Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Me or DD being unreasonable?

139 replies

Shoebills · 10/08/2023 12:07

Sorry, didn't know how to word the title.

We have a dog and a puppy, but the puppy is kind of irrelevant here as this is about the older dog. We take it in turns to take older dog out for the second walk of the day, near the local park/fields. The main walk is always done by me on the weekdays (right now, the younger kids come with me and at the weekends we all go as a family).

She's 17 and her day is the Thursday, as I'm really busy that day with the younger ones. She refuses to do it in the daylight hours... will only go once the sun has gone in. I've told her that I don't feel comfortable with her going at night. She's 17 and I don't want her in fields or parks in darkness. Surely this isn't unreasonable? She is so "idc" about it, says she has more chance dying on the way to college (she drives) and that's when she will do it and if I'm not happy with that, someone else can do it earlier.

Would you just let her do it at that time? I spend the whole time worrying!

OP posts:
grumpycow1 · 14/08/2023 00:52

I can’t believe all the responses here. I’m late 30s. When we go for dinner locally, we all walk our one friend back home as a group, as she has to go past the local park and it’s pitch dark and scary. It’s just common sense. I travel for work to lots of places abroad and there’s lots of stuff I do by myself… but I would never go to a park by myself after dark. It’s sad but the way of the world. It’s not about treating your daughter younger than she is, it’s teaching her that yes she feels invincible, but how to take care of herself. Avoiding remote locations by herself after dark - definitely a major step!

Daffodil63 · 14/08/2023 00:45

I totally agree -too risky. I don't take my dog walking on my own in the park, fields or woods when it's getting dark and I definitely wouldn't let my daughter. Simply not a risk worth taking.

JudgeRudy · 14/08/2023 00:38

I think the real issue here is do you have the right to control what your daughter does...in this case no.
Are you privy to information she isn't? No
She's carried out her own risk assessment and has decided to go ahead. Just as she probably have unprotected sex at some stage or simply go to a lads house alone. Some people are just more or less risk averse.

Wife2b · 14/08/2023 00:33

I also think the age is irrelevant, the risk remains the same irrespective of 17, 32 or 50.

Wife2b · 14/08/2023 00:32

You’re not being silly or unreasonable OP. Walking late at night in fields and parks is irresponsible, of course anyone should be able to go where they please but it’s not a risk I’d be happy with. Footpaths, busy roads etc with street lighting sure, not sure why anyone would feel comfortable walking alone in secluded areas.

momtoboys · 14/08/2023 00:30

I’m sorry I didn’t read all the replies. I think taking a walk with a dog will be a little protection. At 17 she should be able to do the walk on her own.

Missrabbithasfaintedagain · 14/08/2023 00:15

Women on here just love to be contradictory.

If a thread was started about a news article where a 17yo girl was attacked in a field in the dark where she walks her dog every week, people would question why the mother was happy to let her go through a field in the dark.

It’s about risks and weighing them up and avoiding them. Should a young woman be able to walk at night through a field alone? Of course. Does it go against all advice given after Sarah Everard to not go into an unlit area with no people around? Yes it does.

op, I don’t think there is much you can do if that’s when she wants to do it. But it is risky and people are twats (and in usual MN fashion) for suggesting it’s overly anxious.

SequentialAnalyst · 14/08/2023 00:11

Why not get her a rape alarm? Their primay use is to ward off an attacker, not, as many think, to summon help.

I was on a work course once about personal safety, delivered by a member of the police, and the advice was to get the alarm out and hold it in your hand ready if approaching somewhere like, say, a subway. This puts you in a resourceful state.

If attacked, pull the little lanyard and hold it up as near to the attacker's ear, so they are blasted with the incredibly loud noise it produces. This should freeze them, at least for a moment. Then you run away as fast as you can.

And probably, so does the attacker. In the opposite direction.

Also, may I ask, would the dog protect her?

WongWifi · 14/08/2023 00:10

The responses you’re getting shows that there’ll be no slowing down of awful news items and stories for real crime shows.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 14/08/2023 00:10

YABU, if you’re that anxious about it I agree you should do it yourself. Or why can’t she just walk the dog on the street and not in a field/ park?

NewName122 · 14/08/2023 00:06

Yabu op.

neilyoungismyhero · 14/08/2023 00:04

Shoebills · 10/08/2023 12:13

Of course she can go out in the dark, visit friends, go places... but to a field or park in the dark is a bit different imo

My daughter's Park is 5 houses away from her house but she feels very nervous when she has to go out with her young lab in the early dark mornings and late nights on her own. I agree with you it's dodgy although as a family we probably listen to far too many crime podcasts tbf.

WannaBeRecluse · 13/08/2023 23:59

I understand why you are worried and I wouldn't do it myself. You might have to make a choice though. Do you want the dog walked by someone whose responsibility it isn't really to do so, as it works for them? Or do you want to make the time to do it yourself at a better time? Or pay a professional dog walker?

My father brought home a dog when I was in my teens (I never asked for one or anticipated one) and it was decided by my parents I would walk it each day. Not fair really.

Bellyblueboy · 13/08/2023 23:55

JudgeRudy · 13/08/2023 23:28

YABU to ask her to do something that's not her responsibility but then expect her to do it your way. She doesnt want to walk the dog. She probably doesn't want to be seen out walking the dog either. She has enough of a heart tho to walk it but at a time/place that suits her. I'd say in the teens stakes your winning.
Incidently what happens when the goes out at night with/to visit friends? Does she always take her car? What of she's drinking or just popping out. Surely st 17 she goes out at night alone.

I go out at night alone all the time: still
wouldnt all the dog through the park and across the fields at midnight.

I travel to big global cities all the time and use the Subway and walk through busy streets at 2am. But you wouldn’t catch me alone in the pitch dark in the park or I the middle of a field at midnight😂

Bellyblueboy · 13/08/2023 23:53

That should have said wouldn’t walk the dog through fields at night

Bellyblueboy · 13/08/2023 23:53

This thread is bonkers. I am 40 and I would walk the dog through fields in the dark!! I live in a city and I just don’t through the park at night. I was there tonight at about 8pm with the dog and it was lovely. Wouldn’t be out there at 11pm though.

Mirabai · 13/08/2023 23:51

JudgeRudy · 13/08/2023 23:32

I'm not sure the risks are lower for males. Sexual attack by a lone perp maybe, but a lad of 17 would be the perfect age for confrontational violence inc stabbing. Much, much higher risk.

Physical assault risk higher for men; sexual assault risk higher for women.

Mirabai · 13/08/2023 23:50

Really depends where you are - Powys - probably ok, edge of London - I wouldn’t.

Chiswickgal · 13/08/2023 23:47

I’d go with your gut instinct… you’d never forgive yourself if something happened. She’s only 17 and when she’s at university or whatever, she’ll be with other people in a busy area. I don’t think it’s wise to walk in isolated places when it’s dark

HelenTherese2 · 13/08/2023 23:38

They aren’t though. Men are far, far more likely to be attacked than women.

JudgeRudy · 13/08/2023 23:32

Shoebills · 10/08/2023 12:24

I think the risk is lower if she was male, I think we are silly to ignore that fact.

Tbf, she is always happy to have find a friend on her phone and tells me where she plans to go, but I don't think it's all that helpful, that won't prevent her being attacked really

I'm not sure the risks are lower for males. Sexual attack by a lone perp maybe, but a lad of 17 would be the perfect age for confrontational violence inc stabbing. Much, much higher risk.

MamskiBell · 13/08/2023 23:31

Given the way you're responding to everyone's comments and suggestions, you've already made your mind up that you're right and everyone else is wrong so I don't see the point in your post if you're not willing to take on board or entertain the suggestions being offered.

Cardboardcup · 13/08/2023 23:29

I agree with you. My daughter is 17 and I dint like her out in parks etc in the dark. If she’s with friends that’s fine but in her own nope definitely not. Luckily she wouldn’t want to either. There were 2 rapes in our local park last year .

JudgeRudy · 13/08/2023 23:28

YABU to ask her to do something that's not her responsibility but then expect her to do it your way. She doesnt want to walk the dog. She probably doesn't want to be seen out walking the dog either. She has enough of a heart tho to walk it but at a time/place that suits her. I'd say in the teens stakes your winning.
Incidently what happens when the goes out at night with/to visit friends? Does she always take her car? What of she's drinking or just popping out. Surely st 17 she goes out at night alone.

5128gap · 13/08/2023 23:16

GrumpyOldCrone · 13/08/2023 22:44

Attacks are rare, but when they do happen they can have catastrophic consequences. It’s irrelevant that men are attacked more often than women: a man has a much better chance of fighting off a male attacker, and cannot possibly get pregnant as a result of the attack.

Your daughter might feel safer being with a dog, but dog walking is different from walking from A to B and more likely to involve locations that are less safe (like parks). Moreover, if a man attacks your daughter the dog will probably try to protect her and could also come to harm.

So perhaps it’s not a huge risk, but in my opinion it’s not a risk worth taking. Especially when there’s an alternative.

Its absolutely this. The very basics of risk assessment. Likelihood AND severity of harm must both go into the calculation.
Too many people are focusing only on the first, which makes no sense. Far more people get papercuts than cut their hands off with a chain saw. That doesn't mean we need to be more cautious around paper than power tools.