Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not respond to DD's father's texts?

105 replies

mylife9 · 10/08/2023 14:48

Ex and I separated 2 years ago, but we're still married. We share 6 year old DD who he only chooses to see, twice a year. I have prompted for more frequent visits but he refuses claiming he travels a lot for work (not true - he works from home and moved abroad to live with family/friends). Anyways, last year, he connected with DD on her ipad so he can have direct communication with her (his wish). He never calls, just sends interactive emojis or very short voice notes (literally, 3 seconds long) asking how she's doing, very sporadically (every 3/6 weeks). DD has completely forgotten about him to the point where I am constantly having to remind her to check if daddy sent her a message. A few months ago, I put him on child support and thankfully he's been paying on time with no problems. My issue now is instead of him directly contacting DD, he messages me to ask how she's doing, I've informed him previously that she has access to her ipad and can reply but he always finds something to text about. A few weeks ago, he texted to ask if we have a holiday planned, baring in mind, I informed him we're going away, 3 weeks prior - I didn't reply so he proceeded to text "?" every couple of days and then "can I please have some news". I have up until now sent him photos, videos, invitations to birthdays, reception graduation, theme parks etc. but with no appreciation from his part. He communicates only when he wants to and expects immediate replies. AIBU for ignoring his messages and only responding about visit arrangements?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mylife9 · 16/08/2023 11:17

Thank you.💐

OP posts:
Zoda8 · 14/08/2023 18:17

I think it would be a mistake to search for a one size fits all solution, as every family is so different. These are a few general ideas that might help (not listed in order of importance!)

Firstly, you are not responsible for the happiness, well-being and social acceptability of your ex partner.

Secondly though, as a continuing, albeit limited presence in your daughter’s life and therefore your life, it is generally better to have amicable rather than hostile relations.

Thirdly, your own mental health and well-being is an important consideration in your ability to function as a parent.

Fourthly (most importantly), the best interests of your daughter should guide your decisions on contact.

Fifthly, whilst good quality face to face contact is best, indirect contact like cards, gifts, phone calls and video calls can sometimes (though not always) be beneficial for a child’s relationship with her father.

I sense from your posts that we would be in agreement on all of the above points.

Against that backdrop, whether or not you answer a text asking whether you are going on holiday would appear to have no direct impact on the provision of contact for your daughter. The competing issues seem to be the emotional upset to you in having to deal with a seemingly pointless intrusion into your life on the one hand, against the general feeling that amicability is usually preferable to hostility.

Not that this is directly relevant, or that it should dictate your approach as it is hypothetical, but I believe if contact arrangements like yours were to end up in front of the family courts, and the father’s lawyer were to raise that the father would like to know of holidays that his daughter is going on, it is at least possible that the mother’s own lawyer would advise, in the spirit of co-operation, that this is something that would not be unduly onerous to facilitate. It is more than conceivable if a justice or judge was asked to rule on this as a specific issue (which they would be very reluctant to do), that they may in some cases specify that such information be provided, under some broad interpretation of parental responsibility.

I wonder, as others have suggested, whether part of the problem is that unwelcome text messages feel particularly immediate and intrusive by comparison, for instance, to emails. If so, one possibility would be to agree to communicate by email except for the purposes of agreed contact between daughter and father, or in case of emergency. In response to an email about holidays you could then, in your own time, say ‘Yes we’re going to Spain. We’ll be back on 8.8. Let me know if you would like to ring DD to talk about her holiday after we get back’. In response to an email saying ‘how is she getting on?’, you could say, in your own time, ‘Thank you for asking. DD is happy at home and in school. Perhaps you could ring the school office and ask for a copy of her report? Let me know if you would like to ring DD and chat to her about how she is getting on.’ If these emails then prompted satellite requests for more information, you could bin them or respond to them as you see fit.

In relation to the direct contact of twice a year, this is as you say a disappointing level of commitment from Dad. It is, however, considerably better than nothing, particularly if the contact is of good quality. It is also in my view better than the type of father (or mother) who agrees to contact every week and then rarely turns up, leaving their child distraught for the resident parent or cater to pick up the mess. So I don’t think the fact that direct contact is at a disappointing level should dictate your approach to other issues like indirect contact or communication - decide those issues in their own right.

In relation to indirect contact, I would only encourage this where it has potential to strengthen your daughter’s relationship with her father. Firstly, if he is going to let her down, by promising to ring and then not ringing, don’t do it. Secondly, if DD has nothing to talk about, don’t set up a phone call of embarassed silence. An example might be if her father sent her a gift that she liked, she could ring to thank him. Or he could ring after a holiday or joining a new class and talk about that.
If other classmates are making a Father’s Day card, either as a whole class activity or individually, your daughter should feel able to join in with this activity if she wants to, and I think it would be worth an envelope and a second class stamp to send it on. It is also possible that this might just tug at some cord in her father’s mind.

As I find myself starting to write your life for you I revert to what I started with - there is never one magic answer for all families - in fact there are almost always several equally good solutions to one issue in one family. I wish you the strength to find your way forward, and the happiness to enjoy motherhood.

LegoNinjago · 14/08/2023 11:37

Absolutely agree.

This thread has been eye opening.
How many women agree for them and their children to be treated like a doormats. Utterly pathetic “dad” apparently has to be worshiped and accommodated ffs

PollyPut · 14/08/2023 11:20

@mylife9 thanks for the update and I'm very pleased you're going to be controlling DD's ipad access more.

Don't ignore his messages to you though; it won't help in anyway and could be used against you in divorce proceedings. A short response should be possible

Make sure you give him plenty of details of any important dates/meetings about your daughter that he is not being informed of through another route, so that he has the option to attend and also so he can't say you didn't tell him about them. If you can make sure he is copied on school newsletters by the school, then that will help you out - and also will make it easier for him to talk to his DD if he knows a bit more about what is going on in her life (if he reads them).

mylife9 · 14/08/2023 10:25

A few people have asked about Birthdays and Christmas - He has missed them for the last 2 years. He also doesn't call to wish DD well. He sends voice notes that are also a few seconds long.

OP posts:
mylife9 · 14/08/2023 10:19

Thank you for for your input on this thread. I have decided to continue to ignore his messages. I'm not too sure about providing regular updates, just yet. If I do go down this route, updates will be brief and every couple of months. He can call and visit if he wants to. I have made him aware countless times, I am all for DD and him having a consistent and positive relationship. He clearly doesn't want to and I no longer want to force information onto him. He is a grown man in his late 30's, he can manage all other relationships just fine, as soon as it comes to his 6 year old daughter, it suddenly becomes problematic. I will 100% immediately reply to messages about visits and and an arrangement of weekly/monthly calls. If he calls to speak to DD, I will facilitate that, also. Going forward, contact on DD's ipad will be managed by me. Thank you to the poster who suggested checking for messages whenever I charge it - brilliant idea. Child maintenance is DD's entitlement. My only regret is leaving it too long to ask in hopes he'd prioritise DD and see her frequently. If I had known, he'd behave this way, I would've applied the minute we separated.

OP posts:
1037370E · 14/08/2023 09:58

I wouldn't ignore his messages - I would answer specific questions. However, I wouldn't be providing a weekly/monthly update. If he wants to know what's going on in her life, he should be in her life. I speak from experience. I used to do this with my son's father, sending him pictures, videos, info about how he was doing, despite the fact that he didn't see him. One day I bumped into a mutual friend, who said that my ex had been proudly telling him all about our son - how well he was doing at school, his birthday party, the fact that he had learned to ride a bike etc, he had no idea that he hadn't seen him for 2 years. After that, I stopped updating him. I figured that the next time someone asked him how DS is doing, he will either have to lie/make things up or admit that he didn't know because he hasn't seen him. It's been 6 years since he last saw him. He doesn't deserve regular updates. If he wants to know what is going on in DS's life, he needs to have a relationship with him.

nevynevster · 14/08/2023 09:52

I'm a bit confused as to where he lives and why he has so little contact. There are many pssible reasons and not all of them are bad (lives abroad, is depressed and struggling for ex). But regardless, when the kids were young both my ex and I made an effort to at least provide a short update on major stuff re the kids. A WhatsApp with a photo or just am FYI re holiday plans that sort of thing. Such as you did for the Sports day. In fact the easiest may be to setp a WhatsApp group with a bunch of family and then just post some generic updates on that "DD tried climbing for the first time" plus pic. Because your DD may want a stronger relationship with her dad when she's older and it may be useful for him to have a bit of context on things that have happened in her life.

Yes it's annoying for you and you are making all the effort but I do think you need to take a deep breath, no matter how annoying he is, and make some effort for your DD sake. Like I said, doesn't need to be special for him or every day but just a regular update for a family group. If you do this then I think you can reasonably ignore other requests for updates.

However, you have to tell him that, At 6 years old, she is too young to constantly be checking ipad so it would be best to have a set time at the weekends for messages or at least an agreement that messages are sent and replied to at the weekend. This is good practice for her device usage and makes it easier all round.

LegoNinjago · 14/08/2023 09:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Christ on bike. Give your head a fucking wobble

LegoNinjago · 14/08/2023 09:40

LifeExperience · 11/08/2023 14:00

If he wanted a relationship with his daughter he would have one. You are under no obligation to keep him informed.

This.

Amazed at the posters advising OP to bend over with regular updates etc.

Your STBX is an absolute twat, OP.

sixtiesbaby88 · 14/08/2023 09:38

Doone21 · 14/08/2023 08:46

I agree. A 6yr old doesn't think about this. It's up to you to maintain basic communication and yes it's unreasonable to leave him hanging for days for an answer you have at your fingertips. It's not like he's forcing a conversation with you just collection of information.

It's not relevant how much of a dick he has been previously been

I agree. Fast forward to a teenage daughter. The last thing you want is to be accused of blocking contact with her dad. ideally you want to be able to show how the door was always open for him but he chose not to make contact.

GabriellaMontez · 14/08/2023 09:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

take his money

You mean, accept his financial contribution to meeting their daughters needs.

In the absence of any other practical or emotional contribution from him...

ConnieTucker · 14/08/2023 09:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

and the bar for men gets lower and lower

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 14/08/2023 09:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

1.That's not how it works.

  1. If he cared that much he could you know, actually see her or talk to her.
dhilez · 14/08/2023 09:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Doone21 · 14/08/2023 08:46

I agree. A 6yr old doesn't think about this. It's up to you to maintain basic communication and yes it's unreasonable to leave him hanging for days for an answer you have at your fingertips. It's not like he's forcing a conversation with you just collection of information.

It's not relevant how much of a dick he has been previously been

MamskiBell · 13/08/2023 20:30

mylife9 · 10/08/2023 15:02

On a number of occasions he expressed his wish to communicate with DD directly and not through me. When she replies to him he takes a couple of days to open the message and then more to reply back to her.

So he's doing to her what you're doing to him yet he has the brass back to be annoyed at you while he's literally doing that to a 6 year old kid? Dick.

MamskiBell · 13/08/2023 20:30

mylife9 · 10/08/2023 15:02

On a number of occasions he expressed his wish to communicate with DD directly and not through me. When she replies to him he takes a couple of days to open the message and then more to reply back to her.

So he's doing to her what you're doing to him yet he has the brass back to be annoyed at you while he's literally doing that to a 6 year old kid? Dick.

Mamma2017 · 13/08/2023 18:49

towriteyoumustlive · 10/08/2023 15:04

YABU.

Your daughter is 6 so not exactly going to be able to communicate well so it's nice he is asking after her and taking an interest along side the ipad messages.

He asked a simple question about the holiday and it was rude for you not to answer it given it would have taken you 20 seconds to reply. He may have just forgotten you'd told him.

It’s nice he’s asking after her? His own daughter? Wow give him a medal!! He sees her twice a YEAR he is a deadbeat dad who hardly replies …seriously how r u getting that he’s nice for replying???? 🤦🏼‍♀️

CornishIrish · 13/08/2023 18:43

unisexforreal · 13/08/2023 10:26

@mylife9

If you haven’t seen the Barbie movie OP (overrated IMO) there is that great speech by America Ferrara which has been on social media.

when you come on mumsnet asking a question you can seem to do no right and get attacked from all sides. You can’t win.

im just coming on to say you are doing a Great job in bringing up your daughter. Do what’s right for her and you and no more and no less. If he can’t be arsed your daughter needs to become aware of that sooner rather than later.

carry on being you x

This right here… You are doing a great job. He is a loser.

Set a regular contact time and if he doesn’t make it, he doesn’t make it. He abandoned his daughter and has left you an insecure living position. F him.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 13/08/2023 18:20

More to the point, for as long as you are taking child support from this bloke, you need to continue communicating with him about his daughter- no matter how useless his communication is. Why are you taking his money otherwise???

That's not how it works. That's not how any of it works.

canfor · 13/08/2023 17:40

I agree with @OhmygodDont -maybe quarterly updates - a few lines 'DD doing well at school, looking forward to Christmas/Birthday/Holiday, can be available on these days next month and if you want to speak to her on my phone we can do that x time x date, please email me to confirm that you want to do that and I will call you. And for good measure send a snap of DD or a picture of a painting she has done.

I agree with everyone that you are not his PA and it shouldn't be for him to rely on you for this. But...these emails will be your receipts when he rolls up in later years and explains to your DD that you made it difficult. Or he didn't know about xyz big life event. This puts you in control of comms. And as for any other messages from him, just ignore. I would block him on everything and let him know you only want to communicate by email or post from now and you don't have time for chit chat between updates. Have his emails go into a folder automatically so they don't bother you.

Shurleyknot · 13/08/2023 17:22

I would not go monthly so much as quarterly. If he wanted to know so much he would see her more often. Send him an update once every few months and then tell him you will not speak to him again until he has access or again in a few months. He has no right to demand you give up your tme to entertain him when he chooses not to see his child.

GabriellaMontez · 13/08/2023 17:17

More to the point, for as long as you are taking child support from this bloke, you need to continue communicating with him about his daughter- no matter how useless his communication is. Why are you taking his money otherwise???

@mealtickety the money is his contribution to meeting his daughters needs. It's his only contribution. He's not involved in the day to day grind of looking after a child.

It is not, for the OP to provide updates, newsletters or any other tasks he deems necessary. If he wants to be involved, he can quite literally, be involved.

OhmygodDont · 13/08/2023 17:13

I’d just send one monthly or bi monthly update text. Even if there is nothing just a DD had a lovely month nothing out of the ordinary.

Dd had a lovely month, she can’t wait to go Lego land next month.

Dd has had a hard time with medical continue this month X Y Z

Then when he texts asking if you are day going to Lego land, you can say as per last message we are going to Lego land next month.

You’ve got the proof that you sent regular updates when he decided to tell her you didn’t tell him anything about her life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread