blame parents for behaviour that’s as old as the hills.

There’s nothing to say that there’s more to this. Even the police statement backs up the mother’s account.

It’s just another day in clown world where the police are taking advantage of their power.

I’m now waiting for the announcement that the police officer is a trans man or NB, and that’s why the comment that she looked like a lesbian was ridiculously deemed homophobic. The only homophobia is from the police woman who was so triggered by overhearing that she looked like a lesbian that she had to race back into the house to arrest the teen 🙄

Jellyx · 11/08/2023 08:19

The police can't reveal all information due to data protection laws. I'm sure they'd love to share their side!

If 7 officers have attended it's likely due to a history of violent behaviour from the individual. Sorry- but the police aren't there to be punched so perhaps 7were required to minimise risk of injury.

In addition - the police will have been contacted to be there (in order to be verbally abused) ...so why was that?

AND since when is it ok to verbally abuse people? The public have a right to charge someone for verbal abuse - why not the police? It's very likely been a 'tag on' charge to others.

AND sometimes a record of these police incidents ends up being helpful for the family who can evidence the support needs and access funding.

Scatterbrainbox · 11/08/2023 08:10

SoShallINever · 10/08/2023 22:37

There were some horrible disablist posts on here earlier tonight too, minimising ASD and stating that "everyone's precious child has it these days". We need to challenge this sort of nonsense.
Autism is real, it causes meltdowns.
West Yorks police should be ashamed of themselves.

Exactly. And it shows ignorance. At its most basic level autism is a social communication disability...the teenage girl will have just stated whatever was jn her kind and would not have had the ability to understand the negative way in which it might be taken.
The number if officers for 1 teenaged girl cowering in a cupboard is just an aggression tactic.
I would hope the force have guidelines about dealing with disabled people, ypu would think informed hy an LD nurse or similar.
I am normally very sympathetic towards the police. Making split second decisions, however this is horrific and cased by ignorance.
I have a 14 hear old autistic daughter who can appear very 'normal' ( ie she has learned how to fit in and masks) but would behave in a very similar way to this girl if utterly overwhelmed).
Essentially what has happened as far as I can see is that the young girl has said she thought the female, short haired police officer is a lesbian (possibly linking to her nan's appearance) and the female officer has thought she was insulting her.
This could have been resolved with a conversation if those officers had acted professionally. They could have signposted family or made a safeguarding referral to school if they really felt there was some sort of homophobic issue.
Essentially the female officer felt insulted and and wanted to 'get her own back'
Disgraceful.

Aminorpoet · 11/08/2023 08:03

Whilst lots of police are able to de escalate situations and would have managed this differently, what happened is not unusual in my experience.

It's not unusual for someone in distress to end up with criminal charges - often of assault against police - when the police have been heavy handed.

Happens frequently with women in a mental health crisis.

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 08:01

Secondary teachers will have experienced worse on a daily basis. Are they supposed to call for a public disorder squad every time?

Enfys1982 · 11/08/2023 07:58

The police in this country a joke. Only interested in protecting ‘their own’.

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 07:47

When my autistic daughter was brought home by police she was handled with nothing but kindness. Her disabilities put her at a priority, they certainly didn’t say they didn’t care about her autism. Quite the reverse. I have 2 autistic teens and the police have been very autism aware and kind in both our very different dealings with them.Thanking my lucky stars we don’t live in the same area as this story.

This story gives me chills in the same way footage of autistic youngsters bring deliberately heightened and abused in care does. Since when is it ok for professionals to say they don’t care about a protected disability?

FloweryName · 11/08/2023 07:45

That’s disgusting. I feel quite upset watching that.

The police need more training. I hope they are made to apologise for their lack of professionalism and for causing so much distress.

Naunet · 11/08/2023 07:43

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 10/08/2023 23:22

I don't think so, just the video that a family member took without any background ie why 7 police officers had to be called out (probably because there were quite a few family members in the house, so for the police's protection). Also I don't believe we heard the teenager make a simple observation about the police officer looking like a lesbian, it could've been said in any way/tone. Not taking either side here, but we only have a snippet of what went on here.

Who cares? Attempted murderers are allowed to publicly call for women to be punched, and that, according to the police is fine, but this isn’t? They’re huge power mad hypocrites.

HardieHa · 11/08/2023 07:38

If they felt they really had to arrest her they should have left the mother to calm her down and asked her to bring her in the next day, there was no need to do it the way they did.

At that point they would also have looked at the body cam footage, agreed whether what was said was homophobic or a misunderstanding, found a correct crime to charge her with (I have read that a public order offense cannot be one that happens in a private residence and it also has to be reported by a member of the public but IANAL) and sorted this all out without all the violence.

I think the officer involved needs to be investigated for her homophobic attitude, saying someone looks like a lesbian you know is not an insult, but this does depend on what she thinks she heard, at the very least she needs disability training, anger management and a removal from frontline policing until she learns how to behave, deescalate, not jump t conclusions and not abuse her position. She also needs to be arrested for assaulting the mother, unlawfully entering their home and possibly assaulting the daughter.

It's all appalling but unfortunately not surprising. I was told by a domestic abuse police officer that someone with autism is more likely the abuser in a domestic violence situation when ALL evidence points the other way, they are more likely to be the victim. What hope is there when the people whose job it is to protect you are under the impression that you are more likely to be violent due to your disability?

Heyhoherewegoagain · 11/08/2023 07:36

Green777 · 11/08/2023 07:28

No, not really. That is what the police want you to think.

Facts of the matter are she was arrested and dragged away by 7 police officers for saying she looked like her lesbian nana. ‘Verbal abuse’ to the PO.

There is literally no other charge or crime or anything else that they can say or cling to because they would have.

There’s absolutely no point in engaging with you now, your mind is made up and closed

MoustacheTwirler · 11/08/2023 07:34

@Green777 We do not know for definite if that is what she actually said. We currently only have the mums account that the girl said that. It doesn't mean that the mums account is not true, but we cannot be definite unless we have the police footage.

But regardless, I cannot imagine anything anyone could possibly say to warrant such a heavy handed response from the police.

bellac11 · 11/08/2023 07:33

Livinginanotherworld · 11/08/2023 01:49

what the hell is a vulnerable young teenager doing out at 1am in the morning pissed out of her mind in the first place ? Where were the parents ? There is more to this, i think she is already known to the police.

And why didnt the family go to get her and bring her home, why phone the police to do that?

Heyhoherewegoagain · 11/08/2023 07:29

Ducksurprise · 11/08/2023 07:21

A comment, and 'hurty feelings' because that is what the police are saying happened- words not a physical attack or risk to life- does not warrant 7 officers, shouting, hands being made into fists and the escalation of the situation to anyone, let alone a distressed drunk autistic child.

And frankly if anyone thinks it does then we are heading to hell in a handcart.

That’s quite a jump of reading something that isn’t there from a post! The pp asked what the police statement was, and I deliberately gave a summary without opinion.

Id hate to see a lot of posters on this thread do jury service!

TodayInahurry · 11/08/2023 07:28

They won’t turn up for real crime, this is a total disgrace. The gender nonsense is not the Police’s job

Green777 · 11/08/2023 07:28

Heyhoherewegoagain · 11/08/2023 07:22

It’s all interpretation of very little information, but judgement is being jumped to based on literally half the story

No, not really. That is what the police want you to think.

Facts of the matter are she was arrested and dragged away by 7 police officers for saying she looked like her lesbian nana. ‘Verbal abuse’ to the PO.

There is literally no other charge or crime or anything else that they can say or cling to because they would have.

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 11/08/2023 07:26

Regardless of whether police involvement was reasonable, it did not need seven police officers.

I recognise the courts system is broken and has lengthy delays, but that should not stop the police using only the number of officers necessary, so others can be dealing with other criminal matters.

MoustacheTwirler · 11/08/2023 07:23

Unless the police release their video footage then we only have the story from one side and therefore cannot be certain exactly what was said and how the situation escalated. We currently only have the mothers version of what the girl said.

Regardless, it is clear the police were escalating the situation and the girl was in distress. The police should be acting in the public interest and I can not see at all how it was in the public interest to have arrested this girl. Autism aside, she was in her own home, a few words to a police officer is hardly a hate crime and ultimately she is highly unlikely to be convicted of anything and therefore this was a huge misuse of police time and resources.

I can appreciate that police officers have to deal with harassment and violence day in day out and it must be an incredibly tough job but they can't go bulldozing in to a situation and making it worse. The female police officer looked like she has a chip on her shoulder and if she is really offended by what a 16 year old girl said to her then she is not in the right job.

Heyhoherewegoagain · 11/08/2023 07:22

Green777 · 11/08/2023 07:05

They say their officers shouldn’t have to put up with verbal abuse.

So that is the crux of the matter, her comment about the PO’s likeliness to her grandmother.

The whole statement sounds like they’re trying to shirk it off and cast doubt on the girl but can not say anything other than ‘verbal abuse’.

It’s all interpretation of very little information, but judgement is being jumped to based on literally half the story

Ducksurprise · 11/08/2023 07:21

Heyhoherewegoagain · 11/08/2023 06:56

That what’s in the media is literally half the story

A comment, and 'hurty feelings' because that is what the police are saying happened- words not a physical attack or risk to life- does not warrant 7 officers, shouting, hands being made into fists and the escalation of the situation to anyone, let alone a distressed drunk autistic child.

And frankly if anyone thinks it does then we are heading to hell in a handcart.

Blondebutnotlegally · 11/08/2023 07:13

Everyone is complaining about the number of officers but the more handling someone the better and safer. One on each limb and one supporting the head is the end game. Including one overseeing. That's 6!!! The outcome can be dangerous if it's just one or two

Green777 · 11/08/2023 07:05

Heyhoherewegoagain · 11/08/2023 06:56

That what’s in the media is literally half the story

They say their officers shouldn’t have to put up with verbal abuse.

So that is the crux of the matter, her comment about the PO’s likeliness to her grandmother.

The whole statement sounds like they’re trying to shirk it off and cast doubt on the girl but can not say anything other than ‘verbal abuse’.

OP posts:
Heyhoherewegoagain · 11/08/2023 06:56

Augustisthesundayofsummer · 10/08/2023 23:09

What does the police statement say?

That what’s in the media is literally half the story

Green777 · 11/08/2023 06:52

(Sorry not the OP, the PO’s response)

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread