Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

7 police officers versus 1 autistic girl

242 replies

Green777 · 10/08/2023 22:14

https://metro.co.uk/video/teen-girl-autism-arrested-telling-officer-looks-like-lesbian-nana-2995683/

AIBU to think these Police officers should be disciplined for arresting this autistic

girl for a ‘hate crime’ then dragging her out of her home kicking and screaming?

The police officer who the girl said looked like her ‘lesbian nana’ seems very unprofessional.

Teen girl with autism arrested for telling officer she 'looks like my lesbian nana'

West Yorkshire Police's professional standards panel is investigating video footage of the incident involving an autistic 16-year-old girl following a complaint by her mother.

https://metro.co.uk/video/teen-girl-autism-arrested-telling-officer-looks-like-lesbian-nana-2995683/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
sashh · 12/08/2023 08:05

I've just had a thought that has cheered me up.

I know the police give each other nicknames, and I know what Ms Blond short hair will now be called, for the rest of her (hopefully short) career.

LimeDrizzled · 12/08/2023 04:53

The girl was having a meltdown because she was frightened of the police. Regardless of the rights and wrongs of anything she did in the first place, they should know how to handle someone having a meltdown.

LimeDrizzled · 12/08/2023 04:52

sashh · 12/08/2023 04:47

Don't be ridiculous.

The point I was making is that a disability does affect an individual's life and the way they behave.

What about someone with Tourette's? Should they be arrested every day?

Even if someone has committed a crime or public order offence it doesn't mean the police get to manhandle them. This is the issue here.

sashh · 12/08/2023 04:47

oakleaffy · 11/08/2023 13:18

This 16 yr old was drunk in a public place. Her sister called police asking that they escort her home. {Why didn't the sister escort her home?}

Being autistic surely. doesn't absolve anyone if they have done or said something wrong- otherwise anyone on the Spectrum could go round saying what they want and claiming 'Disability is my excuse.. Police can't touch me because I have {insert disability here}.

It would be a free pass to do so many things.

Don't be ridiculous.

The point I was making is that a disability does affect an individual's life and the way they behave.

What about someone with Tourette's? Should they be arrested every day?

Siameasy · 11/08/2023 23:09

https://www.met.police.uk/notices/met/introduction-right-care-right-person-model/
most police forces have signed up to this. Basically triaging mental health calls. Previously the default was to send police to any call involving “concern for welfare”.

Police have powers to use force to detain under S136 but aren’t medically trained at all

lifeturnsonadime · 11/08/2023 22:51

Just picking up about the MH issue, its not correct that the police are the service needed if someone is a risk to themselves or others due to a MH crisis

Well that has changed recently then. We have been specifically signposted by CAMHS to the police if their out of hours can't deal with it.

imautisticandalsoabitch · 11/08/2023 21:34

@sashh so sorry that happened to you 🌸

Clymene · 11/08/2023 21:26

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 19:35

The 18 yr old sister couldn’t find the drunk and vulnerable 16 yr old, how is that not a police matter?

The actions taken by the police at this stage seem responsible and just what I would hope would happen.

I’m lucky enough to have never been in this situation with my son, but I know people who have had to involve the police for their autistic teens and they are reassured that they are doing the right thing.

The 18 yo was with her sister. She couldn't contact her mum so she called the police to help her get her sister home

If she hadn't, the police would never have been involved.

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 19:35

The 18 yr old sister couldn’t find the drunk and vulnerable 16 yr old, how is that not a police matter?

The actions taken by the police at this stage seem responsible and just what I would hope would happen.

I’m lucky enough to have never been in this situation with my son, but I know people who have had to involve the police for their autistic teens and they are reassured that they are doing the right thing.

bellac11 · 11/08/2023 19:27

HatFamster · 11/08/2023 18:25

In this case, it would have been far better if the parents had gone to collect their daughter, again Im not sure why the police are being used for things like this.

The 16 yr old was supposedly on a sleepover, but went to find her 18 yr old sister. The sister couldn’t find her, couldn’t get in touch with her parents (asleep and didn’t hear the phone) so rang the police as she was drunk and vulnerable, which was exactly the right thing to do.
Once home and inside the 16 yr old commented that the WPC looked like her nana who’s a lesbian, WPC took offence, allegedly assaulted the mother to get to the teen to arrest her. Illegally.

In this case it would be far better if the police had done their jobs within the law, and had some understanding of an autistic child who did nothing to deserve arrest.

I didnt make any comment on the rights and wrongs of the fall out, but again the police are being used for things that are not police matters. I'd be interested in why the police for example didnt make the parents aware they were needed and instruct them to go and collect their daughter. Perhaps that was a decision taken somewhere by someone that they would go and collect the girls instead.

bellac11 · 11/08/2023 19:25

Fuckingfuming1 · 11/08/2023 19:05

Just picking up about the MH issue, its not correct that the police are the service needed if someone is a risk to themselves or others due to a MH crisis

@bellac11 I dialled 999 for an ambulance and was sent the police. I didn’t ask for them that’s what I got.

If thats in the last few weeks, it will change significantly now

Fuckingfuming1 · 11/08/2023 19:05

bellac11 · 11/08/2023 18:06

Just picking up about the MH issue, its not correct that the police are the service needed if someone is a risk to themselves or others due to a MH crisis

That is a health matter and you'll have heard, if you've needed to phone 999 or 101 recently, a message saying exactly this, if you are in a MH crsis put the phone down and contact health services.

Obviously it may not always be clear if its a MH crisis that someone is having if someone is lunging at you with a knife or being verbally abusive/intimidating you and then you'll call the police obviously but ultimately its a health matter

In this case, it would have been far better if the parents had gone to collect their daughter, again Im not sure why the police are being used for things like this.

I wonder when more detail will come out about the wider context

Just picking up about the MH issue, its not correct that the police are the service needed if someone is a risk to themselves or others due to a MH crisis

@bellac11 I dialled 999 for an ambulance and was sent the police. I didn’t ask for them that’s what I got.

Clymene · 11/08/2023 18:30

They have decided to take no further action.

I bet angry blonde PC is fuming

7 police officers versus 1 autistic girl
HatFamster · 11/08/2023 18:25

In this case, it would have been far better if the parents had gone to collect their daughter, again Im not sure why the police are being used for things like this.

The 16 yr old was supposedly on a sleepover, but went to find her 18 yr old sister. The sister couldn’t find her, couldn’t get in touch with her parents (asleep and didn’t hear the phone) so rang the police as she was drunk and vulnerable, which was exactly the right thing to do.
Once home and inside the 16 yr old commented that the WPC looked like her nana who’s a lesbian, WPC took offence, allegedly assaulted the mother to get to the teen to arrest her. Illegally.

In this case it would be far better if the police had done their jobs within the law, and had some understanding of an autistic child who did nothing to deserve arrest.

bellac11 · 11/08/2023 18:06

lifeturnsonadime · 11/08/2023 11:35

You do know that CAMHS is so underfunded that they literally tell parents to call the emergency services when a child is in meltdown.

Sorry that's not quite right, police should be called when there is a situation where they are a danger to themselves or others.

In this case the only person in danger from the child's actions was herself.

Just picking up about the MH issue, its not correct that the police are the service needed if someone is a risk to themselves or others due to a MH crisis

That is a health matter and you'll have heard, if you've needed to phone 999 or 101 recently, a message saying exactly this, if you are in a MH crsis put the phone down and contact health services.

Obviously it may not always be clear if its a MH crisis that someone is having if someone is lunging at you with a knife or being verbally abusive/intimidating you and then you'll call the police obviously but ultimately its a health matter

In this case, it would have been far better if the parents had gone to collect their daughter, again Im not sure why the police are being used for things like this.

I wonder when more detail will come out about the wider context

Sunfl0w3r5 · 11/08/2023 15:34

FuppingEll

What are you talking about. No lesbians were threatened.

imautisticandalsoabitch · 11/08/2023 14:19

To all the people who've said that autistic teenagera shouldn't be let out at night.....you know that autistic teenagers turn into autistic adults right? You know we're all allowed out nowadays rather than beimg locked in asylums, yes?

We evil autistics walk amongst you mwahahahahahahahaha 😎

Ifeelsuchflutterings · 11/08/2023 13:34

FuppingEll · 11/08/2023 13:18

Nope. I haven't made the same decisions. And my child has never had any involvement with police or social services so it's working well for us. As an aside I have also taken parenting courses, knowledge is never a bad thing 🙂

So your child/ren never gets to go on sleepovers?

HardieHa · 11/08/2023 13:21

oldwhyno · 11/08/2023 12:44

Sure, you can be autistic and and act stupidly. But nobody's claimed the mother is autistic and all she did was make matters much worse.

I heard an interview with a former policeman now consultant on LBC this morning and he thought the mother did not resist the unlawful arrest enough! He said as the arrest was unlawful it was technically a kidnapping.

I have also heard the mother is autistic but I don't know if that is true. Autism is genetic but nobody has confirmed it either way. What I saw was a mother trying to protect her scared, vulnerable child from violent home intruders.

FuppingEll · 11/08/2023 13:19

endofthelinefinally · 11/08/2023 13:17

No lesbians were threatened in the situation being discussed on this thread.
An autistic child mentioned to her mother, in her own home, that a police officer looked like her Nanna, who happens to be a lesbian.
I don't think anyone could really take that as a threat.
The fact that police generally (at least in London, Manchester, Wales and Scotland) do not take death threats, rape threats and physical assault on lesbians seriously, suggests double standards to me.
However, nobody is forced to agree on that point.

Oh has the video with the child's remarks come out now then? I've been busy so haven't seen. I'll go take a look.

oakleaffy · 11/08/2023 13:18

sashh · 11/08/2023 12:51

Stupid?

This child has a disability that makes her try to hide ina cupboard to be safe.

It's like the police telling a paralised person to stand up, would you call them stupid too?

This 16 yr old was drunk in a public place. Her sister called police asking that they escort her home. {Why didn't the sister escort her home?}

Being autistic surely. doesn't absolve anyone if they have done or said something wrong- otherwise anyone on the Spectrum could go round saying what they want and claiming 'Disability is my excuse.. Police can't touch me because I have {insert disability here}.

It would be a free pass to do so many things.

FuppingEll · 11/08/2023 13:18

Ifeelsuchflutterings · 11/08/2023 11:34

They let their child go on a sleepover

She snuck out and went drinking

If you have ever let a teenager go on a sleepover then you have made the exact same parenting choice as these parents

Do you also need a parenting course if that is the case?

Nope. I haven't made the same decisions. And my child has never had any involvement with police or social services so it's working well for us. As an aside I have also taken parenting courses, knowledge is never a bad thing 🙂

endofthelinefinally · 11/08/2023 13:17

No lesbians were threatened in the situation being discussed on this thread.
An autistic child mentioned to her mother, in her own home, that a police officer looked like her Nanna, who happens to be a lesbian.
I don't think anyone could really take that as a threat.
The fact that police generally (at least in London, Manchester, Wales and Scotland) do not take death threats, rape threats and physical assault on lesbians seriously, suggests double standards to me.
However, nobody is forced to agree on that point.

FuppingEll · 11/08/2023 13:12

endofthelinefinally · 11/08/2023 12:44

FuppingEll · Today 09:17

"Sorry I disagree. As the mother of a gay 16yo I would expect the police to take any homophobic public order offences against him seriously, not go 'wah, wah, hurty feelings'. I really can't believe that you are reducing homophobia down to 'hurty feelings'. I presume you feel the same way about sexism too? How about ablism? Wah, wah hurty feelings right?"

There is no evidence of homophobia in this case at all so far. Neither did the remark that annoyed the police officer happen in public. Lesbians are threatened and assaulted in public all the time, often in the presence of police, and nothing is done. You only have to watch the LWS events to see this.

This assault by police on a vulnerable, disabled child is shocking.

I really don't know what you are on about. Someone was arrested for a homophobic offense. You think that lesbians should be threatened in peace because its just hurty feelings? Or you think because some lesbians are threatened and nothing is done nothing should ever be done about it? Good for you. I disagree.