Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So many child haters here

457 replies

Sabrinasummersamples · 10/08/2023 17:59

So many threads on here seem to attract the same sort of answer along the lines of
-In my day we'd have got a smack. Never did me any harm. Give em a clip round the ear.
-kids today are entitled shrieky brats
-kids should stand for adults
-kids shouldn't be allowed in restaurants

Yet often those same posters are the first to call "agism" when people disagree.
Why do so many people hold such contempt for kids?
I mean I know kids can be annoying but honestly you could say that about any group of people. Plus we were all kids once 🤷

OP posts:
Maddy70 · 11/08/2023 07:46

Kids are bloody awful to be around generally. I actively avoid them where I can

BMrs · 11/08/2023 07:44

Yellowlegobrick · 10/08/2023 18:35

But id disagree in part anyway, having my own children I feel has made me much more accepting of normal child behaviour and much more socially responsible about children. I helped a young girl who was very travel sick on a ferry ride recently as her parent was busy struggling with her sibling, no way would have stepped into help in that way before i had my own kids. I suppose you become aware that you'd want other grown ups to be kind and helpful to your own kids and so become willing to do that for other people's children.

Exactly this! If I hear a toddler having a meltdown I try not to look as I feel "we've all been there" and it's bloody hard

LolaSmiles · 11/08/2023 07:41

Those who decide it's "gentle parenting" that's the issue when they see permissive parenting are unlikely to have asked the parents if they are "gentle parenting" so I kind of suspect they're just blaming gentle parenting based on their own misconceptions of what it is. Positioning authoritarian parenting as the only alternative to permissive parenting is obviously something that an authoritarian is likely to do. It doesn't make it true.
I agree with you.
My parenting would fall under the gentle parenting umbrella.

I think it matters that those of us who take a empathetic and authoritative approach have to keep making it clear that permissive and lazy parenting is not gentle parenting if attitudes are going to change.
I always say on threads that people won't notice people who take the genuinely gentle parenting approach because they'll look like any other parent calmly holding boundaries.

Sabrinasummersamples · 11/08/2023 07:41

@Littlemissfroggy I think you've pretty much put into words exactly what I was thinking actually.

And posts like this one are exactly the sort of thing I was talking about:

Finlesswonder · Today 06:28
Most kids today are badly brought up.
Everybody's child seems to have some unique quirk that makes teaching them manners "challenging" or not applicable to them.

I don't think we should go back to the good old days of clips around the ear but I do think "seen and not heard" was actually a pretty good system. You do notice on holiday that it's only the UK kids who are loud.

It's just not true. I have 8 year olds. I've spent quite a lot of time with their school mates and even with their whole class because I try and take time off work to help out on school trips or events. On the whole the kids are well behaved. Sure one or 2 are a bit more challenging, but honestly those couple of kids DO have SEN however much the seen and not heard brigade might deny it, and actually they're not even that "badly" behaved anyway.
And other than at softplay (which is admittedly hell on earth) I very rarely hear kids actually shrieking.
And no, the "certain age" I was referring to is not in their 90s. In my experience the very elderly actually do seem to love kids. It tends to be late 50s to say 70s I'd say. Obviously not all of them at all. Plenty of people in this age group love kids but I really have heard a lot of harping on about how in the "60s we had respect"
But you know what? Ive also seen plenty of horrendous behaviour from that age group!. You don't get respect and reverence just for making it to a certain age. You actually have to earn it by being a decent person first. And actually I hope some of those kids you were horrible to end up working in your nursing home and remember!

FWIW I wouldn't say I've heard more hate from child free. I'd say there is just as much that comes from those whose kids have grown up.

And lastly, British kids are NOT in my experience worse behaved than those from elsewhere. This is just the same old crap that gets brought out regularly. I guess kids from Europe say, do spend more time in adult company, because they're accepted more as members of society, so maybe they have more experience. When we were in Crete recently, we noticed that the ones who were allowed to run around and generally make a nuisance of themselves in an outside restaurant were French speaking. And I mean really make a nuisance of themselves. They were climbing on the walls that separated the restaurant from a drop to the beach and pushing each other off a pretty big drop while their parents ignored them.

OP posts:
Littlemissfroggy · 11/08/2023 07:37

I also think many millennials are choosing to parent differently (less authoritarian) because though they are "successful" in terms of career, education, socially acceptable behaviour etc they are also struggling with their own self esteem, boundaries, mental health and life direction. And they relate this to a childhood of (well-intentioned) emotional invalidation. There is less of a belief in the societal grind - adherence to the authoritarian systems of education and traditional work is far less rewarding than for previous generations. Duty and obedience are more likely to result in exploitation than reciprocation.

Rising awareness and discussions around emotional and mental health are causing parents to think more carefully about what they are hoping to achieve when they parent (an adult that behaves well because they are frightened or ashamed of the alternatives Vs a well rounded adult who is emotionally mature, empathetic and able to balance consideration and respect for others alongside self advocacy and self respect).

bladebladebla1 · 11/08/2023 07:35

BMW6 · 10/08/2023 18:28

Come off it OP. People don't hate ALL kids - just the badly behaved ones.

But people are generally more grumpy nowadays and tolerance has significantly dropped, not just with kids with everything. On here in particular

Sux2buthen · 11/08/2023 07:33

There's a lot of it on here.
Kids in garden too noisy
Kids in house should be outside
Kids in cafes on screens
Kids in cafes should be quieter
Kid spoke to my kid
Kid didn't speak to my kid
Kid cheeky
Kid quiet

The list goes on, I believe about a third of the opinions on here are real at best.

GrandParentsOrDoctor · 11/08/2023 07:30

I only see it really on dog threads. Where people’s only defence of their poor training of their badly behaved mutts is ‘but but children are worse’.

DatumTarum · 11/08/2023 07:21

Littlemissfroggy · 11/08/2023 07:07

I identify with gentle parenting and actually I don't think it's difficult, I think it's the most natural and easiest way to parent. However, you have to have overcome certain messages/beliefs/patterns from your own childhood and you have to have the emotional maturity to sit with your child's emotions and to not be reactive - that's the most difficult part.

Eg gentle parenting
Child "I want an ice-cream"
Adult "We're not having an ice-cream right now because it's nearly lunchtime"
Child's emotional response which may include tantrum (usually related to factors like tiredness, hunger etc not whether they are "good" or "bad")
Adult does not relent and buy an ice-cream but neither do they scream at or punish the child for a completely normal emotional response. They help the child to identify the emotions, offer them empathy and try to redirect attention positively. They do not lose control. This is clearly not permissive aka "lazy" parenting.

I find the idea that gentle parenting is actually lazy/lax parenting interesting as in my experience self identifying gentle parents are parenting very consciously and are often (too) perfectionist. Gentle parenting is a type of authoritative parenting - it's not permissive parenting.

Often re "badly behaving" children whilst there may be aspects of permissive parenting I think the bigger factor is straightforward rolemodelling. If you demonstrate to children that when you have power over them you will exercise that power arbitrarily to do what you want without considering their needs/wants, then they will adopt a similar position towards you and others if they find that they are in the position of power. If you resolve conflict with your children by shouting, they will learn to resolve conflict by shouting. Etc Children who aren't considerate toward others are typically copying their parents who aren't considerate to others or them.

In these cases becoming (even) more authoritarian (which is different than authoritative) will work to suppress unwanted behaviour through fear, leading to the belief that "lax parenting" is the problem. But imo a better alternative is to teach children empathy and respect by showing them empathy and respect (!), which authoritarian parenting does not. It's completely possible to show children empathy and respect whilst remaining in control and giving them the security of boundaries and clear expectations.

Those who decide it's "gentle parenting" that's the issue when they see permissive parenting are unlikely to have asked the parents if they are "gentle parenting" so I kind of suspect they're just blaming gentle parenting based on their own misconceptions of what it is. Positioning authoritarian parenting as the only alternative to permissive parenting is obviously something that an authoritarian is likely to do. It doesn't make it true.

Good post.

To some, gentle parenting is any method that doesn't involve screaming and shouting or even hitting. Those people think that if you're not demonstrably doing those things then you're not in charge.

I

CloudyMcCloud · 11/08/2023 07:15

@Littlemissfroggy i agree with you and good post. The Icecream but is a good example. Losing it or relenting are likely easier than dealing with each situation as you say.

Littlemissfroggy · 11/08/2023 07:07

I identify with gentle parenting and actually I don't think it's difficult, I think it's the most natural and easiest way to parent. However, you have to have overcome certain messages/beliefs/patterns from your own childhood and you have to have the emotional maturity to sit with your child's emotions and to not be reactive - that's the most difficult part.

Eg gentle parenting
Child "I want an ice-cream"
Adult "We're not having an ice-cream right now because it's nearly lunchtime"
Child's emotional response which may include tantrum (usually related to factors like tiredness, hunger etc not whether they are "good" or "bad")
Adult does not relent and buy an ice-cream but neither do they scream at or punish the child for a completely normal emotional response. They help the child to identify the emotions, offer them empathy and try to redirect attention positively. They do not lose control. This is clearly not permissive aka "lazy" parenting.

I find the idea that gentle parenting is actually lazy/lax parenting interesting as in my experience self identifying gentle parents are parenting very consciously and are often (too) perfectionist. Gentle parenting is a type of authoritative parenting - it's not permissive parenting.

Often re "badly behaving" children whilst there may be aspects of permissive parenting I think the bigger factor is straightforward rolemodelling. If you demonstrate to children that when you have power over them you will exercise that power arbitrarily to do what you want without considering their needs/wants, then they will adopt a similar position towards you and others if they find that they are in the position of power. If you resolve conflict with your children by shouting, they will learn to resolve conflict by shouting. Etc Children who aren't considerate toward others are typically copying their parents who aren't considerate to others or them.

In these cases becoming (even) more authoritarian (which is different than authoritative) will work to suppress unwanted behaviour through fear, leading to the belief that "lax parenting" is the problem. But imo a better alternative is to teach children empathy and respect by showing them empathy and respect (!), which authoritarian parenting does not. It's completely possible to show children empathy and respect whilst remaining in control and giving them the security of boundaries and clear expectations.

Those who decide it's "gentle parenting" that's the issue when they see permissive parenting are unlikely to have asked the parents if they are "gentle parenting" so I kind of suspect they're just blaming gentle parenting based on their own misconceptions of what it is. Positioning authoritarian parenting as the only alternative to permissive parenting is obviously something that an authoritarian is likely to do. It doesn't make it true.

marblesthecat · 11/08/2023 07:04

I don't hate children. I hate shitty parents who can't be arsed to parent said children and as a result I am affected by their bad behaviour.

LolaSmiles · 11/08/2023 07:00

Finlesswonder
I think the actions of the parents is the difference, you're right.

I know I can take my DC out with me and that they'll be generally well behaved and use an appropriate volume. They're children though so they might need some reminders. Most of my friends are the same.
Some parents think fog horn/playground/at the park volume is acceptable everywhere and that it should be accepted by everyone else "because kids".

Finlesswonder · 11/08/2023 06:54

@LolaSmiles
Yeah I think the volume issue is the big one. Yesterday I was in a hotel in another country and went down for breakfast. It was 7am and there was an English family with two kids, they weren't shouting or shrieking but the kids were speaking really loudly, like "we're at a BBQ" loud. I just found it unbelievable that the parents weren't kind of hushing them or asking them to speak in a low voice (which is what everyone else was doing).
The attitude seems to have shifted from "we're sharing this space with lots of other people who are up early to start their day" to "Hey! Kids are kids! It's breakfast, and this is how my kids talk at breakfast at home so I don't see why we would do it differently on holiday!".

It's really weird because these parents are millennials, they would have been raised that way themselves so not sure why they aren't applying it to their own kids. Maybe this generation of small children will grow up to form a society that's so unbearably loud and "my needs" focused that they then swing the other way when they have kids of their own, and we might see a more Victorian style of parenting making a comeback in around 2050?

Saymynameandeverycolourilluminates · 11/08/2023 06:49

How have you manage to come to that conclusion @Finlesswonder do share your research?

LolaSmiles · 11/08/2023 06:36

Great post Littlemissfroggy. Some people have that sort of seen and not heard attitude and think that children shouldn't be children.

I do think the rise of people calling their lazy/permissive parenting "gentle parenting" is leading to an increase in the opposite outlook too, where children should be everywhere, but should be able to do what they like 'because they're children'. Real gentle parenting is about teaching children how to behave, putting them in situations where they're likely to succeed, and holding boundaries calmly and authoritatively (rather than naughty step, isolation, shouting, shaming).

I don't think it's unreasonable to take children out to a cafe or a restaurant, but do think it's reasonable that they generally behave for the circumstances. (Eg colouring, at their table, talking, small toys, device with headphones if that's what the parents want). It is unreasonable to me for parents to allow lots of loud shrieking, shouting, charging around in that situation. The children don't learn how to behave in different situations if the parents decide that everywhere is a loud charging around space.

Finlesswonder · 11/08/2023 06:28

Most kids today are badly brought up.
Everybody's child seems to have some unique quirk that makes teaching them manners "challenging" or not applicable to them.

I don't think we should go back to the good old days of clips around the ear but I do think "seen and not heard" was actually a pretty good system. You do notice on holiday that it's only the UK kids who are loud. You notice kids aren't taught anymore to lower their voices in public spaces, which is what anyone of any age should do really whether you're in a library or a cafe or a bus.

Anycrispsleft · 11/08/2023 05:54

@Littlemissfroggy that's exactly it. I've never seen it written down so clearly but I agree with everything you've said.

Saymynameandeverycolourilluminates · 11/08/2023 05:27

@Littlemissfroggy 👏👏👏👏

Saymynameandeverycolourilluminates · 11/08/2023 05:24

@ChickenMacaroni and all the god damn others who have said this this is because they are children…..their brains are not fully developed won’t be until their 25 with some areas of the brain. Toddlers pre-schoolers etc. those most likely to squeal, throw sand etc. have an under developed pre frontal cortex which makes them do yes sometimes annoying and sometimes stupid things. Parents do need to deal with this things but you can deal with them over and over again - very successfully but on occasion these things will still happen…..are parents and mothers not allowed to leave their house with their children jic???

Gentle parenting I have question marks over because I think it’s like the keto diet - only works if you fully understand it and follow it to the letter - People don’t. No parenting technique eliminates the things above completely - apart from beating the absolute shit out of children and instilling abject fear. I mean it works and Clearly that’s what many on here would love to but I am thankful we have tried to move on from that.

Although not fully. I often wonder when these child abuse cases come up in the news and you think surely other adults have noticed - well of course they have, they just don’t care and probably think it’s acceptable.

And yes to the person up thread (sorry can’t go back to) who commented that this is a uniquely British thing - recently travelled to Indian subcontinent and mainland Europe with DC and couldn’t believe how kind and and welcoming people were to us as a family and the children.

And If someone is required to pay for their minor to have a seat and that minor gets to the the seat first then they get the seat first - fecking unbelievable that one!!

Hibiscrubbed · 11/08/2023 04:16

KimberleyClark · 10/08/2023 22:32

It's just priceless isn't it, blaming the bad behaviour of children on people who don't have children.

Quite. Just unbelievable.

Catsmere · 11/08/2023 03:31

fitzwilliamdarcy · 10/08/2023 23:01

Yes, that was a particularly impressive reach.

Perhaps those who don't have children - especially gasp by choice! - are supposed to be providing free childcare and training other people's children to behave.

momonpurpose · 11/08/2023 03:11

velvetandsatin · 11/08/2023 02:26

And I think tends to be from a certain age group, who think things should go back to the good old ways of their youth. When children were seen and not heard.

Do you mean those in their nineties? Not a lot of them on MN.

👏 😄

TarquinOliverNimrod · 11/08/2023 03:04

Littlemissfroggy · 11/08/2023 02:48

In the UK (and no doubt many other places) children hold a widespread cultural status similar to that of dogs. Eg:

  • Children are an indulgence and are solely the individual responsibility of their parents
  • Children should obey and behave. This takes priority over all other aspects of their development
  • Play has no specific purpose other than to exercise children so that they behave better
  • Children are not equally deserving of respect and consideration. They should defer to the wants/needs of adults and this relates to their status as extensions/property of their parents (who shouldn't take up more space or resources as a result of having children than if they chose not to)
  • It is necessary to dominate children and they respond best to a strict hierarchal and authoritarian family /society structure, literally in the same way as dogs/wolves
  • Children are not part of human society and are not equally entitled to enjoy public spaces. Ideally they should be sequestered into "child-friendly" spaces or stay at home

Unlike dogs, and in this respect their status is worse than that of dogs:

  • Children are not innocent, in fact they're guilty of being intrinsically bad. They begin to manipulate others from infancy. If they are not frequently punished, or if they are given any leeway on bad behaviour then they will turn out to be morally bad adults
  • Children respond to punishment and in the right circumstances it is acceptable to discipline children by physically assaulting them, locking them up, depriving them of affection and company etc
  • Despite all of the above as soon as (and very possibly before) they turn 18 they are expected to become adults who are responsible and functioning members of society, and who will contribute to the support of society including older adults

Obviously not everyone adheres to all of those but these are widely held and accepted beliefs so it's no wonder that people talk about children as they do. People with these attitudes don't view themselves as hating children just as those of us who think dogs should be on a leash don't usually hate dogs. It's just that children aren't dogs.

All of this is, very sadly, spot on 👏🏼 👏🏼

TarquinOliverNimrod · 11/08/2023 03:02

Purplebunnie · 10/08/2023 18:41

What utter shite

It’s not shite though. Family isn’t important, children and the elderly are not treasured. British society is fractured. Our culture is very individualistic. Just have a look at Greek or Italian societal attitudes towards the more vulnerable members of society, couldn’t be more different to the UK. Solipsism rules in Britain.