Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

7 police officers versus 1 autistic girl

242 replies

Green777 · 10/08/2023 22:14

https://metro.co.uk/video/teen-girl-autism-arrested-telling-officer-looks-like-lesbian-nana-2995683/

AIBU to think these Police officers should be disciplined for arresting this autistic

girl for a ‘hate crime’ then dragging her out of her home kicking and screaming?

The police officer who the girl said looked like her ‘lesbian nana’ seems very unprofessional.

Teen girl with autism arrested for telling officer she 'looks like my lesbian nana'

West Yorkshire Police's professional standards panel is investigating video footage of the incident involving an autistic 16-year-old girl following a complaint by her mother.

https://metro.co.uk/video/teen-girl-autism-arrested-telling-officer-looks-like-lesbian-nana-2995683/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
FuppingEll · 11/08/2023 09:52

@FuppingEll can you explain how an autistic teen saying that the policewoman looked like her lesbian nana is homophobic?

All I have seen in the police saying that Upon returning her to the address, comments were made which resulted in the girl being arrested on suspicion of a homophobic public order offence. The nature of the comments made was fully captured on body-worn video. It doesn't say what the comments were? Did the mother release another video showing the daughter abuse?

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 09:52

Maybe it is just that the whole situation is really out there for me because none of that would have happened under my roof but I just can't imagine being 'livid' at the person my child abused

Again, where is the abuse?
An autistic teen comments that the police woman looked like her nana, who is a lesbian - in what world is that abuse? How is this a hate crime?

If you have an autistic child there are certain things, as a parent, that are out of your control, so you do your very best to manage that. Unfortunately it’s all made far more distressing by utter ignorant pricks who clearly don’t understand autism.

The police statement backs up the mother’s side. There may be more backstory, but nothing makes the handling of this by the police acceptable. They’ve screwed up here.

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 09:47

@FuppingEll can you explain how an autistic teen saying that the policewoman looked like her lesbian nana is homophobic?

And public order offence? She was inside her home!

That's assuming she has an appropriate adult. We know nothing about this family except what we have seen which is that they let a vulnerable, disabled 16 year old go out drinking to the point the police need to get involved and instead of calmly trying to de escalate the situation or focus on their daughter in anyway they were shouting and filming the police.

The mother has updated that she was not allowed to be the child’s appropriate adult, but the police provided another (adding to the child’s distress).

Short of putting bars on windows and locking doors (which would be wrong in all sorts of ways) how do you suggest those of us with autistic teens keep them from going out?
Plenty of teens go out and get drunk, because for a lot of teenagers this is the normal time to push boundaries, whether you have loving engaged parents or not! Being autistic doesn’t mean you don’t also have normal teenage behaviour to deal with, but made more complex because they are autistic.

Once the police woman swept in to arrest and called for back up, all the mother was doing was trying to get them to back off from her daughter who was having a meltdown and was hurting herself. The police escalated this, not the mother!
The male police followed the poor girl into the cupboard, blocking her in! Have they had any training whatsoever?

But anyway, another day on MN, where parents of autistic children will be blamed no matter what.

FuppingEll · 11/08/2023 09:47

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 09:20

I too have a gay teen and absolutely would have been livid if his autistic sister had been treated like that with an officer saying they don’t care about her disability.

It’s the lack of complete autism awareness that is worrying. You don’t get to say you don’t care about disabilities protected by law. Nobody does, least of all law enforcers!😳

We are all different. Personally I would understand that the victim of my child's abuse was just reacting in that split second and tried to diffuse the situation by apologising for my child's behaviour not screaming in the face of the people who brought my drunk child home Blush

Maybe it is just that the whole situation is really out there for me because none of that would have happened under my roof but I just can't imagine being 'livid' at the person my child abused after they brought my drunk out of control child home in the middle of the night.

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 09:45

Jellyx

The girl was cowering in a cupboard in her own home. Where was officer safety at risk?

And re ignoring hidden disabilities- wow! Seriously.

ErmWhatever · 11/08/2023 09:44

Absolutely outrageous behaviour. People with such a fragile ego shouldn't be in uniform.

Really worrying that 20% of voters that think this was justified.

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 09:41

Takoneko

I totally agree. Our experience of the police as regards understanding and handling autism in our area has been fantastic. The NHS on the other hand….

Clymene · 11/08/2023 09:41

They've made a statement @Jellyx. I posted it further down the thread.

They haven't said she was violent or aggressive or that the officers feared for their safety and, given they've included a lot of irrelevant detail, I'm sure they would have done.

Jellyx · 11/08/2023 09:39

And the story given isn't the police's version of events - would LOVE to hear their side before everyone starts slagging them all off!!!!

Jellyx · 11/08/2023 09:38

@Green777
Since when is homophobia ok? And how can the office be sure someone is autistic.
And - if she called for back up it's because someone was being aggressive / violent - of course colleagues responded.

Are we saying autistic people don't stab or physically assault others?
Officers physical safety comes first here!!!

Takoneko · 11/08/2023 09:34

This is disgraceful. I’m not anti-police, I come from a family of police and work with police officers regularly in my work as a safeguarding lead in a secondary school.

This is not representative of how the police that I’ve worked with with deal with autistic teenagers. These officers need some serious training. As a general rule, I think British police are really good at deescalation, compared to police in most other countries. Why these officers escalated this situation to this point is beyond me… there was never going to be a good outcome. I have to say, I generally find the police to be very good in situations where autistic kids have run away or become dysregulated in public. I’d expect there to be some action on this, although WYP do seem to have a particularly woeful record on responding to complaints.

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 09:20

I too have a gay teen and absolutely would have been livid if his autistic sister had been treated like that with an officer saying they don’t care about her disability.

It’s the lack of complete autism awareness that is worrying. You don’t get to say you don’t care about disabilities protected by law. Nobody does, least of all law enforcers!😳

FuppingEll · 11/08/2023 09:17

Ducksurprise · 11/08/2023 09:07

Lovely, ignore the video and the statement from the police that back up was caused due to 'hurty feelings'

Sorry I disagree. As the mother of a gay 16yo I would expect the police to take any homophobic public order offences against him seriously, not go 'wah, wah, hurty feelings'. I really can't believe that you are reducing homophobia down to 'hurty feelings'. I presume you feel the same way about sexism too? How about ablism? Wah, wah hurty feelings right?

Ducksurprise · 11/08/2023 09:07

FuppingEll · 11/08/2023 08:58

As others have said if she has verbally insulted the officer and it warranted arrest it should have been handled very differently. Asking her to attend the next day with an appropriate adult.

That's assuming she has an appropriate adult. We know nothing about this family except what we have seen which is that they let a vulnerable, disabled 16 year old go out drinking to the point the police need to get involved and instead of calmly trying to de escalate the situation or focus on their daughter in anyway they were shouting and filming the police. Do we know if they are known to the police? Do we know if they have tried this tactic with this family before and been ignored so know it is pointless because they will have to physically bring the daughter in anyway? We don't know anything, we have no background at all.

Lovely, ignore the video and the statement from the police that back up was caused due to 'hurty feelings'

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 09:06

Caring for teenagers with autism is very difficult. It’s a balancing act I wouldn’t wish on anybody. All the things you manage with NT teens are made a lot harder as there can be impulsivity, black and white thinking, sensory issues, communication difficulties, bolting…. The answer isn’t to stop them going out but to support them. My autistic daughter has drank to excess and needed to be collected by us. We were lucky in that we found her without needing the police on that occasion. We have needed the police hit bolting under distress though and they were fantastic. She is slowly learning how to handle the many things that make modern day living so hard for those with autism.

Naunet · 11/08/2023 09:04

Jellyx · 11/08/2023 08:19

The police can't reveal all information due to data protection laws. I'm sure they'd love to share their side!

If 7 officers have attended it's likely due to a history of violent behaviour from the individual. Sorry- but the police aren't there to be punched so perhaps 7were required to minimise risk of injury.

In addition - the police will have been contacted to be there (in order to be verbally abused) ...so why was that?

AND since when is it ok to verbally abuse people? The public have a right to charge someone for verbal abuse - why not the police? It's very likely been a 'tag on' charge to others.

AND sometimes a record of these police incidents ends up being helpful for the family who can evidence the support needs and access funding.

People really don’t owe the police the benefit of the doubt anymore. They just don’t.

Qilin · 11/08/2023 09:01

Livinginanotherworld · 11/08/2023 01:49

what the hell is a vulnerable young teenager doing out at 1am in the morning pissed out of her mind in the first place ? Where were the parents ? There is more to this, i think she is already known to the police.

Unfortunately 16y don't always make the right choices when it comes to drinking and not coming home when they're supposed to. It's unfair to blame the parents simply in that point. The family, sister I believe, did call the police for help getting the girl home safely.

There is nothing to suggest the girl is known to the police - from the police statement or from the family, at this point. It's unfair to suggest that without more information to prove that point,

FuppingEll · 11/08/2023 08:58

As others have said if she has verbally insulted the officer and it warranted arrest it should have been handled very differently. Asking her to attend the next day with an appropriate adult.

That's assuming she has an appropriate adult. We know nothing about this family except what we have seen which is that they let a vulnerable, disabled 16 year old go out drinking to the point the police need to get involved and instead of calmly trying to de escalate the situation or focus on their daughter in anyway they were shouting and filming the police. Do we know if they are known to the police? Do we know if they have tried this tactic with this family before and been ignored so know it is pointless because they will have to physically bring the daughter in anyway? We don't know anything, we have no background at all.

Heyhoherewegoagain · 11/08/2023 08:57

TodayInahurry · 11/08/2023 07:28

They won’t turn up for real crime, this is a total disgrace. The gender nonsense is not the Police’s job

Whilst I don’t disagree with your sentiment, because it’s been enshrined in law, unfortunately Police do have to deal with it…and because it’s deemed a hate crime, it gets prioritised above a lot of “traditional” crime, including violent crime because ya know “hurty feelings”

Green777 · 11/08/2023 08:56

Jellyx · 11/08/2023 08:19

The police can't reveal all information due to data protection laws. I'm sure they'd love to share their side!

If 7 officers have attended it's likely due to a history of violent behaviour from the individual. Sorry- but the police aren't there to be punched so perhaps 7were required to minimise risk of injury.

In addition - the police will have been contacted to be there (in order to be verbally abused) ...so why was that?

AND since when is it ok to verbally abuse people? The public have a right to charge someone for verbal abuse - why not the police? It's very likely been a 'tag on' charge to others.

AND sometimes a record of these police incidents ends up being helpful for the family who can evidence the support needs and access funding.

Another one who hasn’t bothered to read what actually happened, please take the time to so you avoid looking like an idiot Witt these comments.

Back up was called by the PO in question, which is why so many police ended up there.

She reported a hate crime or speech then the other officers attended to help remove the girl from her home.

All of it hinges on the lesbian comment and the Police haven’t said anything different. She was arrested for only that reason.

OP posts:
HollyBerri · 11/08/2023 08:50

This is awful to watch and has really affected me. Nothing the girl could have said would warrant this behaviour. As others have said if she has verbally insulted the officer and it warranted arrest it should have been handled very differently. Asking her to attend the next day with an appropriate adult.
I presume many call outs involve people with mental health issues and the basic lack of understanding and training here is very frightening.
The girls screams are horrendous. The way she was handled outside too despite the mum saying she has scoliosis’ and it would cause her severe pain.
it seems the young girl pushed the wrong button here which is wrong but not an offence.

Useruser1 · 11/08/2023 08:38

Autistic or not this is horrendous state power misuse in the name of "tolerance".

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 08:32

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 08:01

Secondary teachers will have experienced worse on a daily basis. Are they supposed to call for a public disorder squad every time?

Measures should be put in place to avoid these situations.

In my autistic son’s situation, the only times when he kicked off in class was when a teacher escalated it by deliberately ignoring his needs, which were set out in his EHCP.
People have perceptions of autism that lead to some young people being treated appallingly. If you don’t “look” autistic, or if your autism means you’re challenging, no one wants to help, and some people (teachers, police etc) will go to lengths to try to punish them, to discipline. Which works just as well as punishing an amputee into regrowing a limb.

The police response is typical, and pathetic. No wonder there’s little trust left.

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 08:27

Jellyx · 11/08/2023 08:19

The police can't reveal all information due to data protection laws. I'm sure they'd love to share their side!

If 7 officers have attended it's likely due to a history of violent behaviour from the individual. Sorry- but the police aren't there to be punched so perhaps 7were required to minimise risk of injury.

In addition - the police will have been contacted to be there (in order to be verbally abused) ...so why was that?

AND since when is it ok to verbally abuse people? The public have a right to charge someone for verbal abuse - why not the police? It's very likely been a 'tag on' charge to others.

AND sometimes a record of these police incidents ends up being helpful for the family who can evidence the support needs and access funding.

The girl likened the police woman to her lesbian nana - how is that verbal abuse?

The police statement is clear that this is about a homophobic comment.

The original police woman called for back up after the lesbian comment upset her so much and triggered her to run back into the house (illegal surely?) to make an arrest - surely this is the issue to focus on - why is a grown adult woman so triggered by being likened to a lesbian? What’s going on there? Why did this comment merit such an OTT reaction? Why did the other police not de-escalate the situation, instead of behaving as they did?

Ducksurprise · 11/08/2023 08:22

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 08:01

Secondary teachers will have experienced worse on a daily basis. Are they supposed to call for a public disorder squad every time?

They don't count/deserve it/chose to work with teenagers...