Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

After watching the first episode of Earth to think humans should wipe themselves out.

193 replies

pompomdaisy · 10/08/2023 20:20

After watching the programme about the great extinction 250 million years ago it's made me think this planet will be far better without us and the sooner we become extinct the better.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LuckyPeonies · 13/08/2023 21:37

@Lightningspeed If people aren’t the problem, what is? I am genuinely curious to know. The way I see it, the industrial revolution which was started by people, along with population explosions because of improved medical treatments and living conditions, resulted n huge increases in consumption plus pollution, which caused (or accelerated, depending whom you ask) climate change, etc.

Lightningspeed · 12/08/2023 23:04

So clever, convince people they are the problem. It's so pathetic

Lightningspeed · 12/08/2023 23:00

Malthusian people Always think it will be others, watch the Corbett report about malthusian objectives.

Angrycat2768 · 12/08/2023 22:52

The only way to wipe out humans while not causing huge amounts of differing would be through a massive meteor strike that wiped us all out instantaneously. Although the meteor didn't wipe out all the dinosaurs and many starved to death. But if a meteor wiped out humans then most other species would also go. So no need to worry about who would shear the sheep

LuckyPeonies · 12/08/2023 18:14

If humans disappeared, there would be no need for species bred to supply human wants. So they would either adapt and survive, or not.

As for feral chickens in UK, there was a rather aggressive flock on Jersey. They shot most of them. And there are some in other UK areas as well, Suffolk and Norfolk. I don’t know if people are feeding them though.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 12/08/2023 17:46

Domesticated sheep have been bred for larger fleeces. Wild sheep have smaller fleeces that can be shed naturally.

The point I am making generally is that humans have bred domestic animals for traits that would hamper their ability to survive in the wild.

Wild chickens might do well in the Caribbean but I don’t fancy their chances in a Northern European winter - if they survive the dogs, cats and foxes.

In London we have feral ring necked parakeets which are great fun but it’s not clear they would have survived so well if humans hadn’t been providing food either through feeding or waste.

LuckyPeonies · 12/08/2023 17:30

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 12/08/2023 09:48

If humans were to disappear tomorrow the majority of domesticated animals would die not do better. How long would the average farm cow or sheep live?

Wild species of these animals might be fine without us but domesticated animals have been bred for different traits.

But those are species we have bred to kill/exploit to serve our wants, not naturally occurring species. There are no wild species that depend on humans to survive. In fact, their dwindling populations would most certainly recover and thrive if humans suddenly disappeared.

I would really like to know if the 1.2 million clam was just a random number, or if the poster can provide a scientific link.

On a side note, chickens who have gone feral do quite well, very evident in the Carribean.

LeonardCohensRaincoat · 12/08/2023 17:08

@ChazsBrilliantAttitude

what happens to the fleece of wild sheep? How do they manage without getting shorn?

JudgeAnderson · 12/08/2023 16:28

*bred.

JudgeAnderson · 12/08/2023 16:27

I am not a meat eater but a slow and painful death doesn’t sound like an improvement.

But it would be a one-off mass death and that would be the end of it - no more generation after generation bread for consumption.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 12/08/2023 16:23

JudgeAnderson · 12/08/2023 16:15

How long would the average farm cow or sheep live?

Tbf it's hardly like they're bred to live out a natural lifespan anywhere so overall that would be a welfare win, and I say this as a keen meat eater but realistically.

A dairy cow has much higher energy requirements than a wild cow so they would likely starve. Most farmed chickens would be eaten quite quickly especially if there are loads of hungry pet dogs on the loose. I would imagine unshorn sheep would be at risk of flystrike. I am not a meat eater but a slow and painful death doesn’t sound like an improvement.

JudgeAnderson · 12/08/2023 16:15

How long would the average farm cow or sheep live?

Tbf it's hardly like they're bred to live out a natural lifespan anywhere so overall that would be a welfare win, and I say this as a keen meat eater but realistically.

CherryMaDeara · 12/08/2023 10:32

In that episode the volcanic episodes released gases and ash that heated the planet and that eventually killed 90% of the planet.

Sounds like Mordor.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 12/08/2023 09:48

LuckyPeonies · 12/08/2023 03:28

1.2 million species depend on humans to survive?? Do you have a reliable link to document those numbers? I can’t think of any besides certain pets. Even the animals we breed to kill and eat would do much better without humans.

If humans were to disappear tomorrow the majority of domesticated animals would die not do better. How long would the average farm cow or sheep live?

Wild species of these animals might be fine without us but domesticated animals have been bred for different traits.

Riapia · 12/08/2023 04:53

Everybody seems to believe that evolution has reached its peak with humans.
Whatever life forms are on earth in a few million years will be as different to humans as we are to the first single celled creatures.

MXVIT · 12/08/2023 03:45

"I've had my kids but YOU, you all need to not have any please because the planet"

Fucking hell.

LuckyPeonies · 12/08/2023 03:28

L3ThirtySeven · 10/08/2023 22:46

I dunno.
Number of species that depend on cockroaches to survive: 0
Number of species that depend on humans to survive: 1.2 million

1.2 million species depend on humans to survive?? Do you have a reliable link to document those numbers? I can’t think of any besides certain pets. Even the animals we breed to kill and eat would do much better without humans.

RosaGallica · 11/08/2023 22:43

But not actually control actions to improve it. Who is reading this and driving an unnecessary SUV.

Angrycat2768 · 11/08/2023 21:17

Naunet · 11/08/2023 08:27

But it’ll never change our nature. Humans are greedy, short term thinkers, we want as much as we can get now, without considering the future impact. It’s our nature, (and to be fair, a lot of other animals nature too) hence why people smoke and drink and eat bad food - it’s immediate gratification without concerning ourselves with the longer term impact. We would need to fundamentally change as a species. If we reach other planets before that happens, then we will become the aliens we’ve always feared, the ones that come to plunder and steal resources.

From an objective point of view, why should we have the chance to mature at other animals expense, at the planet’s expense? We’re no more important than any other species, in fact, far less important than many.

Humans are 'greedy, short term creatures' because we are animals, and like all animals, our main purpose is to survive and reproduce. That is it. We are no less brutal than any other animals. We just have a more advanced brain, which means we can think longer term than the average cat for example, so can contemplate the future.

PoseyFlump · 11/08/2023 21:14

Horta · 11/08/2023 19:39

Feel free to start one

Your contribution has been ..... yawn.

Angrycat2768 · 11/08/2023 21:07

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 11/08/2023 00:28

I don't wish for our demise but humans are very destructive to the planet. We will one day meet our demise though, just as many other species before us have, and the planet will continue on and flourish.

I agree with this. We are just a speck on the face of the planet. If 'Earth' should have taught you anything, its that.The dinosaurs were around for 350 million years. We have been around for 6 million. I doubt we will last for even another 10 million years. Environmentalism is about making human life tolerable while we are on this planet. Not wiping out the Human race. The earth will then replenish itself and a new dominant life form will appear.The atmosphere when the dinosaurs were around was toxic to humans. Environmental issues are about making the planet more habitable for us as a species. Lions and tigers don't care whether or not they will be extinct in 50 years time as long as they can find food to eat in he next couple of days and can find another lion to mate with. They only care about their immediate vicinity. The reason we want lions and tigers around are because we care about them. Wishing the human race to die out, as others have said is eugenics couched as environmental concern. You want to wipe out humans, presumably ones who arent' you or your immediate family or friends. Just the 'unworthy' ones.And who decides who is 'unworthy'? People like you? White Europeans? Or maybe all those other people living a much more simple non polluting life. Africa is the only continent with an increasing birthrate. Shall we start with them? Lets let disease run rampant so their babies all die, shall we?

RosaGallica · 11/08/2023 20:16

There are an odd few islands left for wildlife around the coasts of Britain. I have thought once or twice that we could do with leaving more. Maybe this entire group of islands, Madagascar, maybe the islands at the other end of Asia, Japan and Philippines. But I wouldn’t want to lose island cultures: and Britain’s development at least has included humans since it was wiped almost clean by the ice ages, it’s impossible to imagine an ecology without some human interference. Even the wildwoods here are contain results of some human use. Many wild plants thrive on the clearings we make, think of hedgerows. Humans are a natural part of the ecology: we do need fewer of us and much less consumption. Fortunately our population is due to fall, the other species just need to hold out and we need to support them to do so.

Horta · 11/08/2023 19:39

Feel free to start one

PoseyFlump · 11/08/2023 17:31

Why can't we have just one decent discussion on MN without all the personal digs, sniping and downright nastiness?

PoseyFlump · 11/08/2023 17:25

@Horta what you on about? Oh. Sorry. Did I forget to check with you before having an opinion? 🙄