Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So many child haters here

457 replies

Sabrinasummersamples · 10/08/2023 17:59

So many threads on here seem to attract the same sort of answer along the lines of
-In my day we'd have got a smack. Never did me any harm. Give em a clip round the ear.
-kids today are entitled shrieky brats
-kids should stand for adults
-kids shouldn't be allowed in restaurants

Yet often those same posters are the first to call "agism" when people disagree.
Why do so many people hold such contempt for kids?
I mean I know kids can be annoying but honestly you could say that about any group of people. Plus we were all kids once 🤷

OP posts:
Saymynameandeverycolourilluminates · 11/08/2023 21:55

@Rainyday35 it wasn’t Feversham Arms in Yorkshire was it?

Rainyday35 · 11/08/2023 21:25

Went to a ‘luxury’ spa yesterday for a ‘relaxing’ day. May as well have been at local leisure centre. Kids running about, screaming, splashing in the pools (parents blissfully ignoring signs that children shouldn’t be in one of the pools). Felt like I’d been robbed as had paid nearly £300 for the day. How is a spa the right place to take young children???

Jifmicroliquid · 11/08/2023 20:56

Saoirse82 · 10/08/2023 22:03

If they can’t control their child, they seek a label to justify their poor parenting

@Jifmicroliquid this is the biggest load of shite I've probably ever read on here.

😂Ah if only it was!

user9630721458 · 11/08/2023 20:34

@Hibiscrubbed The parents sound very foolish to allow their children to take such risks. I'm glad they are not coming to your farm as I think the risk is too great, and that's not fair on you. I do know a fair few sensible 12 year olds, but I wouldn't let them wander unaccompanied around a farm, unless they had grown up there maybe! Even sensible kids might come a cropper. I don't know what is going on with your friends' children but it does sound like they have some issues.

Hibiscrubbed · 11/08/2023 20:20

user9630721458 · 11/08/2023 20:08

@Hibiscrubbed Are the children wandering the farm unaccompanied/going into fields with animals? Farms can be quite dangerous and you would be entitled to tell your friends the children cannot go anywhere without adult supervision. Or are they with adults but mingling with the cows while their parents watch? I don't know what your responsibilities are as the farm owner, but I'd be very careful to avoid any chance of accidents if I were you. Small children really don't understand the hazards of machinery and livestock.

Yes. I am aware. Hence my irritation…

These are not small children. These are 10-12 year old children. These are children who, when we were all standing at a fence admiring a fresh foal that had been born, one went to climb through the fence without warning. I shouted loudly to stop, they looked at me, smirked, and ran into the field to get to the foal. The mare went bananas. The parents did some ineffective gentle calling and beckoning of said child shitbag and then started to panic and get high pitched. It was absolute chaos.

I have said, until I’m blue in the face, that they are not to be unaccompanied in the yard, around the machinery, and anywhere near the pit. I have told their parents this, how dangerous it is, but they are total indulgent drips ruled by these kids. I won’t have them here anymore. I cannot stand it. It’s a shame. They’re old friends. They never used to be like this.

If they’re actually in my house, they repeatedly break my small kid’s toys and once threw a lovely Loaf mug at a wall in anger at being told no.

I know these kids are the product of duff parenting, but it has produced hideous little people that I won’t be around. And to think I was producing a pony for the Eldest little madam to show. Nope. On your bike, sunshine.

user9630721458 · 11/08/2023 20:08

@Hibiscrubbed Are the children wandering the farm unaccompanied/going into fields with animals? Farms can be quite dangerous and you would be entitled to tell your friends the children cannot go anywhere without adult supervision. Or are they with adults but mingling with the cows while their parents watch? I don't know what your responsibilities are as the farm owner, but I'd be very careful to avoid any chance of accidents if I were you. Small children really don't understand the hazards of machinery and livestock.

Hibiscrubbed · 11/08/2023 19:54

They could just be being polite, and grinning and bearing it in real life. The freedom of an anonymous MB is that you can say what you really think

True. I’d never tell my friends how unbearable I find their whiny, demanding, disobedient, destructive children. I’d never tell them how irritating I find it when they butt in to adult conversations and are immediately pandered to. I’d never tell them how how angry it makes me when they fuck about on my farm and don’t listen to clear instructions (when they get kicked in the head by a spooked horse or flattened by startled cows with calves or overcome in a slurry pit it’ll no doubt be my fault).

But I will tell Mumsnet. I’m under no illusion it’s the fault of the parents, but they’ve created children I have absolutely no interest in being around.

Saymynameandeverycolourilluminates · 11/08/2023 18:22

@FarEast
please scroll up and read my previous post, as! Children are humans but they are not the same as adult humans are they?? Children's brains don't finish developing until their 20's!

Toddlers and pre-schoolers especially havean underdeveloped brain, you can parent all the way to mars but the fact that the brain as a whole and especially the pre frontal cortex - which controls a lot of the elements of behaviour which people and most parents find undesirable (like impulsive behaviour, reckless), means that it is physically impossible to eliminate all undesirable behaviour at those ages especially.

The type of self/social awareness you are meaning, they do not have the capacity to start to develop until between 6 and 8 and that's starting to develop!

HauntedPencil · 11/08/2023 17:04

This thread isn't about those people though is is, as I read it it was about the extreme ridiculous comments and threads popping up lately.

FarEast · 11/08/2023 17:03

So it's not the case that people who dislike child-haters themselves are haters of people without kids

But I didn't actually say that @Sabrinasummersamples

And I actually think it's very OTT to call posters who object to children's inappropriate and selfish behaviour "haters". They are just pointing out that children too, are humans, who share public space with other humans, and parents need to instil some awareness of this - age-appropriate awareness of course - into their DC. It's called parenting, as I'm sure you know.

CurlewKate · 11/08/2023 16:58

I do think people exaggerate for effect on here. One badly behaved child on a train becomes a feral rabble!

Sabrinasummersamples · 11/08/2023 16:35

The thing is @FarEast those people are dicks as well. I can't understand child haters. On the whole I think they're pretty awful people. But I feel the same about anyone who thinks badly about someone because they are single or child-free as well. My best friend is both and she's a fabulous person. Also she loves my kids like they're her family and they (and me and DH) love her in the same way. In fact we have spoken about her potentially being written into our wills as guardian for our kids should something happen to the both of us (and that was her who suggested it btw) although we haven't formalised it as yet. I'd trust her to be a better guardian than any of our DC grandparents. So it's not the case that people who dislike child-haters themselves are haters of people without kids

OP posts:
HauntedPencil · 11/08/2023 16:32

I genuinely don't care if someone finds kids generally super annoying and avoids them - it bothers me not one bit if peolple don't want them themselves life a lovely child free enjoyable life - I like to hear about their lives.

Saying I find kids annoying I tend to avoid is different to the hectoring tone on here saying they shouldn't be allowed out/are running riot / brats/ feckless parents/ bring back the dap shite

FarEast · 11/08/2023 16:28

I don't know anyone in real life who hates children like some seem to on mumsnet. And I find it quite bizarre.

They could just be being polite, and grinning and bearing it in real life. The freedom of an anonymous MB is that you can say what you really think.

Some of the attitudes to single and childless women on this thread are verrrry illuminating, for instance.

And unlike those of us who grin & bear inappropriately noisy children, or jump out of the way of DC careering into us on the street because they've not been taught to consider that they're sharing space with other people, you'd be surprised at how much other people express their views (not quite hatred but certainly not benign) about single and childless women to those very women, to our faces.

HauntedPencil · 11/08/2023 14:32

What you are describing is extreme behaviour and if your telling me every kid on that train but yours were doing that I just do not believe you.

NEmama · 11/08/2023 14:29

Erm no my DC aren't angels but they weren't throwing bottles, sticking their fingers up at strangers, spitting and trying to open stranger's bags!

Sabrinasummersamples · 11/08/2023 14:22

Why on earth was he making his poor mother fly? People with dementia need as much routine and as little disruption as possible. It must have been awful for her.

He was bringing her back to the UK where he and most of her family lived so that they could be closer to her apparently. I felt really bad for him (and her). It was an awful situation.

OP posts:
HauntedPencil · 11/08/2023 14:21

NEmama · 11/08/2023 14:07

I got a train with my own DC earlier this week.
There were some absolutely feral children my DC were shocked.
Some people do not know how to parent

Really? I bet you sat they sat there mouths agape like the railway children whilst all the other children ran amok.

DatumTarum · 11/08/2023 14:16

Sabrinasummersamples · 11/08/2023 14:02

I was on an overnight flight back from NY to London about 15 years ago.
There was a man in his 50s or maybe 60s who happened to be sitting in the same row as us with his elderly mother. The poor lady was obviously suffering from advanced dementia. During the flight she was shouting out a lot. She was hitting him and people walking past, she got out of her seat and he had to get her back in again against her will and she soiled herself and the poor man had to get her cleaned up. It was awful. Luckily not one single person as far as I could tell thought badly if him or her, the only thing I could sense from people nearby was sympathy. Because obviously she didn't have the cognitive ability to behave in the way we would expect most other people to and he couldn't help that. I mean I'm pretty sure shouting at her or threatening her wouldn't have helped the situation (and would obviously have been cruel)
But I wonder what the reaction would have been if she'd been say a 2 year old? I have a feeling there'd have been a lot less compassion and a lot more blame and tutting. Why? Little kids also don't have the cognitive ability to act in a rational way. Why is it ok to blame their parents, or expect them to be bullied into submission?

Good post

KimberleyClark · 11/08/2023 14:10

Sabrinasummersamples · 11/08/2023 14:02

I was on an overnight flight back from NY to London about 15 years ago.
There was a man in his 50s or maybe 60s who happened to be sitting in the same row as us with his elderly mother. The poor lady was obviously suffering from advanced dementia. During the flight she was shouting out a lot. She was hitting him and people walking past, she got out of her seat and he had to get her back in again against her will and she soiled herself and the poor man had to get her cleaned up. It was awful. Luckily not one single person as far as I could tell thought badly if him or her, the only thing I could sense from people nearby was sympathy. Because obviously she didn't have the cognitive ability to behave in the way we would expect most other people to and he couldn't help that. I mean I'm pretty sure shouting at her or threatening her wouldn't have helped the situation (and would obviously have been cruel)
But I wonder what the reaction would have been if she'd been say a 2 year old? I have a feeling there'd have been a lot less compassion and a lot more blame and tutting. Why? Little kids also don't have the cognitive ability to act in a rational way. Why is it ok to blame their parents, or expect them to be bullied into submission?

Why on earth was he making his poor mother fly? People with dementia need as much routine and as little disruption as possible. It must have been awful for her.

NEmama · 11/08/2023 14:07

I got a train with my own DC earlier this week.
There were some absolutely feral children my DC were shocked.
Some people do not know how to parent

HauntedPencil · 11/08/2023 14:05

Loads of complaints about children playing and making too much noise - if they are in their own garden/a playground/ the park/ a play area they are going to make noise.

I don't think children are any louder than they used to be unless you are thinking of Victorian children half the way up a chimney.

This is my point, children are being normal on the whole it's the adults that are being a nightmare.

Sabrinasummersamples · 11/08/2023 14:02

I was on an overnight flight back from NY to London about 15 years ago.
There was a man in his 50s or maybe 60s who happened to be sitting in the same row as us with his elderly mother. The poor lady was obviously suffering from advanced dementia. During the flight she was shouting out a lot. She was hitting him and people walking past, she got out of her seat and he had to get her back in again against her will and she soiled herself and the poor man had to get her cleaned up. It was awful. Luckily not one single person as far as I could tell thought badly if him or her, the only thing I could sense from people nearby was sympathy. Because obviously she didn't have the cognitive ability to behave in the way we would expect most other people to and he couldn't help that. I mean I'm pretty sure shouting at her or threatening her wouldn't have helped the situation (and would obviously have been cruel)
But I wonder what the reaction would have been if she'd been say a 2 year old? I have a feeling there'd have been a lot less compassion and a lot more blame and tutting. Why? Little kids also don't have the cognitive ability to act in a rational way. Why is it ok to blame their parents, or expect them to be bullied into submission?

OP posts:
Sabrinasummersamples · 11/08/2023 13:51

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · Today 13:02

Sorry but EVERY generation thinks kids are 'feral'.

If it's acceptable to not like kids, is it acceptable to not like old people? Middle aged people? Teenagers?

If you even mention someone's age for whatever reason and they are over the age of 50 you'll get called agist on here. Kids though? Fair game for any insults you like.

OP posts:
RedPony1 · 11/08/2023 13:43

FOJN · 10/08/2023 18:17

Children will be children but that doesn't excuse poor parenting.

No it's not OK for your children to be running around in a cafe or restaurant.
Children playing do not sound like they are being murdered.
The supermarket is not a playground.

This!!