Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

7 police officers versus 1 autistic girl

242 replies

Green777 · 10/08/2023 22:14

https://metro.co.uk/video/teen-girl-autism-arrested-telling-officer-looks-like-lesbian-nana-2995683/

AIBU to think these Police officers should be disciplined for arresting this autistic

girl for a ‘hate crime’ then dragging her out of her home kicking and screaming?

The police officer who the girl said looked like her ‘lesbian nana’ seems very unprofessional.

Teen girl with autism arrested for telling officer she 'looks like my lesbian nana'

West Yorkshire Police's professional standards panel is investigating video footage of the incident involving an autistic 16-year-old girl following a complaint by her mother.

https://metro.co.uk/video/teen-girl-autism-arrested-telling-officer-looks-like-lesbian-nana-2995683/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Simonjt · 11/08/2023 10:37

Jellyx · 11/08/2023 10:09

Do we know how many teenagers carry knives these days?

Was she wearing a big badge saying disabled?

And disabled people can still really injure others...

What a shame she forgot to wear her black triangle badge in her own home.

Aminorpoet · 11/08/2023 10:32

Its disappointing people are defending this arrest. This is not how I want to be policed. There are some situations where I can imagine debating the rights and wrongs - but not this one. She is a minor? A female child with a disability. The police absolutely do not have grounds to hold her in custody and I expect it will have been a traumatic experience. I hope this results in disciplinary action but doubt it.

Ifeelsuchflutterings · 11/08/2023 10:25

Jellyx · 11/08/2023 10:09

Do we know how many teenagers carry knives these days?

Was she wearing a big badge saying disabled?

And disabled people can still really injure others...

Was she wearing a big badge saying disabled?

What like a big symbol on her clothes signalling her out at "other"

Yeah I don't think that's a path that ends well personally

borntobequiet · 11/08/2023 10:23

Since when is homophobia ok?

How is saying that someone looks like their lesbian Nanna homophobia? (Unless they’re Nannaphobic and so homophobic by some sort of transitive property.)

imautisticandalsoabitch · 11/08/2023 10:20

Does anyone know if this news story has made it to TV? I hope it does and I hope discussion programmes highlight it. Show these police officers up for who they are on national TV.

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 10:12

Jellyx · 11/08/2023 10:09

Do we know how many teenagers carry knives these days?

Was she wearing a big badge saying disabled?

And disabled people can still really injure others...

Oh fgs. She was not a threat. She was having a meltdown, the police invaded her space and escalated the situation.
Should the police arrest everyone in this way just in case they have a knife? Jesus, the police barely respond to assault or theft these days!

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 10:09

Stopping your vulnerable teen from going out doesn’t give them life skills. And how on earth would that ever be possible. Parents need to work. Vulnerable teens need educating and to live full lives. I thought we’d moved away from locking up people with disabilities. 🤔

Jellyx · 11/08/2023 10:09

Do we know how many teenagers carry knives these days?

Was she wearing a big badge saying disabled?

And disabled people can still really injure others...

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 10:09

MoustacheTwirler · 11/08/2023 10:06

@HatFamster

Your comments are misleading. The police have said "comments were made which resulted in the girl being arrested on suspicion of a homophobic offence." This is not the same as the police corroborating mums version of events that all she said was that police woman looked like her lesbian nana. Currently, we only have mums account of what was said and we do not have a record on camera of what exactly the girl had said.

Just to be clear that I think regardless of what the girl said, the police have acted completely inappropriately however I think we need to be accurate in what the police have actually said at this time.

Fair enough, but the comment was made in her own home, which muddies whether the police acted within the law in this case.

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 10:07

@FuppingEll I’m autistic too.
I stuck to rules rigidly. If I was told to not go out, I’d have done that with bells on.
My son however is very different. I cannot keep him in, even if it’s for his own safety. So it’s a case of managing the situation as best you can. I haven’t had to involve the police, but could easily have been in that situation.

Not all autistic teenagers are the same. You cannot judge by your experience alone.

ToughFuss · 11/08/2023 10:06

I have to be honest, at first glance, I very much doubted she ‘just’ said ‘you look like my lesbian nana’ to the police officer, not at all, but that really doesn’t make a difference! The fact remains she is a teenager with a disability and she was treated appallingly. There was no reason to go in all heavy handed and haul her out there and then. I’m not the first to start shouting about how appalling all police officers are, because that’s not the case at all, but this is a fantastic example of a really shit one being backed by equally culpable colleagues.

MoustacheTwirler · 11/08/2023 10:06

@HatFamster

Your comments are misleading. The police have said "comments were made which resulted in the girl being arrested on suspicion of a homophobic offence." This is not the same as the police corroborating mums version of events that all she said was that police woman looked like her lesbian nana. Currently, we only have mums account of what was said and we do not have a record on camera of what exactly the girl had said.

Just to be clear that I think regardless of what the girl said, the police have acted completely inappropriately however I think we need to be accurate in what the police have actually said at this time.

Takoneko · 11/08/2023 10:05

It doesn’t matter if what the kid said was way worse than what the mum has admitted, or if she has awful parents. Even if the body cam video shows her saying horribly abusive things, this is not an appropriate way to deal with it. She was not a physical threat and couldn’t be questioned until she’d sobered up anyway. They should have left and asked her to attend the station the next day with her mother. The arrest was punitive, it served no purpose in terms of investigation or public safety.

I would have thought that the Child Q case review would have led to police forces really looking at how they deal with vulnerable children, but sadly it appears not. Her mother should have been her appropriate adult.

It sounds like, like many 16 year olds, she lied to her parents about going to a sleepover and then snuck out to join her older sister. That happens to lots of parents of 16 year olds, whether they know it or not. But even if her parents were neglectful and letting her do it, that wouldn’t make treating her that way OK. Kids with shitty parents need more protection, not less.

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 10:03

You don't let your vulnerable teen go out

How do you stop them?
Locking my son permanently in his room and putting bars over the window would be the only way I could guarantee to keep him in - but this is inhumane, plus it would never give him any opportunity to live a normal life (which many MNers would love!). You’d be criticised for keeping a dog this way, let alone a human!

Teenagers sneak out sometimes, some teenagers don’t.
By all accounts the girl left to follow her sister.

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 10:03

FuppingEll

Well aren’t you perfect.

Autism varies a lot in severity and in how it presents in girls and boys.

RavingStone · 11/08/2023 10:01

I don't want my police to have fragile egos and thin skins. I don't want them to react with violence to somebody's words.

THOSE ARE THE PEOPLE WHO I WANT POLICING not to actually be the police.

FFS.

These police should be sacked and the force needs autism training asap. In fact, why the hell have they not already had this? I weep for the days when "inclusive" meant actually including all people and making adjustments for people with disabilities.

FuppingEll · 11/08/2023 10:00

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 09:53

Well when you have a child who can’t help her disability and see with the same disability deliberately heightened and dealt with completely out of proportion and in the wrong way in their own home whilst having officers of the law saying they don’t care about laws there to protect her maybe you’d envisage being livid.

I have a son the same age with the same disability. I don't really have to try too hard to imagine that part. What I can't imagine is letting him get into such an awful situation in the first place.

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 09:58

JokerAndTheQueen · 11/08/2023 09:54

That clip looks horrific but doesn't give any context including why the police were there in the first place. I hope it is investigated properly and if wrong has been commited it is dealt with but I don't agree with making assumptions of what's going on from a snippet at the point of arrest. I would want to know what she was actually arrested for as that bit had no sound....

The arrest was before that point.
According to the mother (whose version of events have been backed up by the police statement) the girl commented that the police looked like her lesbian nana, which the police overheard, and swooped back in to arrest.

The film showed the resulting fallout after backup had been requested, probably due to the teen going into meltdown.

FuppingEll · 11/08/2023 09:57

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 09:54

The mother explained that the teen had said she looked like her lesbian nana. That’s not abuse by any stretch of the imagination.

Yeah, sorry after seeing her behaviour towards her daughter I'm not taking her word for that.

Jellyx · 11/08/2023 09:57

I wonder if we ever post the 10000 good things police do. Or we just take every opportunity to slate them.

Are you guys all perfect in your job?

FuppingEll · 11/08/2023 09:56

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 09:52

Maybe it is just that the whole situation is really out there for me because none of that would have happened under my roof but I just can't imagine being 'livid' at the person my child abused

Again, where is the abuse?
An autistic teen comments that the police woman looked like her nana, who is a lesbian - in what world is that abuse? How is this a hate crime?

If you have an autistic child there are certain things, as a parent, that are out of your control, so you do your very best to manage that. Unfortunately it’s all made far more distressing by utter ignorant pricks who clearly don’t understand autism.

The police statement backs up the mother’s side. There may be more backstory, but nothing makes the handling of this by the police acceptable. They’ve screwed up here.

Again we don't know what the comments were.

If you have an autistic child there are certain things, as a parent, that are out of your control, so you do your very best to manage that.

Spot on. You don't let your vulnerable teen go out, get drunk and have to escorted home by the police. That obviously will lead to situations thay get very out of control so you manage it.

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 09:54

The mother explained that the teen had said she looked like her lesbian nana. That’s not abuse by any stretch of the imagination.

JokerAndTheQueen · 11/08/2023 09:54

That clip looks horrific but doesn't give any context including why the police were there in the first place. I hope it is investigated properly and if wrong has been commited it is dealt with but I don't agree with making assumptions of what's going on from a snippet at the point of arrest. I would want to know what she was actually arrested for as that bit had no sound....

Summerwashout · 11/08/2023 09:53

I, can't understand why they had to persist in taking her at that moment. Why she had to go into a cell for 20 hours to be questioned.
And it's still unclear what about? Is it really lesbian nanna?

Aby didn't they black off and say they would come back later?

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 09:53

Well when you have a child who can’t help her disability and see with the same disability deliberately heightened and dealt with completely out of proportion and in the wrong way in their own home whilst having officers of the law saying they don’t care about laws there to protect her maybe you’d envisage being livid.