Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you have a big lovely house and you don't work.... AIBU?

365 replies

Noangelbuthavingfun · 10/08/2023 16:23

Lighthearted ... walked the dog today. Walked a new route and into a lovely neighbourhood...private road... massive big houses with front gardens and even bigger back gardens...beautiful and houses I could only dream of.
So it had me thinking about what's inside .... of course this isn't reality for everyone but....answer me this:
If YOU live in one of these big beautiful houses (let's just assume it's whatever YOU consider to be big) and you have the lifestyle that means your partner/OH works...long hours let's say, but you have the kids and you get to shop or go to the gym daily, ho for coffee with your girlfriends etc... ARE YOU HAPPY? TRULY HAPPY?
If you are...what makes you happy?
If you are NOT happy...what's the reason?

I'm asking as it would be a fairy tale for me to live in a beautiful house like this, not having to work, but we never will and I have to work full time for our modest 3 bed semi. I'm jealous of you if you are lucky enough to have this lifestyle...BUT on balance I'm happy, so is the grass greener? AIBU to be jealous?

Discuss! And if you are in MY boat, what fo YOU think of this lifestyle ?

OP posts:
RantyAnty · 11/08/2023 03:03

Not working and relying on a man sounds dull and like a fairy tale.

It's much more rewarding to have bought the house without a man.

It also makes me happy to have a career I love.

TooBigForMyBoots · 11/08/2023 01:53

Remembermynamealways · 10/08/2023 17:49

Yes I am that person too.

I don’t know about other people in my position but my life is too busy! I wish sometimes we would just move to a smaller house. We are very happily married, I have many animals that need caring for. I swim daily and I will finish my masters next year. We have time to relax, read, have parties in the garden and at home and an abundance of friends. My children have many friends here and busy sporty lives. I also volunteer - work unpaid in a sector that makes a difference to women.
We travel often and j suppose on paper my life looks beautiful and it often is.

It’s not perfect though. Nothing is perfect that is what I have realised. We all have the same problems as human beings..

The big gates are not my favourite as they shut people out, but we were advised to keep them by our security company, although our area is very safe. We have a period home and it needs a rolling rota of maintenance.

I miss the kinship of having immediate neighbours, especially in the lockdown. I sometimes feel pressure to host often, which is resisted because I need quiet space, and that is the most precious gift - time and freedom to choose in my view.

Seriously.😄😄😄

Lonejohny · 11/08/2023 00:31

I live in a nice house in a nice area. Have a part time house keeper and she does some childcare. We have a gardener who does the basics. I love love love my life. It revolves around everything I adore - my family and my home! I have 4 kids. I quit work after my first - 8 years ago and never looked back.
Recently a family member became ill and they live about an hr away. I really wanted to spend as much time with them as possible. Juggling being out of the house and childcare was a nightmare. It really made me wonder how working mums do it - hats off to you!
The rest of the time I have a really good routine. Wake up, get kids up, school, help housekeeper to square up tidy, toddlers groups, afternoon free to meet friends have coffee, bake, my husband might be home so we go out for a late lunch or just let baby contact nap. After school it's clubs, tea homework and bed. Then I watch some TV do crafts. Do life admin etc. I don't have much time for lazing in front of the tv. I manage all finances husband pay goes into joint account and I sort everything so I'm not worried about money.
I totally love school holidays. I spend all the time i want with my littlies.
My biggest worry is what will I do when they grow up. Maybe be a hands on grandma, maybe foster maybe enjoy hubbies retirement.

Pink0rBlue · 11/08/2023 00:26

I have a lovely large home and am a SAHM to 2 under 5.

There's good bits and bad. I love being able to pick my eldest up from school, never having to worry about making it to an event at school, having time to help out at school, no worries over holiday or sickness cover, being able to facilitate play dates etc.
when both are at school/nursery a couple of sessions a week its nice to potter and have to time to get jobs done or sit with a hot drink.

It's quite lonely though, I do go for the odd coffee with friends /play date with my youngest but once they are at full time school, I'll be alone a lot of the time. I don't live where I grew up or worked, so don't have a large social circle, just mum friends.

I had a good career but it wasn't compatible with being around for my children and part time ended up being full time work, full time stress, with part time hours/pay. DH works long and unpredictable hours but earns significantly more and has ensured we, and our children, are financially comfortable.

It's also hard and unrelenting being a SAHM, one of my children is particularly difficult and I'm often exhausted by the end of the day. If I'm sick or injured I still have to 'work'. My DH is very hands on when he is home though so I'm fortunate.

As for the gym, I should go, I'm quite overweight!

I wouldn't say I'm unhappy as I appreciate how fortunate I am but I wouldn't say I'm particularly happy. I have a lot of issues from my past (narc mother/unstable childhood) that I find it hard to move on from no matter how much I have. I'm doing what I think is best for my family though.

ReginaRegina · 11/08/2023 00:18

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 10/08/2023 23:27

Not while the kids are young perhaps, but what happens when they grow up and leave home? Having a sense of purpose apart from your kids - whether that's paid work or something else entirely - is healthy.

My own poor mum fell apart when I left home. She didn't have anything else to focus on.

This is more down to the individual though IMO. I could fill three lifetimes with the stuff I want to do.

I'd love to have pursued my talent for writing, really mastered Brazilian ju jitsu, thai boxing, and western boxing, maybe compete in one (I was pretty decent at the first two).

I'd love to have continued playing bass and guitar, and also wrote more electronic music as I spent years learning to program it then once my career took off didn't have the energy to sit on a computer in the evening having already been on one for eight hours. Would also like to get really good at the drums and maybe play in a pub band again.

Would also love to learn as many languages as possible and live in as many places as possible. Learn to fly a plane. Finish restoring the pickup truck I gave up on due to lack of time. Etc etc.

There are loads more but I'd absolutely do every single one of the above if I had the time, and to really get elite at something you can't be spinning too many plates anyway.

For me, work isn't a purpose. It's a necessity that massively gets in the way of life.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 10/08/2023 23:27

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/08/2023 23:23

I have friends in this situation. They are generally less stressed and miserable that many I think, but all have anxieties about their looks or social lives or what if their husband cheats or how their kids are doing at school. A lot more thinking time perhaps. None of them care that they don't work though or have any kind of existential crisis about their purpose, if they have kids.

Not while the kids are young perhaps, but what happens when they grow up and leave home? Having a sense of purpose apart from your kids - whether that's paid work or something else entirely - is healthy.

My own poor mum fell apart when I left home. She didn't have anything else to focus on.

bluefrog11 · 10/08/2023 23:26

I have a nice big house (perhaps not as nice as the ones you describe but still a big 5 bed detached in the nicest part of town) with a garden, a nice car etc. I have recently gone back to work (kids are primary school age) because I was SO bored and unhappy. I used to go to the gym, perhaps meet a friend occasionally, shop and tidy my house. That was it. Sometimes I was happy enough but I remember one time bringing in the washing and just heaving sobs in the garden - through boredom, disappointment in myself and frustration. I’d find myself shopping online constantly and getting it deb. I was also weirdly obsessed with other peoples drama. I’m back at work now - part time but quite busy - and now I’m really stressed and would love my old life back!!!🤣🤣🤣🤣 Can’t win!!!

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/08/2023 23:23

I have friends in this situation. They are generally less stressed and miserable that many I think, but all have anxieties about their looks or social lives or what if their husband cheats or how their kids are doing at school. A lot more thinking time perhaps. None of them care that they don't work though or have any kind of existential crisis about their purpose, if they have kids.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 10/08/2023 23:22

I think it's also a possibility that some of the posters who are unhappy at home might still be unhappy if working.

This is very true and quite insightful. Happiness is so often about more than just circumstances.

wordsthreerandom · 10/08/2023 23:19

I have a big house, financially ok and plenty of help round the house.

I have worked very hard in the past, I don't now, and I don't miss it one bit.

I have a family to take care of and then enjoy my downtime with my husband who has now retired.

It's wonderful.

I really don't want to sound smug. Just very appreciative of where I am and honestly loving life.
I burnt out trying to 'do it all' I'm now happy doing much less.

ReginaRegina · 10/08/2023 23:15

I think it's also a possibility that some of the posters who are unhappy at home might still be unhappy if working.

I'm paid well and like my job. Helps that it's 10 mins away and I'm often finished by 2pm but paid 45 hours minimum. However, my boss is a bipolar tyrant who is impossible to please and always flipping out and shouting/swearing at his employees over minor things.

I'd happily live a life of leisure if I was financially sorted. There's so much stuff I want to do that I've already accepted I'll never get the chance to.

GirlOfTudor · 10/08/2023 23:01

I just wanted to add that these houses may look beautiful from the outside, but inside they're often so dated and need a lot of work to bring them up to a modern standard.
There are some lovely big detached houses near mine and I've checked Rightmove whenever they've gone up for sale. I'm always shocked at how old fashioned they are inside!
I'd much rather my 3 bed terrace that feels modern and bright than a huge house that I can't afford to keep updated.

ChaosRule · 10/08/2023 22:55

I'm 50, Dds are 18 & 16. Oxbridge offer and both high achieving academically. Both happy, working well balanced.
DH's career has steadily grown and he's pretty senior in his field in this country.
I was out earning him pre kids and the last three years pro-rata.
I've had long periods of staying at home, carrying the mental load and giving DH the freedom to out compete colleagues without SAHP supporting them.
I picked up a contract which was great in a dinner party boasting way but was awful to deliver. Ultimately it was meaningless, you will have heard of it, maybe enjoyed it but it was box ticking, stressful, fulltime worry. I still carried the domestic load, managed from a premier inn. My kids were lonely, our diets were awful, we felt less connected so I've given up work, again.

We can't have it all - I reckon you can have two out of
Quirky or big home without a lot of help
Happy kids
Two complex careers

But not all three, we mostly dropped one complex career.

Nevertouchakoala · 10/08/2023 22:50

Im bored. If I’m honest. I like aspects like daily gym, but I’m mainly bored/grumpy.

TooBigForMyBoots · 10/08/2023 22:45

My aunt was a SAHM in what was a big house in the 70s and 80s.She played tennis, did voluntary work and had a lovely life. My mum and her sisters were well jell.Grin

SoSo99 · 10/08/2023 22:42

I live in a pretty glamourous house of the type that I never imagined I'd live in (the dosh for the house is mainly due to my husband's investments/jobs, plus historic rises in the property market). However, I'm pretty scruffy so I doubt you'd think of me as a 'lady what lunches' type. In fact, the only lunching I do is in my lunchhour with work colleagues (I work 3 days a week, and in fact, I don't know any women that don't work). It's has been really amazing to be able to work part time, and spend time at home with the kids/doing hobbies whilst also doing a meaningful job. I can't imagine not working.

But this is the reality: one of my children is in a dire state of mental health, and looking after her is pretty much a full-time job. My other daughter has also been severely mentally unwell too. Just to say that it's hard to tell what's really going on behind closed doors (even well-heeled ones).

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/08/2023 22:21

MargaretThursday · 10/08/2023 20:42

I can't imagine anything nicer.

I wouldn't be bored. I could do sewing, potter in the garden, play tennis, read a book, play games, writing, volunteering, spend time with friends... I can think of 100s of things I'd love to just have the time to do without time restraint.

However much you like your job, and not everyone does, then surely you can think of things you'd like to do with as much free time as you want?
And if you really think you would get bored, are you planning on retiring?

Retirement feels different to me. At that point, I will probably be ready to wind down but also, my husband will be retired too and not slogging away at work whilst I was going to the gym or out for coffee.

Janieforever · 10/08/2023 21:45

I live in a big house, big garden, I’m the main bread winner, and no way I’d want to be staying home, doing the childcare and housework, I want to earn it myself. I don’t get the envy, couldn’t stomach it myself.

JustMarriedBecca · 10/08/2023 21:43

I have a lot of friends behind those gates and all are happy (working here). In most instances I'd say the relationship is an equal one. Both husband and wife had excellent careers and bought property young. In several cases, she earned more than him.
Then comes babies and they decide she can't do her job, neither can he, with the 50:50% childcare split. So she stops work. But the relationship is an equal one because either (1) she was his professional superior at one time or (2) he appreciates what she's given up.

She isn't bored. She drops the kids off at school, goes to the gym, meets other school Mums for tennis. She might volunteer at school to hear some kids read. She'll then pick up the kids and run the gauntlet of all the extra curricular activities requiring her to be in 75 different places at the same time. She'll then bath the kids and put them to bed before husband gets home.

Are they all blissfully happy? Yeah.

ReginaRegina · 10/08/2023 21:40

Gotta say, I'm struggling to see the male privilege we so often hear about on here with all this talk of daytime hobbies, picnics, summerhouses, and cleaners/nannies/gardeners. 😂

I get the loneliness aspect but I'm guessing the husband probs gets this too when he's stuck on his own in a hotel whilst his wife has fun with the kids. I know my BIL feels this way - Commercial Director for a household name brand and earns huge £££ but is away from home 1-2 weeks every single month.

Greetingsfellows · 10/08/2023 21:39

I think answers might be skewed by life experiences/personality types/age.

I'm a SAHM after (willingly) giving up my career 2 years ago. We have a 6 bed house with no mortgage. DP has a job where he earns 100k+ a year working from home 9-5. We love it.

DP is nearly 50. He worked long and hard as a younger man to save for the family he knew he wanted one day.

I'm a decade younger. I grew up poor, moving house a lot due to rental contracts. My dad was absent for long periods and my mum's focus was on earning money and never me (yes, they were mutually exclusive). I worked long and hard to give myself more security as an adult and to ensure that I could financially support my parents as they aged. I never expected to find a partner and have children.

DP and I are both introverts. We don't go out lots because we don't want to. We enjoy the simple things in life - family time, walks, cycling, reading, gardening and conversation. None of these things particularly cost money so it has helped us save throughout our lives and allows us to be content with our lives as they are today. There isn't anything wrong with being an extrovert but I imagine it makes the isolation of being a SAHP harder to tolerate.

Mine and DP's ages mean that we had many of the experiences we wanted before we settled down together. If you're younger, I imagine that it's hard not to feel like you're missing out on something. The way we worked in our younger years has helped to give us the freedom to choose the life we live now, which in itself feels like an achievement.

The way I grew up also means that I really appreciate and cherish the time with my DC. I'm not saying others don't but my point is that I'm maybe more content with less stimulation beyond our family because the family stability and parent/child relationship is what I always craved when growing up. I always knew I'd rather have no money but family connections if I had to choose between the two.

As I said, I love conversation about topical issues and I still get that stimulation from my friends. This is part of what stops my brain turning to mush as is the extensive reading I do. However, this is part of who I fundamentally am. I was the same person before I had DC. The same goes for DP, so the lifestyle we have suits us. I totally understand that it doesn't work for everyone. I'm glad that we're fortunate enough to have the choice of doing what works for us.

Noangelbuthavingfun · 10/08/2023 21:37

purpleboy · 10/08/2023 18:58

This is probably me.
We have a beautiful 9 bed 6 bath house.
I had multiple businesses which I've sold over time. DH works, but our house is owned and was paid for by me (now mortgage free).
I am very happy 2 DC one in private primary, the eldest working abroad.
I can attend everything for school, matches, plays, assembly's which is so important to me, I am available to help out friends or relatives. I love DIY so am often doing projects in the house that I do on my own.
I spend my time in many different ways. I volunteer a lot, I have animals that I spend a lot of time with. I have family with various needs that I help out. I read a fair bit, and we travel, are lucky to be away for most of the holidays, and we have a home abroad that we spend a lot of time in.
We are so lucky and I don't think I would change anything about my life.

This sounds amazing - do you mind my asking what kind of business you used to have ? I've never been brave enough to break away from paid employment.. perhaps this is what sets most apart wnd gives you , if successful, a whole new platform. I've often thought about it but then too worried about the potential impact and how to even get started whilst working full time

OP posts:
Noangelbuthavingfun · 10/08/2023 21:30

Finding all the posts fascinating and pretty much equally distributed between happy and possibly not so much ...
It seems, and I can understand it, if you like working and love your job, big house or not you can be happy.
I hate my job... hate working ... can't see a way out that doesn't mean downsizing and the dream slips further away then. Guess I'm just daydreaming and would love to have a beautiful big serene house and be able to live stress free busying myself with all the lovely things posters have mentioned.
Has anyone given up the rat race and just moved to a cheaper area mortgage free to be stress free ?

OP posts:
NewYearNewMNName · 10/08/2023 21:28

I'm now in this position. I used to work in a v stressful role with a lot of responsibility earning a 6th of what my husband earns, then when our second DC came along I never returned from Mat Leave.
Our DC are young, they attend nursery twice a week, my MIL also has them each 1 day a week (her choice - she loves the quality time with them).
We have a cleaner twice a week, a fortnightly gardener and a handyman to keep on top of things. I arrange all of that as well as the other house/life/child admin. I do all the laundry and 90% of the housework/tidying but I don't mind it.
I walk the dog every weekday.
My days with the DC are packed, we visit museums, beaches, long walks in the park/woods, attend stay and plays occasionally, have picnics, play in the garden and it's lovely.
Days without the DC I ensure the house run smoothly and have time for myself, something I never had when I worked.
DH works 8-4 from home and spends time with the kids before and after work. He cooks the evening meals because he enjoys it.
At weekends me and DH are equal as parents and homeowners.
Everyone in the household is far happier and everything runs smoothly with this set up.

Oh and I can't remember the last time I was bored.

Noangelbuthavingfun · 10/08/2023 21:23

japonic · 10/08/2023 18:40

I guess that's me. We live in a big, beautiful house, beautiful garden (not very big though), and I'm at home all day.

We got here by having reasonably wealthy backgrounds, working hard in stressful careers for the best part of 3 decades, then scaled right back. We're not retired, but we both have portfolio careers I guess - a little of this, a little of that. We work as and when we need/want to.

I love being at home with my family. I don't 'do' lunches, I don't go to the gym, I loathe shopping, I don't fritter my time away idly. I do a lot of stuff, but mainly stuff I love to do. Both my DH and I have a good work ethic, which we now apply to doing things for ourselves. If something breaks, we learn how to fix it. If we need bread, I make it. We're always doing something vaguely productive.

We're both creative and spend a lot of time pursuing various interests. We have a very quiet life, very happy, but it wouldn't suit everyone I guess.

What kind of things are portfolio careers please? Sounds like you have the perfect balance now - well done !

OP posts: